Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
ThatFunnyCoralScroller · Yesterday 15:05

What do you/your surgery think of private adhd assessments?

Would you say i was unreasonable for saying i wanted to go elsewhere/different appointment.

I went to my doctor with a breast lump and when I fot onto the bed I noticed a cctv camera on the corner of the wall. When I asked the doctor , she said the room used to be the office and the cctv is turned off. I then asked if we could go elsewhere or I could make a new appointment. She wasn't happy to say the least.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 15:09

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Yesterday 13:47

What should I do if my iron levels are high but my ferritin levels are low?

Your comment makes no sense. Do you mean your haemoglobin is high but ferritin low or iron intake is high?

If iron intake is high and ferritin low you need to look at what might be inhibiting absorption (tannins in tea/wine, calcium competes also), medications can compete and if you’re enhancing absorption by, example, having vitamin C alongside non-heme iron.

If you mean your Hb is high but Ferritin low then you should supplement until your ferritin climbs, it’s likely your stores were depleted somehow and then intake has climbed again. You could also look at if you’ve had symptoms of events or proven events that can lead to iron loss recently - surgery, GI bleeds, heavy periods.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 15:13

Snippit · Yesterday 10:16

My daughter is pretty complex in that it’s physical and mental health. We paid privately for a psychiatrist who then wrote to her GPs with a plan of what’s required and who to signpost her to. It looks as though the letter was scanned onto her records and not actioned, I’ve had to do lots of chasing and still no movement.

Last week she had a complete meltdown, she has CPTSD, BPD and anxiety so called 111 and was contacted by a mental health team who hopefully give her the help she so desperately needs. Her psychiatrist was literally pulling his hair out and was flummoxed as to why nothing had been done. As a mother this is painful to watch, any advice.

GPs dont action private advice unless you make an appointment and ask them to and insist, plus it has to follow their NHS guidelines or they cannot action it. The psychiatrist has to do that privately if it doesn’t follow their NHS pathway.

waitingforlifeonmars · Yesterday 15:20

why are their so few gps out there that it takes weeks to get an appointment yet in years gone by the norm was same day or latest next day appointment. With so many medical students qualifying, why can’t they get jobs? Would running a session whereby the patients were triaged as they arrived and then sent to nurse/nurse practitioner/ dr/pharmacist not reduce waiting times significantly?

Snippit · Yesterday 15:35

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 15:13

GPs dont action private advice unless you make an appointment and ask them to and insist, plus it has to follow their NHS guidelines or they cannot action it. The psychiatrist has to do that privately if it doesn’t follow their NHS pathway.

Thank you so much for the advice, I didn’t know that. We paid privately as she was a complete mess and not getting support from the G.P. Hopefully her cry for help last week will kick start some help. She’s not the easiest person to help at the best of times, she doesn’t think logically, there’s so much going off, 🤦‍♀️

Monty36 · Yesterday 16:02

Do you think that there is a tendency to over medicate people for some conditions and a reluctance to allow people to manage their condition themselves ?

Monty36 · Yesterday 16:05

Do you think that the triage system could be improved ?
And that it lacks dignity when someone who comes into the surgery for an appointment is asked questions out loud for all to hear ?

That, and why do practice managers hide away and are ‘unseen’ behind their receptionists.

And why do GP’s rely so heavily on nurses to perform tasks that previously doctors used to do. And do you see any weaknesses in doing so ?

Lifelover16 · Yesterday 16:21

Do you think the GP system is outdated, ie the private small business model, contracted to the NHS, with no access to on site diagnostics?
Do you think GPs would be better merged into NHS Urgent Care/Diagnostic Centres where they have access to XR, blood tests, ultrasound, CT etc, and other HCPs on site ( specialist nurses, radiographers, physios, minor injury etc). Would it make care easier for GPs?

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 16:44

dodgercity · Yesterday 14:30

That’s not normal. I work with GP surgeries as part of my role. I live in a different borough and my family are in a different borough to both. In all those areas GPs see people to face as a matter of routine.

Well they still won't see people at my surgery. They might after several phone appointments if you get stroppy but by then you have given up, gone to the chemist, died....

dodgercity · Yesterday 16:51

waitingforlifeonmars · Yesterday 15:20

why are their so few gps out there that it takes weeks to get an appointment yet in years gone by the norm was same day or latest next day appointment. With so many medical students qualifying, why can’t they get jobs? Would running a session whereby the patients were triaged as they arrived and then sent to nurse/nurse practitioner/ dr/pharmacist not reduce waiting times significantly?

Many surgeries already do a version of this using the online form. Or, receptionists have set triage questions they ask when people call. O think it works well. It does at my surgery, anyway. But, how many posts do you see on here and other sites from people think that only a GP will do even when other professionals (ie pharmacists, first contact physios) would actually be the more suitable option? Practice nurses are very experienced in dealing with lots of issues such as tonsillitis, UTIs etc. But people feel shortchanged unless they get a faff to face with a GP. So whats the answer?

dodgercity · Yesterday 16:52

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 16:44

Well they still won't see people at my surgery. They might after several phone appointments if you get stroppy but by then you have given up, gone to the chemist, died....

I suggest you change surgeries then. Because as I said, that’s not normal, so you will be able to find one that does face to face.

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 16:55

dodgercity · Yesterday 16:52

I suggest you change surgeries then. Because as I said, that’s not normal, so you will be able to find one that does face to face.

We can't change surgeries because it is the only one in our area. Believe you me if I could travel to the other side of town to another practice I would.

DontGiveUsNoneOfYourAggravation · Yesterday 17:07

What’s your view of GP surgeries like mine, where we have to use the NHS app to request an appointment, which will be that day or not at all, as they don’t allow us to book ahead? If we don’t get an appointment that day then (obviously) we have to jump through the same hoops the next day. All this new system has done is move the old 8am telephone scramble online.

accidentalmillionaire · Yesterday 17:22

Have you ever described your patients as ‘stupid’? A relative is a GP and is partial to that adjective when off duty. I have to bite my tongue because I think it’s inappropriate. But am I overreacting ?

Blushingm · Yesterday 17:30

waitingforlifeonmars · Yesterday 15:20

why are their so few gps out there that it takes weeks to get an appointment yet in years gone by the norm was same day or latest next day appointment. With so many medical students qualifying, why can’t they get jobs? Would running a session whereby the patients were triaged as they arrived and then sent to nurse/nurse practitioner/ dr/pharmacist not reduce waiting times significantly?

I often get same day appointments with my gp

AnotherVice · Yesterday 17:32

Are you one of the GPs who writes ‘hospital for reversible causes’ on RESPECT forms as if a Paramedic doing a basic set of obs has any idea if it is something reversible without taking someone to hospital?

waitingforlifeonmars · Yesterday 18:05

Blushingm · Yesterday 17:30

I often get same day appointments with my gp

Can I join your gp surgery? I only ever go when absolutely necessary and all self help has failed,I’ve exhausted all other options (pharmacist, dr ChatGPT) and it’s a 3-4 week wait! Then I kick myself for not getting in touch immediately to try to get an appointment and then my wait would be from onset not from after all alternatives have failed. Wish pharmacists also did hrt.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:13

DemonsandMosquitoes · Yesterday 07:31

Do you think many people are living too long and we often continue to aggressively treat when it is futile and would be kinder not to?
Practice nurse.

I think GPs are often quite good at being pragmatic/holistic and loosening targets with things like BP, blood sugar as we as deprescribing in order to prioritise quality of life for elderly, comorbid patients (when those patients are on board with this of course)

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:14

PersephoneParlormaid · Yesterday 07:39

My GP employed a paramedic to see patients. I went in twice to see them (first visit told it’s a virus, second visit it’s now a chest infection) and on both occasions they went to get the GP, so what’s the point?

They're probably in the process of training to be independent prescribers

OP posts:
Greedybilly · Yesterday 18:14

What do you say to people with Long Covid?

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 18:14

waitingforlifeonmars · Yesterday 18:05

Can I join your gp surgery? I only ever go when absolutely necessary and all self help has failed,I’ve exhausted all other options (pharmacist, dr ChatGPT) and it’s a 3-4 week wait! Then I kick myself for not getting in touch immediately to try to get an appointment and then my wait would be from onset not from after all alternatives have failed. Wish pharmacists also did hrt.

I could have written this myself. I don't think those of you who have GPs who will see you face to face realise how lucky you are. If you had told me in 2020, that at the end of 2026 I still couldn't see a GP face to face I wouldn't have believed you.

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:16

NorthXNorthWest · Yesterday 08:35

As you are at the actual coal face, what do you think we should do to get the country healthier at all stages of their lives, especially as we are living longer. People seem unhealthier.

I think there should be a lot more top-down public health and government support for people to lead healthier lives - not everyone would agree I'm sure but I can see why plenty of patients with stressful jobs, family lives, limited money etc find comfort in various vices like junk food, smoking, alcohol. We're all human aren't we and some lead incredibly difficult lives

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:17

GustyGertie · Yesterday 07:40

I wonder how GP’s have time to make home visits but assume you must have to including for example to verify a death.

How much time would you say you spend on weekly home visits?

Very little because we have a specific home visit team, mostly made up of paramedics and us GPs are only consulted/required to visit in complex situations

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:18

PersephoneParlormaid · Yesterday 07:41

Do you think that surgeries being open 7 days a week would be better than walk in centres? How can they ease the pressure on A&E?

Many surgeries are open at evenings and at least one weekend day each week

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:21

Dollymylove · Yesterday 07:51

Why is it so difficult to get a doctor appointment nowadays? There are double the amount of GPs at my group surgery now than there were 30 years ago. Back then an appointment could be booked in the next day or 2. Now they say they are saying no appointments for 3 weeks. How did all this happen?

Population growth, an ageing population with more accumulated health issues, people living for longer in general, more medical diagnoses and interventions than ever before, higher expectations from patients sometimes even for support with non medical issues (social issues)

OP posts: