Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

76 year old pedophile buys a baby

177 replies

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Paedophile, 76, had surrogate baby to raise as a single father

Former football coach caught up in custody battle with hospital after it learnt about his past

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

OP posts:
NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 17:36

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:22

I agree with you re the horrors of this story & the reasons behind it. Otoh I can't agree that the woman whose egg is used is not the mum.

Genetically, she indisputably is.

Genetic mother, biological mother, and social mother. Three distinct roles/relationships. Usually the same woman in all three, but not always.

HenriettaHippopotamus · Yesterday 17:40

Horrified but not surprised. What did people think would happen when babies are sold as commodities?

Happyjoe · Yesterday 17:47

Is it surrogacy or the law in America to blame?
Anyway, thankful that he was rumbled and I suspect he will lose custody.

SerendipityJane · Yesterday 17:48

HenriettaHippopotamus · Yesterday 17:40

Horrified but not surprised. What did people think would happen when babies are sold as commodities?

Not much, it seems.

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 18:21

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:24

Single men of any sexuality are also allowed to adopt babies & kids here

It's not about gayness, it's men. I don't think men or a single man should be able to adopt kids with no woman involved.

I am fully against surrogacy, because it involves exploitation of women and doesn’t centre the child’s interests.

I disagree though that gay men should not be able to adopt, because those issues above do not arise, provided there is proper and thorough screening and monitoring (which should include imo a full search of their internet use and devices). Obviously some men are abusers (gay or not) and no child should be adopted without proper safeguards in place.

My gay friends adopted a beautiful boy at about 18 months. He is now 6 and they are fantastic fathers.

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · Yesterday 18:24

Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:27

Why do either of you think it is your sister's right to have a child created for order for her?

By all means she is allowed to have children in her life. The solution is not to treat transacting an infant as if it is a human right.

So, are you against all IVF then?

And presumably sperm donation?

Boreded · Yesterday 18:24

It’s behind a paywall

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:32

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · Yesterday 18:24

So, are you against all IVF then?

And presumably sperm donation?

You really don’t see a difference between IVF using the woman’s own eggs being implanted into her own body, and surrogate pregnancies??

IVF using donor eggs but where the pregnant woman is going to raise the child is somewhere in between but on the whole I would expect that carrying the baby and giving birth to it would create a bond akin to giving birth to one’s own baby.

And using donor sperm is very different to taking a newborn away from the woman who is just given birth to it.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 19:35

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · Yesterday 18:24

So, are you against all IVF then?

And presumably sperm donation?

You mean where the baby is born to and raised by its mother for a lifetime, and isn't sold or donated to other adults?

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 19:35

Jane3212 · Yesterday 17:22

I agree with you re the horrors of this story & the reasons behind it. Otoh I can't agree that the woman whose egg is used is not the mum.

Genetically, she indisputably is.

Legally (in the UK) shes not. Emotionally and from the babies point of view the woman who grew them is their mother.
Morally a woman who has her eggs harvested with the intention of using another woman as a surrogate so she can have a baby is not a mother

OP posts:
Helleofabore · Yesterday 19:43

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · Yesterday 18:24

So, are you against all IVF then?

And presumably sperm donation?

Having assistance to get pregnant is not the same as surrogacy.

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 19:48

@KnownTroublemaker not sure why you feel asking for empirical evidence signifies distress. Did you have bad experiences in academia?
@MrsOvertonsWindow have you been involved in any adoptions. Have you ever seen the type of situation which leads a child to be removed from their birth parents? Believe me it takes A LOT to get the courts to mandate adoption. Would you prefer the child stay in that situation?
@Notmycircusnotmyotter and @Helleofabore so you call it abhorrent that I may carry a child for a sister who lost her womb to cancer. I consider your opinion cruel. Luckily it carries no weight irl.

Above all what’s strikes me about this thread is all the ire directed at women who chose to be a surrogate, women who cannot carry their own children, women who donate eggs, women who use donated eggs.
On a feminism board, following an article about a male paedophile, the majority of criticism, and even hate, is directed at women.

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 19:52

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 19:35

Legally (in the UK) shes not. Emotionally and from the babies point of view the woman who grew them is their mother.
Morally a woman who has her eggs harvested with the intention of using another woman as a surrogate so she can have a baby is not a mother

“Morally” is meaningless? An egg donor is the genetic mother.

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 19:55

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 19:48

@KnownTroublemaker not sure why you feel asking for empirical evidence signifies distress. Did you have bad experiences in academia?
@MrsOvertonsWindow have you been involved in any adoptions. Have you ever seen the type of situation which leads a child to be removed from their birth parents? Believe me it takes A LOT to get the courts to mandate adoption. Would you prefer the child stay in that situation?
@Notmycircusnotmyotter and @Helleofabore so you call it abhorrent that I may carry a child for a sister who lost her womb to cancer. I consider your opinion cruel. Luckily it carries no weight irl.

Above all what’s strikes me about this thread is all the ire directed at women who chose to be a surrogate, women who cannot carry their own children, women who donate eggs, women who use donated eggs.
On a feminism board, following an article about a male paedophile, the majority of criticism, and even hate, is directed at women.

No one is directing any ire or hate towards women here - everyone has pointed out the exploitation of women that is at the heart of surrogacy and the lack of concern for the child. That applies whether the person arranging the surrogacy is male or female.

No one - male or female - is entitled to a child whether they are a paedophile or have lost their own womb or anything in between.

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 20:09

Have you ever seen the type of situation which leads a child to be removed from their birth parents? Believe me it takes A LOT to get the courts to mandate adoption.

Exactly. But in surrogacy, the baby is just wheeled in a cot to another room and leaves with a stranger.

Why isn’t the separation of a baby from its birth mother in surrogacy treated the same as in adoption?

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 20:10

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 19:55

No one is directing any ire or hate towards women here - everyone has pointed out the exploitation of women that is at the heart of surrogacy and the lack of concern for the child. That applies whether the person arranging the surrogacy is male or female.

No one - male or female - is entitled to a child whether they are a paedophile or have lost their own womb or anything in between.

This.

'Hate' is thrown around like confetti these days, it's a silly word for disagreement. The argument being made is that adult feelings and needs should not be used an excuse for a practice that sets aside the child entirely except as the wanted commodity and has many, many ethical issues.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 20:28

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 19:48

@KnownTroublemaker not sure why you feel asking for empirical evidence signifies distress. Did you have bad experiences in academia?
@MrsOvertonsWindow have you been involved in any adoptions. Have you ever seen the type of situation which leads a child to be removed from their birth parents? Believe me it takes A LOT to get the courts to mandate adoption. Would you prefer the child stay in that situation?
@Notmycircusnotmyotter and @Helleofabore so you call it abhorrent that I may carry a child for a sister who lost her womb to cancer. I consider your opinion cruel. Luckily it carries no weight irl.

Above all what’s strikes me about this thread is all the ire directed at women who chose to be a surrogate, women who cannot carry their own children, women who donate eggs, women who use donated eggs.
On a feminism board, following an article about a male paedophile, the majority of criticism, and even hate, is directed at women.

You're evidently angry about criticisms of surrogacy. I presume this is a personal issue for you?
I have been professionally involved in safeguarding for many decades and have worked (in education) with countless children who've been adopted and am very familiar with a range of challenges these vulnerable children and their parents can face. It very much depends on the reasons and context of an adoption and like everyone involved in statutory safeguarding, the only focus must be "what's in the best interests of the child". Establishing that is complex and challenging.

The ire isn't aimed at women surrogates - it's aimed at the ghouls who promote the trade in babies, who commercially exploit often poor women and a society that fails to regulate this human trafficking.

Commercial surrogacy is a trade, A business in commissioning and purchasing babies. The focus is the demands of the adult purchasers with the best interests of the child being ignored.

Just as it's illegal to a sell a kidney, so it should be illegal to sell a baby

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 20:45

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 20:28

You're evidently angry about criticisms of surrogacy. I presume this is a personal issue for you?
I have been professionally involved in safeguarding for many decades and have worked (in education) with countless children who've been adopted and am very familiar with a range of challenges these vulnerable children and their parents can face. It very much depends on the reasons and context of an adoption and like everyone involved in statutory safeguarding, the only focus must be "what's in the best interests of the child". Establishing that is complex and challenging.

The ire isn't aimed at women surrogates - it's aimed at the ghouls who promote the trade in babies, who commercially exploit often poor women and a society that fails to regulate this human trafficking.

Commercial surrogacy is a trade, A business in commissioning and purchasing babies. The focus is the demands of the adult purchasers with the best interests of the child being ignored.

Just as it's illegal to a sell a kidney, so it should be illegal to sell a baby

Rest assured it takes a lot for a child to be removed. Hence you may be conflating distress of an adopted child with the distress from their prior circumstances conferred. In your role I’m sure you’ll work closely with those who professionally help address this type of trauma, so run it past them.

Fortunately this country is wise in making commercial surrogacy and commercial organ donation illegal. So ire about it in this country is the same as ire against open sale of plutonium and machine guns or endangered species.

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 20:53

Altruistic, commercial…the baby is still separated from its mother regardless.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 20:54

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 20:45

Rest assured it takes a lot for a child to be removed. Hence you may be conflating distress of an adopted child with the distress from their prior circumstances conferred. In your role I’m sure you’ll work closely with those who professionally help address this type of trauma, so run it past them.

Fortunately this country is wise in making commercial surrogacy and commercial organ donation illegal. So ire about it in this country is the same as ire against open sale of plutonium and machine guns or endangered species.

Commercial surrogacy is defacto legalised in this country. No parental order has ever been refused in the grounds of excessive "expenses" which can be tens of thousands of pounds.
And of course it's perfectly legal to buy a baby overseas. A parental order will be granted.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 21:01

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 20:54

Commercial surrogacy is defacto legalised in this country. No parental order has ever been refused in the grounds of excessive "expenses" which can be tens of thousands of pounds.
And of course it's perfectly legal to buy a baby overseas. A parental order will be granted.

This.
I'll post again the link to the jugment where two 70 year old women illegally bought 2 babies, commercially exploited the Ukrainian women who carried them and were monumentally selfish in getting their wish for children granted. The judge explained clearly why he had to grant the parental order despite the illegality and exploitation involved:

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/senior-judge-warns-against-unlawful-161145854.html

Senior judge warns against unlawful surrogacies after women ‘exploited’

Sir Andrew McFarlane said anyone ‘following in the footsteps’ of the couple should think again.

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/senior-judge-warns-against-unlawful-161145854.html

ZoeCM · Yesterday 21:50

Ileithyia · Yesterday 13:42

Adoption already does this. Maybe we could fix the barriers to adoption so that it’s more available and better supported, rather than renting out a woman’s body to gestate and traffic a baby.

The problem is that the barriers to adoption are there to protect children and reduce the chance of adoption breakdown.

ZoeCM · Yesterday 22:09

ZoeCM · Yesterday 21:50

The problem is that the barriers to adoption are there to protect children and reduce the chance of adoption breakdown.

I just realised that this post could be read ambiguously. Obviously it's a good thing that those barriers are there. I meant "the problem with removing the barriers".

ZoeCM · Yesterday 22:21

Adults who were adopted, including ones adopted at birth, have been able to explain in detail the harms some of them experience of that primal separation and loss; being expected not to mind about it and be joyful that they were so 'wanted', to not mind about calling a different family member 'mum' to the one who is actually their mother, and having their feelings and needs buried under what adults wanted for them. Adoption processes thoroughly vet parents, with the child's needs, best interests and future being the central focus for all, and not all by any means are approved. The adoption process makes clear to potential parents that they are not receiving a blank slate on which they are projecting their parenting dreams: the child comes to them from a situation of loss. Surrogacy escapes all of that scrutiny and child-centred process. And that's before you even start going into the situation and risks for the mother of the child.

This is very true. I'd say surrogacy is currently at the same stage adoption was at in the 70s, i.e. the focus is entirely on the parents and the child's rights are hand-waved away as unimportant. The depressing part is that society always waits until these kids themselves have grown up and campaigned for their own rights. We saw it with adoption, and we saw it with gamete donor anonymity (and even then, people go abroad to get around the law). The people in power never say, "Hang on, maybe we should think about the impact on the children we're creating."

Jane3212 · Yesterday 22:26

BillieWiper · Yesterday 17:34

Yeah I think deffo no single men. And there should be an age cut off point for everyone.

I kinda want to say no male only couples either but I guess that kinda would be homophobic? The recent Preston Davey case obviously hasn't helped the feelings on this. I think maybe a higher level of scrutiny and checking needs to be done if it is to be two men. And they should prioritise parents where there's at least one woman.

I see no issue with single women though. Let's face it most women don't have much of a choice when they become single parents. But they do it all the time very successfully.

It's not homophobic to say no men without women. What would be homophobic would be banning male couples but letting straight single men do it.