Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WI Talk on Trans women Issues

101 replies

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

OP posts:
Kirschcherries · Today 03:09

@TallShip I understand your reticence to raise your head above the parapet.

One way to approach this is to focus on the risk of legal action. You might consider saying something like - After the talk I was reflecting on why the NFWI advise WIs it was against our charitable status to continue to allow TW to join. Would it be useful to invite a speaker who can explain the Supreme Court Judgement and why NFWI made this decision.

This way you’re focusing on why NFWI made the decision not on being GC.

A second point you could make is - The NFWI must have taken legal advice before making this decision. I assume they were concerned about how expensive it could be if our charitable status was challenged because we were breaking the law. Again a speaker with relevant knowledge could explain the Supreme Court Judgement and the impact on our charitable status if we allow TW to join.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page