Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Have you ever smacked your child, given 2021 UK statistic?

342 replies

Tinkerbelle4 · 09/09/2026 18:25

Just seen this clip, not really a big fan is super nanny but was shocked to hear the UK 2021 statistic that 62% of parents had physically disciplined their child.

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1HXeNmtEDB/?mibextid=wwXIfr

I’m curious- do you fall into that statistic? Especially if you have children say under 16- have you ever smacked them?

OP posts:
ItsAlwaysTwins · 10/09/2026 11:02

Using the word "smack" to bowdlerise the committing of violence against a child rubs me up the wrong way.

Completely agree. I always refuse to use ‘smack’ on discussions such as these. It’s always the shitty parents who tried to justify hitting their children who use the euphemism ‘smack’.

PS as a logophile, I appreciate the use of ‘bowdlerise’ 😊

ginasevern · 10/09/2026 11:42

Yes, I hit my son twice in his life. Once when he was around 11 and he had descended into an extremely frightening frenzy. He was completely out of control and nothing else would stop him. And I hit him on another occasion when he was around 14 whilst he had me pinned to a wall and was trying to attack me with a knife. When I say "hit", on both occasions it was a pathetic attempt to restore some normality as he was (is) considerably bigger and stronger than me. He was subsequently diagnosed with schizophrenia at the age of 15 after years of me begging for help. And even then I didn't get any.

BatsInHibernation · 10/09/2026 12:17

No. Hitting a child is usually done in the heat of the moment, thus being an anger management issue of the parent's, rather than actual discipline. Ditto shouting. Most people who lash out and slap their child, wouldn't do it ten minutes later once they've calmed down.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/09/2026 12:20

absolutely not and never would. It teaches nothing but violence and a lack of self control. If hitting an adult is abuse and criminal, so should be hitting a child.

Milly16 · 10/09/2026 22:15

PonkyPonky · 10/09/2026 07:17

It’s not brave to admit you’re an abuser. What kind of weird logic is this?
I could never hit my child. Anecdotally, I have several friends who do hit their children and they have the worst behaved ones. Children who are taught that violence doesn’t solve a problem are much much better behaved in my experience.
How anyone can hurt a child is beyond me. They’re smaller than you, unable to defend themselves. It’s reprehensible.

The bad behaviour may be the cause not the result. They hit them because they are challenging and they don't know how to cope. I occasionally smacked my eldest. They were very difficult and challenging and I lost control. I do regret it and in no way consider it good parenting or the right approach. Never smacked DC2 as they have a different personality. However, my observation as a parent with older teens is that the most damage is caused by other things, too much pressure, unkind words, lack of affection, parents splitting up (especially if their dad loses interest in them), unfairness as against siblings, frequent criticism etc. Most kids with a stable and loving home life and lots of positive and uncritical love and attention will not be much affected by the odd smack on the bum when they've pushed mum too far.

SlugJam · 10/09/2026 22:21

Interestingly all the people who smacked/are pro smacking are saying ‘I don’t think it does any real harm’. No one is saying it does any good. So doesn’t that show that smacking is all about the parent, and not the child? It’s a complete lack of control on the parent’s side, which they then try and justify with ‘it didn’t do any harm’.
Does anyone who hit/hits their child actually think it’s an effective parenting strategy?

OtterlyAstounding · 10/09/2026 23:26

SlugJam · 10/09/2026 22:21

Interestingly all the people who smacked/are pro smacking are saying ‘I don’t think it does any real harm’. No one is saying it does any good. So doesn’t that show that smacking is all about the parent, and not the child? It’s a complete lack of control on the parent’s side, which they then try and justify with ‘it didn’t do any harm’.
Does anyone who hit/hits their child actually think it’s an effective parenting strategy?

I thought it was useful the few times I used it, because it did work to stop my toddlers trying to touch the stove. I watched them like a hawk, of course, and tried to keep them away, but inevitably they slipped my watch and got a chance, and while I managed to yank them away in time, I wanted to ensure they never tried again. So I smacked them on the hand while shouting at them. One never did try again, and the other tried once more several months later, then not again. I'm comfortable with a smack on the hand being better than horrible burns if they'd pulled a pot off the stove.

So I think it worked effectively as a deterrent to prevent serious harm. I don't think it's an effective 'punishment' for most kids, and other strategies usually work better.

Personally though, as a pp said, in my own childhood I much preferred a smack on the bum to being sent to my room for ten minutes or so – that deeply distressed me and left me screaming and tantruming, in a right state, whereas a smack was over and done with in a second. I think time outs or other consequences can actually affect children quite deeply. My cousin was smacked growing up, but much like me (she's also autistic), what she remembers as being very traumatic was being left to 'calm down' when she had a tantrum (probably a meltdown in hindsight) as an 8/9 year old, not being smacked. I agree with pp that many other things are much more harmful to a child than a smack.

Also, many parenting choices are all about the parent and not necessarily what's in the child's best interests.

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 17:35

SlugJam · 10/09/2026 22:21

Interestingly all the people who smacked/are pro smacking are saying ‘I don’t think it does any real harm’. No one is saying it does any good. So doesn’t that show that smacking is all about the parent, and not the child? It’s a complete lack of control on the parent’s side, which they then try and justify with ‘it didn’t do any harm’.
Does anyone who hit/hits their child actually think it’s an effective parenting strategy?

It does work in that the few things I've smacked them for, they haven't done again. Plus it's dealt with in seconds. Whereas other corrections like time out, grounding, taking things away just prolongs it and often takes repeating a couple of times before they stop doing whatever it was.

MyOtherTimePiece · 11/09/2026 18:55

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 17:35

It does work in that the few things I've smacked them for, they haven't done again. Plus it's dealt with in seconds. Whereas other corrections like time out, grounding, taking things away just prolongs it and often takes repeating a couple of times before they stop doing whatever it was.

So you hit your children because it saves you time? If you do something I don't like, can I just smack you so you don't do it again or would prefer I take a different approach?

CadiFfan · 11/09/2026 18:56

Yes i smacked. All 3.

Jackospice · 11/09/2026 19:14

I was smacked a couple of times. Didn’t traumatise me at all, but it did show me that my mum had lost control and even as a child I didn’t really respect that. I have daughters and I wouldn’t want to risk them thinking that they can do any thing that would ‘make’ someone hit them. I’m surprised by some of the reasons here, like because of disrespect. Or them not wanting to do something. These don’t seem like reasons to justify smacking to me, just reasons why you lost control. Lots of pp positioning it like the choice is between letting them get their way or hitting them, but I think there’s a lot of options between the two.
the running in the road or to ward off something that would hurt more, I kindof understand.

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 19:20

MyOtherTimePiece · 11/09/2026 18:55

So you hit your children because it saves you time? If you do something I don't like, can I just smack you so you don't do it again or would prefer I take a different approach?

If I get in your face and speak to you the way some people on here say their kids do to them, and I threaten violence or throw things at you or come into your house, live under your roof and disrespect you, you have full permission to smack me, and I'd have it coming.

I'd wallop any adult treating me like that. If more people held their kids to the same standard they hold everyone else to, we'd have far less entitled little brats running around.

HowardTJMoon · 11/09/2026 19:42

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 19:20

If I get in your face and speak to you the way some people on here say their kids do to them, and I threaten violence or throw things at you or come into your house, live under your roof and disrespect you, you have full permission to smack me, and I'd have it coming.

I'd wallop any adult treating me like that. If more people held their kids to the same standard they hold everyone else to, we'd have far less entitled little brats running around.

Ugh. This sounds eerily similar to the bullshit justifications you hear from violent men who say the reason they hit their wives was because they were mouthing off and so they "had it coming".

MyOtherTimePiece · 11/09/2026 19:58

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 19:20

If I get in your face and speak to you the way some people on here say their kids do to them, and I threaten violence or throw things at you or come into your house, live under your roof and disrespect you, you have full permission to smack me, and I'd have it coming.

I'd wallop any adult treating me like that. If more people held their kids to the same standard they hold everyone else to, we'd have far less entitled little brats running around.

How old were your children when you hit them?

Has it occurred to you that if you raise them to believe that it's ok to use violence to make them stop doing things you don't like, then they may later use violence to make you stop doing things they don't like.

I disagree that we need to hit children to avoid them becoming "brats". There's a vast number of parenting strategies that fall between violence and zero discipline.

SlugJam · 11/09/2026 20:01

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 19:20

If I get in your face and speak to you the way some people on here say their kids do to them, and I threaten violence or throw things at you or come into your house, live under your roof and disrespect you, you have full permission to smack me, and I'd have it coming.

I'd wallop any adult treating me like that. If more people held their kids to the same standard they hold everyone else to, we'd have far less entitled little brats running around.

My children are absolutely not brats. They’re lovely, polite, hard working, kind… and I’ve never hit them. Anyone would think there are alternative parenting strategies to violence.

Jackospice · 11/09/2026 20:13

Balloonhearts · 11/09/2026 19:20

If I get in your face and speak to you the way some people on here say their kids do to them, and I threaten violence or throw things at you or come into your house, live under your roof and disrespect you, you have full permission to smack me, and I'd have it coming.

I'd wallop any adult treating me like that. If more people held their kids to the same standard they hold everyone else to, we'd have far less entitled little brats running around.

I guess I wouldn’t hit any adult acting like that so it wouldn’t make sense to do it to my dc

MotherOfLittleCrocodiles · 11/09/2026 20:21

Never. Mum mum used to hit me, and I always knew it was a loss of control on her part rather than anything I deserved. I swore I would never do that to my own children.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 12/09/2026 07:14

Fair enough. What's socially acceptable does tend to change though. Something like putting your child into daycare I could see becoming just as frowned upon as smacking, for instance.

@OtterlyAstounding am I not meant to pay my bills or feed my children? 🤨 What exactly do you think is so awful about childcare that it will become equivalent to abusing your child? My DS is 2 and he goes bounding into his nursery with excitement because they have great toys and adults who are there just to play with him! He loves it!

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 07:29

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 12/09/2026 07:14

Fair enough. What's socially acceptable does tend to change though. Something like putting your child into daycare I could see becoming just as frowned upon as smacking, for instance.

@OtterlyAstounding am I not meant to pay my bills or feed my children? 🤨 What exactly do you think is so awful about childcare that it will become equivalent to abusing your child? My DS is 2 and he goes bounding into his nursery with excitement because they have great toys and adults who are there just to play with him! He loves it!

Feel free to defend it, but I think that allowing low paid, overworked nursery employees to spend 8+ hours a day raising your children at the most formative point in their life, is arguably more harmful to the child than an infrequent hit on the hand or bottom in an otherwise loving, stable household. Though neither is ideal.

Personally, I think that parents should do the parenting (shocking concept, I know), and not pay others to do it for them 30 - 50 hours a week.

Plenty of people manage to raise their children with one parent staying home until they start school, or work part-time from toddlerhood until starting school, with the children only spending two days in nursery to get socialisation with other children, while still spending the majority of time with a parent.

I don't think childcare is terribly harmful, but I do wonder if people realise how hypocritical and irrational it is when they get so up in arms over the rare smack, while they send their incredibly vulnerable children off to be minded by total strangers 5 days a week during their most formative years.
People are so easily influenced by fluctuating social norms that aren't driven by what's best for the child, but rather what's convenient for the parent.

doveinitial · 12/09/2026 08:10

Never. I cannot put into words how strongly I feel about smacking and the utter disgust I feel when others do.

MyOtherTimePiece · 12/09/2026 08:38

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 07:29

Feel free to defend it, but I think that allowing low paid, overworked nursery employees to spend 8+ hours a day raising your children at the most formative point in their life, is arguably more harmful to the child than an infrequent hit on the hand or bottom in an otherwise loving, stable household. Though neither is ideal.

Personally, I think that parents should do the parenting (shocking concept, I know), and not pay others to do it for them 30 - 50 hours a week.

Plenty of people manage to raise their children with one parent staying home until they start school, or work part-time from toddlerhood until starting school, with the children only spending two days in nursery to get socialisation with other children, while still spending the majority of time with a parent.

I don't think childcare is terribly harmful, but I do wonder if people realise how hypocritical and irrational it is when they get so up in arms over the rare smack, while they send their incredibly vulnerable children off to be minded by total strangers 5 days a week during their most formative years.
People are so easily influenced by fluctuating social norms that aren't driven by what's best for the child, but rather what's convenient for the parent.

Personally, I think parents shouldn't use violence on their children because it's convenient for them.

Plenty of parents manage it.

Ask a child if they'd prefer to be assaulted or sent to play at nursery for a few hours.

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 08:46

MyOtherTimePiece · 12/09/2026 08:38

Personally, I think parents shouldn't use violence on their children because it's convenient for them.

Plenty of parents manage it.

Ask a child if they'd prefer to be assaulted or sent to play at nursery for a few hours.

I happen to think both are not ideal, while also not being some abhorrent abuse, so I'm not sure what point you're trying to make? Are you agreeing with me? Because it rather sounds like it.

One of my children would most definitely rather have had a smack on the bum on a daily basis rather than go off to nursery 4 or 5 days a week, so if you'd asked him, you might not have got the answer you wanted.
Happily, he both wasn't smacked, and didn't have to go off to nursery.

(And a full work week is hardly 'a few hours'. Not to mention the incidents of non-verbal children and babies being abused physically or sexually at nursery, or neglected, shouted at, or nearly handed off to the wrong parents.)

MyOtherTimePiece · 12/09/2026 09:03

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 08:46

I happen to think both are not ideal, while also not being some abhorrent abuse, so I'm not sure what point you're trying to make? Are you agreeing with me? Because it rather sounds like it.

One of my children would most definitely rather have had a smack on the bum on a daily basis rather than go off to nursery 4 or 5 days a week, so if you'd asked him, you might not have got the answer you wanted.
Happily, he both wasn't smacked, and didn't have to go off to nursery.

(And a full work week is hardly 'a few hours'. Not to mention the incidents of non-verbal children and babies being abused physically or sexually at nursery, or neglected, shouted at, or nearly handed off to the wrong parents.)

Did you ask them if they preferred being slapped? Or are you just assuming so to make yourself feel better about the fact you assaulted children because you couldn't be bothered to parent?

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 09:09

MyOtherTimePiece · 12/09/2026 09:03

Did you ask them if they preferred being slapped? Or are you just assuming so to make yourself feel better about the fact you assaulted children because you couldn't be bothered to parent?

You seem to not be reading? I didn't smack my children growing up as punishment. And yes, my son would most definitely have preferred to be smacked, given the way he reacted to the prospect of going to kindergarten without me.

Clearly the fact that you literally "couldn't be bothered to parent" at all and instead paid strangers to do it during the weekdays has made you defensive. That's fine. It's a little amusing that you'll accuse people of not bothering to parent while defending full-time childcare, though.

This is nicely illustrative of how all parents make (and justify) some choices based on what's convenient to them, and not what's ideal for the child. Luckily, as long as a child has a stable, loving home it's generally not an issue, though.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 12/09/2026 09:42

OtterlyAstounding · 12/09/2026 07:29

Feel free to defend it, but I think that allowing low paid, overworked nursery employees to spend 8+ hours a day raising your children at the most formative point in their life, is arguably more harmful to the child than an infrequent hit on the hand or bottom in an otherwise loving, stable household. Though neither is ideal.

Personally, I think that parents should do the parenting (shocking concept, I know), and not pay others to do it for them 30 - 50 hours a week.

Plenty of people manage to raise their children with one parent staying home until they start school, or work part-time from toddlerhood until starting school, with the children only spending two days in nursery to get socialisation with other children, while still spending the majority of time with a parent.

I don't think childcare is terribly harmful, but I do wonder if people realise how hypocritical and irrational it is when they get so up in arms over the rare smack, while they send their incredibly vulnerable children off to be minded by total strangers 5 days a week during their most formative years.
People are so easily influenced by fluctuating social norms that aren't driven by what's best for the child, but rather what's convenient for the parent.

You sound ridiculous. The people who have cared for my children at nursery and preschool have all been wonderful people. They’re genuinely kind and caring, get down and play with them and take really good care of my children. If I felt they didn’t do any of these things, we would choose different settings.

Other people may be able to afford to go down to one salary but that wasn’t an option for us. I’m also nowhere near as fun as the nursery staff. My children have engaged with far more exciting activities there because there isn’t the worry about mess or space.

My children have never been smacked and never will be. DD2 is suspected to be neurodiverse and has been really challenging to parent. Still never hit her and her behaviour is getting easier to manage because we’re putting the effort into understanding her and nurturing her. That’s from our parenting! They have all loved going to nursery/pre-school/school. They’re all really sociable and want to be with other children. DH are still very much doing all of the parenting but believe what you like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread