Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

76 year old pedophile buys a baby

177 replies

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Paedophile, 76, had surrogate baby to raise as a single father

Former football coach caught up in custody battle with hospital after it learnt about his past

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:41

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:03

Are you using this unique case to criticise all surrogacy processes?
There have been cases where people have used cars as weapons to kill people. By your thought process you should call for all cars to be banned too.
We could extrapolate your reasoning further …

No im not.
What is am doing is pointing out yet another disgusting consequence in the long list of consequences of allowing people to buy children.
I have never denied that I want all surrogacy and egg donation made illegal as nobody should be able to buy another person and nobody has the right to be a parent.
If you cant have children because you are infertile, left it too late, your single or are in a same sex relationship then thats sad but it doesn't give you the right to buy eggs, rent a woman's body and put her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries just because you want a baby

OP posts:
Ileithyia · Yesterday 13:42

MrsSlocombesCat · Yesterday 12:52

I think it would be a shame to ban surrogacy on the grounds that a minority misuse it. It's helped a lot of couples have a family. I would support a ban for single people though.

Adoption already does this. Maybe we could fix the barriers to adoption so that it’s more available and better supported, rather than renting out a woman’s body to gestate and traffic a baby.

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:44

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:41

No im not.
What is am doing is pointing out yet another disgusting consequence in the long list of consequences of allowing people to buy children.
I have never denied that I want all surrogacy and egg donation made illegal as nobody should be able to buy another person and nobody has the right to be a parent.
If you cant have children because you are infertile, left it too late, your single or are in a same sex relationship then thats sad but it doesn't give you the right to buy eggs, rent a woman's body and put her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries just because you want a baby

I hear you.
You are labelling me as evil for giving eggs or carrying a child for my sister who is unable to do so. It doesn’t matter why she is unable (cancer, surgery, assault, age, trauma). You believe she is not allowed the child.
You are allowed your opinion. Luckily I am allowed mine too.

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:47

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:38

Couples are often not buying a baby though. The baby is made in an ivf clinic and the baby is then carried by another woman. The baby is already 'made' so not trafficking. The payment is for the emotional and physical toll on her for carrying said baby. I agree with the aspect about using impoverished women but in the Uk its done via a clinic

They are buying a baby though as they are paying for it to be made and carried by another woman with the sole intention of removing that child from its mother at birth so that they can have the baby they wanted, ordered, bought and paid for. How can that be anything other than buying a baby?

OP posts:
KnownTroublemaker · Yesterday 13:48

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:40

Many people think the trade in propaganda and conspiracy theories is wrong, but social media is allowed to exist.
Many people think only their God should dictate procreation, but contraception continues to be available (in this country).
Many many people believe they have superiority over women and women should be subject to their power and will, but thank Goodness we have rules to try and limit that in this country.
Luckily in a democracy we can try and vote in informed leaders who take advice from experts. Unfortunately we seem to be living in a world where extreme views and bigotry is tolerated more and more

It certainly is an extreme view to accept that babies can and should be created solely to be cleaved from their mother at birth and handed to a complete stranger. We already know how wounded adopted children are by this primal separation - making this a deliberate act is abhorrent.

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 13:51

I am pro-surrogacy for this reason.

The amount of men who buy babies and children to abuse them is much higher than we realise.

Legalising it helps to regulate it and prevent the wrong people from doing it.

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:53

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:47

They are buying a baby though as they are paying for it to be made and carried by another woman with the sole intention of removing that child from its mother at birth so that they can have the baby they wanted, ordered, bought and paid for. How can that be anything other than buying a baby?

The fertilised embryo already exists as mum egg and dad sperm. The woman is paid to carry it.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 13:54

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 13:40

Many people think the trade in propaganda and conspiracy theories is wrong, but social media is allowed to exist.
Many people think only their God should dictate procreation, but contraception continues to be available (in this country).
Many many people believe they have superiority over women and women should be subject to their power and will, but thank Goodness we have rules to try and limit that in this country.
Luckily in a democracy we can try and vote in informed leaders who take advice from experts. Unfortunately we seem to be living in a world where extreme views and bigotry is tolerated more and more

Maybe I've misunderstood but are you saying that arguing against human / baby trafficking is a conspiracy theory - or an extreme view and bigotry? 😅
Your post seemed rather confused.

Kepler22B · Yesterday 13:56

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:53

The fertilised embryo already exists as mum egg and dad sperm. The woman is paid to carry it.

Without the woman carrying it there is no baby. They are buying a baby not an embryo.

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 14:00

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:53

The fertilised embryo already exists as mum egg and dad sperm. The woman is paid to carry it.

The woman whos egg is used is not "mum" the mother is the woman who carries the baby hopefully to term.
The "commissioning parents" ie purchasing owners are still creating a baby with the sole intention of removing it from the only mother that it's ever known and causing both mother and child irreparable emotional harm all because they want the baby they bought

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 14:00

I don't believe any form of surrogacy should be legal. Appalling case, which highlights the lack of safeguarding.

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:01

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 13:51

I am pro-surrogacy for this reason.

The amount of men who buy babies and children to abuse them is much higher than we realise.

Legalising it helps to regulate it and prevent the wrong people from doing it.

Do you know what measures we have in the UK to stop predators buying and abusing babies? The answer is none.

Surrogacy legislation on the UK is toothless. It will only be if someone is known to be a convicted paedophile or is found to be abusing the child that our child safeguarding laws step in.
Recently two 70 year old women bought a baby from abroad and UK law was unable to do anything to stop them. No suggestion they're predators but the child is now saddled with two self centred elderly women who may well not last into their 90s to parent the child.

Gengha · Yesterday 14:02

So disgusting

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 14:08

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 13:18

Many of us think that trading in babies, human trafficking is wrong and unethical. Purchasing humans, removing babies from their mothers at birth to hand over to a purchaser should be a criminal offence.

Some people don't share these ethics and promote the purchase and sale of babies. 🙄

Edited

This. And this abhorrent situation in the OP was inevitable.

Having a child is not a 'right'. This is always, always about the desires of the adults shouting down the interests and rights of the child being created. I have no patience with the whole 'but I paid a lot of money for a lab to create an embryo, the woman only...' - ffs, the woman's body created, grew, fed and developed that sentient child out of genetic material, her voice, her heartbeat is what that child knows. This is creating a commissioned child with the intention from the outset of creating it to remove it from its mother and inflict that primal injury, and then loudly claim to everyone including the child that it doesn't matter. Because to consider otherwise would upset the agenda and the feelings of the adult who want that baby for their own needs.

Adults who were adopted, including ones adopted at birth, have been able to explain in detail the harms some of them experience of that primal separation and loss; being expected not to mind about it and be joyful that they were so 'wanted', to not mind about calling a different family member 'mum' to the one who is actually their mother, and having their feelings and needs buried under what adults wanted for them. Adoption processes thoroughly vet parents, with the child's needs, best interests and future being the central focus for all, and not all by any means are approved. The adoption process makes clear to potential parents that they are not receiving a blank slate on which they are projecting their parenting dreams: the child comes to them from a situation of loss. Surrogacy escapes all of that scrutiny and child-centred process. And that's before you even start going into the situation and risks for the mother of the child.

The grief of infertility is huge, but it's no excuse. Some things don't go our way in life. Surrogacy should be banned. Entirely. In all circumstances.

BernardBlacksMolluscs · Yesterday 14:12

Commercial surrogacy is abhorrent. Yet another example of why

ThunderThunderThunderThunderCats · Yesterday 14:18

This is what happens when women are legally used as commodities to produce babies for profit.

Trwkaw · Yesterday 14:18

Yabu i dont really think this is about surrogacy.
obviously we dont want a paedo getting any child but i just think its exactly the same if adopting or having their own child.

The main issue is paedos being free to do what they want

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 14:20

KnownTroublemaker · Yesterday 13:48

It certainly is an extreme view to accept that babies can and should be created solely to be cleaved from their mother at birth and handed to a complete stranger. We already know how wounded adopted children are by this primal separation - making this a deliberate act is abhorrent.

Extremism can only exist with sweeping statements and emotive rhetoric.
Please do give the peer reviewed evidence for the fundamental wrong in adoption. Or do you have personal experience of individual cases?
Have you ever ever been present when a mother is seperate from her baby with a cleaver? Have you even had real life experience of people who have helped their family or others to have children when they cannot?

LadyInRainbow · Yesterday 14:21

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:41

No im not.
What is am doing is pointing out yet another disgusting consequence in the long list of consequences of allowing people to buy children.
I have never denied that I want all surrogacy and egg donation made illegal as nobody should be able to buy another person and nobody has the right to be a parent.
If you cant have children because you are infertile, left it too late, your single or are in a same sex relationship then thats sad but it doesn't give you the right to buy eggs, rent a woman's body and put her at risk of death and/or serious life long injuries just because you want a baby

What about sperm donation is that okay?

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 14:22

He was caught - proving that it isn't possible for convicted .paedophiles to gain access to children.

Condemning surrogacy based on this makes no sense at all. It's rare for this to happen - the vast, vast majority of surrogate children are planned for, wanted and happy. Same can't be said for a lot of children conceived the usual way.

Most paedophiles don't do this, it's too exposing and risky. They quietly prey on stepchildren, their own children and any they have access to.

We need harsher jail sentences, a far more accurate database of where paedophiles are, and a crackdown on CSA.

As if a whole.system.should be taken down because of an evil guy who was caught.

Woody Allen was allowed adopt more children after being accused of raping his daughter and then marrying someone he raised as a daughter for pity's sake.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 14:25

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:47

They are buying a baby though as they are paying for it to be made and carried by another woman with the sole intention of removing that child from its mother at birth so that they can have the baby they wanted, ordered, bought and paid for. How can that be anything other than buying a baby?

And if their pre-ordered human purchase has any health issues or defects then they can just refuse to claim it, shrug their shoulders and walk away.

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 14:27

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 14:25

And if their pre-ordered human purchase has any health issues or defects then they can just refuse to claim it, shrug their shoulders and walk away.

And sue if its the "wrong" sex

OP posts:
KnownTroublemaker · Yesterday 14:28

LongDarkTeatime · Yesterday 14:20

Extremism can only exist with sweeping statements and emotive rhetoric.
Please do give the peer reviewed evidence for the fundamental wrong in adoption. Or do you have personal experience of individual cases?
Have you ever ever been present when a mother is seperate from her baby with a cleaver? Have you even had real life experience of people who have helped their family or others to have children when they cannot?

Are you okay? I'm sorry this topic is upsetting you.

Dryshampoofordays · Yesterday 14:31

Kepler22B · Yesterday 13:36

I’ve never understood why a mum selling a month old baby for $50,000 is considered different to a surrogate getting $50,000. Yet only one is illegal.

Yes, this. A baby literally has no concept of being a separate being from its biological mum. Taking a baby from it’s mum should only happen when there is no other option, e.g neglect/abuse. When you adopt a child you are taught all about adverse childhood experiences to make sure you under the impact on the child from being separated from their primary caregiver-they will be affected by this on a neurological level even if they are removed at birth. Surrogacy has the buyer’s best interests at heart, not the baby’s.

HortiGal · Yesterday 14:31

His past aside, an agency thought a 76 yr old single dad was a good plan?