Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WI Talk on Trans women Issues

101 replies

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

WorkingItOutAsIGo · Yesterday 23:25

Transwomen should never have been allowed into the WI. It's in breach of their charity status and the equality act.

DaintyBlueLark · Yesterday 23:32

@TallShip You should have spoken out. I'm fed up of women saying they can't do that. You want some other woman to do it for you.

ProfessorRedshoeblueshoe · Yesterday 23:32

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

Because they are men HTH

WhereYouLeftIt · Yesterday 23:33

And this is why I have no interest in joining the WI.

ProfessorRedshoeblueshoe · Yesterday 23:33

And sex is not assigned at birth - it's observed

WhereYouLeftIt · Yesterday 23:34

ProfessorRedshoeblueshoe · Yesterday 23:33

And sex is not assigned at birth - it's observed

And it is observed long before the birth!

TallShip · Yesterday 23:34

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

I don’t trans men, trans identifying women, are very welcome.

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 23:36

TallShip · Yesterday 23:34

I don’t trans men, trans identifying women, are very welcome.

What about trans women, non binary people, etc?

TallShip · Yesterday 23:38

There were 40 plus women in the room plus 2 men, they were all baying for blood; I did not feel comfortable speaking out in a group I was visiting.

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · Yesterday 23:39

Anyone of female sex is welcome.
Anyone of male sex is not.

Schylla · Yesterday 23:39

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

While I appreciate the value of presenting opposing views is there a legitimate opposing view specifically that trans women aren't at risk? Because that seems to be bordering on misinformation.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:42

Ignore the derailers.

It's over for the WI. There's nothing they can do unless they change their constitution.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:43

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:42

Ignore the derailers.

It's over for the WI. There's nothing they can do unless they change their constitution.

Responses are relevant to the thread, aren't a derailment.

DaintyBlueLark · Yesterday 23:44

TallShip · Yesterday 23:38

There were 40 plus women in the room plus 2 men, they were all baying for blood; I did not feel comfortable speaking out in a group I was visiting.

We're not in Russia. You would have survived.

TallShip · Yesterday 23:46

You’ve never met these women!

OP posts:
DaintyBlueLark · Yesterday 23:47

TallShip · Yesterday 23:46

You’ve never met these women!

Of course I have. They are in every social group. They get away with it because no one stands up to them.

Schylla · Yesterday 23:49

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:42

Ignore the derailers.

It's over for the WI. There's nothing they can do unless they change their constitution.

Lol, 'let women speak'….

You realise this is a thread about debate & free speech right? Oh wait….

Lovelyview · Yesterday 23:49

Transperson · Yesterday 23:36

What about trans women, non binary people, etc?

'Trans women' are men Hth

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:49

Transperson · Yesterday 23:43

Responses are relevant to the thread, aren't a derailment.

You assume i was referring to you

Very telling

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 23:50

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

We did. In fact the WI was a good example of that. Then the trans identified men decided to barge their way in. If more women-only groups are established the same thing will happen.
The real question here is why do trans identified men want to take women only spaces away from women?

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Yesterday 23:52

Schylla · Yesterday 23:39

While I appreciate the value of presenting opposing views is there a legitimate opposing view specifically that trans women aren't at risk? Because that seems to be bordering on misinformation.

is there a legitimate opposing view specifically that trans women aren't at risk?

Is there a legitimate view that trans identified men are put at risk by not being able to be members of the Women’s Institute?

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Yesterday 23:54

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 23:50

We did. In fact the WI was a good example of that. Then the trans identified men decided to barge their way in. If more women-only groups are established the same thing will happen.
The real question here is why do trans identified men want to take women only spaces away from women?

Male imperialism, entitlement, supremacism, man spreading …

Schylla · Yesterday 23:56

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Yesterday 23:52

is there a legitimate opposing view specifically that trans women aren't at risk?

Is there a legitimate view that trans identified men are put at risk by not being able to be members of the Women’s Institute?

From the OP's comment it would appear that the risk is about exclusion in general not specifically the exclusion from WI.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:59

They are not able to admit men due their current constitution and policies. That's what they were told when they took legal advice from professionals far more knowledgeable than TRAs.

They will have to change those if they want to admit men.

We've discussed this at great length on here. Please use the search function.