Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie: Employment Tribunal, associated legal claims, and related matters - thread #68

1000 replies

nauticant · 04/10/2026 13:02

Sandie Peggie, a nurse at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy (VH), brought claims in the employment tribunal against her employer; Fife Health Board (the Board) and another employee, Dr B Upton. Ms Peggie’s claims were of sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination and victimisation. Dr Upton claimed to be a transwoman, that is observed as male at birth but asserting a female gender identity.

The Employment Tribunal hearing started on Monday 3 February 2025 and after a prolonged process judgment was handed down on 8 December 2025. That judgment is being appealed and an appeal hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

A second Employment Tribunal, Sandie Peggie vs Royal College of Nursing, has just been heard. The hearing started on Wednesday 23 September 2026 and ended on Thursday 1 October 2026. It is possible that a decision will be handed down before Christmas of this year.

Additional legal claims have been raised. Sandie Peggie is taking action against three senior managers who were witnesses in the first Employment Tribunal - Dr Kate Searle, Dr Maggie Currer and Esther Davidson, against Carol Potter, the chief executive of NHS Fife, for victimisation, against NHS Fife for discrimination, and against its director of people and culture David Miller for harassment. In addition, Sandie Peggie is being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council over fitness to practice.

The past proceedings were live tweeted by www.x.com/tribunaltweets. Tribunal Tweets are likely to be providing coverage in future proceedings. There's additional information on Tribunal Tweets' substack: www.tribunaltweets.substack.com/.

Links to previous threads #1 to #60 can be found in this thread: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5379717-sandie-peggie-list-of-threads-covering-employment-tribunal-and-afterwards

Thread 61: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5472628-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-61 8 January 2026 to 3 August 2026

Thread 62: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5562302-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-62 3 August 2026 to 24 September 2026

Thread 63: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5581909-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-63 24 September 2026 to 27 September 2026

Thread 64: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583133-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-64 27 September 2026 to 29 September 2026

Thread 65: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583663-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-65 29 September 2026 to 30 September 2026

Thread 66: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584074-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-66 30 September 2026 to 1 October 2026

Thread 67: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584523-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-67 1 October 2026 to ????

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
NowSober · 02/11/2026 17:08

Wishesandhorses · 02/11/2026 16:33

This reminds me of the one where someone absolutely knew the law much better than the Supreme Court Judges, and for some mad reason just hadn't been asked to be involved.

@Lacksie has previously opined that the Supreme Court got it wrong in FWS.

borntobequiet · 02/11/2026 17:16

I do hope there is the will and wherewithal to appeal. But poor Sandie to have her life now so defined. And her poor witnesses, who have had their own experiences dismissed as worthless.
It’s horrifying.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 17:19

NowSober · 02/11/2026 17:08

@Lacksie has previously opined that the Supreme Court got it wrong in FWS.

Edited

Yes. They are of the herd mentality that when the SC judgement was announced fettered their SM with ‘fuck the Supreme Court judgement’ slogans. I did laugh as my niece did this all over her Insta whilst cosily living in N1 - pretty central London paid for by my sister. I in the meantime opted out of female swimming sessions because men were allowed in.

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 17:25

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 16:55

That is one of the areas where the judgment is potentially challengeable. They say that, even if the union held the belief claimed, that would not establish of itself that the relevant decision makers acted because of that belief. That flies in the face of established case law. If the union holds beliefs that are hostile to GC individuals as contended by NC, that is enough on its own to establish a prima facie case for the union to answer. In an employment case, if a claimant from a racial minority can show that there is evidence that management is racially prejudiced, that is enough to establish a prima facie case. The same standard should apply here. Rather than the tribunal needing evidence that the minds of the relevant decision makers were influenced by the claimant's protected characteristic as stated in this judgment, they should have needed evidence that their minds were NOT so influenced. Despite correctly stating the test at paragraph 106, the way they have set out the test in paragraph 109 appears to reverse the burden of proof from that set out in law.

I disagree with this interpretation , for reasons already discussed on these threads, and not at all surprised to find that the tribunal judge concurs as parag 110.1 makes clear.

In Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police v Bailey [2017] EWCA Civ 425, among the points the Court of Appeal required to consider was the Tribunal’s reference to reports in the bundle ‘which were relied upon as supporting a contention that the respondent was institutionally racist.’ LJ Underhill, giving the leading judgment, stated that he did not accept the submission made that material showing discriminatory conduct or attitudes elsewhere in a particular institution is always inadmissible in considering the motivation of an individual alleged discriminator. He stated that ‘Authoritative material showing that discriminatory conduct or attitudes are widespread in the institution may, depending on the case, make it more likely that the alleged conduct occurred, or that the alleged motivations were operative. Or there may be some more specific relevance…But
such material must always be used with care, and the Tribunal must in any case identify with specificity the particular reason why it considers the material in question to have probative value as regards the motivation of the alleged discriminator(s) in any particular case: as Elisabeth Laing J put it, there is no “doctrine of transferred malice

NowSober · 02/11/2026 17:34

I didn't hear all the evidence but I know Sandie's solicitor wasn't a witness so how was the statement reported in Paragraph 25 gathered as evidence?

MG stated that the work was being funded by Sex Matters, who were of the view that the claimant’s case, and it the issues it raised, were of significant strategic importance.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 17:35

119.The claimant did not tell RCN Direct, or SF, that she had a philosophical belief that biological sex is real, important, immutable and not to be conflated with gender identity. She did not refer to holding gender critical or sex realist beliefs (as she was unaware of these terms at the time). She simply stated that she felt uncomfortable that a trans doctor, BU, was using the female changing area and did not feel that BU should do so, referring to a recent news story about Isla Bryson when doing so. The information provided to SF did not convey that the claimant held a philosophical belief, rather than simply an opinion or viewpoint, based on a recent news story.

I think there is a problem here that the idea that men should not use female changing rooms is one that can be held in two different ways: merely as an opinion, which is not worthy of protection, or alternatively as a philosophy, which is, and it is up to the holder to make clear which is the case in good time. Unless and until you say "this is my philosophy" then you are not protected. Which doesn't seem correct to me.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea of having just the mere opinion, based on a recent news story, that Jesus died on the cross for our sins, without that counting as a religious belief worthy of respect.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 17:40

@Lacksie you ‘disagree’ with anything and anyone that does nor affirm anything trans.

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 17:53

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 17:25

I disagree with this interpretation , for reasons already discussed on these threads, and not at all surprised to find that the tribunal judge concurs as parag 110.1 makes clear.

In Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police v Bailey [2017] EWCA Civ 425, among the points the Court of Appeal required to consider was the Tribunal’s reference to reports in the bundle ‘which were relied upon as supporting a contention that the respondent was institutionally racist.’ LJ Underhill, giving the leading judgment, stated that he did not accept the submission made that material showing discriminatory conduct or attitudes elsewhere in a particular institution is always inadmissible in considering the motivation of an individual alleged discriminator. He stated that ‘Authoritative material showing that discriminatory conduct or attitudes are widespread in the institution may, depending on the case, make it more likely that the alleged conduct occurred, or that the alleged motivations were operative. Or there may be some more specific relevance…But
such material must always be used with care, and the Tribunal must in any case identify with specificity the particular reason why it considers the material in question to have probative value as regards the motivation of the alleged discriminator(s) in any particular case: as Elisabeth Laing J put it, there is no “doctrine of transferred malice

Edited

I think we are all aware that you disagree with established case law. You think the burden of proof is on the claimant to show that decisions were made due to discriminatory beliefs. The law says otherwise. All the quote you've picked out from the judgment shows is that an ET must identify why it considers material showing discriminatory conduct elsewhere in an organisation has probative value. It does NOT mean that such evidence is insufficient to establish a prima facie case. There is plenty of case law to show that it can be.

Peregrina · 02/11/2026 17:54

I sincerely hope that Sandie Peggie has the stamina to appeal. But this has been going on for three years now, so if she felt that it was the end of the road for her, I would not blame her.

Meanwhile, Upton is now beginning to cause trouble in Australia.

I was a retired member of my union - it wasn't one of the worse, but we had the usual sob story about trans people (men almost certainly) when the Supreme Court judgement was announced. So on the strength of that opinion being expressed I have resigned my membership.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 17:55

@Lacksie you could make fortune getting off MN and stepping up with your understanding and knowledge of literally everything.

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 18:03

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 17:53

I think we are all aware that you disagree with established case law. You think the burden of proof is on the claimant to show that decisions were made due to discriminatory beliefs. The law says otherwise. All the quote you've picked out from the judgment shows is that an ET must identify why it considers material showing discriminatory conduct elsewhere in an organisation has probative value. It does NOT mean that such evidence is insufficient to establish a prima facie case. There is plenty of case law to show that it can be.

My point was always that alleged institutional ‘capture’ does not automatically establish discrimination—its relevance to the facts of the particular case has to be shown. The tribunal expressly took that approach, as I always held. You’ve declared that an error of law. Well, I’m not surprised is all I can say.

(Of course, not to mention that flying a Pride flag and respecting people’s pronouns cannot, in themselves, reasonably be considered sufficient to establish hostility towards people with gender-critical beliefs—but that’s a separate point.)

prh47bridge · 02/11/2026 18:17

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 18:03

My point was always that alleged institutional ‘capture’ does not automatically establish discrimination—its relevance to the facts of the particular case has to be shown. The tribunal expressly took that approach, as I always held. You’ve declared that an error of law. Well, I’m not surprised is all I can say.

(Of course, not to mention that flying a Pride flag and respecting people’s pronouns cannot, in themselves, reasonably be considered sufficient to establish hostility towards people with gender-critical beliefs—but that’s a separate point.)

Edited

It was not claimed that flying a Pride flag, etc., established hostility towards people with GC beliefs. Plenty of other evidence was invoked to show that such hostility existed. And all I've said about the judgment is that a particular paragraph looks challengeable as it appears to reverse the burden of proof set out in law. That does not mean an EAT would overturn the judgment (or that the higher courts would uphold that if they did).

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 18:27

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 18:03

My point was always that alleged institutional ‘capture’ does not automatically establish discrimination—its relevance to the facts of the particular case has to be shown. The tribunal expressly took that approach, as I always held. You’ve declared that an error of law. Well, I’m not surprised is all I can say.

(Of course, not to mention that flying a Pride flag and respecting people’s pronouns cannot, in themselves, reasonably be considered sufficient to establish hostility towards people with gender-critical beliefs—but that’s a separate point.)

Edited

Then as suggested many times @Lacksie start your own thread outlining your views on people with gender-critical beliefs - or as we prefer to call- sex reality.

But you never do. We get tribunals are lost based on legal arguments.

You work incredibly hard to tell women we should accept men in our spaces with no shame or boundary understanding why some of us object.

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 18:35

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 18:27

Then as suggested many times @Lacksie start your own thread outlining your views on people with gender-critical beliefs - or as we prefer to call- sex reality.

But you never do. We get tribunals are lost based on legal arguments.

You work incredibly hard to tell women we should accept men in our spaces with no shame or boundary understanding why some of us object.

I wonder whether I’ll ever be able to make a single post on one of these threads without you chiming in to shame me for contributing?🤔

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 18:50

@Lacksie show me you are a misogynist without trying - ‘chiming in’. Ok. I will get back in the kitchen and shut up.

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 19:05

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 18:50

@Lacksie show me you are a misogynist without trying - ‘chiming in’. Ok. I will get back in the kitchen and shut up.

Edited

‘Chiming in’ because the same personal comments and criticism sound out, repeatedly and reliably, every time—like a bell.

Hedgehogforshort · 02/11/2026 19:07

I just scroll by the TRA’s nonsense now. I am very pleased that our resident lawyers are making helpful analysis.

As with FWS cases have to be dragged out of Scotland in to the senior Courts to get away from Scottish judicial capture.

i was not surprised by this judgement.

I think Sandy will continue in her mission, and am so glad she has the support of the Darlington nurses.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 19:11

Lacksie · 02/11/2026 19:05

‘Chiming in’ because the same personal comments and criticism sound out, repeatedly and reliably, every time—like a bell.

What personal comments or criticisms am I sounding out? You clearly have a deep dislike for Sandie Peggie. You do not even try to disguise it.

NotInMyyName · 02/11/2026 19:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FedUpCelery · 02/11/2026 19:57

I just scroll by the TRA’s nonsense now. I am very pleased that our resident lawyers are making helpful analysis.

Me too. It's a bit like AI. That causes me to zone out too.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 20:01

FedUpCelery · 02/11/2026 19:57

I just scroll by the TRA’s nonsense now. I am very pleased that our resident lawyers are making helpful analysis.

Me too. It's a bit like AI. That causes me to zone out too.

Much of it is sourced via AI. Not necessarily this specific example but some posters get all their talking points from it. The ones who don’t get it from risible sources like the Good Law Project, as well as Reddit and BlueSky where dissenting views are blocked or banned. As AI also heavily draws from Reddit which also has a lot of posters posting AI slop so it’s all self reinforcing.

WFTCHTJ · 02/11/2026 20:14

That was quick. Perhaps we ought to give @nauticant a quick heads up that the latest rash of updates aren't due to another round of pigeon chess, but something relevant actually happening, so thread 69 may be needed soon.

KeepupKardigans · 02/11/2026 21:44

I am disappointed in the ruling particularly that SP needed to state her disquiet as a protected belief despite her being unaware. The important point for me is the service she has done for women in challenging the management of these institutions for their erroneous decisions, intimidation and outright bullying. Managers/ CEO’s/HR/ Unions and even the likes of DU etc must now be under no illusion that women with pc’s are no longer powerless/easily silenced and often championed to challenge/question for their basic rights. In the future(years) those decision makers may have to publicly defend their actions and disclose their processes at tribunals. No more skulking in the shadows backed by corporate legal teams dragging out cases to maximise claimant’s costs and hindering disclosure as a means of controlling the narrative. Us women are watching along with being kind. For that alone SP’s courage should be applauded. It ain’t over yet not by a long chalk.

CatProcrastinator1 · 02/11/2026 23:34

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 17:35

119.The claimant did not tell RCN Direct, or SF, that she had a philosophical belief that biological sex is real, important, immutable and not to be conflated with gender identity. She did not refer to holding gender critical or sex realist beliefs (as she was unaware of these terms at the time). She simply stated that she felt uncomfortable that a trans doctor, BU, was using the female changing area and did not feel that BU should do so, referring to a recent news story about Isla Bryson when doing so. The information provided to SF did not convey that the claimant held a philosophical belief, rather than simply an opinion or viewpoint, based on a recent news story.

I think there is a problem here that the idea that men should not use female changing rooms is one that can be held in two different ways: merely as an opinion, which is not worthy of protection, or alternatively as a philosophy, which is, and it is up to the holder to make clear which is the case in good time. Unless and until you say "this is my philosophy" then you are not protected. Which doesn't seem correct to me.

I'm trying to wrap my head around the idea of having just the mere opinion, based on a recent news story, that Jesus died on the cross for our sins, without that counting as a religious belief worthy of respect.

Edited

I'm really sorry if I missed it during the case, but don't the Workplace (Health , Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 with regard to single sex changing rooms apply here? Is the reason the RCN did not mention these on Sandie's behalf is the RCN's dislike of the consequences of implementation for men who say they are women in these sort of cases?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.