Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

I cannot be a people manager anymore

113 replies

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 18:29

I have been a people manager for around 15 years. I have always enjoyed managing people, playing a part in their development and helping them to reach their potential. I I have a track record of running high performing and happy teams.

I’d been consulting for a couple of years where I hadn’t been doing any management then about 10 months ago, I started a role where I had a team again. I have five direct reports and a team of about 20 in total. My direct reports are generally all fine. They take the work seriously and I can trust them to diligently get on with it.

The juniors are a total and utter nightmare. I’ve got three different teams and my biggest team has eight juniors. We work in professional services in house so they are all highly qualified.

They think they are more important than everybody else, they have no work ethic, they waffle on about their work life balance all the time, they don’t do things I ask them to do and they don’t even bother to apologise or acknowledge that they were asked to do them in the first place. They all want things all of the time and they expect me to solve all of their problems at home and at work.

my boss just says I have to keep them happy because it’s the company culture to have a happy workforce. It’s exhausting and I hate it. I feel like I’m pushing water up a hill constantly. I’ve missed key deadlines because I can’t get my team to deliver.

And I’ve decided I’m done. Life is too short for this. I’m trying to juggle being a parent to young children, a shiftwork husband and a high-pressure full-time senior level job. I can’t take this level of responsibility on top of everything else. I’m not their mother I’m their boss.

Do I just go in and resign next week?

OP posts:
Trickywoowoo · Today 10:23

LifeIsTooShort247 · Yesterday 20:39

I do not blame you its the main reason I do not move up because it means managing people and its a thankless task and often the payrise is not enough to justify having to deal with it all.

I moved to a singleton role managing output not people, with the next fifteen years much easier on my MH.

Lhori · Today 10:42

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 21:15

Someone else needs time off this coming week because their dog is ill and sought my advice on how to get a sick dog to the vet when you don’t have a car. I’ve no idea, I don’t have a dog.

This seems pretty normal for a work place. She is just looking for some advice in case you have experience of it. They are humans, not robots.

EleanorRigby34 · Today 11:16

Yes, culturally this company has been such a weird experience. I haven’t clock watched my entire career, either for myself or for my team. It feels very old-fashioned and infantilising. Lawyers are normally type A, self starters and need very little pushing. I think that’s why it has been a shock to me to encounter this group. The calibre of their work is poor and their attitude is like nothing I’ve encountered before.

I agree with those saying my boss is weak. That said some of it I don’t think is her fault as she feels hamstrung by the company culture and doesn’t feel that she can take any action. In her shoes, I would push senior leadership harder, but that’s not my call.

I think I’m going to call it a day and hand in my notice. I don’t think it will change and it’s really beginning to affect my state of mind. I feel constantly caught in the middle between delivering what the business expect and a team who won’t help me do that. I’m just worn out by trying to make them change and from having to do all the work myself. Even with the help of Copilot, it’s difficult to take on several extra workloads.

OP posts:
EleanorRigby34 · Today 11:20

Lhori · Today 10:42

This seems pretty normal for a work place. She is just looking for some advice in case you have experience of it. They are humans, not robots.

But this person has already had multiple days off because her aunt was unwell and her parents apparently were unable to take her to the doctors because they have full-time jobs (she does too!), additional time off for the poorly dog and loads and loads of time off to study, all at full pay. I gave her two weeks extra study leave when she said she was struggling with her course because it was too much on top of working as well.

She’s also had her full compliment of an annual leave this year taken all in the second half of the year once the course was finished. This was all her right of course, and I’m happy to live with it but having had all of this extra support she then has complained bitterly that the company has let her down and that she doesn’t get to work on as many interesting projects as the rest of the team. Frankly that’s because she’s been there such a limited time through the year, it’s very hard to get her involved in something before she’s off again and it makes it very fragmented.

OP posts:
Didimum · Today 11:21

You’re not wrong to hate it – it’s not for everyone. But I’d argue it’s not something you’re skilled at. Your past success in the role looks like it may have been down to having a generally compliant team rather than actually developing skills that people/teams are very lacking in.

I wouldn’t like it either so you’re not wrong just to stop if you can.

OrangeAndFizz · Today 11:21

My DH worked for a Finnish company wherein the culture was of enforced happiness. No negativity was allowed. OP's place sounds like that.

tumbledownwalls · Today 11:27

The more you've shared, the more toxic the workplace culture sounds. You can't overcome weak leadership and management above you.

I have sometimes encountered graduates who don't seem to understand what a workplace or employment contract means and behave as if they're still at university - with us as their service provider existing to meet their needs. Some of the behaviours you're describing sound similar. Like they think their TC is just a paid version of university rather than employment.

SirChenjins · Today 11:29

After 30 years of managing a team I have had enough and am moving to a new role where the management will be minimal. I genuinely can't do it anymore. I've worked with some lovely people over the years, and I will miss them, but I won't miss sorting the OH stuff, having difficult conversations, managing absences, dealing with rosters, dealing with organisational changes, managing interpersonal stuff while going through things like my ever increasing workload, bereavement, the menopause, other personal stresses - it's all got too much. I now want to focus on doing a job, rather than having to deal with the management stuff on top.

Dinnerontheterrace · Today 11:34

I find managing people is much easier when the riles are clear and consistently enforced. It also helps if senior leaders walk the talk.

It’s a nightmare to manage a bunch of people when there are loads if discretionary rules to enforce and you have directors who want everyone in the office but are rarely there themselves.

Are you in a law firm OP?

herbetta · Today 11:38

EleanorRigby34 · Yesterday 23:40

What answer were you expecting? I don’t think people should be browsing LinkedIn jobs or doing their fantasy football at work either, so I agree with you. If you’re asking me what I’ve done about it, the answer is nothing because it would cause a massive furore.

How could it cause a massive furore?? That is literally a conduct issue. What mitigation could he possibly have?

MushMonster · Today 11:46

Clear tasks, clear expectations, clear deadlines, consequences if those are not met.
It is really not the company job to make the workers happy beyond a reasonable point. If A does think he is underpaid, just make sure he is paid the same as others in similar role and if he keeps going on, then advice him to find a better paid role. Real life advice. If B is not finding her projects interesting, just point out that it was due to the length of her training and to give it time now that she is back in the office. If she keeps going, advice to find another role.
Really, the problem is the lack of consequences. The old, do not like it, then find another job.
What can they do? Take the company to court? Well, nope. If they are paid fairly within the team, allowed time for training, allowed time for issues at home, shown flexibility, and treated legally fairly, then they are happy at work or leave. It is the trying to make them happy beyond what is fair to the company and their colleagues that generates the problem. Vague boundaries get walked all over.
Then, it is you and your reports and those good juniors that have to take the extra work. Well, don't. Stop doing their job. Your managers needs to really get the extent of the issues here. And fire those who will not step up to the mark.

Bobbybobbins · Today 11:51

Wow this thread has been such an eye opener! I don’t blame you at all for wanting to leave OP.
I’m a teacher and details like arriving on time are a non negotiable really. Interesting to see attitudes of some workers elsewhere described.

ChickNorris · Today 11:53

Lifeistulips · Yesterday 23:16

And? Maybe 9 isn’t easy if you have a long way to travel and child care responsibilities. My work has core hours of 10-3 so you can work around that however you please. So long as you get your job done, which we all do as adults. Who gives a fuck if they start a little later? Unless you’re in a people facing job obviously

You do 5 hours a day? Well listen, we'd all love to be paid full time hours for working Monday and Wednesday only but that's not really realistic is it.

And what do you even mean 9 is early. Try starting work at 6. And I don't mean getting up at 6. I mean being awake, washed, dressed, coffee drank, make up done, fed, lunch packed, car defrosted and ready at your station at 5:55. THAT'S early! I'd gladly campaign for that never being a thing.
You sound like you have a lovely set up there and I am happy for you. But we need to agree on what's reasonable and more than fair because OP's employees are getting their ideas from somewhere..

tumbledownwalls · Today 11:58

ChickNorris · Today 11:53

You do 5 hours a day? Well listen, we'd all love to be paid full time hours for working Monday and Wednesday only but that's not really realistic is it.

And what do you even mean 9 is early. Try starting work at 6. And I don't mean getting up at 6. I mean being awake, washed, dressed, coffee drank, make up done, fed, lunch packed, car defrosted and ready at your station at 5:55. THAT'S early! I'd gladly campaign for that never being a thing.
You sound like you have a lovely set up there and I am happy for you. But we need to agree on what's reasonable and more than fair because OP's employees are getting their ideas from somewhere..

"Core hours" is a feature of flexitime. It means everyone has to be available and working during those hours but that you can work the rest of your hours flexibly. E.g. start early and finish at 3pm, or start at 10am and finish late. It doesn't mean you only work those few hours in the middle!

MushMonster · Today 12:02

ChickNorris · Today 11:53

You do 5 hours a day? Well listen, we'd all love to be paid full time hours for working Monday and Wednesday only but that's not really realistic is it.

And what do you even mean 9 is early. Try starting work at 6. And I don't mean getting up at 6. I mean being awake, washed, dressed, coffee drank, make up done, fed, lunch packed, car defrosted and ready at your station at 5:55. THAT'S early! I'd gladly campaign for that never being a thing.
You sound like you have a lovely set up there and I am happy for you. But we need to agree on what's reasonable and more than fair because OP's employees are getting their ideas from somewhere..

I think with the core hours OP means they can flexibly choose to do 8-4, 5-9, 10-6, 10-3 plus 6-9....
Of course, this is not possible in all industries. There are plenty of us who has to be at work at a said time, including the middle of the night.

MushMonster · Today 12:05

Oops sorry, you already clarify it while I was typing!
Flexible hours is great. Honestly, it would have helped me while raising a family. I had some flexibility, but no to this level. And it would have really sorted all the stress about drop offs and pick ups.

ChickNorris · Today 12:30

@MushMonster @tumbledownwalls thanks guys. I didn't mean for anyone to start worrying that people don't understand that core hours don't just mean those hours. So please worry not. I'll hold my hands up and say that I worded it badly, I guess I let myself get a bit carried away because of the rest, more than anything.

And yes it does sound great. I'm all for a bit of flexibility where possible.
I also understand what we need to put in to get the good stuff. Cos sadly giving people too much good stuff whilst letting them realize that they're being given more than they should expect can lead to what the OP is witnessing now. More demands. It's annoying but it's human nature. Recognizing when you've had it good may come after they've done 10 jobs and with that attitude it is on course to happen.

TherapyName · Today 12:31

Unfortunately this is the culture embedded in education for the last 15 years or so. No one is allowed to fail, schools were expected to provide a lot of hand holding and a bottomless well of empathy. Everything was about the rights of pupils and young people with no emphasis on responsibilities. They then go to universities where students are seen as consumers who must be appeased. Finally, they enter the workplace with an attitude of entitlement and 'You're so lucky to have me here!' We have created a selfish and entitled society which is all about personal pleasure and individual fulfilment, rather than seeing ourselves as part of a collective whole.

Having a number of family members, friends and clients who are or were teachers and academics, I am convinced that this rot sets in very early and needs robustly challenged. By the time you are seeing this in the workplace it is effectively hardwired into a person's personality.

Eddielizzard · Today 12:45

I would resign and find a better company. It sounds toxic. All the people who are competent and productive will get pissed off and leave. Things will only get worse

PooPooPootin · Today 12:48

Lhori · Today 10:42

This seems pretty normal for a work place. She is just looking for some advice in case you have experience of it. They are humans, not robots.

Well, that is the sort of easily foreseeable issue that needs to be thought about before getting a dog. Or she could ask Mumsnet. Somebody on the dogs board is more likely to have a useful suggestion than her non-dog-owning manager.

Atlastarest · Today 12:51

Honestly if you have no support from your boss or higher up, you will never win and you will waste your life trying to tie yourself in knots trying to get somewhere. How dare your boss laugh when you tell her you’re struggling! It’s that which stands out for me. Your boss doesn’t have to boss, your workers don’t have to work, but somehow old Sally in the middle (you) has to produce output and cohesion with zero back up from either side? No.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 12:56

DreamyRedNewt · Today 09:10

It would be interesting to hear the other side of the story from the staff in more junior positions. You have to find a balance and try to keep staff happy (without meaning they can do whatever they want) but there has to be some give and take. Because if you don't keep them happy, they will leave and if most people are unhappy the reality is that the problem may be you. What do you think is going to happen? If you replace all staff and keep the same conditions, most likely they will all be un happy too.

Keeping staff happy doesn't mean allowing them to saunter in at whatever time they want. If other staff are keeping to their contracted hours and arriving on time, it is going to seriously piss them off if other people come in late and management allow them to get away with it. So that's not going to create a happy atmosphere either, is it?

FiveEightNine · Today 13:26

Is there actually any work which needs to be done by them?

Or, is the work generally done (aside of the internal stuff as KPI reporting) and they hust create noisw around it?

In my experience this can happen when people can't own their work and their success, so everyone is just surviving and muddling through.

MyLifeInBooks · Today 13:59

@EleanorRigby34 - some of this sounds like my old workplace, although yours is a more professional setting. and management without a backbone
We used to employ young people and graduates in junior roles. Usually
their first professional job with tight d
eadlines and higher expectations. Most needed further development by either attending training coursees or doing them online with limited study time due to workload. Often new in town, living fully independent and being overwhelmed und quiet frankly a bit lost.

The job at hand is about developing their skills further. They need nurturing, someone to take them under their wings and show them the ropes.

As you have realised, you are not the right fit for the role. The example with taking the dog to the vet made me chuckle. My worst experience was a phone call at 11pm because they were booted out of their home the next day - sub let situation. Like your work manager could do anything about it...

MushMonster · Today 14:38

There is always the possibility that they are being unproductive and obnoxious on purpose. If the task they do not do gets done by someone else, that person will get fed up, and if management has no backbone, they will go. Creating a vacancy, which will be filled up by the trouble maker. Or the trouble maker will start looking more indispensable as the others quit. Bear that in mind.
Again, it is all about consequences and clear expectations and boundaries. Write it up on an office/ team or company policy and KPIs and point at it each everytime they are out of line.
Write the expected times of arrival and work. The allowed lunch and coffee breaks. To hand in work x hours or days ahead to deadline. Quality of work expected. Min and max trainingvoffered. That x amount of people must remain in office while others are absent or in training. What is expected of them to consider that they are progressing. How rotas work. That the kitchen must be kept clean... all in writing somewhere.
And stick to it! You cannot allow someobe to sit by you playing games and moaning that they are underpaid.
And what previous poster says that you are not suited to this role because you have to nurture them.. well, do not let anyone push you aside, ever! Put on your big girl pants and start disciplining anyone who is not working on working hours. Engage with HR above your useless boss if needed. Do not let any of them walk over you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread