Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:54

AnotherVice · Yesterday 17:32

Are you one of the GPs who writes ‘hospital for reversible causes’ on RESPECT forms as if a Paramedic doing a basic set of obs has any idea if it is something reversible without taking someone to hospital?

Shamefully I've not really thought about it from that perspective. We write that to mean "yes this patient has advanced cancer and if they are dying please let them do so at home , but take them in if they've broken their leg"!

OP posts:
Doriangraysattic · Yesterday 18:55

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:27

We have social prescribers. I find them helpful in signposting patients to external resources but they are quite clear with us they they're not there for emotional support which is actually a bit of a shame as many of our patients need just that and it takes up a huge amount of our time as GPs

Thank you. I don't just signpost, I'll refer on and actually do emotionally support a lot of them, Some are on my caseload for a couple of years and I've done PIP support and housing help as well.. We have care coordinators and health coaches as part of the team as well, so do, I hope, take a fair bit of non medical work away from the GPs

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:58

paraseetamollie · Yesterday 18:42

Thank you so much for all your hard work. I have a great GP practice here in London, but I also use eConsult and ChatGPT to try to make some sense of what might be going on before making an appointment. Surely that's the perfect patient in the modern era: someone who does a bit of homework, comes prepared, knows what they want to ask, but still values and relies on their GP's professional judgement.

That said, I can see how, for less tech-savvy or older patients, the real value is simply having the time to sit down with you, explain what's troubling them and feel that they're being listened to. That human contact and reassurance can be just as important as the medical advice itself.

And I can also see that, without patients doing a bit of that initial preparation themselves, you could find yourself facing a lot of unfiltered, often quite confusing symptoms and problems all at once. Is that your experience?

I mean we are experts in the undifferentiated so I don't mind unfiltered symptoms. But I agree with you access is harder for older and less tech savvy patients, patients with learning disabilities etc. We do put measures in place to try to make this fairer but it's not perfect

OP posts:
vicryl4 · Yesterday 18:58

I have worked with many GPwER and they have been made a huge difference to our workload. Do you have an area of particular interest?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:58

Doriangraysattic · Yesterday 18:55

Thank you. I don't just signpost, I'll refer on and actually do emotionally support a lot of them, Some are on my caseload for a couple of years and I've done PIP support and housing help as well.. We have care coordinators and health coaches as part of the team as well, so do, I hope, take a fair bit of non medical work away from the GPs

It sounds like you do what I wish ours would!

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 19:00

Silverwombat · Yesterday 18:44

If you started all over again, would you choose to be a GP again?
(from an ex-GP!)

I actually would - which probably suggests an astounding lack of imagination on my part! What did you move on to?

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 19:02

JacknDiane · Yesterday 18:49

Be honest. Do you have private healthcare and if you do, who is it with and what level of cover?

Nope, not rich enough for that and I wouldn't want it (ethically I don't like the two tier system and I don't believe patients get better care privately at least where I am)

OP posts:
ILoveKits · Yesterday 19:07

Onemoremole · Yesterday 19:02

Nope, not rich enough for that and I wouldn't want it (ethically I don't like the two tier system and I don't believe patients get better care privately at least where I am)

If a patient asks for a referral, do you keep those views to yourself? Also, do you not think that if a patient has something like cataracts or a knee replacement privately, they free up an NHS slot for someone without choices.

Silverwombat · Yesterday 19:07

Onemoremole · Yesterday 19:00

I actually would - which probably suggests an astounding lack of imagination on my part! What did you move on to?

That is great to hear - our GPs are an amazing resource though I think it is becoming harder to provide continuity of care. I switched to palliative care, where most of the time I have the privilege of being able to spend as long talking to my patients as they'd like.

Saddaughter999 · Yesterday 19:19

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

Please tell me more about diagnosing someone with Health Anxiety. I have friend with MH issues (she denies it), goes to GP or A&E every week with different problems. There is an active diagnosis "Health Anxiety " on her list in NHS app. How can GP push her to seek some mental health help? Thank you

Shortbreadel · Yesterday 19:24

Why do some GPs differ so much despite being in the same profession? Some that dismiss patient symptoms as they say they are too young or don't believe it's an issue despite the patients symptoms and worries, and other GPs who do their up most to listen and help?

Happyjoe · Yesterday 19:28

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:44

The additional risk is very small unless you've had breast cancer yourself (risk of promoting recurrence) or there's a strong family history

Why don't the offer the gene test? My mum had breast cancer, I've had ovarian and the GP initially refused HRT. I went to a specialist who said in the end no further risk. But every time I asked for the blood test to see if I had the gene it was refused. Surely this is the safest measure to see if able to prescribe HRT?

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 19:30

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 18:14

I could have written this myself. I don't think those of you who have GPs who will see you face to face realise how lucky you are. If you had told me in 2020, that at the end of 2026 I still couldn't see a GP face to face I wouldn't have believed you.

I feel extremely lucky that I can easily get a face to face appointment with a GP at my surgery, and usually within a few days. I sympathize with all those people who can't.

Blanketsandcandles · Yesterday 19:32

I had a difficult experience with my GP cert recently, following some advice on here ironically. It was WRT possible pans/pandas in my child. I was met with a demonstrative sceptical look, told they had never heard of it let alone seen a case in practice and therefore pretty much impossible. Wouldn’t even look at the GP information leaflet I had printed off to take along. There was a real sense of “this is wasting my time”. I felt incredibly dismissed and am now wondering if I can afford to go private (which I really cannot). Any advice or thoughts on why that happened? I’ve since read other parents who are wondering about PP actually take a male partner or family member along as statistically it’s more likely their concerns are taken seriously compared to “just” a mum. You sound caring and empathic and obviously all professions have their cynics, but reading into it it seems widespread. TIA.

Slimtoddy · Yesterday 19:32

How do you like patients advocating for themselves. I watched a GP on social media show is a typical day in the life of a GP and it made me realise how much admin you do. I decided then to provide my GP with a typed note of everything I think is relevant at start of our session - partly so I don't forget anything and partly to support their admin. Have you got any other tips?

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 19:33

Shortbreadel · Yesterday 19:24

Why do some GPs differ so much despite being in the same profession? Some that dismiss patient symptoms as they say they are too young or don't believe it's an issue despite the patients symptoms and worries, and other GPs who do their up most to listen and help?

Because GPs are human beings and are all different? Just like in life, some people do their utmost and others have different opinions and priorities, some are more enthusiastic and energetic, some are more tired or experienced or pragmatic.

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · Yesterday 20:16

Have you ever watched GPs behind closed doors? How do you and colleagues feel about it? It seems to show both the pressures that GPs are under (really eye-opening seeing how much mental health issues people come in with, or non-medical things, etc) but also unrealistic in how quickly people seem to get seen and for what minor things. Real differences from before and after covid, though - before covid, the shows ended with a summary of what happened to the patient, after covid, they end with 'patient is now on a waiting list for...'
But some of the doctors on there are just so incredibly nice!! I can't imagine how they do it all day. Some of them seem so so caring, and really kind and easy to talk to and I'd love to have them as my GP.

mrbojangle · Yesterday 20:34

I work in the NHS. Do you get fed up with patients using AI to diagnose themselves and then demanding whatever medication or tests that an AI bot thought they needed?

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · Yesterday 20:56

@Onemoremole , do you do private work? There was a thread on here recently where posters were insistent that most NHS GPs work privately also. My elder son an NHS GP partner laughed when I asked him if he thought most NHS GPs did private work too. He finds finding time to spend time with his family hard given that he works an absolute minimum 60hr week (frequently more). I find the lack of understanding of how all consuming his work life is a bit heartbreaking to be honest.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 21:09

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · Yesterday 20:56

@Onemoremole , do you do private work? There was a thread on here recently where posters were insistent that most NHS GPs work privately also. My elder son an NHS GP partner laughed when I asked him if he thought most NHS GPs did private work too. He finds finding time to spend time with his family hard given that he works an absolute minimum 60hr week (frequently more). I find the lack of understanding of how all consuming his work life is a bit heartbreaking to be honest.

I don't do any private work and, out of the maybe 50 GPs I know, I can only think of one or maybe two that I know does

OP posts:
Cattyisbatty · Yesterday 21:11

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · Yesterday 20:16

Have you ever watched GPs behind closed doors? How do you and colleagues feel about it? It seems to show both the pressures that GPs are under (really eye-opening seeing how much mental health issues people come in with, or non-medical things, etc) but also unrealistic in how quickly people seem to get seen and for what minor things. Real differences from before and after covid, though - before covid, the shows ended with a summary of what happened to the patient, after covid, they end with 'patient is now on a waiting list for...'
But some of the doctors on there are just so incredibly nice!! I can't imagine how they do it all day. Some of them seem so so caring, and really kind and easy to talk to and I'd love to have them as my GP.

Not the OP but I love that programme for the same reasons you say - all GPs on it are lovely.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · Yesterday 21:19

If you are ill, pregnant or need a smear test, do you see your colleagues for that or do you go to a different GP surgery?

Roughly what percentage of your patients didn't need to see you and could have seen a pharmacist instead?

What's the most unusual illness or injury you have treated?

Have you ever had a complaint made against you that wasn't your fault?

Is there any particular age group you see more of than others eg babies, school aged children, elderly people, pregnant women?

startthedaywithkindnesd · Yesterday 21:22

I asked a question earlier about weight loss drugs .. and your opinion for good for bad .. and would be really interested in your opinion .. my disclosure was that I have lost 9!stone and now have to see you guys twice a year instead of most months ..

Mumoftwoteenagers · Yesterday 21:25

70isaLimitNotaTarget · Yesterday 18:35

How do you handle Non-Attendance and/or lateness
Especially in the patients who are frequency late attenders .
Do the Reception staff rebook or ask them to wait ?

My GP surgery regularly runs late , over 45 minutes is not unusual.
I will try and get the first of the day but often the GP comes in 20 minutes late to start .

I'm an HCP , often get the "Well I phoned in to say I'd be late" ones
That DOES NOT stop time
I cannot juggle appointments because the next one is not always there <sigh>

Off topic but our GP does something that works really well for dealing with late people……

They see people in the order that they arrive.

It encourages people to get there a bit early (as you might get to “jump the queue” which makes everyone feel a bit victorious!) and so means it is more likely that the next person will be there.

FunPartyIdeas · Yesterday 21:25

Does your GP surgery shut for two hours in the middle of the day every day? Ours does - not sure why?