Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

I cannot be a people manager anymore

113 replies

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 18:29

I have been a people manager for around 15 years. I have always enjoyed managing people, playing a part in their development and helping them to reach their potential. I I have a track record of running high performing and happy teams.

I’d been consulting for a couple of years where I hadn’t been doing any management then about 10 months ago, I started a role where I had a team again. I have five direct reports and a team of about 20 in total. My direct reports are generally all fine. They take the work seriously and I can trust them to diligently get on with it.

The juniors are a total and utter nightmare. I’ve got three different teams and my biggest team has eight juniors. We work in professional services in house so they are all highly qualified.

They think they are more important than everybody else, they have no work ethic, they waffle on about their work life balance all the time, they don’t do things I ask them to do and they don’t even bother to apologise or acknowledge that they were asked to do them in the first place. They all want things all of the time and they expect me to solve all of their problems at home and at work.

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce. It’s exhausting and I hate it. I feel like I’m pushing water up a hill constantly. I’ve missed key deadlines because I can’t get my team to deliver.

And I’ve decided I’m done. Life is too short for this. I’m trying to juggle being a parent to young children, a shiftwork husband and a high-pressure full-time senior level job. I can’t take this level of responsibility on top of everything else. I’m not their mother I’m their boss.

Do I just go in and resign next week?

OP posts:
EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:38

The company’s employment contracts stipulate a start time of 9am. I have historically not cared much about stuff like this but my boss had asked them all to come in for 9 before I started because they all were wandering in halfway through the morning, making breakfast to eat at their desks and she felt like hardly any work was getting done before lunch. Then they’d all start to drift off by 5. None of them have caring responsibilities or live far away. I do and I have to be at breakfast club bang on when it opens at 7.45 to guarantee I’ll be in for 9 so I rush about screaming at my kids in the morning because I’m constantly worried I’m going to be late. I’ve never done this before ever in my career.

Everywhere else I’ve worked I’ve had the luxury of trusting my people to get the work done as and when it needed to be done. They were hard-working and diligent and didn’t need micro managing. I’ve never cared about start or finish times because I knew they were all easily doing their hours and probably more. But I guess in a place where the culture is to do the bear minimum making them do their hours is the only control my boss feels she has.

OP posts:
EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:40

Huckleberries · Yesterday 23:18

Well, everybody doesn’t have to start work at 9 am

I do think people shouldn’t be on their LinkedIn and fantasy football at work, but you didn’t wanna answer that

What answer were you expecting? I don’t think people should be browsing LinkedIn jobs or doing their fantasy football at work either, so I agree with you. If you’re asking me what I’ve done about it, the answer is nothing because it would cause a massive furore.

OP posts:
ApplesAreAmazing · Yesterday 23:49

If you're thinking of leaving why don't you start managing them as you see fit. That is hold a meeting and tell them the need to work! Give them all an action plan, pip or something and put a bomb under them and tell them they are lucky to have a job!

Huckleberries · Today 00:05

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:40

What answer were you expecting? I don’t think people should be browsing LinkedIn jobs or doing their fantasy football at work either, so I agree with you. If you’re asking me what I’ve done about it, the answer is nothing because it would cause a massive furore.

Yeah, you’re really up against it if no one will back you up complaining about that

Time to look elsewhere, I think
I don’t know how this company is going to survive from the sound of it

PanteraRosa · Today 00:10

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

Excuse me, have you just assumed that all of the juniors are young? Whoops 😂

Friendlygingercat · Today 00:24

I hear you OP and know where you are coming from. I was in this position in my early 40s. I was working in local government at a public service point. So I had the worry of the service users whining and sometimes the staff as well. I dropped the rope and went off to uni but I was single and childfree. I went on to become an academic but I was managing projects not people.

When I see these proposals to make jobs for all these young people who have slight nervous conditions i wonder who is going to manage them and work with them? Most jobs are hard enough without having a bunch of lame ducks to coddle.

Frankenspencer · Today 00:28

My team are middle aged and have the same problems you mention op, along with critical illness, ailing parents, and aversion to change.

Being the boss is tough regardless of your or their age! That’s why we get the extra 3.50 a month!

saymynamesaymynamedestinyschild · Today 00:30

Are they young? Late teens, early twenties? These are probably the people that saw some of their peers get special treatment at school because they couldn’t cope with lessons so they had extra ‘decompression’ playtime to make them more manageable in class.

ComedyGuns · Today 00:39

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

What?

EleanorRigby34 · Today 08:48

saymynamesaymynamedestinyschild · Today 00:30

Are they young? Late teens, early twenties? These are probably the people that saw some of their peers get special treatment at school because they couldn’t cope with lessons so they had extra ‘decompression’ playtime to make them more manageable in class.

They’re a mix of ages mid 20s to mid 30s

OP posts:
Gengha · Today 08:51

ApplesAreAmazing · Yesterday 23:49

If you're thinking of leaving why don't you start managing them as you see fit. That is hold a meeting and tell them the need to work! Give them all an action plan, pip or something and put a bomb under them and tell them they are lucky to have a job!

This really

Having a “happy workforce” doesn’t mean they should be allowed to take the piss. They don’t sound happy anyway if they are whining constantly

If you can afford to resign then I would abd make sure you cite your own managers weak management as the reason

Monty36 · Today 08:55

I experienced some of this years ago. Moaning constantly about the lack of opportunities. Moaning that they were not invited to every single meeting.
Some of them had a very peculiar attitude to work. And for some reason felt being on the lowest rung of the ladder was demeaning. I had to explain I started on the lowest rung of the ladder. It wasn’t a demeaning activity. They often did not want to actually do the tasks related to that job. I found it odd.
One or two expected to be promoted after six months or so. Just because they had a degree. I had to remind them many people had a degree plus a lot of work experience. It had not occurred to them that when they left university others would have done so year on year ahead.
I felt sometimes it was not their fault. They have been raised as a generation who expects to get what they want, told they are really clever and to look down their nose at older generations. They are the products of their upbringing. So they can come across as immature and entitled.
But as a manager it is hard work. And personal performance jobs seemed much more attractive compared to managing staff. Where you just are responsible yourself for what work gets done.
This is a general view of some staff. They did want to get on, they wanted to do more but didn’t have the patience to realise that doing the first rung job was actually a very good grounding toward the next.
As to letting someone not do work in front of you, no, you have to manage that I am afraid. And smart backchat I wouldn’t put up with either. It is really annoying but that is the job.

Mulledjuice · Today 08:56

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:15

Someone else needs time off this coming week because their dog is ill and sought my advice on how to get a sick dog to the vet when you don’t have a car. I’ve no idea, I don’t have a dog.

it sounds a big tiresome but it also sounds like you and your DRs need some training/support in having difficult performance conversations.

Gengha · Today 08:58

Lifeistulips · Yesterday 23:03

I can’t help but think, good. ‘Waffling on’ about life/ work balance? Good. I’m glad the years of employers demanding the souls of their employees is over. Fair play to workers who want fair play. By combating this you’re not helping yourself, only the billionaire owners of large companies.

I do think this is true, to be fair. I now do the same. Laptop goes off at 5.30 on the dot provided I’ve recorded enough time (always have) and the work piling up going out of KPI is a them problem. I work hard but I have too much of it. These people don’t even work when they are there according to OP.

As for the expecting work to be a solution for everything, I have found this too. Staff eg suspended/long term sick - get given a welfare contact - moan they are only available during business hours and “who do I call if I am struggling at weekends or in the evening?” - erm your family, friends, the Samaritans?

DreamyRedNewt · Today 09:10

It would be interesting to hear the other side of the story from the staff in more junior positions. You have to find a balance and try to keep staff happy (without meaning they can do whatever they want) but there has to be some give and take. Because if you don't keep them happy, they will leave and if most people are unhappy the reality is that the problem may be you. What do you think is going to happen? If you replace all staff and keep the same conditions, most likely they will all be un happy too.

BeKhakiReader · Today 09:26

I agree with the pp who said if you’re considering leaving, you’ve nothing to lose. Next time the bloke is on fantasy football in work time, look him in the eye and tell him it’s inappropriate and to get on with his work. If he doesn’t, raise the appropriate report. Remind people, in writing, that the start time is 9am. Etc etc. stop letting them walk over you.

DreamyRedNewt · Today 09:32

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:38

The company’s employment contracts stipulate a start time of 9am. I have historically not cared much about stuff like this but my boss had asked them all to come in for 9 before I started because they all were wandering in halfway through the morning, making breakfast to eat at their desks and she felt like hardly any work was getting done before lunch. Then they’d all start to drift off by 5. None of them have caring responsibilities or live far away. I do and I have to be at breakfast club bang on when it opens at 7.45 to guarantee I’ll be in for 9 so I rush about screaming at my kids in the morning because I’m constantly worried I’m going to be late. I’ve never done this before ever in my career.

Everywhere else I’ve worked I’ve had the luxury of trusting my people to get the work done as and when it needed to be done. They were hard-working and diligent and didn’t need micro managing. I’ve never cared about start or finish times because I knew they were all easily doing their hours and probably more. But I guess in a place where the culture is to do the bear minimum making them do their hours is the only control my boss feels she has.

It is a shame that you are screaming at your kids for the sake of not being 5 minutes late that you can make up for later...In my job we have a manager very similar to you, being just three minutes late is such a massive problem, even if you stay later to make up for the time it seems to be a problem. Nobody would dare to make breakfast where I work though, that will be probably considered fraud and I am not even exaggerating! So stressful (I have a daughter and need to drop her off breakfast club), I many times have been feeling on edge of a panic attack just because I am running late (5/10 minutes) and wondered if I can keep doing this job. Just for thr sake of 5 minutes in a non public facing job where I then can work until later and have lunch at my desk most days anyway. Ridiculous way to stress people out. The sickness and turnover is crazy

Staff not knowing their responsabilities, KPI's...if your direct reports responsability

BeKhakiReader · Today 09:38

DreamyRedNewt · Today 09:32

It is a shame that you are screaming at your kids for the sake of not being 5 minutes late that you can make up for later...In my job we have a manager very similar to you, being just three minutes late is such a massive problem, even if you stay later to make up for the time it seems to be a problem. Nobody would dare to make breakfast where I work though, that will be probably considered fraud and I am not even exaggerating! So stressful (I have a daughter and need to drop her off breakfast club), I many times have been feeling on edge of a panic attack just because I am running late (5/10 minutes) and wondered if I can keep doing this job. Just for thr sake of 5 minutes in a non public facing job where I then can work until later and have lunch at my desk most days anyway. Ridiculous way to stress people out. The sickness and turnover is crazy

Staff not knowing their responsabilities, KPI's...if your direct reports responsability

I don’t think that’s a fair comment. It’s not the OP who’s saying everyone has to be in by 9.

Mumtoabillion · Today 09:41

I feel you..When dealing with a Flexible working request going on about work life balance and the menopause I was wondering the same. But you do need to have a reasonably happy and certainly a productive work force..

Depends how employable you feel right now. and your personal finances. Sorry haven't RTFT. I do get where you're coming from. Good luck

MushMonster · Today 09:42

Right this is a tough situation for you and your direct reports.
There is a lack of work ethics in your workplace. The origin is surely this keep them happy shite. What does that mean? You are there to keep them working, performing and progressing. If they do not like it, then they can leave. Ask hep from HR.
You cannot allow for a worker to sit by you wasting time. That spreads to others faster than light. Asses his performance, set targets, disciplinaries if he keeps fucking around.
Training, set max hours, stop them getting all the emails about training, send the emails only to the managers and you sort which dates you want to offer. Set a min and max training targets.
The dog thing, good of you to allow time, be kind. This one you have to suck it up, I think. I do not know really, works well. Follow, I hope you can figure it up.

The most important thing is to challenge this keep them happy shite.

ProfessorofDarkArts · Today 09:45

I’ve recently left a job for exactly this reason. I felt more like a counsellor than a boss and it was a nightmare trying to juggle people’s increasing needs outside of the workplace that impacted on how, where and when they could do their job. I got very little support from management and in the end I’d had enough. A few extra grand a year wasn’t worth the stress.

MushMonster · Today 09:48

DreamyRedNewt · Today 09:32

It is a shame that you are screaming at your kids for the sake of not being 5 minutes late that you can make up for later...In my job we have a manager very similar to you, being just three minutes late is such a massive problem, even if you stay later to make up for the time it seems to be a problem. Nobody would dare to make breakfast where I work though, that will be probably considered fraud and I am not even exaggerating! So stressful (I have a daughter and need to drop her off breakfast club), I many times have been feeling on edge of a panic attack just because I am running late (5/10 minutes) and wondered if I can keep doing this job. Just for thr sake of 5 minutes in a non public facing job where I then can work until later and have lunch at my desk most days anyway. Ridiculous way to stress people out. The sickness and turnover is crazy

Staff not knowing their responsabilities, KPI's...if your direct reports responsability

I think to be strict with timing and company time is important. In these circumstances.
Would I be flexible for a parent dropping their child? Yes. 5-10 min. Just sort meeting around this member of the team. No problem.
But, what about those who arrive at 9:30 or close to 10, then go to make themselves breakfast. Then proceed to take 1 hour lunch. And scroll the internet too. Then moans that they have to stay late.... Flexibility does not work for everyone. Some people feels like work is an extension of their living room coach.

PooPooPootin · Today 09:56

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:53

Maybe but I used to have one or two of these things at a time. Now I have multiple every week. And any piece of work I have ever asked to be done has never been done or done in a half baked way after the deadline because I chased. I have zero authority. I’ve given up asking for them to do things now and just get Copilot to produce all my first drafts instead, it’s much less obnoxious!

In other places I also had the freedom to put people on a PIP, exit them, give them tough feedback etc. Here I’m supposed to be nice to everyone all the time. My boss just laughs and says they remind her of her teenage kids and I need to accept it what’s young people are like now and that they will all complain to HR at the drop of a hat so watch yourself 😩

Edited

How is your company still in business? Does it make or do something very specialist that cannot be done by anyone else?

MushMonster · Today 10:15

As the issue seems to rest with the juniors, I suppose the undone tasks are smaller things, like tidying up, revising documents, getting quotes, taking inventory, maintaining spreadsheets....
These would have to be addressed at some point by the direct line managers and this may not be that visible for a while. Just stressfull for those who have to pick up the slack. They have missed deadlines, so that should trigger a full on investigation of why.
Only managing personals tasks by allocating them in a formal system and setting a deadline for each can this be properly monitored. Then those guilty can have this old thing called consequences.

mybiggreenfrog · Today 10:19

You've got to manage those who are not hitting deadlines, including getting rid if they continue to do so longer term.

Swipe left for the next trending thread