Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
Periperi2025 · Yesterday 18:22

My colleauge (Advanced paramedic practitioner in primary care) wants to set up a practice staffed almost exclusively by ACPs (particularly ones with different backgrounds (Advanced paeds nurse practitioner for the kids, advanced physio practitioner for the MSK stuff, palliative ACP etc etc) with a couple of GPs for oversight/ to satisfy the funding bodies. Double the staff and appointments for the same cost.
What's your view on his plan?!

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:24

Cattyisbatty · Yesterday 08:29

What is your view on PPIs for long-term use for chronic GORD?

Why do you think diagnoses of ND conditions are increasing so rapidly?

Does your surgery use e-consult? Sometimes I just want to see (or talk) to a GP and I just get a text about taking a medication where I might want to discuss pros/cons of taking the medication in a bit more detail (unf I have 3 chronic conditions!).

I think longterm PPIs have their place. Risks and benefits with every intervention , including doing nothing. Untreated reflux over longterm can cause esophageal cancer for example

I am not sure about the ND issue. Certainly increased awareness plays a part. I admit I feel uncomfortable about the number of patients with ?ADHD we are prescribing amphetamines for

We use econsult. It's tricky but it helps manage demand which would otherwise be overwhelming. I might triage 80+ requests to see a doctor in just one morning

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:26

weebarra · Yesterday 09:56

Do you often work till midnight? My friend who is a GP is ‘part-time’ but often works really long hours to make sure referrals etc are done.
Have many of your peers moved out of general practice or to other countries? My dad and fil were both GPs (retired now) and I think it was a much less pressured job in the past.

No but where I work is quite boundaried and well run in terms of work load. Which stops us getting burnt out and ending up on longterm sick leave which obviously helps noone!

OP posts:
startthedaywithkindnesd · Yesterday 18:26

What is your opinion on weight loss injections and GLP-1 medication (prescribed privately) .. full disclosure , I’ve lost 9!Srone and see you guys soon much less now I’m a healthy weight…

Watermelongum · Yesterday 18:27

Does your practice actually allow patients to have face to face appointments with you? Close to impossible to see a GP at our practice. If you enter the building, the air of quiet and the distinct lack of busy-ness is mind blowing. Which leads me to wonder what the GPs do with their time. Are you busy?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:27

Doriangraysattic · Yesterday 10:25

Do you have a personalised care team in your practice? I'm a Social Prescriber and like to think we are helpful but some of the GPs still don't understand our roles and send daft referrrals!

We have social prescribers. I find them helpful in signposting patients to external resources but they are quite clear with us they they're not there for emotional support which is actually a bit of a shame as many of our patients need just that and it takes up a huge amount of our time as GPs

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:29

Cantpee · Yesterday 13:25

Do GPs talk about patients amongst themselves? I had a difficult birth with a big birth injury and had a nephrostomy which my gp was obviously aware of. When I saw a nurse and another gp about my baby, both asked if I was the mum with the nephrostomy, without me prompting the conversation.

I've never heard a GP colleague talk in a gossipy/pejorative way about a patient, though we may - without giving patient names - share interesting cases. Is it possible they just both had access to your notes when you went to see them?

OP posts:
70isaLimitNotaTarget · Yesterday 18:30

Cantpee · Yesterday 13:25

Do GPs talk about patients amongst themselves? I had a difficult birth with a big birth injury and had a nephrostomy which my gp was obviously aware of. When I saw a nurse and another gp about my baby, both asked if I was the mum with the nephrostomy, without me prompting the conversation.

They would've read your notes ....

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:30

CherryKerry · Yesterday 13:46

How common is it for men to make up symptoms as having an intimate examination is sexually stimulating to them?

(Family member works in a care home and has come across several men over the years that try to get female carers to wash their bits, once a pervert always a pervert 🤮).

Thankfully this has never happened to me but a patient did expose himself to me (unecessarily) on a home visit many years ago!

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:31

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 13:48

I'm in a top profession myself, although not medicine.

I would never do this as it's unprofessional. Why do you feel the need?

I disagree. We have GMC guidance for this and I'm well within it thanks

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:32

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 13:52

You say that you think that a 2 week wait is reasonable.

Do you accept that for your family? I guess you can diagnose them yourself, but I imagine you can’t (legally) prescribe for them?

What do you think of the waiting time/scarcity of some tests like MRIs?

I ask the above because, in France (I have a relative who lives there) you can book a same day GP appointment and an MRI is the first test of anything more complex than a fracture, rather than the last. No one would accept a 2 week wait.

I genuinely would accept it for me or my family, yes

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:34

Norwaygirl · Yesterday 14:05

Do you feel guilty that when the rest of society has gone back to normal after Covid GPs still won't see people face to face? I appreciate surgeries vary but mine will only consult patients by telephone and that is about a 4 to 6 week wait.

I see at least 20 of my patients face to face each day. The others are telephone calls which often suit patients. Even during covid my colleagues and I saw patients in person when needed, even did home visits. Its a misconception

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:35

accidentalmillionaire · Yesterday 17:22

Have you ever described your patients as ‘stupid’? A relative is a GP and is partial to that adjective when off duty. I have to bite my tongue because I think it’s inappropriate. But am I overreacting ?

No, I wouldn't personally

OP posts:
70isaLimitNotaTarget · Yesterday 18:35

How do you handle Non-Attendance and/or lateness
Especially in the patients who are frequency late attenders .
Do the Reception staff rebook or ask them to wait ?

My GP surgery regularly runs late , over 45 minutes is not unusual.
I will try and get the first of the day but often the GP comes in 20 minutes late to start .

I'm an HCP , often get the "Well I phoned in to say I'd be late" ones
That DOES NOT stop time
I cannot juggle appointments because the next one is not always there <sigh>

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:36

Watermelongum · Yesterday 18:27

Does your practice actually allow patients to have face to face appointments with you? Close to impossible to see a GP at our practice. If you enter the building, the air of quiet and the distinct lack of busy-ness is mind blowing. Which leads me to wonder what the GPs do with their time. Are you busy?

Yes we do. And we're always busy, even lunchbreak is really admin. When there's not many folk in the waiting room, there will be telephone appointments happening

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:37

70isaLimitNotaTarget · Yesterday 18:35

How do you handle Non-Attendance and/or lateness
Especially in the patients who are frequency late attenders .
Do the Reception staff rebook or ask them to wait ?

My GP surgery regularly runs late , over 45 minutes is not unusual.
I will try and get the first of the day but often the GP comes in 20 minutes late to start .

I'm an HCP , often get the "Well I phoned in to say I'd be late" ones
That DOES NOT stop time
I cannot juggle appointments because the next one is not always there <sigh>

Depends on how vulnerable the patient is/their reason for being late

I will squeeze them in and go home later if they are seriously ill, a child, have dementia or took 3 buses in

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:41

Periperi2025 · Yesterday 18:22

My colleauge (Advanced paramedic practitioner in primary care) wants to set up a practice staffed almost exclusively by ACPs (particularly ones with different backgrounds (Advanced paeds nurse practitioner for the kids, advanced physio practitioner for the MSK stuff, palliative ACP etc etc) with a couple of GPs for oversight/ to satisfy the funding bodies. Double the staff and appointments for the same cost.
What's your view on his plan?!

Lot of pressure/responsibility for those poor 2 GPs to oversee!!

OP posts:
paraseetamollie · Yesterday 18:42

Thank you so much for all your hard work. I have a great GP practice here in London, but I also use eConsult and ChatGPT to try to make some sense of what might be going on before making an appointment. Surely that's the perfect patient in the modern era: someone who does a bit of homework, comes prepared, knows what they want to ask, but still values and relies on their GP's professional judgement.

That said, I can see how, for less tech-savvy or older patients, the real value is simply having the time to sit down with you, explain what's troubling them and feel that they're being listened to. That human contact and reassurance can be just as important as the medical advice itself.

And I can also see that, without patients doing a bit of that initial preparation themselves, you could find yourself facing a lot of unfiltered, often quite confusing symptoms and problems all at once. Is that your experience?

Silverwombat · Yesterday 18:44

If you started all over again, would you choose to be a GP again?
(from an ex-GP!)

Sammyspurs · Yesterday 18:45

I drunk from Friday night to Sunday night on holiday in Morocco and woke with a racing heart rate- I’m 41yo F peri menopause- does peri cause your heart rate to be a higher resting anyway? My DR didn’t want to know! I am asthmatic too but weather related

BeKhakiReader · Yesterday 18:45

I’m lucky in that my practice is amazing. Wonderful doctors, lovely receptionists and I’ve never not got a same day appointment when I’ve needed it.

Assuming all surgeries get the same amount of money, why do think all surgeries aren’t as good. My sister for example, one rang for an appointment and was 87 in the queue. She just put the phone down, obviously.

IncaAztec · Yesterday 18:49

What do you think about continuity of care issues? I wonder if things would be better structured as if you genuinely did have a Family Doctor - a named GP doesn't seem to come close. I had some blood results recently and was asked if I wanted to book in with a different GP to discuss the results than the person who ordered them. Just felt like a waste of everyone's time recanting everything. Also, what do you think to Same Day Access Service? We have this at our GPs...seems to involve sending you to another GP practice to see an AHP...giving rise to supervision and continuing care issues again.

JacknDiane · Yesterday 18:49

Be honest. Do you have private healthcare and if you do, who is it with and what level of cover?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:51

Tiptoethroughthehallway · Yesterday 08:49

What are the best and worst bits of your role?

Also how has your role changed in the last ten years?

I absolutely love helping people and I get to do that, in small ways and big ways, tens of times a day. I'd not be motivated by a job in sales or similar, it is a vocation

The worst bits are probably when you know there's not much you can do to help or that there would be but the specialist services aren't available/are oversubscribed and have a ridiculous waiting list or aren't accepting new patients

OP posts:
Norwaygirl · Yesterday 18:53

Onemoremole · Yesterday 18:34

I see at least 20 of my patients face to face each day. The others are telephone calls which often suit patients. Even during covid my colleagues and I saw patients in person when needed, even did home visits. Its a misconception

Not where I live, even now.