Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

76 year old pedophile buys a baby

177 replies

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Paedophile, 76, had surrogate baby to raise as a single father

Former football coach caught up in custody battle with hospital after it learnt about his past

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

OP posts:
MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:31

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 14:20

Extremism can only exist with sweeping statements and emotive rhetoric.
Please do give the peer reviewed evidence for the fundamental wrong in adoption. Or do you have personal experience of individual cases?
Have you ever ever been present when a mother is seperate from her baby with a cleaver? Have you even had real life experience of people who have helped their family or others to have children when they cannot?

That's not what the poster said - they commented about children who are adopted speaking about their feelings of loss in the face of this "primal separation?"
They weren't calling adoption a "fundamental wrong " - surprised to see you use that emotive phrase.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 14:32

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:01

Do you know what measures we have in the UK to stop predators buying and abusing babies? The answer is none.

Surrogacy legislation on the UK is toothless. It will only be if someone is known to be a convicted paedophile or is found to be abusing the child that our child safeguarding laws step in.
Recently two 70 year old women bought a baby from abroad and UK law was unable to do anything to stop them. No suggestion they're predators but the child is now saddled with two self centred elderly women who may well not last into their 90s to parent the child.

Edited

Which is shocking but it’s likely that those women bought that baby from a country where it is not legalised and therefore have less regulations around it.

Women who are desperate for a baby will go to great lengths to get one.

Making it legal means it can go through the correct processes and make sure men like this one don’t have access to them.

Ashhh56 · Yesterday 14:37

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:38

Couples are often not buying a baby though. The baby is made in an ivf clinic and the baby is then carried by another woman. The baby is already 'made' so not trafficking. The payment is for the emotional and physical toll on her for carrying said baby. I agree with the aspect about using impoverished women but in the Uk its done via a clinic

Why is it never wealthy women carrying babies for poor couples? Finances are almost always the reason women become surrogates and its exploitative as hell.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 14:38

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 14:27

And sue if its the "wrong" sex

I got annoyed yesterday when Amazon sent me a clothes basket which wasn't the colour I ordered, can only imagine how much more aggravating that would be if I'd been sent the wrong sex of human I'd ordered!

In all seriousness though that case and the level.of disdain those men feel towards women is chilling.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 14:40

Ashhh56 · Yesterday 14:37

Why is it never wealthy women carrying babies for poor couples? Finances are almost always the reason women become surrogates and its exploitative as hell.

I don't think.I have ever seen this question answered whenever the surrogacy topic has come up. Strange, that.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:43

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 14:32

Which is shocking but it’s likely that those women bought that baby from a country where it is not legalised and therefore have less regulations around it.

Women who are desperate for a baby will go to great lengths to get one.

Making it legal means it can go through the correct processes and make sure men like this one don’t have access to them.

I'm just pointing out that (unlike many other countries) the UK hasn't outlawed surrogacy. Yet in the face of these women's selfish decisions, the law was impotent to stop them getting control of two children (I was wrong - there were 2 babies).
The judge went to great lengths to explain the problems with what the women had done yet and how it was illegal. Along with pointing put that the two Ukrainian women used as surrogates, were "being exploited for commercial gain".

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/senior-judge-warns-against-unlawful-161145854.html

It's why surrogacy needs to be illegal.

Senior judge warns against unlawful surrogacies after women ‘exploited’

Sir Andrew McFarlane said anyone ‘following in the footsteps’ of the couple should think again.

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/senior-judge-warns-against-unlawful-161145854.html

Periperi2025 · Yesterday 14:44

StillAutumnColours · Yesterday 12:58

Why?

why is a single person wanting to be a parent any less valid than a couple wanting to be parents? Yes. An ideal world. Every child would have two healthy, happy parents, but we don't live in a mythical ideal world, lots of children only have one parent parenting them & and not because that's how they chose to have their children, so individuals seeking surrogacy are already one step ahead, knowing that they are going it alone.

However, I'm not sure how a 76 year old person of either gender was able to get that far through the process.

Nor how a pedophile was able to even get past stage one of the process, that's the truly concerning part.

A single women can try her luck at getting pregnant herself.
A single man should not have the right to buy a womens body.
Nobody has the right to buy & sell babies as commodities.

Having a baby is not a right.

MabelAnderson · Yesterday 14:47

You can’t buy a kidney. It’s recognised that this is open to exploitation, and a risky procedure for the donor. Yet you can buy another person. It’s absolutely wrong.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 14:52

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:38

Couples are often not buying a baby though. The baby is made in an ivf clinic and the baby is then carried by another woman. The baby is already 'made' so not trafficking. The payment is for the emotional and physical toll on her for carrying said baby. I agree with the aspect about using impoverished women but in the Uk its done via a clinic

So by that logic if I buy a bespoke kitchen I'm not actually buying a kitchen. I'm just buying the wood and paying the joiner for the emotional and physical labour of assembling it.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · Yesterday 14:53

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:03

Are you using this unique case to criticise all surrogacy processes?
There have been cases where people have used cars as weapons to kill people. By your thought process you should call for all cars to be banned too.
We could extrapolate your reasoning further …

I think surrogacy is absolutely abhorrent, tantamount to child abuse and should be banned. This case is just one of very many reasons why.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 14:55

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 14:32

Which is shocking but it’s likely that those women bought that baby from a country where it is not legalised and therefore have less regulations around it.

Women who are desperate for a baby will go to great lengths to get one.

Making it legal means it can go through the correct processes and make sure men like this one don’t have access to them.

Making it criminal means it can be handled the same way as all other forms of human trafficking. Or do you think it should just be legal to buy and sell humans because if you can't stop it happening you may as well regulate the market?

Emilesgran · Yesterday 15:03

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 14:32

Which is shocking but it’s likely that those women bought that baby from a country where it is not legalised and therefore have less regulations around it.

Women who are desperate for a baby will go to great lengths to get one.

Making it legal means it can go through the correct processes and make sure men like this one don’t have access to them.

People who are desperate for a kidney will go to great lengths to get one, but we don’t make buying human body parts legal for that reason.

grindergirl · Yesterday 15:04

Horrific case, obviously. But if slavery and trafficking are wrong, then so is surrogacy as a financial transaction. Babies should not be bought and sold

The instance of a poster carrying a baby for her sister is different. It would not have been called surrogacy, but in the dim and distant past, the shame of bearing a child out of wedlock was real. A sister, or even the girl's mother, would often have raised the child as their own

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 15:06

“Are we really going use this one example ten examples multiple endless examples of things that can go wrong with surrogacy to try and ban it?”

n+1 again isn’t it?

user1471538275 · Yesterday 15:10

@Kepler22B There's no difference apart from one is 'made to order' and the other is 'get what I've got'

Absolutely vile trade in infants via the use of women's bodies.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · Yesterday 15:11

Kepler22B · Yesterday 13:36

I’ve never understood why a mum selling a month old baby for $50,000 is considered different to a surrogate getting $50,000. Yet only one is illegal.

This. They're not different, they're the exact same thing, selling human beings. Slavery. AT least the Mum selling the baby at a few months old didn't rip it away from the body it had grown in at birth, causing trauma, so technically that's probably a little better though still abhorrent.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Yesterday 15:18

cariadlet · Yesterday 12:44

I've thought for years that surrogacy should be banned but have never come across anything this bad before. Thank goodness the hospital rumbled him.

It happened in Australia a few years ago and more recently there were those two men who adopted a baby boy and raped him to death (not a surrogacy but same principle)

WhoKnowsAboutTheDog · Yesterday 15:20

Disgusting piece of shit.

Surrogacy should be banned everywhere. Renting wombs and selling babies is disgusting.

DabOfPistachio · Yesterday 15:21

I find it bizarre that people think women growing and selling babies is okay if a couple really wants one, but if we were to talk about selling organs like kidneys then suddenly it's understood how that would be exploitative and subject to huge ethical issues, even when that kidney might save someone's life.
Pregnancy and childbirth is not risk free, and it's not an organ that's being given away, it's a human being.
Like kidneys, it would make sense if not for profit and is instead a conscious decision by a family member or someone equally close. Anything else is incredibly dubious.

RedToothBrush · Yesterday 15:21

MrsSlocombesCat · Yesterday 12:52

I think it would be a shame to ban surrogacy on the grounds that a minority misuse it. It's helped a lot of couples have a family. I would support a ban for single people though.

ALL surrogacy is child trafficking.

No exceptions.

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:22

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:38

Couples are often not buying a baby though. The baby is made in an ivf clinic and the baby is then carried by another woman. The baby is already 'made' so not trafficking. The payment is for the emotional and physical toll on her for carrying said baby. I agree with the aspect about using impoverished women but in the Uk its done via a clinic

It is a transaction whether there is payment involved or not.

It requires a woman to hand over a product when the product is an infant.

An infant who has spent 9 months development within a person that the infant has shared a bond with where that bond is destroyed by the infant being removed from that mother. No comfort available from that mother who that infant has known her voice and her movements while that infant gets to know the world around it.

The infant is turned into a product that has been transacted. No matter how someone attempts to use soft language to describe it, that is the reality.

SerendipityJane · Yesterday 15:24

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Surrogacy simply makes babies commodities, with all the attendant properties.

Stealing. Smuggling. Lying. Acting for greed and profit.

Even if it were banned outright, you'd never stop it. But at least the principle is laid out.

Otherwise, as GBS noted we are "just arguing about the price"

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:27

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:44

I hear you.
You are labelling me as evil for giving eggs or carrying a child for my sister who is unable to do so. It doesn’t matter why she is unable (cancer, surgery, assault, age, trauma). You believe she is not allowed the child.
You are allowed your opinion. Luckily I am allowed mine too.

Why do either of you think it is your sister's right to have a child created for order for her?

By all means she is allowed to have children in her life. The solution is not to treat transacting an infant as if it is a human right.

Pearlstillsinging · Yesterday 15:29

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 13:18

Many of us think that trading in babies, human trafficking is wrong and unethical. Purchasing humans, removing babies from their mothers at birth to hand over to a purchaser should be a criminal offence.

Some people don't share these ethics and promote the purchase and sale of babies. 🙄

Edited

Puppies have to stay with their birth mother until 8 weeks old, legally. 8 week.old pups are much more mature than 8 week old humans.

Anyone who is "desperate for a family' can offer a home to a child who is also "desperate for a family". It's normally called fostering or adoption.