Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm an NHS GP, AMA

161 replies

Onemoremole · 14/11/2026 15:37

Worked as NHS GP for 10yrs, AMA

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:09

SquadGoals75 · Yesterday 06:50

Is very painful ovulation and associated bloating normal?

Can be but I obviously can't provide medical advice on here/based on so little info and definitely suggest seeing your GP if you haven't already

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 07:10

Do you have a physician associate in your practice and do you plan to keep the post?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:12

PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 06:59

Just to say - I have worked in the NHS since 1996 and as an AHP for 15 years and I firmly believe that GPs are the NHS. When you are in trouble, the health service is in trouble. So I hope you enjoy your work.

Would you like to see District Nurses go back into being employed by GP practices, and the half of them that have been cut since 2010 replaced? Personally it seems insane that in an ageing population that desperately wants to keep people in the community, the DN service has been cut so much.

Thank you, that is very kind of you to say. And absolutely I would, DNs are the lifeblood of community healthcare and so important in making healthcare accessible to our most vulnerable patients as well as keeping them out of hospital

OP posts:
Zapx · Yesterday 07:19

How do you reckon AI will change your job?

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:20

PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 07:10

Do you have a physician associate in your practice and do you plan to keep the post?

We do not - we never have. I'm not a partner but I believe it was considered a bit risky clinically and to a degree in terms of optics following some high profile cases. Many doctors feel sorry for PAs for being put in the position they have been. But it's not reasonable to expect a PA to do the work of a doctor without the equivalent training and to have an extra person to supervise (alongside junior doctors) is unfeasible and unfair, in my view.

OP posts:
Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:21

Zapx · Yesterday 07:19

How do you reckon AI will change your job?

Some GPs use it regularly to scribe notes, formulate referral letters from notes etc. I'm still wary of it as when I've tried it, there have been AI "hallucinations "

I imagine it'll replace us eventually, along with the rest of humanity 😂

OP posts:
Kerfflufeln · Yesterday 07:25

What are your thoughts on the Government 10 year plan of care closer to home, do you think it’s doable, if so can you share any practical steps that you can see working or that might work?

DemonsandMosquitoes · Yesterday 07:31

Do you think many people are living too long and we often continue to aggressively treat when it is futile and would be kinder not to?
Practice nurse.

PersephoneParlormaid · Yesterday 07:39

My GP employed a paramedic to see patients. I went in twice to see them (first visit told it’s a virus, second visit it’s now a chest infection) and on both occasions they went to get the GP, so what’s the point?

GustyGertie · Yesterday 07:40

I wonder how GP’s have time to make home visits but assume you must have to including for example to verify a death.

How much time would you say you spend on weekly home visits?

PersephoneParlormaid · Yesterday 07:41

Do you think that surgeries being open 7 days a week would be better than walk in centres? How can they ease the pressure on A&E?

Dollymylove · Yesterday 07:51

Why is it so difficult to get a doctor appointment nowadays? There are double the amount of GPs at my group surgery now than there were 30 years ago. Back then an appointment could be booked in the next day or 2. Now they say they are saying no appointments for 3 weeks. How did all this happen?

PermanentTemporary · Yesterday 07:57

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:20

We do not - we never have. I'm not a partner but I believe it was considered a bit risky clinically and to a degree in terms of optics following some high profile cases. Many doctors feel sorry for PAs for being put in the position they have been. But it's not reasonable to expect a PA to do the work of a doctor without the equivalent training and to have an extra person to supervise (alongside junior doctors) is unfeasible and unfair, in my view.

Thank goodness for that.

My main view of all the non-doctor stuff and of the reduction in the number of GP hours per population is that it’s just so stupidly inefficient, measurably so. Whereas having a highly trained GP up front as first contact is extremely efficient. It’s just that people don’t like it, because it means that the vast majority of contacts don’t result in what looks like ACTION. And it looks expensive at the top of the budget. But as with couples counselling versus divorce, if you think proper GPs are expensive, wait until you see the cost of not having them.

Cattyisbatty · Yesterday 08:29

What is your view on PPIs for long-term use for chronic GORD?

Why do you think diagnoses of ND conditions are increasing so rapidly?

Does your surgery use e-consult? Sometimes I just want to see (or talk) to a GP and I just get a text about taking a medication where I might want to discuss pros/cons of taking the medication in a bit more detail (unf I have 3 chronic conditions!).

NorthXNorthWest · Yesterday 08:35

As you are at the actual coal face, what do you think we should do to get the country healthier at all stages of their lives, especially as we are living longer. People seem unhealthier.

Tiptoethroughthehallway · Yesterday 08:49

What are the best and worst bits of your role?

Also how has your role changed in the last ten years?

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 09:02

Onemoremole · Yesterday 06:50

I really hope so because I'm a left leaning idealist! Having grown up in a council house myself, I worry about people slipping through the cracks if the NHS is replaced by private healthcare. I also see a lot of private healthcare providers doing a terrible job, ordering unnecessary tests, causing patients anxiety, starting unnecessary medications, all because they're motivated by money and the dynamic is more customer/provider than patient/doctor

People are slipping through the cracks now!

BarbaraUsher · Yesterday 09:36

Are there secrets to staying well? What do you wish all your patients would do to help themselves?

TrepidationOfTheSpheres · Yesterday 09:42

Onemoremole · Yesterday 07:08

I think the points you raise are very valid.

I do like the doctor triage system because it means I can direct someone with knee pain directly to a physio who is much better qualified than I to diagnose the exact issue and treat it. Or to a nurse practitioner if it sounds like a simple infection like tonsillitis. It leaves me more time to deal with the complex patients (and we are all getting more complex over time as we live longer with varied ailments) which is more satisfying professionally but, yes, also exhausting and I'd like to see a simple UTI every now and then!

Surgeries vary vastly and where I work noone waits more than 2 weeks for an appointment (which to me is totally reasonable if the issue isn't acute or life threatening) and we always see someone same day if needed. But pressures may be higher in different areas

I can see the benefits to GPs of this. It's hard for patients at times though, as you don't really get to know your doctor at all, whereas you used to when you saw them briefly and more often for small things, and they could see you as a whole person. Now it's just randomly sent to nurse or pharmacist or whatever who don't always have the training to link things up, or notice if it isn't actually just a simple infection or whatever. And then when you do see the GP, they don't know you at all, and they just have to refer you to hospital if you meet enough tick boxes. There doesn't seem to be much of a middle ground where they see and treat you - simple things, go to the nurse/pharmacist. Difficult things - refer to hospital, if you can convince them it's bad enough. Otherwise, everything is just 'wait and see', but then never enough time to come back to it.

When does a patient become an annoying 'frequent attender'? Obviously some people really do need to be seen a lot, and the GP tells them to come back. But for typical patients, how many times a year (month) would be still counted as 'normal'? Since turning 50, I seem to have various different things wrong, and I would probably be in once a month if I were brave enough to go and see about them - arm pain, menopause issues, blood pressure, tendon problems, low iron, skin flare-up, etc. Each one needs an appointment, then maybe tests, then maybe follow-up, and I think the GP will write me off as hypochondriac or attention-seeking, if I went in ten times a year. But they all have quite an impact on quality of life.

SilenceInside · Yesterday 09:51

Apologies, my questions are all weight loss medication related.

Have you personally prescribed Mounjaro to patients directly, that qualify under the NHS criteria?
Do you know how many people your whole practice prescribes Mounjaro to?
Do you wait until people come to you to ask for Mounjaro or do you contact them to offer it?
Were you inundated with people (of any weight) asking for it when it was announced that it was available via GPs on the NHS?
Would you take GLP1 medication yourself if you were obese or overweight with a weight related health condition?

weebarra · Yesterday 09:56

Do you often work till midnight? My friend who is a GP is ‘part-time’ but often works really long hours to make sure referrals etc are done.
Have many of your peers moved out of general practice or to other countries? My dad and fil were both GPs (retired now) and I think it was a much less pressured job in the past.

allthemind · Yesterday 09:57

How do you handle patients with health anxiety or social issues that make repeated appointments that aren't necessary. My mother has some long term conditions like diabetes which are well managed but outside of those appointments, she goes to the GP with concerns and worries about things that dont materialise into anything at least once or twice a month. How do you / the surgery deal with those people, especially when appointments are scarce?

Snippit · Yesterday 10:16

My daughter is pretty complex in that it’s physical and mental health. We paid privately for a psychiatrist who then wrote to her GPs with a plan of what’s required and who to signpost her to. It looks as though the letter was scanned onto her records and not actioned, I’ve had to do lots of chasing and still no movement.

Last week she had a complete meltdown, she has CPTSD, BPD and anxiety so called 111 and was contacted by a mental health team who hopefully give her the help she so desperately needs. Her psychiatrist was literally pulling his hair out and was flummoxed as to why nothing had been done. As a mother this is painful to watch, any advice.

Takeapause · Yesterday 10:20

I find that my GPs are awful at diagnosing very small issues, and I, and so many others, end up queueing up in A&E for issues that our GPs would have historically dealt with. For me my GP got a constipation diagnosis wrong, and also they would not look into or refer me for a pain I’ve had for several years in the same place and it’s on record.

Do you think that GPs could do more to relieve the pressure from A&E by being more responsive to patients. Have GPs lost power over the years? Is there anything I can do to be heard by my GP.

JoanofCamden · Yesterday 10:21

What do you think of the transgender issue, particularly in relation to children?