Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

I cannot be a people manager anymore

113 replies

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 18:29

I have been a people manager for around 15 years. I have always enjoyed managing people, playing a part in their development and helping them to reach their potential. I I have a track record of running high performing and happy teams.

I’d been consulting for a couple of years where I hadn’t been doing any management then about 10 months ago, I started a role where I had a team again. I have five direct reports and a team of about 20 in total. My direct reports are generally all fine. They take the work seriously and I can trust them to diligently get on with it.

The juniors are a total and utter nightmare. I’ve got three different teams and my biggest team has eight juniors. We work in professional services in house so they are all highly qualified.

They think they are more important than everybody else, they have no work ethic, they waffle on about their work life balance all the time, they don’t do things I ask them to do and they don’t even bother to apologise or acknowledge that they were asked to do them in the first place. They all want things all of the time and they expect me to solve all of their problems at home and at work.

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce. It’s exhausting and I hate it. I feel like I’m pushing water up a hill constantly. I’ve missed key deadlines because I can’t get my team to deliver.

And I’ve decided I’m done. Life is too short for this. I’m trying to juggle being a parent to young children, a shiftwork husband and a high-pressure full-time senior level job. I can’t take this level of responsibility on top of everything else. I’m not their mother I’m their boss.

Do I just go in and resign next week?

OP posts:
LadyLapsang · Today 15:48

In terms of the culture, you are very much reliant on senior leaders and the quality of your HR function, not to do the managing, but to have your back (assuming you are doing the right thing). I have been a people manager for over four decades, but was doing a personal performance role more recently, and coming back to managing staff has been a total eye opener, and not in a good way.

It’s not solely age, we had a fantastic Oxbridge undergraduate during the summer who could have easily stayed on. I could see some of the juniors looking at them and wondering why they got some great opportunities. I imagine lots thought it was to do with class etc. but didn’t make the connection with their great timekeeping, attendance, willingness to work hard / finish work - even on basic tasks, positive attitude etc. I think those that come from families where their parents model this type of behaviour have such a head start.

On the browsing LinkedIn for work, in times gone past, we would have given them some extra work because clearly they didn’t have enough to do; they would have got the message if they had to treasury tag some briefing papers. Now, some would probably complain.

EleanorRigby34 · Today 17:20

Thank you all, so much good advice on this thread.

I think you’ve all given me a good reality check. The culture is broken and I don’t have management’s support to drive high performance.

Im going to hand in my notice this week and go back to consulting whilst I regroup and reflect on this experience. It’s really impacted my confidence and I need to work out how I get that back and what I might be able to do in the future that’s more of an individual contributor role.

OP posts:
Dinnerontheterrace · Today 18:54

You should do what’s right for you OP.

I don’t think this is your fault or that you are a bad manager. The rules have changed drastically and it’s very difficult to deal with people who are messing around. It requires a good HR team and unified senior management which seems to be missing.

MummyWillow1 · Today 19:07

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:13

I hear what you’re all saying about my direct reports managing but a lot of the stuff comes up to me as an escalation point because the direct reports are at the end of their tether.

Several of them wanted to go to an extra training session a law firm was running on a given morning. I suggested we divide and conquer and look at the training sessions available through the whole training season (we get invited to umpteen things) and workout who was going to go to what. One of the juniors turned around to me and said, “well how are you proposing to train me if I can’t go to the training sessions I want? I’m junior and you need to train me.” Someone else feels “let down by the company” even though she has had all of her training funded by the company and been given extensive day release to attend college days (she she’s had a way above what a normal expectation would be for a trainee). But she feels constantly aggrieved because somebody else is qualifying a few months before her and she can’t get past her jealousy. Somebody else has been complaining about salary since the day he joined last December and now sits next to me browsing the job ads on LinkedIn and doing his fantasy football when he should be working. Every so often he tells his manager and me how much he could be earning elsewhere. Somebody else wants a sabbatical next year because since qualifying their mental health is really suffering. We don’t have a sabbatical policy an HR are telling me this is not something we can offer.

There’s loads more of these examples. These are just the ones fresh in my mind from this week.

Why are you allowing them
to get away with this behaviour? The one browsing Linked In - if he thinks the grass is greener let him
go. We’ve just had almost 500 people apply for 1 job - you will
replace them in a flash with someone who actually wants to be there.

Gwenna · Today 19:10

NimbleLemonEagle · Yesterday 22:27

Just re. the pets thing. Once worked with a guy who had loads of cats. Every time one was run over ( which was a lot) his wife would call him in sick. Too heartbroken to come in. He would be off for days each time. This was late 90s so not a Gen Z problem.

He would be a total anomaly back then though. Things have definitely changed - you see a lot more unhinged behaviour like that these days.

Gwenna · Today 19:12

LadyLapsang · Today 15:48

In terms of the culture, you are very much reliant on senior leaders and the quality of your HR function, not to do the managing, but to have your back (assuming you are doing the right thing). I have been a people manager for over four decades, but was doing a personal performance role more recently, and coming back to managing staff has been a total eye opener, and not in a good way.

It’s not solely age, we had a fantastic Oxbridge undergraduate during the summer who could have easily stayed on. I could see some of the juniors looking at them and wondering why they got some great opportunities. I imagine lots thought it was to do with class etc. but didn’t make the connection with their great timekeeping, attendance, willingness to work hard / finish work - even on basic tasks, positive attitude etc. I think those that come from families where their parents model this type of behaviour have such a head start.

On the browsing LinkedIn for work, in times gone past, we would have given them some extra work because clearly they didn’t have enough to do; they would have got the message if they had to treasury tag some briefing papers. Now, some would probably complain.

I’ve experienced a similar attitude from a younger entitled staff member at the same level, who also didn’t make the connection with my good attitude etc.!.

Meeatcheese · Today 19:35

I felt like this but luckily at the end of my career. The self-obsessed, entitled, whining strutting, the utter contempt for the customers, the flakiness, the tears, the arguments about who got to sit by a window, the bitchiness about their peers…I spent the journey home leaving all the WhatsApp groups and I’ve never looked back. I feel for you.

MushMonster · Today 19:37

I think it is a shame that you are leaving your job because their lack of work ethics. It should not be like this.
But I fully get it and if you can jump into another role to keep you financially, that makes sense. Your health is more important. Wishing you the best.
On the overall, managers and colleagues cannot be picking up the slack left by lazy and disengaged idiots like these. And senior management needs to support this.
There are plenty of hard working people. Plenty. Many of them looking for a job.

Daisymail · Today 19:43

Atlastarest · Today 12:51

Honestly if you have no support from your boss or higher up, you will never win and you will waste your life trying to tie yourself in knots trying to get somewhere. How dare your boss laugh when you tell her you’re struggling! It’s that which stands out for me. Your boss doesn’t have to boss, your workers don’t have to work, but somehow old Sally in the middle (you) has to produce output and cohesion with zero back up from either side? No.

"Your boss doesn't have to boss, your workers don't have to work, but somehow old Sally in the middle (you) has to produce output and cohesion with zero backup from either side"

This☝️for your own sanity, leave.

BlueOrangeRed · Today 19:55

hdhdjd · Yesterday 18:57

You are ageist so its best you quit while you are ahead

What an odd thing to take away from reading the OP. And anyway, OP mentions she’s got young children so she’s unlikely to be over 45 or so.

Junior staff can be any age, as can senior staff.

Zanatdy · Today 20:27

They need to wind their necks in. I had a young member of the team call me this week to argue his case why he should have got more reward for something when he’s had so much and trust me, he really did not deserve this and was due to some kind of miscommunication. He felt he had to argue his cause and I said I welcome the discussion, but really I was thinking i’d never be so rude challenging my manager who generously gives me rewards on a regular basis. I’m just grateful for what I get. Hope my own adult kids don’t behave like this in the workplace.

EleanorRigby34 · Today 20:35

Daisymail · Today 19:43

"Your boss doesn't have to boss, your workers don't have to work, but somehow old Sally in the middle (you) has to produce output and cohesion with zero backup from either side"

This☝️for your own sanity, leave.

This quote absolutely nails how I feel!

OP posts:
Newusername2026 · Today 20:48

So these juniors report into your direct reports I think. If so you you need to focus on developing that management layer to train and manage the juniors properly. That might mean some external management training which your own bosses should facilitate for the overall good and growth of the organisation. It may not be the fault of the juniors but just that until now they have not had to deal with problems

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread