Please or to access all these features

AMA

Is there an AMA American thread?

386 replies

upskilledotter · 16/08/2026 22:06

I have so many (probably really boring) questions to ask of Americans (USA) but don’t know if a suitable thread exists.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
trainedopossum · 01/11/2026 16:36

Hard to know where to recommend for a holiday, it depends on what you like, but the US holiday that left the strongest impression on me was the Grand Canyon. The Blue Ridge Mountains are also incredible and two weeks gives you time to explore the towns around the mountains, the barbecue trail etc.

I grew up near NYC and used to love it but it has changed so much, I don’t love it now.

rachel734 · 01/11/2026 16:54

I agree with MissConductUS that the U.S. may be less fractured after the midterms. Many of us felt confused and betrayed by the turn towards Trump, especially in the Rust Belt and other swing states. If the Republicans get a shellacking in the midterms, it will be a reassuring sign that common sense is reemerging. The Democrats are running some interesting, moderate candidates for Senate in places like North Carolina, Georgia, Iowa, Kansas, and Texas.

upskilledotter · 01/11/2026 17:13

Thanks everyone- it’s very interesting what you say about the midterms- I imagine less showy personalities are what’s needed now.

DH would love to do the Deep South - specifically anywhere with Blues music but at 75+ (I’m a lot younger) - I fear that ship has sailed. I’ve done California and Seattle and will probably do more as a solo traveller but I feel he wants a “taste of USA” before it’s too late. East coast may be the good compromise.

Do people play games or reminisce or visit graves at Thanksgiving? Are there traditions that are not related to food?

OP posts:
rachel734 · 01/11/2026 17:35

upskilledotter · 01/11/2026 17:13

Thanks everyone- it’s very interesting what you say about the midterms- I imagine less showy personalities are what’s needed now.

DH would love to do the Deep South - specifically anywhere with Blues music but at 75+ (I’m a lot younger) - I fear that ship has sailed. I’ve done California and Seattle and will probably do more as a solo traveller but I feel he wants a “taste of USA” before it’s too late. East coast may be the good compromise.

Do people play games or reminisce or visit graves at Thanksgiving? Are there traditions that are not related to food?

Edited

If your husband likes Blues music, how about combining some time in Memphis with some time in New York City? Memphis has a lively music scene, the Stax Museum of American Soul Music, a major civil rights museum, the Peabody ducks (just Google them), and light outdoor activities such as a botanical garden and riverboat cruises. You would need to change planes in one of the East Coast airports, ideally JFK, to get to Memphis, but that would make it easy to stop in New York City for a few days on your return. New York City also has some blues cafes, and the jazz club at Lincoln Center, Dizzy's, is good fun: you can order cocktails or dinner or dessert, and the room overlooks the southern end of Central Park.

It would also be possible to fly from London via Chicago or Atlanta, if one of those cities appeals to you more.

knitnerd90 · 01/11/2026 21:10

Thanksgiving (which we quite enjoy since moving here) — you eat, you socialise, you watch football on TV if you like, then you pass out. It's lovely actually, less pressure than a British Christmas. Menus do vary depending on part of the country and ethnic group, for example Black families have sweet potato pie and macaroni and cheese with theirs. Southerners favor cornbread dressing/stuffing (some will be very insistent that if you make it outside the bird, it's dressing), Northerners are more likely to use toasted white bread cubes. Some parts of the South like an oyster dressing, but sausage is more common.

Southerners also often serve ham alongside the turkey, which is much less common up North. (I am in the DC area so border country) I know Italian-American families who serve lasagne or other pasta along with the American menu. We stick to a fairly typical northern style menu: turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes (no marshmallows!), gravy, cranberry sauce, Brussels sprouts, green beans (not the casserole), corn pudding, a salad, pumpkin pie, and apple pie.

MissConductUS · 01/11/2026 22:09

Menus do vary depending on part of the country and ethnic group, for example Black families have sweet potato pie and macaroni and cheese with theirs.

I’m of mostly Irish heritage and Mac and cheese is an absolute requirement at our Thanksgiving dinner. The pie has to be apple, though, with posh vanilla ice cream.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 01/11/2026 22:25

Are there traditions that are not related to food?
Mainly watching football. And the Macy's parade.

I'm in the Deep South, and our menu usually consists of turkey and also ham. My favorite dish is cornbread dressing (not stuffing because it has always been cooked outside the bird). I married a Yankee so we also have mashed potatoes and bread stuffing with apples and walnuts (also cooked outside the bird for safety reasons, but it's called stuffing and not a Southern thing) We also have deviled (aka stuffed) eggs, rice and gravy, green bean casserole (I think it's a law), mac and cheese, mashed sweet potatoes (we don't do the marshmallow topping), fruit salad with cranberries, cranberry sauce, and for desert pumpkin pie, apple pie, and pecan pie. We also sometimes have Kentucky Derby pie, which is a chocolate pecan pie flavored with Bourbon. We have yeast rolls, sometimes home made, but more often Pillsbury Crescent rolls or Sister Schubert yeast rolls (a regional brand).

On some of the regional differences: I grew up in coastal Georgia where rice was much more common as the go-to starch than potatoes. We always had rice and turkey gravy at Thanksgiving, never mashed potatoes until some of us started marrying folks from other parts. Also mac and cheese is often part of the Southern thanksgiving, but might not be found outside the South except among African American families.

It's my favorite holiday. No presents to buy; just food, friends, and family. I like a big Thanksgiving and a low key Christmas.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 01/11/2026 22:28

I forgot corn pudding; we always have that. It's my son's favorite. It's especially good with ham.

mathanxiety · 02/11/2026 05:17

Thanksgiving is imo a more relaxed holiday than Christmas. I cook the same sort of turkey dinner my DM used to cook at Christmas in Ireland - roast (brined) turkey, sage and onion stuffing, sometimes with chestnuts added, cranberry-orange dressing (jam?), Brussels sprouts, green beans, carrots, sweet potatoes mashed with butter and molasses, roast potatoes, roast parsnips. For dessert I make a pecan pie and a pumpkin pie. The only thing that has changed for me is experimenting with different ways of doing the sprouts. Brussels sprouts had a little culinary moment a few years ago, and now everyone wants theirs boiled in balsamic vinegar or whatever...

Apart from all the cooking, it's a pressure free holiday. RC parishes usually hold a Mass on the day in the morning but attendance is optional. My late ILs expected us to go, back in the day when we used to go to theirs for Thanksgiving. They final hymn at their parish church was always America the Beautiful.

Fingers tightly crossed for the midterms, hoping a spirit of brotherhood will prevail.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 02/11/2026 11:58

I always recommend New England for US trips, not just because I live here. Everyone who visits Maine raves about it. You can easily combine it with a few days in Boston, and also with a bit more time you could include a few days in NYC or Washington DC.

Having said that my absolute favorite US city to visit is Chicago. If you choose the right weekend in October, lots of buildings are open to visit that wouldn’t usually be open - it’s called Open House Chicago. But it’s a wonderful city to visit especially if you avoid the hottest and coldest parts of the year.

For Blues music I’d go to the South - New Orleans or Nashville.

upskilledotter · 04/11/2026 07:09

Thanks for all the recommendations - will get planning!

Some lovely insights into Thanksgiving too - it does sound a lot less stressful than Christmas.

Hope this evening’s midterm results were what people wanted - and herald calmer times.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page