Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
PersephoneParlormaid · 14/11/2026 17:46

What are your personal thoughts on HRT and breast cancer?

Thegirlwhowent · 14/11/2026 17:47

Are there any patients that make your heart sink? Are there any ailments or body parts you really don't want to look at?

Fayrazzled · 14/11/2026 17:49

I've just spent a week in hospital. Parts of my care were amazing and I came across some fantastic doctors, nurses and HCAs. But I was also astounded at the inefficiency and waste I witnessed.

Do you think there is any hope for the NHS?

Lifecircle · 14/11/2026 17:50

Do you think hyperparathyroidism is not taken seriously enough?

LasVegass · 14/11/2026 17:50

Are you still working?

EveningSpread · 14/11/2026 17:51

Do you get empathy fatigue? Do you dread the next patient coming in case they’re difficult/particularly ill or vulnerable?

BareGrylls · 14/11/2026 17:51

With complex patients is there a benefit to always seeing the same doctor and does your practice enable this?

What do you think about AHPs and physician's assistants acting as doctors?

thesplendourfalls · 14/11/2026 17:53

Do you choose to get health screenings and vaccinations?

CelticSilver · 14/11/2026 17:55

Who dis?

Champagneponies · 14/11/2026 17:57

Do you feel like the government is behind you?

Do you think there is an agenda to push towards privatisation of healthcare in this country?

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · 14/11/2026 18:19

Do you like the current system where patients are supposed to see pharmacists, first contact physios, nurses, and just about anyone else, instead of seeing a GP - does it mean you never see the basics/easy stuff any more, but only the complex things? It seems that are our surgery, you see everyone else, but if it's serious enough to see the GP, they can't actually treat it but are just gatekeepers that you have to convince to refer you to the specialists. There is never enough time for them to read your notes, look at you holistically, follow up on previous things that they've said 'wait and see' about, even when it's the same GP. They're just so very focused on getting you out of there within the ten minutes, and nothing ever seems to be looked at properly or joined up. Their main job these days just seems to be determining if you hit enough of the tick-boxes for a referral to whatever specialty might be able to deal with it.

Do you find yourself logging on in evenings and weekends or days off to check notes, tests, referrals etc? The GPs we have are usually 2 days a week each, and they get the letters and tests and prescription requests sent to them specifically, so it's often quite a long wait til they can do things. You can only book 3 weeks in advance, as well, and when they're only 2 days a week, that usually means you're told to ring back each time to see if anything has come available for the 4th week, on repeat, if you actually want to see the same GP. Continuity seems to be a real problem, even though they encourage the idea of it - in practice it doesn't really work.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:44

PersephoneParlormaid · 14/11/2026 17:46

What are your personal thoughts on HRT and breast cancer?

The additional risk is very small unless you've had breast cancer yourself (risk of promoting recurrence) or there's a strong family history

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:47

Thegirlwhowent · 14/11/2026 17:47

Are there any patients that make your heart sink? Are there any ailments or body parts you really don't want to look at?

There are patients that are very complex with multiple physical and mental health problems that - if too many of them are booked in one day - it can make me feel a bit overwhelmed and I may well be totally emotionally depleted by the end of the day. But I have absolutely nothing against them personally

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:50

Fayrazzled · 14/11/2026 17:49

I've just spent a week in hospital. Parts of my care were amazing and I came across some fantastic doctors, nurses and HCAs. But I was also astounded at the inefficiency and waste I witnessed.

Do you think there is any hope for the NHS?

I really hope so because I'm a left leaning idealist! Having grown up in a council house myself, I worry about people slipping through the cracks if the NHS is replaced by private healthcare. I also see a lot of private healthcare providers doing a terrible job, ordering unnecessary tests, causing patients anxiety, starting unnecessary medications, all because they're motivated by money and the dynamic is more customer/provider than patient/doctor

OP posts:
SquadGoals75 · Yesterday 06:50

Is very painful ovulation and associated bloating normal?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:51

Lifecircle · 14/11/2026 17:50

Do you think hyperparathyroidism is not taken seriously enough?

Hard to say. Whenever I've diagnosed patients with it, I've referred them to endocrinology and it's been treated/appropriately monitored where it can't be treated?

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:52

LasVegass · 14/11/2026 17:50

Are you still working?

Yes!

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:54

EveningSpread · 14/11/2026 17:51

Do you get empathy fatigue? Do you dread the next patient coming in case they’re difficult/particularly ill or vulnerable?

Definitely at times. But I try to mitigate this by working part time (I know people hate this about their GPs but its a very intense job and even 3 days can be 36hrs), having interests outside of work, talking to colleagues and my DH who is also a GP

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:57

BareGrylls · 14/11/2026 17:51

With complex patients is there a benefit to always seeing the same doctor and does your practice enable this?

What do you think about AHPs and physician's assistants acting as doctors?

There have been proven benefits to continuity and at my practice we do try to offer this, especially for "complex" patients. Sometimes it's difficult if the GP they are registered with is very popular/not working many days a week. Sometimes patients would rather be seen quicker than wait for their own GP. But I do think a fresh pair of eyes can be helpful clinically as well

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 06:59

Just to say - I have worked in the NHS since 1996 and as an AHP for 15 years and I firmly believe that GPs are the NHS. When you are in trouble, the health service is in trouble. So I hope you enjoy your work.

Would you like to see District Nurses go back into being employed by GP practices, and the half of them that have been cut since 2010 replaced? Personally it seems insane that in an ageing population that desperately wants to keep people in the community, the DN service has been cut so much.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:00

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:57

There have been proven benefits to continuity and at my practice we do try to offer this, especially for "complex" patients. Sometimes it's difficult if the GP they are registered with is very popular/not working many days a week. Sometimes patients would rather be seen quicker than wait for their own GP. But I do think a fresh pair of eyes can be helpful clinically as well

Sorry, to answer your bit about AHPs

I think it's a strategic cheapening of our roles as doctors to be honest. And concerning in terms of things that may be missed if the "clinician" doesn't have a medical degree and the 5+ years of training after that (a mix of hospital jobs and primary care) needed to qualify as a new GP

But I also work with many of them and count them as friends so its tricky! I think some are much better qualified than others, just depending on the experience they've had

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:01

thesplendourfalls · 14/11/2026 17:53

Do you choose to get health screenings and vaccinations?

Definitely

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:03

Champagneponies · 14/11/2026 17:57

Do you feel like the government is behind you?

Do you think there is an agenda to push towards privatisation of healthcare in this country?

Hard to know. I am obviously more hopeful about a labour government than Conservative. I think money corrupts everything and healthcare shouldn't be profit driven

OP posts:
InkyWink · Yesterday 07:08

@Champagneponies GP practices are private businesses.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:08

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · 14/11/2026 18:19

Do you like the current system where patients are supposed to see pharmacists, first contact physios, nurses, and just about anyone else, instead of seeing a GP - does it mean you never see the basics/easy stuff any more, but only the complex things? It seems that are our surgery, you see everyone else, but if it's serious enough to see the GP, they can't actually treat it but are just gatekeepers that you have to convince to refer you to the specialists. There is never enough time for them to read your notes, look at you holistically, follow up on previous things that they've said 'wait and see' about, even when it's the same GP. They're just so very focused on getting you out of there within the ten minutes, and nothing ever seems to be looked at properly or joined up. Their main job these days just seems to be determining if you hit enough of the tick-boxes for a referral to whatever specialty might be able to deal with it.

Do you find yourself logging on in evenings and weekends or days off to check notes, tests, referrals etc? The GPs we have are usually 2 days a week each, and they get the letters and tests and prescription requests sent to them specifically, so it's often quite a long wait til they can do things. You can only book 3 weeks in advance, as well, and when they're only 2 days a week, that usually means you're told to ring back each time to see if anything has come available for the 4th week, on repeat, if you actually want to see the same GP. Continuity seems to be a real problem, even though they encourage the idea of it - in practice it doesn't really work.

I think the points you raise are very valid.

I do like the doctor triage system because it means I can direct someone with knee pain directly to a physio who is much better qualified than I to diagnose the exact issue and treat it. Or to a nurse practitioner if it sounds like a simple infection like tonsillitis. It leaves me more time to deal with the complex patients (and we are all getting more complex over time as we live longer with varied ailments) which is more satisfying professionally but, yes, also exhausting and I'd like to see a simple UTI every now and then!

Surgeries vary vastly and where I work noone waits more than 2 weeks for an appointment (which to me is totally reasonable if the issue isn't acute or life threatening) and we always see someone same day if needed. But pressures may be higher in different areas

OP posts: