Please or to access all these features

AMA

Is there an AMA American thread?

386 replies

upskilledotter · 16/08/2026 22:06

I have so many (probably really boring) questions to ask of Americans (USA) but don’t know if a suitable thread exists.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SpuytenDuyvil · 09/09/2026 22:58

Especially where the ceremony has lots of bridesmaids and groomsmen there are often short rehearsals at the church/synagogue/venue for everyone to know where to stand, etc. It often takes place right before the rehearsal dinner which, in my experience, is paid for by the groom's parents. When DS and DIL got married, her parents, while supportive of the union, have a family policy of "we don't pay for weddings or university" which is the opposite of our family position. We paid for everything and were happy to do it. We called the rehearsal dinner a "gathering," not to sound too twee, but we wanted all the out-of-towners and locals to just come and hang out in casual clothes at a nice Greek restaurant here in our town. Then the day after the wedding we had a brunch at our house for anyone still around, also in casual dress. Gosh, thinking about all this is just making me happy. It was a wonderful weekend and DS and DIL are so great. DH and I are so proud of them.

mathanxiety · 10/09/2026 04:43

Wedding rehearsals are very useful when the wedding party consists of people of all sorts of different religious denominations, who might not know any of the protocols of a given church or temple.

At the rehearsal, the celebrant in a religious wedding walks everyone with a formal role (wedding party, flower children, ring bearer) through the entire ceremony. Details include the entry procession, precise seating positions, the bride and groom processing to the location in the church or temple where the vows will be exchanged, and practicing any bits like lighting candles, signing the register, etc. Anyone doing readings will be given instructions on using the microphone and a chance to practice the readings. There may also be some preliminary blessing and prayers that can be done at the rehearsal (which is usually held in the late afternoon/ early evening of the day before the wedding).

At a secular ceremony, the wedding planner will organise the wedding party at the venue, and bridesmaids/ groomsmen/ parents of the bride and groom/ flower girls and boys, and ring bearer will practice walking toward their seats, sprinkling petals, bringing the rings forward, etc. Again, this is usually a late afternoon/ early evening event.

After the rehearsal comes the meal, which was traditionally offered to out of town guests, with the wedding party and anyone else the couple wanted to invite. Tradition held that the groom's family hosted this meal and the bride's family paid for the wedding.

I'm firmly in camp 'If you can't afford to pay for your own wedding then you shouldn't be getting married', and so far, my two DCs have married people from families who felt the same. There was one secular ceremony and one church wedding. Both have had rehearsals and rehearsal gatherings, and both had wedding receptions - very different from each other but also hugely enjoyable.

Jaywalking - you can only legally cross the street at an intersection/ marked crossing point. Crossing anywhere else is jaywalking. I suspect the reason for this kind of by-law was pedestrian safety and reducing traffic disruption. Perhaps also the fact that there were trams and tramlines in many cities cities made it necessary to desigalnate crossing points. Many American cities have major streets that have more than one lane of traffic going in each direction, so taking a chance on crossing mid-block would be crazy.

As an Irish person with anarchical street crossing habits when I first landed in the US, I got yelled at a few times, but no tickets or cautions. Lots of horn blowing too. As a driver, it's easy to understand how chaotic it would be if people en masse decided to cross wherever they felt like it.

The fact that bus drivers will often wait for you if you wave wildly from the opposite side of the street helps prevent people thinking they need to take chances.

mathanxiety · 10/09/2026 04:52

A rehearsal dinner/ gathering can be as cheap or expensive as the couple (or the parents) want them to be. I've been to rehearsals that were casual backyard BBQs and sit down meals in very nice restaurants.

One of the nice aspects of rehearsals is that they can function as icebreaking events - you get to meet people from the other side of the wedding, and it makes it easier to take up the conversation where it left off the previous evening. It also gets you into a festive mood before the event itself.

upskilledotter · 10/09/2026 07:53

Thank you all so much that’s really interesting.

I can see how with greater distances to travel to a wedding that the rehearsal adds another dimension as well as different religious aspects.

I think I’d finding it daunting personally to host one but that’s just me! One big get together (actual wedding) is more than enough socialising for me. I wonder (without trying to generalise) if Americans tend to be more sociable?

Also wonder if the rehearsal so close to wedding may cause tensions prior to ceremony? If folks don’t get on or perhaps drink too much or behave inappropriately at the rehearsal?

Thanks for detail re jaywalking too - and tip that buses will wait

OP posts:
CarolinaInTheMorning · 10/09/2026 13:19

I think I’d finding it daunting personally to host one but that’s just me! One big get together (actual wedding) is more than enough socialising for me. I wonder (without trying to generalise) if Americans tend to be more sociable?

I think it's just differences in traditions. For one thing, in the US, we don't generally have a separate "evening do" with a B-list guest list as is common in the UK (and based on MN seems to cause all manner of upset). In the US, there is usually one reception after the wedding and everyone is invited to that. However, not everyone who is invited to the wedding will be invited to the rehearsal dinner. The rehearsal dinner is usually a much smaller guest list.

There is another event that is more a Southern thing: the bridesmaids' luncheon, brunch or breakfast, which has to be slotted into the wedding weekend somewhere. Mine was an informal breakfast the morning of the wedding. The guest list is normally the bridesmaids, the MOB and MOG, and mothers of any children in the wedding party.

SpuytenDuyvil · 10/09/2026 18:26

I agree with @CarolinaInTheMorning. All the events are to give the wedding party an opportunity to get to know each other a little better, especially if there are distances involved. I gave a little luncheon at a nice restaurant for my DM, DSis, DMIL, DSisterIL and DGrandmother-in-law the Friday before our wedding on Sunday. The two sides didn't know each other and it was a pleasant way to meet and hangout. The US is really big. DH and I are in California where the wedding was held, my family is from New England and DH's family is from the South.

PointedFirs · 10/09/2026 18:38

SpuytenDuyvil · 10/09/2026 18:26

I agree with @CarolinaInTheMorning. All the events are to give the wedding party an opportunity to get to know each other a little better, especially if there are distances involved. I gave a little luncheon at a nice restaurant for my DM, DSis, DMIL, DSisterIL and DGrandmother-in-law the Friday before our wedding on Sunday. The two sides didn't know each other and it was a pleasant way to meet and hangout. The US is really big. DH and I are in California where the wedding was held, my family is from New England and DH's family is from the South.

Exactly this. The only two times I’ve been at a US rehearsal dinner, the bride and groom were from Maine and France, and from Massachusetts and Seattle, and their families and close friends had had not much opportunity to meet beforehand.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 10/09/2026 19:55

Similar situation for me. I'm from the Deep South and so are most of my family (one sister hightailed it to the Pacific Northwest at the first opportunity), and DH's family are all from Pennsylvania and New York State. We also had a contingent of close friends coming from California, another from New England and yet another from the Chicago area. This type of situation is very common in the US, where people tend to be fairly mobile, and friends (especially from university years) are often flung far and wide. So you do want to create opportunities at weddings for people to get to know each other better.

I do have to chuckle a bit at some of the wedding threads on MN of the "I'm not having anyone at my wedding I have never met" variety. I met two of my brothers-in-law (actually husbands of DH's sisters) for the first time at my wedding. That's not all that uncommon here in the US, and in the South, it would be considered the height of rudeness to invite one half of a couple and not invite their spouse/partner.

upskilledotter · 10/09/2026 21:45

It all seems very considerate and also quite civilised. Do people tend not to consume much alcohol at these smaller gatherings or rehearsals?

OP posts:
SpuytenDuyvil · 10/09/2026 21:51

@upskilledotter I think it would depend on your crowd. Everyone drinks, but no one really drank to excess at our events.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 11/09/2026 01:32

No one drank to excess (that I am aware of) at any of the family weddings I have attended. In fact, I don't think I've ever been to a wedding event where I noticed anyone who had been visibly drunk. And living in the Bible Belt as I do, I have been to several weddings where no alcohol was served at all.

Add to this, I have also never been to a wedding in the US where guests had to pay for their own drinks. Some have had a complete open bar, while others often will just offer beer and wine.

mathanxiety · 11/09/2026 04:40

Everyone drank at all the weddings and rehearsals I ever went to, but not to the point of drunkenness. That is considered really rude in the US, even in a big northern city with a strongly blue collar identity, and long, cold winters.

All the events had an open bar. Asking guests to pay for their own drinks would be considered cheap and inhospitable.

SpuytenDuyvil · 11/09/2026 04:47

Yes to the open bar. I have never been to a wedding where we had to pay. But, in the US, the bride does not pay for the bridesmaid dresses or shoes or even hair and makeup. I like the way you Brits do it better. Especially when you are young and there are so many weddings, it is incredibly expensive to travel and buy a gift and, if you are in the wedding party, a dress, shoes and all the other stuff.

knitnerd90 · 11/09/2026 08:47

Wedding traditions also vary hugely in the US. A wedding in NYC will be very different from one in rural Nebraska, never mind differences between different cultures and religions. Traditionally, for example, Jews wouldn't have a rehearsal dinner because many of us have a tradition where the bride and groom don't see each other for a week before the wedding (though IME that tradition is weakening amongst the non-observant).

And south Asian weddings put white American ones to shame, they have multiple events and it takes days.

x2boys · 11/09/2026 09:03

CarolinaInTheMorning · 10/09/2026 19:55

Similar situation for me. I'm from the Deep South and so are most of my family (one sister hightailed it to the Pacific Northwest at the first opportunity), and DH's family are all from Pennsylvania and New York State. We also had a contingent of close friends coming from California, another from New England and yet another from the Chicago area. This type of situation is very common in the US, where people tend to be fairly mobile, and friends (especially from university years) are often flung far and wide. So you do want to create opportunities at weddings for people to get to know each other better.

I do have to chuckle a bit at some of the wedding threads on MN of the "I'm not having anyone at my wedding I have never met" variety. I met two of my brothers-in-law (actually husbands of DH's sisters) for the first time at my wedding. That's not all that uncommon here in the US, and in the South, it would be considered the height of rudeness to invite one half of a couple and not invite their spouse/partner.

I think thats probably a mumsnet thing tbh
Most people would expect to be able to take there partner to a wedding in the uk too.

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 11/09/2026 09:34

To all you lovely Americans,I just wanted to say I'm thinking of you today. I remember watching Sky news and seeing the second plane hit live. It is the most atrocious thing I've ever seen in my lifetime and probably will ever see. It still shocks me to my core, even 25 years on. Never forget 🫂🇺🇸

AngleofRepose · 11/09/2026 18:51

Youllnevergetabetterbitofbutteronyourknife · 11/09/2026 09:34

To all you lovely Americans,I just wanted to say I'm thinking of you today. I remember watching Sky news and seeing the second plane hit live. It is the most atrocious thing I've ever seen in my lifetime and probably will ever see. It still shocks me to my core, even 25 years on. Never forget 🫂🇺🇸

Thank you for that. I've been thinking about it a lot today, as well as 7/7. And feeling very down, somehow. Hardly seems like 25 years ago. It's certainly not a week that I will ever forget. 💐 for everyone who remembers

MissConductUS · 11/09/2026 22:16

AngleofRepose · 11/09/2026 18:51

Thank you for that. I've been thinking about it a lot today, as well as 7/7. And feeling very down, somehow. Hardly seems like 25 years ago. It's certainly not a week that I will ever forget. 💐 for everyone who remembers

I feel the same way. It’s especially poignant for me as a New Yorker who was in the city that day. The smell was awful for weeks afterwards, which made it hard to forget about momentarily.

Ineffable23 · 11/09/2026 22:34

I'm also thinking of you folks. I can't really believe it was a quarter of a century ago.

upskilledotter · 18/09/2026 21:37

Thank you all for responses so far and I also echo sentiments re 9/11.

It felt disrespectful to ask more questions without taking a pause.

I have a few other general questions if anyone happy to indulge me - and please feel free to ask your own things or if from USA ask here re equally unfathomable or confusing European/UK things!

Are basements a thing? Are they in most houses? What are they used for? I have seen films where they are creepy af but also ones where they are bedrooms too

Do you buy school supplies for you children or are they probably the school? I mean things like paper, pens, books, rulers etc

Do you get annoying older kids on Trick or Treat night? Do you have mischief night? What do you do if you don’t want to participate (as a child or adult)?

What one convenience that is common in the US do you rate above all others?

Does no one ever steal from those outdoor post boxes? And do newspaper delivery kids really throw papers onto the lawn or porch as seen in films?

How can you tell that someone is American or Canadian? I can’t tell with accents but is it obvious to North Americans?

OP posts:
rachel734 · 18/09/2026 22:41

Hello, upskilledotter! I am enjoying these questions. I'll just tackle a few.

Basements are common in many parts of the U.S., though not in places that are flood-prone. They may be finished (with paneling and carpet, supposedly habitable) or unfinished. Some are partially finished and partially unfinished. My mother’s basement is unfinished; it is used for laundry (including a drying rack), the cat’s litter box, and storage. My brother once had a small workshop there. It's also the tornado shelter. A finished basement might include a TV room or a party area with a built-in bar. To me, a basement never feels quite as finished as the rest of the house; there tend to be spiders, bugs or other critters, and dust. There is some natural light, but it’s always shadowy. Even outside known flood zones, flooding occasionally happens; I lost many of my childhood keepsakes when my mother’s basement flooded while I was away at university. On the plus side, basements are naturally cooling. When I was a teenager, in a house without air-conditioning, I would go down to the basement on hot summer afternoons and sit on the cold cement floor.

I’ve never heard of anyone stealing for an outdoor post box. In New York City, people worry about the theft of packages from the unlocked vestibules of apartment buildings, but I don’t think it happens very often.

I don’t usually know if new acquaintances are Canadian until they tell me. At the same time, I’m usually not surprised. There is an accent zone that spans Ontario, the population hub, and the Upper Great Lakes region of the U.S., where I grew up. If I hear an accent very similar to mine, I tend to guess Michigan, Minnesota, or Ontario. The Quebec accent is distinct from a French accent, with more relaxed vowels and a sing-song cadence. Canadians from Ontario and sometimes even Quebec feel more culturally familiar to me, as a product of the Upper Midwest, than do Americans from the South and Southwest. Incidentally, people in the UK often take me for Canadian based on my accent (which is I rather like, and perceive as a compliment).

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2026 06:33

I can often tell someone is Canadian but it’s not 100%. Newfoundland has a very distinct accent. Many Francophone Quebecois have an accent in English (and they have a distinct accent in French that i can hear). There is a tell that many Canadians have where “about” is closer to “aboat” (sometimes parodied as aboot, but it’s not). And there are some vocabulary differences. But I have heard Canadians who are indistinguishable from what’s called General American (the non-geographically-specific accent).

i have never had anything stolen from curbside mail. It’s a serious crime actually. Not everyone has curbside mail; the density of your neighbourhood determines whether you have curbside mail or if the mail carrier walks around the neighbourhood and the mailbox is fixed next to the door. Some newer neighbourhoods have cluster boxes where there is a central bank of mail boxes.

basements are normal in most of the northeast/Mid-Atlantic and Midwest, though some homes are on slab foundations. For geographical reasons they’re not used in Florida or Texas and I don’t think they’re done in California. In the Midwest/Great Plains states you really want the basement because it’s where you go if there’s a tornado.

Here in the mid-Atlantic, while newer homes have main level or upstairs laundry, homes from before 1990 or so have it in the basement. Often it’s in the unfinished part so the machines are on concrete and there’s just a single lightbulb with a pull chain. Some basements do get done up really nicely. It also depends on the house. If it’s on a hill, the basement may be a walkout in back and you’ll have decent windows and lighting.

i bought school supplies. What my friend’s district did was great: the PTA organised all the supplies for the elementary students and the children just had to bring pencils. (I’m not sure if elementary students are eating the pencils or feeding them to the electric pencil sharpener, but they go through so many!) In secondary it’s trickier. I haven’t had any of the more outrageous demands you hear about online. We did learn straight away that the teachers are dead serious about Crayola crayons and Dixon Ticonderoga pencils. The cheap ones break right away.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2026 06:49

Basements:
I'd say 95% of the houses and apartment buildings where I live have basements. Some are very spiffy, with huge TVs, big couches, walls finished with drywall, full bathroom, built in storage, laundry room, all furnaces and boilers, etc partitioned off. They serve as family rooms, places to watch a big game, spaces to put a ping pong table, hold a children's party, etc. A basement has to have a door to the outside of the building as well as access to the rest of the house, per building/ fire regs.

Apartment buildings sometimes have storage cubicles for residents, older buildings have the washing machines and dryers in the basement.

School.supplies - depends on the school. My DCs went to a RC elementary school that issued a supply list in spreadsheet form, one page for all grades from PK3 to 8th grade, with the items down the left of the page, the grades across the top, and the quantity of items in each grid square. I used to just draw a vertical line with a highlighter to keep track of what to buy. The items on the list included markers (finenpoint and stubby point), colored pencils, crayons - colors plus skin tone crayons, water colors, poster paint, paint brushes, rulers, erasers (art as well as pencil), red pens, blue pens, pencils (Ticonderoga brand), black "Flair" felt tip pens, highlighters, protractor and other geometry stuff, binders, loose paper for binders, dividers for binders, one subject notebooks, three subject notebooks, five subject notebooks, some wide ruled and some narrow ruled, pocket folders, composition notebooks, graph paper, calculator (not TI for elementary), small ziplock bags, gallon ziplock bags, antibac wipes, hand sanitizer, boxes of tissues, rolls of paper towels, and I know there was more. Books were all state loaned and issued by the school. Each book was numbered, and you had to return it at the end of the year. The books were free, but if you lost or destroyed a book, you had to pay a token amount as a fine.
In high school (state) there was an initial book deposit, but that was shelved for purposes of equity. Again all books were loaned, with items like modern novels, Shakespeare, etc, bought from the school bookstore at a steep discount. The school supplied everything students needed for all areas of art, music, cooking, sewing, and also provided swimsuits (speedos for everyone) for daily swimming when students did their semester in of daily swimming (PE daily for four years). The school.also provided school PE shorts and T-shirt for $5 per year. Students bought their own writing supplies, binders, and loose leaf paper. The school issued chromebooks to all students. Students had to buy their own TI calculators.

Hallowe'en is a a lot of fun here. Kids usually decide for themselves around age 15ish that trick or treating isn't for them any more, and they have parties instead. Some get their hands on fireworks and set then off. Older kids/ teens don't really make nuisances of themselves here the way they do in the UK. There isn't any evening traipsing around with friends, so not the same culture of mischief any night, let alone Hallowe'en. Back in the 1950s, vandalism and wild behaviour were much more the norm, but Hallowe'en was turned into a very family friendly holiday by the 1970s, and it remains so. It's generally understood that trick or treating is over at 9pm - we get the odd knock on the door after that, and frankly, if we have any candy left, the kids are welcome to it.

Most convenient US thing - basements, screens for windows, AC, right turns on red, four way stops, dryers...

Stealing from a postbox is a crime, iirc.
There's much less casual theft around here (suburb of a large midwest city) than in Britain, or at least much less fear of it, and a strong assumption that it would not happen.

Paper routes are a thing of the past. About twenty years ago, a family used to deliver papers all over town. The parent drove a van slowly up and down each street with the back doors open, and teenagers would jog alongside, tossing the papers they got from the back of the van onto front porches or into bushes. Neighbours would later exchange whatever landed on their property for the paper that should have been thrown at them.

I get Canadians and Americans mixed up, especially Canadians from the west.

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2026 09:28

Oh yes, the best small convenience has to be window screens!

you also learn quickly that in much of the US, air conditioning and dryers are closer to necessities than luxuries. Over half the year, if I wanted to line dry, I would have to do it indoors.

I did have to buy the TI calculators. I was almost able to pass eldest's down to DC3, but she needed it one more year. I had to buy a few novels for English but mostly they were supplied (there were optional texts in AP classes). High schoolers are provided with laptops/chromebooks. I had to supply headphones, wired only. Our high school got rid of mandatory PE uniform during Covid. Public schools in my area don't have uniforms (they do in DC proper and parts of the South).

trainedopossum · 19/09/2026 11:12

Where I grew up in the suburbs (NYC commuter belt) our house was built in 1920 and had a basement. It was “unfinished” so concrete floors and blocks for walls and a metal basement door that was almost horizontal and opened outward into the back yard. We lived at the top of a gentle hill and the basement was always dry (damp with patches of powdery white mould, but no water) until one year when there was unusual heavy rainfall and it flooded (like a pp I had moved out and a lot of my childhood stuff was lost).

My dad’s basement used to flood regularly and there was a channel built into the edges of the concrete floor to deal with that on some level although there was also an electric pump when it got too wet. Nothing was kept down there except the washer and dryer and he had a fridge and freezer to keep game (he was a hunter).

My mum moved to the barrier island that runs down the east coast (maybe 50 miles southeast of our old home) when she retired and that house had no basement. She says the house was “built on a slab” which I think just means the foundation is directly under the living space. There was a crawlspace for pipes and wires and if you had a holiday home you could squeeze under there and turn the water off at the end of the season to avoid burst pipes in the winter.

That house was destroyed by a storm in 2012 and she rebuilt on pilings to protect from future floods, so the new house is suspended (maybe 12-14 feet?) above the ground. No basement obvs. They also require your washing machine, air conditioner etc to be on a higher level so the laundry room is upstairs on the bedroom level and the AC is on a higher platform outside, that’s required to rebuild and have access to insurance, mortgage etc. This is largely due to global warming changes and it used to be a southern coastal feature but you see it in more places now.

The house sways and shakes in the wind and one time when I was visiting there was a very tiny earthquake and the drawer pulls on a dresser vibrated audibly for about 15 seconds afterwards.

I don’t think I’ve ever had so many thoughts about basements 😀

Swipe left for the next trending thread