Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

WI Talk on Trans women Issues

101 replies

TallShip · Yesterday 23:17

A local WI has had 2 trans women and 2 lesbians come to explain why the Supreme Court ruling is putting transwomen at risk.

They were invited by the WI committee which is very “understanding” of trans women’s upset at the WI exclusion.

I seemed to be the only gender critical woman in the room. I do understand why trans women might be upset; toilets and hospital wards were also mentioned, but I did not feel I could speak out.

The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men.

There has been no suggestion they should have a talk by any groups who may offer an alternative view.

Is it unreasonable to think women’s groups should be invited to offer the opposing point of view?

OP posts:
Schylla · Today 00:55

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 00:50

As a result of the supreme court ruling? Is this what you meant when you said The same sorts of risks women are from men?

Yes because they will be forced to share spaces with cis men. Unless gender neutral toilet availability & other segregated accommodations are substantially increased given their regular inaccessibility they are in danger.

maltravers · Today 00:56

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Yesterday 23:54

Male imperialism, entitlement, supremacism, man spreading …

Don’t forget the enjoyment some men get in breaching women’s boundaries.

Transperson · Today 00:59

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:54

What, trans people at claiming gay people "do crime"? How fucking homophobic of them!

Although my gay son thinks the "be gay do crime" thing is funny. I suppose its not really that many years since being gay (or at least acting on being gay) was a crime so gay men are "doing crime" just for being themselves.

They could also be referring to the stonewall riots, since a lot of them were illegal

RogueFemale · Today 00:59

@TallShip "The trans women were very encouraging for the branch to write to NFWI to suggest a change in the charity status wording but still exclude cis, their word not mine, men."

Then neither the trans-claiming-men nor the WI understand the legal position, that they cannot exclude so-called 'cis' men without also excluding trans-claiming-men.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:00

MyDucksAreHavingAParty · Today 00:41

Wtaf are you on about? What does this mean?

Transperson is drunk again

Transperson · Today 01:02

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:00

Transperson is drunk again

I'm having a lovely cocktail atm (mango, pineapple and vodka) but it's my first drink of the night.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:02

alcovecupboards · Today 00:30

Oh no, you must understand that anything anyone GC does is automatically seen in the best possible light - even child abuse - whereas if a trans person does anything - saving kittens from fires - then it's automatically the worst possible motive. It is deranged.

But what's good for the goose etc so I'm sure the OP won't feel dreadfully bullied by being asked about her claims that this group were 'baying for blood'. Perhaps they had pitchforks or she'd actually stumbled into a Werewolf Institute meeting instead?

Has there been a sudden outbreak of trans people saving kittens from fires that I've somehow missed?

Sounds a bit suss to me.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:03

Schylla · Today 00:55

Yes because they will be forced to share spaces with cis men. Unless gender neutral toilet availability & other segregated accommodations are substantially increased given their regular inaccessibility they are in danger.

Edited

So male on male violence? Not really The same sorts of risks women are from men is it? It’s actually nothing whatsoever to do with women at all, let alone the WI.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:03

Transperson · Today 01:02

I'm having a lovely cocktail atm (mango, pineapple and vodka) but it's my first drink of the night.

Edited

Lightweight 🍹

Transperson · Today 01:05

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:02

Has there been a sudden outbreak of trans people saving kittens from fires that I've somehow missed?

Sounds a bit suss to me.

The cat distribution system works as intended I assume.

RogueFemale · Today 01:06

Schylla · Today 00:55

Yes because they will be forced to share spaces with cis men. Unless gender neutral toilet availability & other segregated accommodations are substantially increased given their regular inaccessibility they are in danger.

Edited

If you believe that, then focus on making men's single sex spaces safe for trans-claiming-men, not on forcing women to have trans-claiming men in their single sex spaces.

Schylla · Today 01:09

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:03

So male on male violence? Not really The same sorts of risks women are from men is it? It’s actually nothing whatsoever to do with women at all, let alone the WI.

So you're perfectly fine with male children being subjected to "male on male violence" I take it?

And preventing violence is in everyone's interest. Part of the prevention of violence against women is an appeal to social responsibility. Now see how far women get living in the animal kingdom you think women can survive in without it.

You can't expect what you don't reflect.

Schylla · Today 01:12

RogueFemale · Today 01:06

If you believe that, then focus on making men's single sex spaces safe for trans-claiming-men, not on forcing women to have trans-claiming men in their single sex spaces.

Don't get ahead of yourself spaces aren't 'owned' by any one group. Our legal system requires a justification for exclusion of which is yet to be proven in case law. In other words, its early days yet for making any claims on spaces.

IwantToRetire · Today 01:13

Hi OP, its a bit late at night and sadly I now normally ignore threads that have just become tedious groundhog day posts because obvious derailets delight in making what was once a supportive and pro woman forum and schoolyard level tit for tat.

But if you are a member of whichever branch of the WI it is, and I do not feel you had to stand up in public to ask this, cant you just email the organisers of meetings, or whoever sets the agendas and ask when in the interest of balance and equality they will be organising a meeting where women who support women's sex based rights, which the Supreme Court only confirmed has always been about biological female, would be invited to speak.

If they say they cant, wont or dont think it necessary to give the right of reply ask how that doesn't make them aligned to a particular politics and thus stopping the WI from representing the range of women's voices.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:14

Schylla · Today 01:09

So you're perfectly fine with male children being subjected to "male on male violence" I take it?

And preventing violence is in everyone's interest. Part of the prevention of violence against women is an appeal to social responsibility. Now see how far women get living in the animal kingdom you think women can survive in without it.

You can't expect what you don't reflect.

Are trans identified men using male children as shields now? Makes a change from using women I suppose 🙄

see how far women get living in the animal kingdom you think women can survive in without it

Didn’t take long for your misogyny to show itself, did it?

Transperson · Today 01:15

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:14

Are trans identified men using male children as shields now? Makes a change from using women I suppose 🙄

see how far women get living in the animal kingdom you think women can survive in without it

Didn’t take long for your misogyny to show itself, did it?

Misogyny how?

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:16

Transperson · Today 01:15

Misogyny how?

Misogyny howse

Schylla · Today 01:19

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Today 01:14

Are trans identified men using male children as shields now? Makes a change from using women I suppose 🙄

see how far women get living in the animal kingdom you think women can survive in without it

Didn’t take long for your misogyny to show itself, did it?

Are trans identified men using male children as shields now?

Principles need to maintain consistency to be principles.

misogyny

The misogyny is all yours dear in claiming women don't need to be a part of the social contract.

maxslice · Today 01:56

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · Yesterday 23:54

Male imperialism, entitlement, supremacism, man spreading …

Because they consider themselves women and believe as such, women’s spaces should be open to them. They don’t think of themselves as men in costumes trying to pass as what they’re not, but as women whom others refuse to acknowledge. Gender critical people like OP do consider gender a “feeling” or a state of mind or adopting chosen pronouns. They are certain that gender is sex is a biological fact and that nothing, not hormones, not surgery, or wishful thinking can alter. They are, at most, reluctant to participate in what they’re see as delusion and mental illness.
I don’t know a way to bridge those perspectives.

2021x · Today 02:13

I am now fully on the other side of the hill of anger. I peaked when Reddit accused me of bigotry and hate speech for saying Transwomen are men.

Now I can confidently say that I cannot take any person in authority seriously if they think a person can change gender by thinking it, that being trans is within the range of normal behaviour and that society should be organised around trans people's feelings.

paraphrasequeen · Today 02:29

I cannot fathom why women would allow men to pontificate on our legally held sex based rights. It's truly baffling.

(And we need a better strategy for dealing with derailers. They're clearly getting off on it at this point).

2021x · Today 02:33

paraphrasequeen · Today 02:29

I cannot fathom why women would allow men to pontificate on our legally held sex based rights. It's truly baffling.

(And we need a better strategy for dealing with derailers. They're clearly getting off on it at this point).

Precisely.

If a person is in a leadership position and thinks that all that I have said is fine and not going to cause an issue for women, then I, as a normal member of society, simply have no confidence in them to manage difficult people.

Yeah, it's probably the same dude; I wonder if the people who constantly respond are also the same dude or a bot?

Manyanamanyana · Today 02:54

Schylla · Today 00:24

What's your point?

Whats your point?

IwantToRetire · Today 02:55

paraphrasequeen · Today 02:29

I cannot fathom why women would allow men to pontificate on our legally held sex based rights. It's truly baffling.

(And we need a better strategy for dealing with derailers. They're clearly getting off on it at this point).

The best strategy is do NOT respond. It only encourages them.

And we aren't obligated to engage.

Any more that if we were a faith group and some arrogant entitled person get coming to our meetings and lecturing us about our faith.

Added to which they dont care what we say,

If they did they would have stopped their contempt for us with their irrelevant and arrogance entryism.

Do not validate them by responding.

Also it means threads are more valuable as the focus is on women's sex based rights.

Manyanamanyana · Today 03:00

maltravers · Today 00:56

Don’t forget the enjoyment some men get in breaching women’s boundaries.

And the humiliation fetish