Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

76 year old pedophile buys a baby

177 replies

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Paedophile, 76, had surrogate baby to raise as a single father

Former football coach caught up in custody battle with hospital after it learnt about his past

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

OP posts:
Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:29

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 18:21

I am fully against surrogacy, because it involves exploitation of women and doesn’t centre the child’s interests.

I disagree though that gay men should not be able to adopt, because those issues above do not arise, provided there is proper and thorough screening and monitoring (which should include imo a full search of their internet use and devices). Obviously some men are abusers (gay or not) and no child should be adopted without proper safeguards in place.

My gay friends adopted a beautiful boy at about 18 months. He is now 6 and they are fantastic fathers.

Yes, I am not fully decided.. I know some gay men are very good fathers and while Preston's case was terrible, the tragedy was arguably caused primarily by warning signs being ignored. A straight paedophile could adopt a child with a woman and she might not report, obviously many children are abused by biological fathers and mothers are often not aware, for one.

I am not sure though, I need to think more.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:30

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 20:54

Commercial surrogacy is defacto legalised in this country. No parental order has ever been refused in the grounds of excessive "expenses" which can be tens of thousands of pounds.
And of course it's perfectly legal to buy a baby overseas. A parental order will be granted.

Very disturbing. What can be done?

aster10 · Yesterday 22:33

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:41

No im not.
What is am doing is pointing out yet another disgusting consequence in the long list of consequences of allowing people to buy children.
I have never denied that I want all surrogacy and egg donation made illegal as nobody should be able to buy another person and nobody has the right to be a parent.
If you cant have children because you are infertile, left it too late, your single or are in a same sex relationship then thats sad but it doesn't give you the right to buy eggs, rent a woman's body and put her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries just because you want a baby

Would you be against buying sperm also? And perhaps any fertility treatments?

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:33

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 19:52

“Morally” is meaningless? An egg donor is the genetic mother.

Yes I mean I have issues also with egg donation being pressured in various contexts , especially in US : the egg donor is the genetic mother and that DOES matter.

https://thenewinquiry.com/over-easy/

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:34

aster10 · Yesterday 22:33

Would you be against buying sperm also? And perhaps any fertility treatments?

Sperm should not be bought imo, and definitely not anonymously donated.

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 22:35

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:30

Very disturbing. What can be done?

Surrogacy is banned in many countries, including progressive “normal” countries. It’s perfectly doable.

If anyone breaches it, and brings a child in from overseas, charge and convict for human trafficking.

aster10 · Yesterday 22:37

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:34

Sperm should not be bought imo, and definitely not anonymously donated.

So eggs cannot be given at all, but sperm can be given for free if if’s not anonymous? Why different treatment?

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:44

aster10 · Yesterday 22:37

So eggs cannot be given at all, but sperm can be given for free if if’s not anonymous? Why different treatment?

I don't think eggs should never be donated necessarily but the way women are often pressured (as memtioned in the article I linked) is very unethical.

It is also complex as if a man donates sperm there is clarity over who the biological father is. Egg donation can split motherhood 3 ways as there is the social mother, sometimes an extra woman who carries, so is the birthing mother, then the woman who donates the egg, the genetic mother.

How many women who donate eggs would want to be involved in the child's life once they are born? What if the child later wanted to meet them? It is complex.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 22:46

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:30

Very disturbing. What can be done?

Wish I knew.
I guess it's a bit like TWAW. A few years ago most people just didn't think about it or if they did then their sympathies were with the commissioning parents because they have the loudest voices. But there's a lot more awareness now.
For example I never thought twice about the surrogacy plotline on "Friends" until a few years ago. Or look at the comments on Sophie Beresiner's articles in the times on her "journey" from a few years ago vs any recent article about surrogacy. Massive shift in opinion.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:56

I was talking to Google AI and they said a few things I want to check but are interesting:

You have put your finger on the exact dilemma that UK judges and lawmakers struggle with—often called the "fait accompli" (done deal) problem.
When a surrogacy case reaches a UK family court, the baby has already been born and is usually living with the intended parents. If a judge refuses to grant a Parental Order to punish the parents for paying commercial fees, it creates an immediate legal mess for the child:
• Legal limbo: Under UK law, the surrogate (and her husband, if she is married) remains the child's legal parent, even if she lives thousands of miles away, has no genetic link to the baby, and wants nothing to do with raising them (usually)
• No practical alternative: The intended parents are usually the child's biological parents and the only caregivers the baby knows. Removing the child from a loving, stable home and placing them into the UK care system simply to enforce a ban on commercial payments would cause direct harm to an innocent child.
• Loss of legal protections: Without a Parental Order, the intended parents lack full parental responsibility. This complicates basic necessities like consenting to medical treatment, enrolling the child in school, getting a passport, or securing inheritance rights.
Because the law requires judges to put the child's lifelong welfare above everything else, courts have repeatedly concluded that granting the order is the lesser of two evils—even when judges explicitly criticize the intended parents for bypassing UK rules.

How Reformers Propose Solving This

This trap is the main reason the Law Commission of England and Wales (along with the Scottish Law Commission) proposed major reforms to UK surrogacy law:
• Pre-conception screening: Instead of waiting until after the baby is born—when it is too late to say no—regulated surrogacy organisations would vet the arrangement before conception.
• Clearer payment rules: Replacing the vague "reasonable expenses" loophole with a strict, transparent list of permitted costs (such as medical bills, lost earnings, and pregnancy-related expenses) while keeping commercial profit banned.
• Deterrence before birth: By blocking unapproved commercial arrangements before a pregnancy happens, the system aims to prevent the "fait accompli" situation from arising in the first place.
(Note: While the Law Commission published its draft bill in 2023, the UK government has indicated it is not currently a legislative priority, leaving the courts stuck with this dilemma for now.)

It should be a priority!

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 22:56

Would you be against buying sperm also? And perhaps any fertility treatments

Do either of those involve renting a woman's body, putting her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries, and intentionally creating a child with the intent of separating it from its mother at birth regardless of the impact on that child, just because a baby is wanted?

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:57

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 22:56

Would you be against buying sperm also? And perhaps any fertility treatments

Do either of those involve renting a woman's body, putting her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries, and intentionally creating a child with the intent of separating it from its mother at birth regardless of the impact on that child, just because a baby is wanted?

Yes, a surrogacy pregnancy is riskier as pps have pointed out..

itstoolateforsnacks · Yesterday 22:58

This is the natural conclusion of surrogacy. He isn’t the first and won’t be the last I’m sure, he’s one that made the news. Paedophiles will expend great effort and cunning in order to abuse.

Yet another reason surrogacy is an entirely unethical practice.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 22:59

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:56

I was talking to Google AI and they said a few things I want to check but are interesting:

You have put your finger on the exact dilemma that UK judges and lawmakers struggle with—often called the "fait accompli" (done deal) problem.
When a surrogacy case reaches a UK family court, the baby has already been born and is usually living with the intended parents. If a judge refuses to grant a Parental Order to punish the parents for paying commercial fees, it creates an immediate legal mess for the child:
• Legal limbo: Under UK law, the surrogate (and her husband, if she is married) remains the child's legal parent, even if she lives thousands of miles away, has no genetic link to the baby, and wants nothing to do with raising them (usually)
• No practical alternative: The intended parents are usually the child's biological parents and the only caregivers the baby knows. Removing the child from a loving, stable home and placing them into the UK care system simply to enforce a ban on commercial payments would cause direct harm to an innocent child.
• Loss of legal protections: Without a Parental Order, the intended parents lack full parental responsibility. This complicates basic necessities like consenting to medical treatment, enrolling the child in school, getting a passport, or securing inheritance rights.
Because the law requires judges to put the child's lifelong welfare above everything else, courts have repeatedly concluded that granting the order is the lesser of two evils—even when judges explicitly criticize the intended parents for bypassing UK rules.

How Reformers Propose Solving This

This trap is the main reason the Law Commission of England and Wales (along with the Scottish Law Commission) proposed major reforms to UK surrogacy law:
• Pre-conception screening: Instead of waiting until after the baby is born—when it is too late to say no—regulated surrogacy organisations would vet the arrangement before conception.
• Clearer payment rules: Replacing the vague "reasonable expenses" loophole with a strict, transparent list of permitted costs (such as medical bills, lost earnings, and pregnancy-related expenses) while keeping commercial profit banned.
• Deterrence before birth: By blocking unapproved commercial arrangements before a pregnancy happens, the system aims to prevent the "fait accompli" situation from arising in the first place.
(Note: While the Law Commission published its draft bill in 2023, the UK government has indicated it is not currently a legislative priority, leaving the courts stuck with this dilemma for now.)

It should be a priority!

The proposed reforms do not protect mothers or babies. They protect the commissioning parents.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:00

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 22:46

Wish I knew.
I guess it's a bit like TWAW. A few years ago most people just didn't think about it or if they did then their sympathies were with the commissioning parents because they have the loudest voices. But there's a lot more awareness now.
For example I never thought twice about the surrogacy plotline on "Friends" until a few years ago. Or look at the comments on Sophie Beresiner's articles in the times on her "journey" from a few years ago vs any recent article about surrogacy. Massive shift in opinion.

I haven't seen Friends, why is surrogacy used there? Probably not a coincidence it was a US show.

Re Beresiner, her having had cancer & then losing fertility due to that probably made people sympathetic...but it's not an excuse.

aster10 · Yesterday 23:03

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 22:56

Would you be against buying sperm also? And perhaps any fertility treatments

Do either of those involve renting a woman's body, putting her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries, and intentionally creating a child with the intent of separating it from its mother at birth regardless of the impact on that child, just because a baby is wanted?

I believe you’re talking about surrogacy. I simply wondered why sperm donation should be treated differently to egg donation even when there is no surrogacy involved.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:04

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 22:59

The proposed reforms do not protect mothers or babies. They protect the commissioning parents.

Good point. It would be somewhat of an improvement but much more is needed. As the women being exploited are often abroad, it's easy for their suffering to be ignored.

JemimaTiggywinkles · Yesterday 23:09

aster10 · Yesterday 23:03

I believe you’re talking about surrogacy. I simply wondered why sperm donation should be treated differently to egg donation even when there is no surrogacy involved.

The potential side effects and consequences of egg collection make it far more risky than sperm donation. And the current UK practice of offering women ££££ off their fertility treatment in exchange for egg donation is exploitative as fuck. Plus there’s the problem of egg factories overseas. None of those apply to sperm donation.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:10

aster10 · Yesterday 23:03

I believe you’re talking about surrogacy. I simply wondered why sperm donation should be treated differently to egg donation even when there is no surrogacy involved.

Egg donation is much more physically uncomfortable than sperm donation, which is generally painless- that's another factor. Sperm donation involves providing a semen sample via masturbation, whereas egg donation requires weeks of hormone injections and surgical retrieval under sedation.
Daily hormone injections can cause temporary side effects (bloating, headaches, mood swings) or Ovarian Hyperstimulation Syndrome (OHSS), where ovaries swell and leak fluid. The retrieval procedure also carries minor surgical risks like bleeding, infection, or ovarian twisting.
While current evidence shows no link to future infertility or cancer, researchers note there is still a lack of long-term tracking data on donors decades later.

Men can donate sperm for years and often are older. Young women are often targeted by egg donation campaigns and are less likely sometimes to have considered the greater physical issues and implications of the resulting children.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 23:14

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:44

I don't think eggs should never be donated necessarily but the way women are often pressured (as memtioned in the article I linked) is very unethical.

It is also complex as if a man donates sperm there is clarity over who the biological father is. Egg donation can split motherhood 3 ways as there is the social mother, sometimes an extra woman who carries, so is the birthing mother, then the woman who donates the egg, the genetic mother.

How many women who donate eggs would want to be involved in the child's life once they are born? What if the child later wanted to meet them? It is complex.

Sperm donation is now much more regulated than it was 20 years ago, and this was done because of the child's right to know their parents.

Surrogacy, again, just bypasses the child as a stakeholder in this.

The regulations haven't stopped bought and paid for sperm donation, but controlled and changed a lot of dodgy practice and made it harder to do as well as difficult to do while avoiding those legal constraints.

A basic end to the aww bless attitude by a strong public information campaign would be a good start. The child's rights should be made paramount as with adoption and sperm donation, the same right of the child to information on their biological parents, and the public should know the much darker, serious issues involved. Surrogate agencies encouraging and brokering this could be ended.

It could be that bringing babies in to the UK is made legally extremely difficult with this being well publicised.

There could also be a requirement for immediate reporting by health visitors and doctors of babies not associated with the carers having a health record of having a pregnancy, a requirement for mothers followed through pregnancy who then surrendered the child to do so only with the involvement of social services who are there to be focused on the interests and support of the actual birth mother, her decisions and autonomy including changes of mind, and of the child's needs and interests, in the same way as with a child being surrendered for adoption.

And for all surrogate parents identified before or after the baby has changed hands immediately being assigned a social worker, the child's safety assessed and monitored to avoid bastards like the one in the OP getting away with things, and having to go through the full adoption checks, training and passing at pannel in order to keep the child.

That ought to slow the pathway down some.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:15

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 23:14

Sperm donation is now much more regulated than it was 20 years ago, and this was done because of the child's right to know their parents.

Surrogacy, again, just bypasses the child as a stakeholder in this.

The regulations haven't stopped bought and paid for sperm donation, but controlled and changed a lot of dodgy practice and made it harder to do as well as difficult to do while avoiding those legal constraints.

A basic end to the aww bless attitude by a strong public information campaign would be a good start. The child's rights should be made paramount as with adoption and sperm donation, the same right of the child to information on their biological parents, and the public should know the much darker, serious issues involved. Surrogate agencies encouraging and brokering this could be ended.

It could be that bringing babies in to the UK is made legally extremely difficult with this being well publicised.

There could also be a requirement for immediate reporting by health visitors and doctors of babies not associated with the carers having a health record of having a pregnancy, a requirement for mothers followed through pregnancy who then surrendered the child to do so only with the involvement of social services who are there to be focused on the interests and support of the actual birth mother, her decisions and autonomy including changes of mind, and of the child's needs and interests, in the same way as with a child being surrendered for adoption.

And for all surrogate parents identified before or after the baby has changed hands immediately being assigned a social worker, the child's safety assessed and monitored to avoid bastards like the one in the OP getting away with things, and having to go through the full adoption checks, training and passing at pannel in order to keep the child.

That ought to slow the pathway down some.

This. Definitely. The person in OP was in the US which is much less regulated but that could still happen here, I think.

Xmascandycane · Yesterday 23:40

if This is true it’s abhorrent. Thankfully it was prevented! I am not a fan of surrogacy I think it’s very cruel to the baby.

PosyFossilsShoes · Yesterday 23:56

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:29

Yes, I am not fully decided.. I know some gay men are very good fathers and while Preston's case was terrible, the tragedy was arguably caused primarily by warning signs being ignored. A straight paedophile could adopt a child with a woman and she might not report, obviously many children are abused by biological fathers and mothers are often not aware, for one.

I am not sure though, I need to think more.

I know a lot of gay male adopters who are incredible people - altruistic, compassionate, endless patience (ie the qualities you need to be adoptive parents). Given the evidence that male abusers often target single mothers in order to get access to their children, and the number of male abusers who abuse their own children / stepchildren / grandchildren / nieces and nephews, I think the priority in tackling abuse is heterosexual abusers who seem to be numerically far greater. I'm also aware that the need for adoptive families is vast and the harm that comes to children from being in long-term foster care is very real. Adoptive families go through enormous hoops to be allowed to adopt and one slipping through the net is obviously terrible but it is unusual.

I feel particularly sympathetic to gay male adopters at the moment because in my LGBT families group (I'm a gay mum) it is clear that the surrogacy dads look down on the adopting dads. The surrogacy dads are generally very well-off, kids are beautifully presented, private schools, extracurriculars, etc. The adoptive dads are not impoverished but they're less well-off while dealing with children who have trauma, MH or ND difficulties, and often at least one dad has had to leave work to support the adopted child(ren). Often also while dealing with social services begging them to take a newborn sibling which creates a lot of additional pressure and heartache. I know in our group there are adoptive dads who find it very difficult hearing things along the lines of "Oh yes, what a term! Saskia did get into St Custards, but it was touch and go whether we could keep up the pony AND the bassoon lessons during the 11+" while they are staring down the barrel of a pupil referral unit for their kid and navigating homophobic abuse from the child's birth siblings at annual contact.

One thing which genuinely has surprised me - I would have expected the surrogacy children to start showing signs of trauma similar to the adoptive children at least as adolescents. So far, not at all. They seem to be a remarkably well balanced, resilient, and high achieving group. Maybe it will fall apart in their 20s but no sign so far in our group which has surrogacy children from babies up to early teens.

I still disagree with surrogacy on principle, I think it is exploitative of mothers and babies, but I am beginning to question whether the more extreme effects attributed to trauma that we see in adopted children are actually more likely to be foetal drug and alcohol injury.

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:57

AquaRegia31 · Yesterday 13:14

Even discounting the paedophile aspect, how is a 76-year-old ever considered suitable to be the sole parent to a baby created for him via surrogacy? The chances of him being able to properly care for the child even up to the age of 10 are slim and to adulthood, remote. It seems utterly selfish.

I don't think 76yo men should be new fathers at all, but unfortunately that can't be fully stopped.

The DM reported a veryworrying case where both commissioning people were in their 70s.

https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&source=web&rct=j&url=www.dailymail.com/news/article-14756779/Elderly-couple-70s-parents-surrogate-baby.html&ved=2ahUKEwjz_5jGoZqYAxXLVkEAHVckMWYQms4VegoIAggACAAIHxAJ&opi=89978449&cd&psig=AOvVaw3ZuSKYEeakIEA9eRGvTHNs&ust=1795391735308000

They did it in California where this is legal!

Redirect Notice

https://www.google.com/url?cd=&opi=89978449&psig=AOvVaw3ZuSKYEeakIEA9eRGvTHNs&rct=j&sa=i&source=web&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dailymail.com%2Fnews%2Farticle-14756779%2FElderly-couple-70s-parents-surrogate-baby.html&ust=1795391735308000&ved=2ahUKEwjz_5jGoZqYAxXLVkEAHVckMWYQms4VegoIAggACAAIHxAJ

Jane3212 · Yesterday 23:59

PosyFossilsShoes · Yesterday 23:56

I know a lot of gay male adopters who are incredible people - altruistic, compassionate, endless patience (ie the qualities you need to be adoptive parents). Given the evidence that male abusers often target single mothers in order to get access to their children, and the number of male abusers who abuse their own children / stepchildren / grandchildren / nieces and nephews, I think the priority in tackling abuse is heterosexual abusers who seem to be numerically far greater. I'm also aware that the need for adoptive families is vast and the harm that comes to children from being in long-term foster care is very real. Adoptive families go through enormous hoops to be allowed to adopt and one slipping through the net is obviously terrible but it is unusual.

I feel particularly sympathetic to gay male adopters at the moment because in my LGBT families group (I'm a gay mum) it is clear that the surrogacy dads look down on the adopting dads. The surrogacy dads are generally very well-off, kids are beautifully presented, private schools, extracurriculars, etc. The adoptive dads are not impoverished but they're less well-off while dealing with children who have trauma, MH or ND difficulties, and often at least one dad has had to leave work to support the adopted child(ren). Often also while dealing with social services begging them to take a newborn sibling which creates a lot of additional pressure and heartache. I know in our group there are adoptive dads who find it very difficult hearing things along the lines of "Oh yes, what a term! Saskia did get into St Custards, but it was touch and go whether we could keep up the pony AND the bassoon lessons during the 11+" while they are staring down the barrel of a pupil referral unit for their kid and navigating homophobic abuse from the child's birth siblings at annual contact.

One thing which genuinely has surprised me - I would have expected the surrogacy children to start showing signs of trauma similar to the adoptive children at least as adolescents. So far, not at all. They seem to be a remarkably well balanced, resilient, and high achieving group. Maybe it will fall apart in their 20s but no sign so far in our group which has surrogacy children from babies up to early teens.

I still disagree with surrogacy on principle, I think it is exploitative of mothers and babies, but I am beginning to question whether the more extreme effects attributed to trauma that we see in adopted children are actually more likely to be foetal drug and alcohol injury.

Thanks, that's a very interesting post. I do think adoption is different and these adoptive couples sound really positive. There need to be careful checks but it is a qualitatively different situation from surrogacy, definitely.

Hopefully surrogacy does not usually have long term severe mental health consequences as adoption can..it's worrisome there are so few studies.