Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

I cannot be a people manager anymore

113 replies

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 18:29

I have been a people manager for around 15 years. I have always enjoyed managing people, playing a part in their development and helping them to reach their potential. I I have a track record of running high performing and happy teams.

I’d been consulting for a couple of years where I hadn’t been doing any management then about 10 months ago, I started a role where I had a team again. I have five direct reports and a team of about 20 in total. My direct reports are generally all fine. They take the work seriously and I can trust them to diligently get on with it.

The juniors are a total and utter nightmare. I’ve got three different teams and my biggest team has eight juniors. We work in professional services in house so they are all highly qualified.

They think they are more important than everybody else, they have no work ethic, they waffle on about their work life balance all the time, they don’t do things I ask them to do and they don’t even bother to apologise or acknowledge that they were asked to do them in the first place. They all want things all of the time and they expect me to solve all of their problems at home and at work.

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce. It’s exhausting and I hate it. I feel like I’m pushing water up a hill constantly. I’ve missed key deadlines because I can’t get my team to deliver.

And I’ve decided I’m done. Life is too short for this. I’m trying to juggle being a parent to young children, a shiftwork husband and a high-pressure full-time senior level job. I can’t take this level of responsibility on top of everything else. I’m not their mother I’m their boss.

Do I just go in and resign next week?

OP posts:
WimbleOfWombledon · Yesterday 21:33

It sounds like no one is managing this poor behaviour at work - you and the rest of the management team need to set clear expectations with the whole team and explain what the consequences are of not meeting them (eg formal action).

I can’t believe someone is getting away with doing fantasy football and job searching in work time in full view of their snr manager. Anyone doing that in my workplace would have an informal conversation about it then next time - disciplinary action. He’s paid to work - not do his personal admin!

its perfectly possible to have a nice happy workplace without letting people take the piss!

greenheetah · Yesterday 21:38

These examples all sound like general people management issues tbh.

Maybe you just aren’t in the right place right now to take on this role?

SilverGlitterBaubles · Yesterday 21:38

The expectation seems to be that work is a substitute support system for people’s personal lives. While most managers are equipped to deal with certain circumstances such as illness or major life events they are not equipped to be social workers, therapists or parents to their team. Trying to deliver the actual work is incredibly challenging while also dealing with all this extra stuff that simply was not part of the workplace 5-10 years ago.

SilverGlitterBaubles · Yesterday 21:41

Agreed @WimbleOfWombledonthis behaviour would warrant a serious conversation.

greenheetah · Yesterday 21:42

SilverGlitterBaubles · Yesterday 21:38

The expectation seems to be that work is a substitute support system for people’s personal lives. While most managers are equipped to deal with certain circumstances such as illness or major life events they are not equipped to be social workers, therapists or parents to their team. Trying to deliver the actual work is incredibly challenging while also dealing with all this extra stuff that simply was not part of the workplace 5-10 years ago.

I disagree. I was managing a department of about 35 people 10/15 years ago.

Complaints about training, squabbles about who had had the most personal development experience, issues with sick pets, staff dealing with divorce and bereavement, job dissatisfaction and people being arseholes, needing to be put through a capability process, wanting to work flexibly. All part of the role…

Greatbigtuna · Yesterday 21:52

Its the big companies fault with all the 'bring your whole self to work' and 'we care deeply about our employees' bullshit. The employees took them seriously and now need a handhold and emotional support to get through the working day.

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:53

greenheetah · Yesterday 21:42

I disagree. I was managing a department of about 35 people 10/15 years ago.

Complaints about training, squabbles about who had had the most personal development experience, issues with sick pets, staff dealing with divorce and bereavement, job dissatisfaction and people being arseholes, needing to be put through a capability process, wanting to work flexibly. All part of the role…

Maybe but I used to have one or two of these things at a time. Now I have multiple every week. And any piece of work I have ever asked to be done has never been done or done in a half baked way after the deadline because I chased. I have zero authority. I’ve given up asking for them to do things now and just get Copilot to produce all my first drafts instead, it’s much less obnoxious!

In other places I also had the freedom to put people on a PIP, exit them, give them tough feedback etc. Here I’m supposed to be nice to everyone all the time. My boss just laughs and says they remind her of her teenage kids and I need to accept it what’s young people are like now and that they will all complain to HR at the drop of a hat so watch yourself 😩

OP posts:
Minasama · Yesterday 21:57

You shouldn’t be handling the juniors, your direct reports should, with you as the threat option. Do they have the accountability ladder, regular 1:1s and use Excel/Microsoft planner and team meetings to hold these people to account?
Failing that, PIP or verbal warnings?

If this is a general problem with juniors, can HR hold some sessions about behavioural expectations, what gets rewarded with bonus etc?

SilverGlitterBaubles · Yesterday 22:04

I think a big part of the problem OP is that you do not have the authority you need to manage.

greenheetah · Yesterday 22:05

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:53

Maybe but I used to have one or two of these things at a time. Now I have multiple every week. And any piece of work I have ever asked to be done has never been done or done in a half baked way after the deadline because I chased. I have zero authority. I’ve given up asking for them to do things now and just get Copilot to produce all my first drafts instead, it’s much less obnoxious!

In other places I also had the freedom to put people on a PIP, exit them, give them tough feedback etc. Here I’m supposed to be nice to everyone all the time. My boss just laughs and says they remind her of her teenage kids and I need to accept it what’s young people are like now and that they will all complain to HR at the drop of a hat so watch yourself 😩

Edited

It sounds like you have a shit boss problem.

The Gen Z staff at my workplace are really hardworking and quite brilliant tbh. The two who give me regular issues are Millennials.

I would start looking around for something else. Or keep encouraging your boss to go for other jobs. That worked for me once.

Boreded · Yesterday 22:07

No you document it, pips in place, start moving them out if they don’t improve. You’ve managed people for 15 years yet it sounds like you’ve stopped now and just let them do what they want…

ChocolateCinderToffee · Yesterday 22:08

I worked with someone who expected work to fit in round her social life. We had a restructure and her new manager deleted her post.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 22:26

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:53

Maybe but I used to have one or two of these things at a time. Now I have multiple every week. And any piece of work I have ever asked to be done has never been done or done in a half baked way after the deadline because I chased. I have zero authority. I’ve given up asking for them to do things now and just get Copilot to produce all my first drafts instead, it’s much less obnoxious!

In other places I also had the freedom to put people on a PIP, exit them, give them tough feedback etc. Here I’m supposed to be nice to everyone all the time. My boss just laughs and says they remind her of her teenage kids and I need to accept it what’s young people are like now and that they will all complain to HR at the drop of a hat so watch yourself 😩

Edited

You don't have a problem with the juniors, you have a problem with your boss.

NimbleLemonEagle · Yesterday 22:27

Just re. the pets thing. Once worked with a guy who had loads of cats. Every time one was run over ( which was a lot) his wife would call him in sick. Too heartbroken to come in. He would be off for days each time. This was late 90s so not a Gen Z problem.

Gengha · Yesterday 22:29

Seems a common thread in a lot of workplaces, wet blanket employees who I am amazed can wipe their arses without getting someone to do it for them. The lack of personal responsibility of many people nowadays is shocking

Aquasoap · Yesterday 22:34

Presumably your boss will be OK with your happy team not meeting their KPIs then.

cheeseomelette · Yesterday 22:37

I’d be looking to move. You’re stuffed if you don’t have senior support. It’s hard enough as it is. Don’t blame you at all.

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 22:45

Aquasoap · Yesterday 22:34

Presumably your boss will be OK with your happy team not meeting their KPIs then.

They’ve never once met their KPIs! Last quarter when I asked everyone to update their OKRs and how they’d met them two people said they didn’t even know they had OKRs. FFS I asked for weeks for them to propose Q3 OKRs and then when they persistently didn’t and I missed the deadline for submission I wrote the OKRs myself and told them what they were. Now they claim I never did even though I can see I did looking back through my emails.

OP posts:
islingtonparent · Yesterday 22:56

speak to HR and step down from being a manager?

HoppityBun · Yesterday 22:59

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 22:45

They’ve never once met their KPIs! Last quarter when I asked everyone to update their OKRs and how they’d met them two people said they didn’t even know they had OKRs. FFS I asked for weeks for them to propose Q3 OKRs and then when they persistently didn’t and I missed the deadline for submission I wrote the OKRs myself and told them what they were. Now they claim I never did even though I can see I did looking back through my emails.

and then when they persistently didn’t and I missed the deadline for submission I wrote the OKRs myself and told them what they were

Is that the problem? You’re no longer managing them, you’re covering up for them. There are no consequences for them not delivering and no accountability.

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:00

HoppityBun · Yesterday 22:59

and then when they persistently didn’t and I missed the deadline for submission I wrote the OKRs myself and told them what they were

Is that the problem? You’re no longer managing them, you’re covering up for them. There are no consequences for them not delivering and no accountability.

Yes although I’m not really covering it up as I told my boss that was what I’d done

OP posts:
Lifeistulips · Yesterday 23:03

I can’t help but think, good. ‘Waffling on’ about life/ work balance? Good. I’m glad the years of employers demanding the souls of their employees is over. Fair play to workers who want fair play. By combating this you’re not helping yourself, only the billionaire owners of large companies.

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:12

Lifeistulips · Yesterday 23:03

I can’t help but think, good. ‘Waffling on’ about life/ work balance? Good. I’m glad the years of employers demanding the souls of their employees is over. Fair play to workers who want fair play. By combating this you’re not helping yourself, only the billionaire owners of large companies.

Hahaha, these are people who had to be asked to try to arrive at the office for 9 because, you know, that’s when they are supposed to start work 🤣

OP posts:
Lifeistulips · Yesterday 23:16

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:12

Hahaha, these are people who had to be asked to try to arrive at the office for 9 because, you know, that’s when they are supposed to start work 🤣

And? Maybe 9 isn’t easy if you have a long way to travel and child care responsibilities. My work has core hours of 10-3 so you can work around that however you please. So long as you get your job done, which we all do as adults. Who gives a fuck if they start a little later? Unless you’re in a people facing job obviously

Huckleberries · Yesterday 23:18

Well, everybody doesn’t have to start work at 9 am

I do think people shouldn’t be on their LinkedIn and fantasy football at work, but you didn’t wanna answer that

Swipe left for the next trending thread