Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
Doriangraysattic · Yesterday 10:25

Do you have a personalised care team in your practice? I'm a Social Prescriber and like to think we are helpful but some of the GPs still don't understand our roles and send daft referrrals!

RaggedRocks · Yesterday 10:26

How many patients are time wasters, with invented conditions?

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · Yesterday 10:27

Do you refuse to action things in hospital letters because the hospital should be dealing with them, and get the patient to try to go back and get the clinic there to sort it? I understand why GPs do this, as so much is being put onto primary care that shouldn't be, but equally it's frustrating for patients, when GP says 'if consultant thinks you should have that medication, they should prescribe it' or 'if you didn't get enough pain relief after surgery, go back to them and ask for more' or 'I don't have the information/knowledge to refer you to another specialty ,the consultant should have done it' etc, and then the patient is just left high and dry, as it's impossible realistically to contact outpatient clinics etc once you've left them, or get any kind of follow-up care, especially if you're already in pain. So you end up not being referred or prescribed at all, which is unintended consequences of the GPs (understandable) attempts to get the hospital to do what they're paid to rather than the GP.

Now it seems my hospital letters just get read and filed, GP never brings them up or actions anything on them, luckily I've read them on the hospital app, so I guess I could make another appointment to ask her to refer me or whatever it says on the letter, but chances are she won't, as it won't meet the GP criteria.

Blushingm · Yesterday 10:30

PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 06:59

Just to say - I have worked in the NHS since 1996 and as an AHP for 15 years and I firmly believe that GPs are the NHS. When you are in trouble, the health service is in trouble. So I hope you enjoy your work.

Would you like to see District Nurses go back into being employed by GP practices, and the half of them that have been cut since 2010 replaced? Personally it seems insane that in an ageing population that desperately wants to keep people in the community, the DN service has been cut so much.

DNs used to be based in surgeries but not employed by them so I think you’ve misunderstood. DNs still work incredibly closely with surgeries, particularly now when patients are complex and require many different treatments that practice nurses would find difficult to maintain competency on top of what they already do.

Why do you think DNs being employed by a surgery than by the UHB/Trust makes a difference? DNs cover geographical areas usually rather than by surgery and almost all their patients are housebound

The service has been cut and they’re not directed to do more and more but it’s not due to the GP surgeries

dizzydizzydizzy · Yesterday 11:40

What’s your view of ADHD and autism diagnoses
in mature adults? I feel like my usual GP does not approve of my ADHD diagnosis. I know it is common among the general public to disapprove of adults getting these diagnosed but how common is this feeling with doctors?

I recently had a strange health problem and I was referred to a rheumatologist. The rheumatologist said my problem was a side-effect of my ADHD stimulants and I needed to stop taking them. My ADHD psychiatrist said the rheumatologist was wrong and gave 2 or 3 reasons why he was incorrect. The GP (who is usually fantastic) said the rheumatologist was right and I needed to either stop take it the adhd meds or continue taking them plus another med to counteract the “side effect.” . I cannot see a reason to not believe the psychiatrist, who is a consultant with decades of experience…:: the only explanation I can think of is that the GP is an “adhd sceptic” or she was having a very bad day.

BareGrylls · Yesterday 11:46

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:50

I really hope so because I'm a left leaning idealist! Having grown up in a council house myself, I worry about people slipping through the cracks if the NHS is replaced by private healthcare. I also see a lot of private healthcare providers doing a terrible job, ordering unnecessary tests, causing patients anxiety, starting unnecessary medications, all because they're motivated by money and the dynamic is more customer/provider than patient/doctor

Where some secondary care is contracted out to private providers do GPs have any choice in where they refer to?
My reason for asking is thatI was referred to a private company (DMC) for dermatology and my experience was dreadful. I would far prefer to see an NHS dermatologist at my local hospital.

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · Yesterday 13:11

Also what do GPs generally think of newer diagnoses that seem to be more common now like hypermobility/EDS, mast cell disorders, POTs, and all that? I know some GPs privately are rolling their eyes a bit at patients who think these explain loads of their symptoms. The older GPs don't seem to have done much cpd on them and I have heard people say that the GPs don't recognise the common symptom constellations and just see individual minor symptoms as trivial.

0psiedasiy · Yesterday 13:23

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:50

I really hope so because I'm a left leaning idealist! Having grown up in a council house myself, I worry about people slipping through the cracks if the NHS is replaced by private healthcare. I also see a lot of private healthcare providers doing a terrible job, ordering unnecessary tests, causing patients anxiety, starting unnecessary medications, all because they're motivated by money and the dynamic is more customer/provider than patient/doctor

On the flip side it can be so hard to get my GP to refer on. I have several examples where earlier intervention could have helped much sooner. Recently I hurt my leg, several visits to gp, pain killers (referral to physio, I would be seen in 6 weeks), I went through my husbands private health insurance seen same week, X-ray and stress fracture. Yes it cost his employer more, and saved nhs £, but there was the cost of 3 pg visits, referral etc.

Cantpee · Yesterday 13:25

Do GPs talk about patients amongst themselves? I had a difficult birth with a big birth injury and had a nephrostomy which my gp was obviously aware of. When I saw a nurse and another gp about my baby, both asked if I was the mum with the nephrostomy, without me prompting the conversation.

Vinvertebrate · Yesterday 13:32

0psiedasiy · Yesterday 13:23

On the flip side it can be so hard to get my GP to refer on. I have several examples where earlier intervention could have helped much sooner. Recently I hurt my leg, several visits to gp, pain killers (referral to physio, I would be seen in 6 weeks), I went through my husbands private health insurance seen same week, X-ray and stress fracture. Yes it cost his employer more, and saved nhs £, but there was the cost of 3 pg visits, referral etc.

Agree, tbh I’d far rather be tested unnecessarily than told “it’s IBS” for 6 months, with no tests conducted or alternative diagnoses considered. It was of course bowel cancer. I would hope GP’s diagnostic skills have improved since then, but I’m
not willing to risk it, so I pay for an annual colonoscopy. No doubt my GP thinks that is “unnecessary testing” but he’s proved he couldn’t diagnose his way out of a damp paper bag, so I don’t really care.

greensauna · Yesterday 13:35

I love the NHS and am so grateful to the wonderful doctors, nurses and staff for the many times it has saved people I love. However it staggers me that doctors dismiss gut health or rather don’t mention it or consider it. I’ve suffered really badly with hives and angiodema. Seen many NHS doctors and dermatologists only to be told repeatedly there’s no know cause and offered me stronger antihistamines, steroids and potentially injections. I refused to accept this and out of desperation paid for a holistic health specialist over a few months and have got rid of both through gut health work and working on stress, sleep and nervous system regulation. I guess it’s a lack of resources but not once did the NHS mention gut health. Seems crazy to just mask health issues with drugs rather than get to the root problem. Would love your opinion on this.

CherryKerry · Yesterday 13:46

How common is it for men to make up symptoms as having an intimate examination is sexually stimulating to them?

(Family member works in a care home and has come across several men over the years that try to get female carers to wash their bits, once a pervert always a pervert 🤮).

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Yesterday 13:47

What should I do if my iron levels are high but my ferritin levels are low?

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 13:48

I'm in a top profession myself, although not medicine.

I would never do this as it's unprofessional. Why do you feel the need?

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 13:52

You say that you think that a 2 week wait is reasonable.

Do you accept that for your family? I guess you can diagnose them yourself, but I imagine you can’t (legally) prescribe for them?

What do you think of the waiting time/scarcity of some tests like MRIs?

I ask the above because, in France (I have a relative who lives there) you can book a same day GP appointment and an MRI is the first test of anything more complex than a fracture, rather than the last. No one would accept a 2 week wait.

dodgercity · Yesterday 13:56

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 13:48

I'm in a top profession myself, although not medicine.

I would never do this as it's unprofessional. Why do you feel the need?

Do you mean the AMA is unprofessional? Can I ask why?

wildnwilde · Yesterday 13:59

Do you think the horror’ missed DX ‘ stories on social media are to blame for rise in health anxiety etc ?

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 14:05

Do you feel guilty that when the rest of society has gone back to normal after Covid GPs still won't see people face to face? I appreciate surgeries vary but mine will only consult patients by telephone and that is about a 4 to 6 week wait.

Aftip · Yesterday 14:09

How much of your working time is patient facing contact time?

topcat2014 · Yesterday 14:09

Is healthcare rationed, do you think?

I feel we get fobbed off with cheapest oldest generic drugs that do nothing at the first instance, and have to keep going back to get onto something that actually works.

(in my case finally getting biologic drugs for eczema)

Tiptoethroughthehallway · Yesterday 14:18

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 13:48

I'm in a top profession myself, although not medicine.

I would never do this as it's unprofessional. Why do you feel the need?

So far op is being professional and careful with their answers. Do you not agree?

NorthernDancer · Yesterday 14:19

What's the issue with hypothyroidism? I have not yet found a GP who understands it and am engaged in a constant fight to not have my dose reduced, despute my FT4 and FT3 being well within range. I am being told that you are only taught to dose by TSH, which makes no sense at all, and keeps thousands of people, mostly women, unwell.

ILoveKits · Yesterday 14:20

@Onemoremole my GP practice, alomg with the others, is part of a PCN which has a budget of £10 million. This is extrapolated across the country hundreds of times.

I had to deal with mine and to query why I appeared on a potentially vulnerable report and why I was sent a patronising email based on incorrect assumptions. The explanation was that the IT team ran a report using the wrong parameters, the comms team wasn't very sophistocated, and the co-ordinator was out of their depth. If this is replicated across the country, are the PCN's providing value for money, or are they just another layer of bureaucracy and the money would be better spent at the coalface?

As a rider, whilst I am very happy to have a telephone consultation, they always come as a three hour window. Do GPs appreciate many patients also have professional jobs and can't clear such big windows to wait for the time the GP calls? So often it seems GPs want patients to respect their time but this isn't reciprocated.

ohtowinthelottery · Yesterday 14:22

Do you think that too many people are being prescribed medication because they won't take personal responsibility for their health/lifestyles (or are in denial) and that they then end up taking more medication to counteract the side effects of the initial prescribed medication? And the only winner is Big Pharma?

dodgercity · Yesterday 14:30

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 14:05

Do you feel guilty that when the rest of society has gone back to normal after Covid GPs still won't see people face to face? I appreciate surgeries vary but mine will only consult patients by telephone and that is about a 4 to 6 week wait.

That’s not normal. I work with GP surgeries as part of my role. I live in a different borough and my family are in a different borough to both. In all those areas GPs see people to face as a matter of routine.