Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

I cannot be a people manager anymore

113 replies

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 18:29

I have been a people manager for around 15 years. I have always enjoyed managing people, playing a part in their development and helping them to reach their potential. I I have a track record of running high performing and happy teams.

I’d been consulting for a couple of years where I hadn’t been doing any management then about 10 months ago, I started a role where I had a team again. I have five direct reports and a team of about 20 in total. My direct reports are generally all fine. They take the work seriously and I can trust them to diligently get on with it.

The juniors are a total and utter nightmare. I’ve got three different teams and my biggest team has eight juniors. We work in professional services in house so they are all highly qualified.

They think they are more important than everybody else, they have no work ethic, they waffle on about their work life balance all the time, they don’t do things I ask them to do and they don’t even bother to apologise or acknowledge that they were asked to do them in the first place. They all want things all of the time and they expect me to solve all of their problems at home and at work.

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce. It’s exhausting and I hate it. I feel like I’m pushing water up a hill constantly. I’ve missed key deadlines because I can’t get my team to deliver.

And I’ve decided I’m done. Life is too short for this. I’m trying to juggle being a parent to young children, a shiftwork husband and a high-pressure full-time senior level job. I can’t take this level of responsibility on top of everything else. I’m not their mother I’m their boss.

Do I just go in and resign next week?

OP posts:
BakedAl · Yesterday 18:34

Talk to HR. Apunds like your direct reports need advice on how to handle the juniors. If they aren't doing what's expected they need to start a capability process.

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

JustFrustrated · Yesterday 19:00

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

Sorry where is she ageist?

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 19:04

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

I can’t see any ageism. In my last job I was a junior member of staff - I was also the oldest member. Junior indicates position, not age, in a work context.

Ilikewinter · Yesterday 19:09

Totally understand you OP! Can you afford to resign?, if so then I'd be out of there like a shot!.

SilverGlitterBaubles · Yesterday 19:09

I think that people management is becoming increasingly difficult especially when you are expected to solve your team members problems at home and at work. Workplaces are no longer seen simply as places where people get the job done and earn a salary, there is an expectation now to be an all round support system. It is certainly more challenging than it used to be OP.

Ilikewinter · Yesterday 19:10

Oh you could also tell your boss that your not happy, so the 'company culture' isn't working for you and what he is going to do to support you!?

Lemonfrost · Yesterday 19:36

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

Are you one of juniors OP is talking about 😂

DandyTealSeal · Yesterday 19:40

I feel you, people seem to blame everything on work rather than looking at the whole picture and expect me to resolve it for them. Nothing to do with age, in fact the younger ones are the ones that are much more enthusiastic and bringing new ideas. I’m actively thinking about what I can do outside of managing staff.

VivX · Yesterday 19:43

You can't be expected to ensure everyone's happiness at all times inside and outside work, that's bonkers.
Also, they're there to do their job, which is the primary purpose of their employment, presumably.
Your boss's expectations of happiness cannot be at the expense of doing their work. If your boss insists that their happiness trumps their work then s/he'll have to reduce their expectations of meeting deadlines.

Also, your direct reports need to manage the juniors better. I appreciate they are doing their own work diligently but they're failing to properly manage the juniors.
For example, why are you having to ask the juniors to do work and problem-solve for them isn't that the job of your direct reports?

What personal problems are they expecting to be solved by their employer?

ArcticPebble · Yesterday 19:45

Do a bit of reverse mentoring or whatever it's called. Shadow a few of the juniors for a day or two. Best case scenario, you find out more about what their issues are and can work on solving them.

tulippa · Yesterday 19:45

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce.

There is a balance to be had. They can't just do what they fancy. They're getting paid for their work. SLT who won't support you in managing poor behaviour will make your job impossible.

MummyWillow1 · Yesterday 19:50

It is unreasonable for any employee to expect their line manager to resolve personal problems - if the company want to offer that level
of support it should be provided by professionals (there are companies who specialise in this). All
you are required to do as a line manger is refer to occ health where appropriate or point them
in the right direction (eg their GP). It is inappropriate and unprofessional to be giving personal advice beyond recommending where to get a decent lunch near the office and which coffee shop has decent coffee.

Mumofamasingboys · Yesterday 19:51

I hear you. I am also a people manager trying to get out of managerial role.

tumbledownwalls · Yesterday 20:03

Sounds slightly toxic. Are your direct reports supposed to be managing the juniors?

Babyenroute · Yesterday 20:08

I hear you too! It's becoming increasingly hard to manage corporate expectations and expectations of the juniors these days. I appreciate that the ideal would be somewhere in the middle but my attitude to work when I first joined was so different. I tried to describe what the expectations were like back then to my team and they admitted they would have just quit.

Blanketwaffle · Yesterday 20:16

I hear you - and I expect a lot of fellow senior managers are also pulling their hair out. I would add that on top of all you listed that everyone, but more so the more junior staff, are ill a lot and struggle with their wellbeing. I say this as someone that works in a low pressure happy place to work company.

LifeIsTooShort247 · Yesterday 20:39

I do not blame you its the main reason I do not move up because it means managing people and its a thankless task and often the payrise is not enough to justify having to deal with it all.

StartupRepair · Yesterday 20:44

I found I just couldn't be a manager while I had young DC. Just drained me in the same way at home and work. Now DC are grown I have much more energy and patience for managing and developing teams. So it may be seasonal for you.

chirrupybird · Yesterday 20:49

Just be less available and less helpful, surely it's their immediate bosses that should sort out the kiddies little problems.

mumumental · Yesterday 21:09

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

She is not.

mumumental · Yesterday 21:13

I think the likely cause is poor immediate management by your reports and possibly a misunderstood company culture. People can’t have everything they want. You have to be reasonable, though.

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:13

I hear what you’re all saying about my direct reports managing but a lot of the stuff comes up to me as an escalation point because the direct reports are at the end of their tether.

Several of them wanted to go to an extra training session a law firm was running on a given morning. I suggested we divide and conquer and look at the training sessions available through the whole training season (we get invited to umpteen things) and workout who was going to go to what. One of the juniors turned around to me and said, “well how are you proposing to train me if I can’t go to the training sessions I want? I’m junior and you need to train me.” Someone else feels “let down by the company” even though she has had all of her training funded by the company and been given extensive day release to attend college days (she she’s had a way above what a normal expectation would be for a trainee). But she feels constantly aggrieved because somebody else is qualifying a few months before her and she can’t get past her jealousy. Somebody else has been complaining about salary since the day he joined last December and now sits next to me browsing the job ads on LinkedIn and doing his fantasy football when he should be working. Every so often he tells his manager and me how much he could be earning elsewhere. Somebody else wants a sabbatical next year because since qualifying their mental health is really suffering. We don’t have a sabbatical policy an HR are telling me this is not something we can offer.

There’s loads more of these examples. These are just the ones fresh in my mind from this week.

OP posts:
EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:15

Someone else needs time off this coming week because their dog is ill and sought my advice on how to get a sick dog to the vet when you don’t have a car. I’ve no idea, I don’t have a dog.

OP posts:
Huckleberries · Yesterday 21:24

@EleanorRigby34 “Somebody else has been complaining about salary since the day he joined last December and now sits next to me browsing the job ads on LinkedIn and doing his fantasy football when he should be working. Every so often he tells his manager and me how much he could be earning elsewhere”

okay, and what have you said to him about browsing LinkedIn and playing fantasy football? Or his manager?

If it’s coming from the top that you have to pander to these people, then that’s a problem.

I have heard industry leaders saying that this is a big problem now, that there’s a sort of level of handholding that’s expected, because the culture is no longer about work Support

I heard a complaint from someone about a workplace session on stress. It seems to have come as a shock to her that the session was about managing workplace stress. What else would it be about? She really thought it was going to be about managing the stress of life in general. I explained that a workplace session is obviously going to be geared to getting the most out of the workforce, but that seemed to be a totally foreign concept to her