Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WI Talk on Trans women Issues

101 replies

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

OP posts:
GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:25

alcovecupboards · Today 00:23

How brave of you! After all these women were all 'baying for blood'!

Stop trying to bully the OP

It's a turn of phrase FGS

Transperson · Today 00:27

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:25

Stop trying to bully the OP

It's a turn of phrase FGS

Maybe those women are trying to fight for women's rights where no one questions them or other marganlised groups about them being in safe(er) places?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:28

Transperson · Today 00:27

Maybe those women are trying to fight for women's rights where no one questions them or other marganlised groups about them being in safe(er) places?

Er....?
Actually no, don't bother

alcovecupboards · Today 00:30

Transperson · Today 00:27

Maybe those women are trying to fight for women's rights where no one questions them or other marganlised groups about them being in safe(er) places?

Oh no, you must understand that anything anyone GC does is automatically seen in the best possible light - even child abuse - whereas if a trans person does anything - saving kittens from fires - then it's automatically the worst possible motive. It is deranged.

But what's good for the goose etc so I'm sure the OP won't feel dreadfully bullied by being asked about her claims that this group were 'baying for blood'. Perhaps they had pitchforks or she'd actually stumbled into a Werewolf Institute meeting instead?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:31

#letthemspeak

😂

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:32

"Sauce" for the goose

Transperson · Today 00:35

alcovecupboards · Today 00:30

Oh no, you must understand that anything anyone GC does is automatically seen in the best possible light - even child abuse - whereas if a trans person does anything - saving kittens from fires - then it's automatically the worst possible motive. It is deranged.

But what's good for the goose etc so I'm sure the OP won't feel dreadfully bullied by being asked about her claims that this group were 'baying for blood'. Perhaps they had pitchforks or she'd actually stumbled into a Werewolf Institute meeting instead?

Yk I heard that trans people made the frogs gay by putting soy in the water to force fem people. So horrible, glad we have GC groups to protect us against them 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Otherwise we wouldn't have insiders in those horrible meetings.

Transperson · Today 00:37

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:31

#letthemspeak

😂

Let's stop trans agenda, we must protect the frogs!!

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:37

I see the totally coherent and not at all crazy sounding crew are out in force tonight to fight their corner

Transperson · Today 00:38

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:37

I see the totally coherent and not at all crazy sounding crew are out in force tonight to fight their corner

You don't care about the frogs?

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:39

Schylla · Today 00:24

What's your point?

What are these risks?

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:41

Transperson · Today 00:35

Yk I heard that trans people made the frogs gay by putting soy in the water to force fem people. So horrible, glad we have GC groups to protect us against them 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Otherwise we wouldn't have insiders in those horrible meetings.

Wtaf are you on about? What does this mean?

Transperson · Today 00:42

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:39

What are these risks?

Did you know that like all of the gay and trans of people are gangsters? They always say be gay, do crime. We obviously have to stay away from them.

Schylla · Today 00:43

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:39

What are these risks?

Sexual & physical assault.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:44

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:41

Wtaf are you on about? What does this mean?

It means he finds it highly entertaining to derail nearly every thread with nonsense

It's a blatant cry for attention and acceptance

Quite sad really

Transperson · Today 00:44

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:41

Wtaf are you on about? What does this mean?

Trans people are dangerous!!
I keep seeing them telling people to do crime.

Text Animated Pride Flag Animation GIF
MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:47

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:44

It means he finds it highly entertaining to derail nearly every thread with nonsense

It's a blatant cry for attention and acceptance

Quite sad really

That's what I thought. It is sad.

NumberTheory · Today 00:47

Transperson · Yesterday 23:21

Why do you want to take away spaces from trans people?

If you want to make groups that are exclusively based on sex assigned at birth you can. Why try to change all of the existing ones to exclude trans women? Jeez.

OP isn’t suggesting taking spaces away from anyone. Want to recover and maintain spaces without men. And the more we see of TRA advocacy the clearer it is that trans identified men need keeping out for the exact same reasons all the other men do.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:47

Transperson · Today 00:42

Did you know that like all of the gay and trans of people are gangsters? They always say be gay, do crime. We obviously have to stay away from them.

Thinking gay people do crime is one of the risks trans identified men are put at by Supreme Court ruling? Stonewall did once describe same sex attraction as akin to racism, is that what you mean?

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:48

Transperson · Today 00:44

Trans people are dangerous!!
I keep seeing them telling people to do crime.

What's that got to do with trans ppl?

GreyskySexRealistsky · Today 00:49

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:47

That's what I thought. It is sad.

When i was 20-something I wouldn't have spent my whole Saturday nights on mumsnet

No offence to mumsnet 😃

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:50

Schylla · Today 00:43

Sexual & physical assault.

As a result of the supreme court ruling? Is this what you meant when you said The same sorts of risks women are from men?

Transperson · Today 00:50

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:48

What's that got to do with trans ppl?

It's a common trope I see them spread.

NumberTheory · Today 00:52

OP it’s not at all unreasonable to think alternative positions should be given a platform to counter the rhetoric. But you know that isn’t going to happen until you find the support and courage to start speaking up.

is there anything we can do to help you advocate for women?

I suggest we ignore the assault on the thread and try to focus on your concern.

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:54

Transperson · Today 00:50

It's a common trope I see them spread.

What, trans people at claiming gay people "do crime"? How fucking homophobic of them!

Although my gay son thinks the "be gay do crime" thing is funny. I suppose its not really that many years since being gay (or at least acting on being gay) was a crime so gay men are "doing crime" just for being themselves.