Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie: Employment Tribunal, associated legal claims, and related matters - thread #68

1000 replies

nauticant · 04/10/2026 13:02

Sandie Peggie, a nurse at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy (VH), brought claims in the employment tribunal against her employer; Fife Health Board (the Board) and another employee, Dr B Upton. Ms Peggie’s claims were of sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination and victimisation. Dr Upton claimed to be a transwoman, that is observed as male at birth but asserting a female gender identity.

The Employment Tribunal hearing started on Monday 3 February 2025 and after a prolonged process judgment was handed down on 8 December 2025. That judgment is being appealed and an appeal hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

A second Employment Tribunal, Sandie Peggie vs Royal College of Nursing, has just been heard. The hearing started on Wednesday 23 September 2026 and ended on Thursday 1 October 2026. It is possible that a decision will be handed down before Christmas of this year.

Additional legal claims have been raised. Sandie Peggie is taking action against three senior managers who were witnesses in the first Employment Tribunal - Dr Kate Searle, Dr Maggie Currer and Esther Davidson, against Carol Potter, the chief executive of NHS Fife, for victimisation, against NHS Fife for discrimination, and against its director of people and culture David Miller for harassment. In addition, Sandie Peggie is being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council over fitness to practice.

The past proceedings were live tweeted by www.x.com/tribunaltweets. Tribunal Tweets are likely to be providing coverage in future proceedings. There's additional information on Tribunal Tweets' substack: www.tribunaltweets.substack.com/.

Links to previous threads #1 to #60 can be found in this thread: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5379717-sandie-peggie-list-of-threads-covering-employment-tribunal-and-afterwards

Thread 61: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5472628-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-61 8 January 2026 to 3 August 2026

Thread 62: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5562302-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-62 3 August 2026 to 24 September 2026

Thread 63: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5581909-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-63 24 September 2026 to 27 September 2026

Thread 64: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583133-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-64 27 September 2026 to 29 September 2026

Thread 65: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583663-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-65 29 September 2026 to 30 September 2026

Thread 66: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584074-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-66 30 September 2026 to 1 October 2026

Thread 67: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584523-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-67 1 October 2026 to ????

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
OP posts:
nauticant · 03/11/2026 07:53

Please would posters continue to post on this thread until it's full before moving over to the new thread. Thanks.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 09:07

Yay, thanks @nauticant- a close shave 😂

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 09:25

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 18:35

I wonder whether I’ll ever be able to make a single post on one of these threads without you chiming in to shame me for contributing?🤔

“Single post” ?

No-one is shaming you, they are disagreeing with you. They are also observing where your sympathies lie and hence what this does to how you read and interpret everything.

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 09:46

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 17:35

119.The claimant did not tell RCN Direct, or SF, that she had a philosophical belief that biological sex is real, important, immutable and not to be conflated with gender identity. She did not refer to holding gender critical or sex realist beliefs (as she was unaware of these terms at the time). She simply stated that she felt uncomfortable that a trans doctor, BU, was using the female changing area and did not feel that BU should do so, referring to a recent news story about Isla Bryson when doing so. The information provided to SF did not convey that the claimant held a philosophical belief, rather than simply an opinion or viewpoint, based on a recent news story.

I think there is a problem here that the idea that men should not use female changing rooms is one that can be held in two different ways: merely as an opinion, which is not worthy of protection, or alternatively as a philosophy, which is, and it is up to the holder to make clear which is the case in good time. Unless and until you say "this is my philosophy" then you are not protected. Which doesn't seem correct to me.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea of having just the mere opinion, based on a recent news story, that Jesus died on the cross for our sins, without that counting as a religious belief worthy of respect.

Edited

I agree. I don't think a union's support for a member should depend on the member knowing the right magic words. However, incompetence is not unlawful discrimination.

The judgment has not, as far as I can see, ruled on whether RCN is hostile to members with GC views and whether that hostility has affected the training or guidance they gave to SF and others. Even if we accept that RCN is hostile to GC views (which I think is pretty clear), that doesn't necessarily mean that hostility was behind SF's actions, for example. However, is there an argument that their hostility meant that SF was not adequately trained, resulting in unlawful discrimination? I don't know. That will be one for the EAT if Sandie appeals.

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 09:49

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 09:25

“Single post” ?

No-one is shaming you, they are disagreeing with you. They are also observing where your sympathies lie and hence what this does to how you read and interpret everything.

All of that pp's posts go well beyond disagreement; she repeatedly makes personal comments, including about my family. The particular post I was responding to said the below, none of which has anything to do with disagreeing with the legal discussion I was having.

*start your own thread outlining your views on people with gender-critical beliefs - or as we prefer to call- sex reality.

But you never do

You work incredibly hard to tell women we should accept men in our spaces with no shame or boundary understanding why some of us object*

StealthTroublemaker · 03/11/2026 10:12

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 09:49

All of that pp's posts go well beyond disagreement; she repeatedly makes personal comments, including about my family. The particular post I was responding to said the below, none of which has anything to do with disagreeing with the legal discussion I was having.

*start your own thread outlining your views on people with gender-critical beliefs - or as we prefer to call- sex reality.

But you never do

You work incredibly hard to tell women we should accept men in our spaces with no shame or boundary understanding why some of us object*

Edited

But the quote you have quoted is accurate. What bit did that poster get wrong?

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 11:08

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 09:49

All of that pp's posts go well beyond disagreement; she repeatedly makes personal comments, including about my family. The particular post I was responding to said the below, none of which has anything to do with disagreeing with the legal discussion I was having.

*start your own thread outlining your views on people with gender-critical beliefs - or as we prefer to call- sex reality.

But you never do

You work incredibly hard to tell women we should accept men in our spaces with no shame or boundary understanding why some of us object*

Edited

But that’s pretty accurate representation of your position. You approach everything from the position that trans women are women and pose no risk (physical, emotional or psychological) to biological women. Anyone who objects to trans women being considered no different to biological women can only be doing so because they are motivated by transphobia.

It’s not “shaming” you.

ickky · 03/11/2026 11:20

Nick Wallis article

nickwallis.substack.com/p/peggie-loses-rcn-tribunal?

Wishesandhorses · 03/11/2026 11:45

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 11:08

But that’s pretty accurate representation of your position. You approach everything from the position that trans women are women and pose no risk (physical, emotional or psychological) to biological women. Anyone who objects to trans women being considered no different to biological women can only be doing so because they are motivated by transphobia.

It’s not “shaming” you.

Yes.

Unless of course the poster feels shame about this view and the way it treats women. In which case no one is 'shaming' them, this is the voice of their conscience telling them that they know it is wrong.

Kirschcherries · 03/11/2026 12:08

I am disappointed for Sandie but not surprised. It was fairly evident the RCN witnesses were ignorant about Forstater, the guidance to affirm child patients as Eunuchs etc. They did roughly follow their normal practice which makes it not discriminatory.

However, whilst RCN has “won” this ET they have suffered damage to their reputation. As a TU representing c600k predominantly women they have illustrated institutional bias against women’s rights. It’s clear there had been no critical thought at Board level and all levels below about the impact on women’s rights by openly and publicly promoting the T part of LGBT+ and supporting no debate = not training staff on Forstater etc.

If I was an RCN member I would be looking to move to the Darlington nurses TU. Hitting the RCN with a significant drop in membership results = lost revenue to fund board members and full time TU reps.

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 03/11/2026 12:28

Kirschcherries · 03/11/2026 12:08

I am disappointed for Sandie but not surprised. It was fairly evident the RCN witnesses were ignorant about Forstater, the guidance to affirm child patients as Eunuchs etc. They did roughly follow their normal practice which makes it not discriminatory.

However, whilst RCN has “won” this ET they have suffered damage to their reputation. As a TU representing c600k predominantly women they have illustrated institutional bias against women’s rights. It’s clear there had been no critical thought at Board level and all levels below about the impact on women’s rights by openly and publicly promoting the T part of LGBT+ and supporting no debate = not training staff on Forstater etc.

If I was an RCN member I would be looking to move to the Darlington nurses TU. Hitting the RCN with a significant drop in membership results = lost revenue to fund board members and full time TU reps.

It does sound like the prioritizing of men that was previously found to permeate the RCN is still alive and well

Bullying, misogyny and sexual culture at Royal College of Nursing, inquiry finds | Nursing | The Guardian

Client Challenge

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/oct/10/bullying-misogyny-and-sexual-culture-at-royal-college-of-nursing-inquiry-finds

rebax · 03/11/2026 12:29

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 09:46

I agree. I don't think a union's support for a member should depend on the member knowing the right magic words. However, incompetence is not unlawful discrimination.

The judgment has not, as far as I can see, ruled on whether RCN is hostile to members with GC views and whether that hostility has affected the training or guidance they gave to SF and others. Even if we accept that RCN is hostile to GC views (which I think is pretty clear), that doesn't necessarily mean that hostility was behind SF's actions, for example. However, is there an argument that their hostility meant that SF was not adequately trained, resulting in unlawful discrimination? I don't know. That will be one for the EAT if Sandie appeals.

From the judgment

The claimant also asserted that SF acted as he did because he had received no training or guidance from the respondent, to help him notice that the claimant’s objection to BU’s use of the women’s changing room was (or might be) a manifestation of a protected belief. If however SF was unaware of particular issues (whether due to lack of training or otherwise) those issues could not have operated on his mind, consciously or subconsciously, when he acted as he did. As noted in Bailey, there is no doctrine of transferred malice.

moto748e · 03/11/2026 12:36

So a full-time TU official knows nothing of one of the most remarked issues in employment law in recent times, because he hasn't had any specialised training? Yeah, right...

Londonmummy66 · 03/11/2026 12:38

moto748e · 03/11/2026 12:36

So a full-time TU official knows nothing of one of the most remarked issues in employment law in recent times, because he hasn't had any specialised training? Yeah, right...

and his ignorance gives them a pass whilst her not knowing that she should have said the magic words means her case fails - double standard pr what?

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 12:56

nutmeg7 · 03/11/2026 11:08

But that’s pretty accurate representation of your position. You approach everything from the position that trans women are women and pose no risk (physical, emotional or psychological) to biological women. Anyone who objects to trans women being considered no different to biological women can only be doing so because they are motivated by transphobia.

It’s not “shaming” you.

I was having a discussion about discrimination law and the burden of proof.

If you can't see why responding to that with "take it elsewhere, you have no shame or boundaries " is not a disagreement with my arguments , but an attempt to shame and silence my person, I really can't help you further.

Have a lovely day.

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 13:15

rebax · 03/11/2026 12:29

From the judgment

The claimant also asserted that SF acted as he did because he had received no training or guidance from the respondent, to help him notice that the claimant’s objection to BU’s use of the women’s changing room was (or might be) a manifestation of a protected belief. If however SF was unaware of particular issues (whether due to lack of training or otherwise) those issues could not have operated on his mind, consciously or subconsciously, when he acted as he did. As noted in Bailey, there is no doctrine of transferred malice.

Edited

Yes, I know that is what the judgment said. The question is whether that is a correct interpretation. If RCN is institutionally biased against women with GC views and, as a result, fails to train reps like SF in those issues even though it provides training in all other types of discrimination and therefore reps fail to recognise the issues, is that unlawful discrimination? I am not saying it is, but I don't think there have been any rulings on this by the higher courts.

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 13:23

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 13:15

Yes, I know that is what the judgment said. The question is whether that is a correct interpretation. If RCN is institutionally biased against women with GC views and, as a result, fails to train reps like SF in those issues even though it provides training in all other types of discrimination and therefore reps fail to recognise the issues, is that unlawful discrimination? I am not saying it is, but I don't think there have been any rulings on this by the higher courts.

It seems to match the judgment given in Maistry vs BBC (which the EJ cited):
https://casenode.ai/case/uk.ewca.civ.2014.1116/maistry-v-british-broadcasting-corporation-2014-ewca-civ-1116 see [5] and [14] of Lord Justice Underhill's refusal to allow permission to appeal from the EAT (I don't have the EAT judgment to hand).

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 13:28

rebax · 03/11/2026 12:29

From the judgment

The claimant also asserted that SF acted as he did because he had received no training or guidance from the respondent, to help him notice that the claimant’s objection to BU’s use of the women’s changing room was (or might be) a manifestation of a protected belief. If however SF was unaware of particular issues (whether due to lack of training or otherwise) those issues could not have operated on his mind, consciously or subconsciously, when he acted as he did. As noted in Bailey, there is no doctrine of transferred malice.

Edited

I'm not sure I follow the argument the tribunal is making here? SF may not have known that being "gender critical" is a protected belief, but he doesn't need to be aware of that to observe SP's behaviour and infer attitudes that he might disapprove of surely? In which case he still could have discriminated against her even if he didn't realise it was discriminatory. Or maybe I have misunderstood

Ereshkigalangcleg · 03/11/2026 13:28

moto748e · 03/11/2026 12:36

So a full-time TU official knows nothing of one of the most remarked issues in employment law in recent times, because he hasn't had any specialised training? Yeah, right...

Well quite. Chinny reckon. These people always have “only just heard last week” about Forstater.

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 13:37

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 13:28

I'm not sure I follow the argument the tribunal is making here? SF may not have known that being "gender critical" is a protected belief, but he doesn't need to be aware of that to observe SP's behaviour and infer attitudes that he might disapprove of surely? In which case he still could have discriminated against her even if he didn't realise it was discriminatory. Or maybe I have misunderstood

Again reading from Maistry vs BBC, Lord Justice Underhill:

The starting point is that since this is a claim based on discrimination what matters is what motivated the various individual colleagues and managers who were responsible for the acts complained of. What the Applicant himself thought or meant by anything he said is not directly relevant. The Tribunal was, therefore, unquestionably right that if the individuals in question were unaware that the Applicant held the philosophical belief in question they could not be motivated by that fact or, therefore, be guilty of discrimination;

What I am seeing is that discrimination against a belief is acceptable; discrimination against the holder of a belief because they hold that belief, is not.

By that reasoning, the union can lawfully decline to support anyone who wants a single-sex changing room, as long as they apply the same criteria to anyone who wants a single-sex changing room (and therefore don't discriminate between people who hold a GC belief and people who don't.)

Or maybe that should properly be argued as indirect discrimination: as a PCP it disproportionately affects people who are GC.

Did SP argue indirect discrimination?

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 13:48

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 13:23

It seems to match the judgment given in Maistry vs BBC (which the EJ cited):
https://casenode.ai/case/uk.ewca.civ.2014.1116/maistry-v-british-broadcasting-corporation-2014-ewca-civ-1116 see [5] and [14] of Lord Justice Underhill's refusal to allow permission to appeal from the EAT (I don't have the EAT judgment to hand).

Edited

Agreed, but I think it may be arguable that this is a different situation. In that instance, the belief was concerned with the higher purpose of public service broadcasting. It was not argued that the BBC was institutionally biased against such beliefs, just that the claimant had been dismissed due to his beliefs. Here, the argument would be that RCN is institutionally biased against GC beliefs and therefore deliberately fails to train reps appropriately, resulting in individuals with such beliefs not being properly supported by the union. I'm not saying the courts would accept this argument, but that is broadly the approach I would take if I was arguing this case.

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 13:53

prh47bridge · 03/11/2026 13:48

Agreed, but I think it may be arguable that this is a different situation. In that instance, the belief was concerned with the higher purpose of public service broadcasting. It was not argued that the BBC was institutionally biased against such beliefs, just that the claimant had been dismissed due to his beliefs. Here, the argument would be that RCN is institutionally biased against GC beliefs and therefore deliberately fails to train reps appropriately, resulting in individuals with such beliefs not being properly supported by the union. I'm not saying the courts would accept this argument, but that is broadly the approach I would take if I was arguing this case.

That's indirect discrimination, isn't it? That the RCN has a PCP that disadvantages anyone who shares a GC belief.

Did she argue indirect discrimination?

rebax · 03/11/2026 13:54

SF original notes also say

discussed with the member the potential that this could be seen as discriminatory and is most likely what has caused the suspension. discussed with member process of investigation and potential outcomes etc

which implies he had some understanding of the issues.

Lacksie · 03/11/2026 14:09

MyAmpleSheep · 03/11/2026 13:37

Again reading from Maistry vs BBC, Lord Justice Underhill:

The starting point is that since this is a claim based on discrimination what matters is what motivated the various individual colleagues and managers who were responsible for the acts complained of. What the Applicant himself thought or meant by anything he said is not directly relevant. The Tribunal was, therefore, unquestionably right that if the individuals in question were unaware that the Applicant held the philosophical belief in question they could not be motivated by that fact or, therefore, be guilty of discrimination;

What I am seeing is that discrimination against a belief is acceptable; discrimination against the holder of a belief because they hold that belief, is not.

By that reasoning, the union can lawfully decline to support anyone who wants a single-sex changing room, as long as they apply the same criteria to anyone who wants a single-sex changing room (and therefore don't discriminate between people who hold a GC belief and people who don't.)

Or maybe that should properly be argued as indirect discrimination: as a PCP it disproportionately affects people who are GC.

Did SP argue indirect discrimination?

Edited

By that reasoning, the union can lawfully decline to support anyone who wants a single-sex changing room, as long as they apply the same criteria to anyone who wants a single-sex changing room (and therefore don't discriminate between people who hold a GC belief and people who don't.)

Oh I see. So the argument is that SP could have wanted a single sex changing room for all kinds of reasons, but the claimant's complaint rested on the claim that she was being discriminated against specifically for holding gender critical beliefs, but SP didn't even know that she held gender critical beliefs, because there could have been other reasons for calling DU "he" and asking for a single sex changing room?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread