Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie: Employment Tribunal, associated legal claims, and related matters - thread #68

1000 replies

nauticant · 04/10/2026 13:02

Sandie Peggie, a nurse at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy (VH), brought claims in the employment tribunal against her employer; Fife Health Board (the Board) and another employee, Dr B Upton. Ms Peggie’s claims were of sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination and victimisation. Dr Upton claimed to be a transwoman, that is observed as male at birth but asserting a female gender identity.

The Employment Tribunal hearing started on Monday 3 February 2025 and after a prolonged process judgment was handed down on 8 December 2025. That judgment is being appealed and an appeal hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

A second Employment Tribunal, Sandie Peggie vs Royal College of Nursing, has just been heard. The hearing started on Wednesday 23 September 2026 and ended on Thursday 1 October 2026. It is possible that a decision will be handed down before Christmas of this year.

Additional legal claims have been raised. Sandie Peggie is taking action against three senior managers who were witnesses in the first Employment Tribunal - Dr Kate Searle, Dr Maggie Currer and Esther Davidson, against Carol Potter, the chief executive of NHS Fife, for victimisation, against NHS Fife for discrimination, and against its director of people and culture David Miller for harassment. In addition, Sandie Peggie is being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council over fitness to practice.

The past proceedings were live tweeted by www.x.com/tribunaltweets. Tribunal Tweets are likely to be providing coverage in future proceedings. There's additional information on Tribunal Tweets' substack: www.tribunaltweets.substack.com/.

Links to previous threads #1 to #60 can be found in this thread: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5379717-sandie-peggie-list-of-threads-covering-employment-tribunal-and-afterwards

Thread 61: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5472628-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-61 8 January 2026 to 3 August 2026

Thread 62: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5562302-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-62 3 August 2026 to 24 September 2026

Thread 63: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5581909-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-63 24 September 2026 to 27 September 2026

Thread 64: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583133-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-64 27 September 2026 to 29 September 2026

Thread 65: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583663-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-65 29 September 2026 to 30 September 2026

Thread 66: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584074-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-66 30 September 2026 to 1 October 2026

Thread 67: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584523-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-67 1 October 2026 to ????

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 13:29

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 27/10/2026 13:23

We have known for over 3000 years, since Greek writers and Hebrew writers (among others, those are just the ones I'm most aware of) that a man, the type that provides sperm, and a woman, the type that provides eggs and gestates and gives birth and feeds, are needed for reproduction. We all know the differences between women and men. A few examples where it's more difficult to tell don't invalidate the definition, but of course those whose whole identity depends on this being complicated try to pull down any definition by saying that this or that exception invalidates it completely. So we have to explain how the definition actually works.

None of this nitpicking makes a man a woman or a woman a man. Most trans people, from a point in puberty, are absolutely clearly male (sperm producers, such as Dr Upton) or female (egg producers, such as Isla Bumba, Esther Davidson, Kate Searle, Sandie Peggie). We don't need to check that they actually produce, or even have the capacity to produce, gametes to be sure which they are, because it is nearly always obvious.

I hope that was polite enough. I'm only human, and I get frustrated when people play dumb or nitpick in order to 'win' an argument.

I sometimes wonder how people think the human race evolved with noone knowing until a week a last Thursday that males made sperm and females made eggs. Did we rely on pure chance to produce offspring both human and in the animals we domesticated and bred?

Tallisker · 27/10/2026 13:30

My cat definitely preferred men. Tart.

NotAtMyAge · 27/10/2026 13:31

Tallisker · 27/10/2026 13:30

My cat definitely preferred men. Tart.

Whereas our male rescue cat seems to prefer women. He's fine with DH for brushing and stroking, but come to me for a cuddle and a lie-down.

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 27/10/2026 13:52

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 13:29

I sometimes wonder how people think the human race evolved with noone knowing until a week a last Thursday that males made sperm and females made eggs. Did we rely on pure chance to produce offspring both human and in the animals we domesticated and bred?

As I’ve said before on these threads, I presume we all just ran around bashing our nethers randomly into each other until something happened.

Frankly, for me it’s the fact that until 5 minutes ago, none of this was even in question. It reminds me of something I read recently about AI use: it’s as if, a year after automatic doors were invented, your friend insisted that not only could they not open a door with a door knob, but in fact that no one, anywhere in the world, was currently able or had ever been able to open a door with a door knob.

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 14:13

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 27/10/2026 13:52

As I’ve said before on these threads, I presume we all just ran around bashing our nethers randomly into each other until something happened.

Frankly, for me it’s the fact that until 5 minutes ago, none of this was even in question. It reminds me of something I read recently about AI use: it’s as if, a year after automatic doors were invented, your friend insisted that not only could they not open a door with a door knob, but in fact that no one, anywhere in the world, was currently able or had ever been able to open a door with a door knob.

We had fertility investigations coming up for 20 years ago. At no point did they check my sperm count or DHs egg reserves. Should I sue do we think?

MarieDeGournay · 27/10/2026 14:40

So you claim that 'male' and 'female' are distinguishable by the size of gametes, GriseldaandMike?

Female mammals are the ones with the type of body that is formed to produce large gametes, male mammals have bodies of the type that is formed to produce small mobile gametes.

Maybe they're not small gametes, maybe they're just far away....
😁

GrandmaMazur · 27/10/2026 14:46

Blimey. I’ve finally caught up with these threads. Thank you for all the information from the RCN case. I am looking forward to the Union showcasing women’s rights merchandise and flags.

However, all that back and forth with one person is so tedious. It really made me think just how much havoc can be wreaked in an organisation by just one personality disordered transperson!

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 15:19

MarieDeGournay · 27/10/2026 14:40

So you claim that 'male' and 'female' are distinguishable by the size of gametes, GriseldaandMike?

Female mammals are the ones with the type of body that is formed to produce large gametes, male mammals have bodies of the type that is formed to produce small mobile gametes.

Maybe they're not small gametes, maybe they're just far away....
😁

No no I'm suggesting they didn't do a sperm count of the person that had a long conversation about football with the consultant and they didn't find out if the person with long hair was ovulating. This must be negligence.

ickky · 27/10/2026 15:54

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 27/10/2026 09:19

Newborns don’t make gametes; neither do post-menopausal women, nor many infertile women, nor women who’ve had hysterectomies

Crikey. That was a pretty basic misunderstanding.

I hate this saying but...

Tell me you're male without telling me you're male.

Helleofabore · 27/10/2026 16:01

ickky · 27/10/2026 15:54

I hate this saying but...

Tell me you're male without telling me you're male.

Considering the lectures we have been subject to in the past about sex development and categorisation in the past, it did seem a very uninformed post.

It is almost like a poster was too keen to do some kind of ‘gotcha’ that they didn’t actually think it through. In the past, I have quoted dr Emma Hilton who talks about this on Twitter.

ickky · 27/10/2026 16:05

I really cannot believe anyone engages with the troll. They are delighted that they know they are winding you all up.

We have all heard the gender slop for years, enough now.

Do not get mugged off.

ickky · 27/10/2026 16:06

I am also looking forward to seeing Carol Potter being questioned.

When does everyone think it will be, Summer?

NotAtMyAge · 27/10/2026 16:08

HannahinHampshire · 27/10/2026 16:04

More from the Dundee Courier (who have been great covering Sandie’s case)
https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/politics/5606276/inside-nhs-fife-talks-sandie-peggie-statement/

Archive version: https://archive.ph/hnquc

ickky · 27/10/2026 16:12

I still can't believe NHS Fife released that statement. I think the Tribunal would have ended earlier that day but for all of the JR interruptions.

We all got to the see it play out.

So Good Chefs Kiss GIF by Your Happy Workplace
NaomiCunninghamHasHadHerWeetabixAgain · 27/10/2026 16:59

At best, I'd have thought it was a well intentioned but completely idiotic off-the-cuff press release from someone who just wanted it all to go away and everyone to be nice to each other......but the lawyer was actually involved in this?! I mean, commenting on a live case via a press release and the lawyer at no point advised 'we should not be doing this'. Astonishing levels of incompetence. Utterly astonishing.

DrBlackbird · 27/10/2026 17:18

HannahinHampshire · 27/10/2026 16:04

More from the Dundee Courier (who have been great covering Sandie’s case)
https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/politics/5606276/inside-nhs-fife-talks-sandie-peggie-statement/

I find the photos used in that article illuminating. There’s SP facing the camera, smiling, saying this is who I am. There’s Dr U wrapped up with just the eyes showing as if to prevent judgement from strangers reading the article who would otherwise say, that looks like a bloke to me. No comment on JR.

CriticalCondition · 27/10/2026 18:10

ickky · 27/10/2026 16:12

I still can't believe NHS Fife released that statement. I think the Tribunal would have ended earlier that day but for all of the JR interruptions.

We all got to the see it play out.

Yes, Casting my mind back, I think according to the original listing dates the hearing was due to end that day, a Friday. But JR had objected and deliberately waffled on so much it was running well behind. As the week went on the statement (9 plus drafts) was bouncing around between Potter and HR and Comms and it looks like the Fife lawyer, who was aware of the continuing hearing and the impact a statement might have on it, did not sign off the final draft.
But Fife were so determined to get it out that someone there who didn't realise the legal implications and/or that the hearing was still ongoing pressed the button.

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 18:15

Does any one with Fife local knowledge have any thoughts on who the politician might be? From the other end of the UK it sometimes feels like everyone in politics north of the boarder is fully captured.

NoWordForFluffy · 27/10/2026 18:27

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 18:15

Does any one with Fife local knowledge have any thoughts on who the politician might be? From the other end of the UK it sometimes feels like everyone in politics north of the boarder is fully captured.

Won't it be the guy (whose name escapes me) who has been on Sandie's side the whole time?

GriseldaandMike · 27/10/2026 18:31

NoWordForFluffy · 27/10/2026 18:27

Won't it be the guy (whose name escapes me) who has been on Sandie's side the whole time?

That was sort of my assumption but I was wondering if there were any other candidates.

moto748e · 27/10/2026 18:55

Neale Hanvey? No longer an MP, though.

NoWordForFluffy · 27/10/2026 19:05

moto748e · 27/10/2026 18:55

Neale Hanvey? No longer an MP, though.

He was at the time of the tribunal though. I think the quote is from an email sent at the time of publication of the statement.

ETA: he was a politician, not an MP.

WearyAuldWumman · 27/10/2026 22:03

NoWordForFluffy · 27/10/2026 19:05

He was at the time of the tribunal though. I think the quote is from an email sent at the time of publication of the statement.

ETA: he was a politician, not an MP.

Edited

Neale Hanvey was the MP for Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy until 2024. (Gordon Brown's former constituency.)

I do wonder what Gordon Brown's take on this is... He doesn't strike me as someone who is daft and he was brought up in the area, so he's likely to have a good handle on how we locals feel about it.

I recall that the local Labour MSPs supported the Lamont amendment.

NoWordForFluffy · 27/10/2026 22:05

WearyAuldWumman · 27/10/2026 22:03

Neale Hanvey was the MP for Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy until 2024. (Gordon Brown's former constituency.)

I do wonder what Gordon Brown's take on this is... He doesn't strike me as someone who is daft and he was brought up in the area, so he's likely to have a good handle on how we locals feel about it.

I recall that the local Labour MSPs supported the Lamont amendment.

Yes, but he was still a politician until March 2026 (depute leader of Alba from March 2025). I corrected my post to say he was a politician, not an MP.

ETA: the story calls him a 'politician'.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.