Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WI Talk on Trans women Issues

101 replies

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

OP posts:
NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:01

Schylla · Yesterday 23:56

From the OP's comment it would appear that the risk is about exclusion in general not specifically the exclusion from WI.

Oh, so no need “for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men” then.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:01

OP, you won't have been the only gc person in the room. And I totally understand why you didn't feel you could speak out.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:02

They cannot currently admit TW without admitting all men. We've been through this. The WI know this.

Schylla · Today 00:03

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:01

Oh, so no need “for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men” then.

That's not relevant to the OP's context:

"A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk."

Raininthesummertime · Today 00:05

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

Why do you want to take spaces way from women?
Why are you advocating for men to be part of a group for women that has existed for over a hundred years? Why don’t you start your own group? Why try and change existing groups for women so that they include men? Jeez

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:06

Schylla · Today 00:03

That's not relevant to the OP's context:

"A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk."

OP’s context was that it was suggested at the meeting “for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men”. I put it in quote marks because is a quotation. From the OP.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:08

Start their own group? Way too much effort and no validation

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:10

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

Men like you are not wanted or welcome in women only spaces. Take the hint.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:11

Transperson · Yesterday 23:36

What about trans women, non binary people, etc?

There is no such thing as a non binary person.

everyone is either male or female. You’re male BTW.

Schylla · Today 00:13

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:06

OP’s context was that it was suggested at the meeting “for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men”. I put it in quote marks because is a quotation. From the OP.

Yes the trans people made that recommendation following the talk but that was not the purpose of their talk. Trans people at risk was.

alcovecupboards · Today 00:13

TallShip · Yesterday 23:38

There were 40 plus women in the room plus 2 men, they were all baying for blood; I did not feel comfortable speaking out in a group I was visiting.

"Baying for blood"? In what way? Please be specific.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:14

Schylla · Today 00:13

Yes the trans people made that recommendation following the talk but that was not the purpose of their talk. Trans people at risk was.

At risk of what?

Transperson · Today 00:14

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:11

There is no such thing as a non binary person.

everyone is either male or female. You’re male BTW.

Edited

Why are you even responding to me?

alcovecupboards · Today 00:14

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:10

Men like you are not wanted or welcome in women only spaces. Take the hint.

You mean apart from the trans women invited to this WI group? They were very much wanted it appears.

Runningupthecurtains · Today 00:16

Transperson · Yesterday 23:36

What about trans women, non binary people, etc?

.

Schylla · Today 00:16

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:14

At risk of what?

The same sorts of risks women are from men not to mention hate crimes.

Transperson · Today 00:17

Runningupthecurtains · Today 00:16

.

Edited

We are talking about a group that explicitly wants to include trans women.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:17

Transperson · Today 00:14

Why are you even responding to me?

Because every time we show you up for being a bullying misogynistic man who thinks women shouldn’t have rights, not to mention a very suspect attitude to sex by deception, the better.

every time you say something g and it gets demolished the arguments get better and your cause is damaged.

keep it up bro.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:18

We are talking about a group that explicitly wants to include trans women.

Not all groups within the WI do

Tough

Transperson · Today 00:20

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · Today 00:17

Because every time we show you up for being a bullying misogynistic man who thinks women shouldn’t have rights, not to mention a very suspect attitude to sex by deception, the better.

every time you say something g and it gets demolished the arguments get better and your cause is damaged.

keep it up bro.

"Demolish" - funny how people stopped saying it's against Scottish law after I quoted copfs :D

Maybe focus on the thread instead of me.

suzip08 · Today 00:20

To be honest I would have probably walked out.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:23

Schylla · Today 00:16

The same sorts of risks women are from men not to mention hate crimes.

The supreme court ruling but not the lack of WI membership has put men at risk of [specifically womanly but unnamed things] from other men?

alcovecupboards · Today 00:23

suzip08 · Today 00:20

To be honest I would have probably walked out.

How brave of you! After all these women were all 'baying for blood'!

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:23

On all these threads, and there have been several, about the WI it never fails to amuse me how many people would not normally give a single shit about the WI but for the fact they are excluded and all of a sudden it's like a red rag to a bull

Schylla · Today 00:24

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:23

The supreme court ruling but not the lack of WI membership has put men at risk of [specifically womanly but unnamed things] from other men?

What's your point?