Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

76 year old pedophile buys a baby

177 replies

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 12:21

So a 76 year old convicted pedophile was able to buy a baby through surrogacy to raise as a single "father", however thankfully the hospital found out that he is a pedophile and called social services and the pedophile is battling the hospital and social work to regain custody of the poor baby.
I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.
Gift token for the article

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

Paedophile, 76, had surrogate baby to raise as a single father

Former football coach caught up in custody battle with hospital after it learnt about his past

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/8b55e9b63572660f

OP posts:
Helleofabore · Yesterday 15:30

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 13:51

I am pro-surrogacy for this reason.

The amount of men who buy babies and children to abuse them is much higher than we realise.

Legalising it helps to regulate it and prevent the wrong people from doing it.

Yet surely if a couple or a single person appears with an infant in their lives with no explanation, then they will be investigated and the source of that infant established. If it is child that requires a passport to be brought home, then this also can trigger an investigation.

Why do you believe making it legal will have a better result than procuring an infant being illegal?

Whether it is legal or not, it is someone exploiting at least one female person and an infant. It is transacting an infant.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · Yesterday 15:37

@MrsSlocombesCat I understand you feel your view is "kind" but it confuses me. What about the baby? Does it help the baby to be separated from it's mother immediately? It is illegal to do this to kittens and puppies but we do this to babies. Why does an adults want for a baby matter more than a babies right to it's mother?

viques · Yesterday 15:44

MrsSlocombesCat · Yesterday 12:52

I think it would be a shame to ban surrogacy on the grounds that a minority misuse it. It's helped a lot of couples have a family. I would support a ban for single people though.

It’s baby breeding.

Thatarianagrandesongstuckinmyhead · Yesterday 15:45

This is horrific, was be buying the baby to abuse it, death penalty. He's already ruined so many poor boys lives already and was out of prison in eight years

WhoKnowsAboutTheDog · Yesterday 15:46

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · Yesterday 15:37

@MrsSlocombesCat I understand you feel your view is "kind" but it confuses me. What about the baby? Does it help the baby to be separated from it's mother immediately? It is illegal to do this to kittens and puppies but we do this to babies. Why does an adults want for a baby matter more than a babies right to it's mother?

The needs of the baby are rarely mentioned. It’s all about the wants of adults. Those type of adults don’t have what it takes to be good parents as they’re incapable of putting anyone else’s needs before their own. It’s not a good start on their ‘parenting journey’ that the first parenting decision they make is selfish and harms their child.

user1471538275 · Yesterday 15:46

No one is owed a child.

Being a parent is a huge responsibility, that too few people take seriously.

Whilst it is very sad if you are unable to have a child, many people have taken this loss and turned it to the advantage of non biological children - through fostering, adoption or simply being a fantastic aunt or godparent, or even working with children.

I don't see why we need 'ownership' of children to have positive relationships with them.

mysittingduck · Yesterday 15:55

He paid money for a baby and he's a pedophile. How does his age make this any worse?

MsMacheath · Yesterday 15:59

MrsSlocombesCat · Yesterday 12:52

I think it would be a shame to ban surrogacy on the grounds that a minority misuse it. It's helped a lot of couples have a family. I would support a ban for single people though.

It should be completely banned. No exceptions.

IcedPurple · Yesterday 16:02

Surrogacy needs to be banned. Always and everywhere.

MsMacheath · Yesterday 16:02

Cheese55 · Yesterday 13:38

Couples are often not buying a baby though. The baby is made in an ivf clinic and the baby is then carried by another woman. The baby is already 'made' so not trafficking. The payment is for the emotional and physical toll on her for carrying said baby. I agree with the aspect about using impoverished women but in the Uk its done via a clinic

I don't care. You (general you) can't always get what you want. All surrogacy should be banned. It is banned in several countries.

IcedPurple · Yesterday 16:04

OneHazelBird · Yesterday 14:32

Which is shocking but it’s likely that those women bought that baby from a country where it is not legalised and therefore have less regulations around it.

Women who are desperate for a baby will go to great lengths to get one.

Making it legal means it can go through the correct processes and make sure men like this one don’t have access to them.

You're making it sound like a baby is an illegal drug, that people will 'go to great lengths' to get.

Nobody 'needs' their own baby. Infertility is sad, but human trafficking, which is what surrogacy is, is worse.

shuggles · Yesterday 16:07

@Hoardasurass I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.

That's what you took from this?

... Not the fact that the man is a disgusting sack of shit and should never be allowed near a child or baby?

shuggles · Yesterday 16:08

@IcedPurple You're making it sound like a baby is an illegal drug, that people will 'go to great lengths' to get.

Weird comment. It should be quite clear that there are people who long deeply for a child of their own, and it can cause immense distress if they are unable to have one.

IcedPurple · Yesterday 16:11

shuggles · Yesterday 16:08

@IcedPurple You're making it sound like a baby is an illegal drug, that people will 'go to great lengths' to get.

Weird comment. It should be quite clear that there are people who long deeply for a child of their own, and it can cause immense distress if they are unable to have one.

Yes, and that's sad. But lots of people want lots of things they can't have in life.

You were saying surrogacy should be legalised because if it were not, 'desperate' women will go to any lengths to do it anyway. That's exactly the argument made for legalising drugs. Hence my comment.

MsMacheath · Yesterday 16:11

MrsOvertonsWindow · Yesterday 14:43

I'm just pointing out that (unlike many other countries) the UK hasn't outlawed surrogacy. Yet in the face of these women's selfish decisions, the law was impotent to stop them getting control of two children (I was wrong - there were 2 babies).
The judge went to great lengths to explain the problems with what the women had done yet and how it was illegal. Along with pointing put that the two Ukrainian women used as surrogates, were "being exploited for commercial gain".

https://uk.news.yahoo.com/senior-judge-warns-against-unlawful-161145854.html

It's why surrogacy needs to be illegal.

Someone was wittering on about how great it was we live in a democracy which allows surrogacy.

Bulgaria, Croatia, France, Germany, Italy, Lithuania, Malta, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Spain explicitly ban surrogacy, while countries like Austria, Estonia, Finland, Hungary, and Sweden have implicit bans or restrict it. (Italy also criminalizes citizens seeking surrogacy abroad).

These are all democracies. It's a great pity the UK doesn't implement criminal penalties against UK surrogacy tourists. The do against illegal sex tourists.

overnightangel · Yesterday 16:11

StillAutumnColours · Yesterday 12:58

Why?

why is a single person wanting to be a parent any less valid than a couple wanting to be parents? Yes. An ideal world. Every child would have two healthy, happy parents, but we don't live in a mythical ideal world, lots of children only have one parent parenting them & and not because that's how they chose to have their children, so individuals seeking surrogacy are already one step ahead, knowing that they are going it alone.

However, I'm not sure how a 76 year old person of either gender was able to get that far through the process.

Nor how a pedophile was able to even get past stage one of the process, that's the truly concerning part.

“why is a single person wanting to be a parent any less valid than a couple wanting to be parents?

erm… do you know how babies are made?

No one is entitled to have a child just because they want one.

Annalouisa · Yesterday 16:16

Kepler22B · Yesterday 13:36

I’ve never understood why a mum selling a month old baby for $50,000 is considered different to a surrogate getting $50,000. Yet only one is illegal.

this is a good point: why is ordering a 'fresh' baby a totally valid way of getting a baby, but you can't sell 'second' hand babies - essentially? This drives home the madness of surrogacy being allowed.

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 16:16

shuggles · Yesterday 16:07

@Hoardasurass I know that this is America rather than the UK but surely people have to see the harm that surrogacy is allowing and causing now.

That's what you took from this?

... Not the fact that the man is a disgusting sack of shit and should never be allowed near a child or baby?

Do you think it's an accident that the paedophile used surrogacy to access a child? There is no screening for people purchasing a baby in this manner.

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 16:17

DabOfPistachio · Yesterday 15:21

I find it bizarre that people think women growing and selling babies is okay if a couple really wants one, but if we were to talk about selling organs like kidneys then suddenly it's understood how that would be exploitative and subject to huge ethical issues, even when that kidney might save someone's life.
Pregnancy and childbirth is not risk free, and it's not an organ that's being given away, it's a human being.
Like kidneys, it would make sense if not for profit and is instead a conscious decision by a family member or someone equally close. Anything else is incredibly dubious.

The thing is with so called altruistic surrogacy especially within families the emotional pressure and often abuse applied to women in the family to be a surrogate is huge and the emotional fallout worse particularly when the surrogates eggs are used as you have to watch a family member raise your baby that you carried and was produced with your own egg.
All forms of surrogacy should be illegal and imho everybody involved in it should be jailed for child trafficking

OP posts:
MabelAnderson · Yesterday 16:21

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 13:47

They are buying a baby though as they are paying for it to be made and carried by another woman with the sole intention of removing that child from its mother at birth so that they can have the baby they wanted, ordered, bought and paid for. How can that be anything other than buying a baby?

This. Also the baby is often made in this way using a third woman’s eggs.

SiberFox · Yesterday 16:22

NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 16:16

Do you think it's an accident that the paedophile used surrogacy to access a child? There is no screening for people purchasing a baby in this manner.

That’s the most horrible thing. For one case that has been found out there will be many more that go unseen.

Surrogacy is abhorrent.

VarioPerfect · Yesterday 16:23

It’s absolutely inevitable that paedophiles will use this route to procure victims. This man won’t be the first or the last.

However that is only one of the many reasons why surrogacy should not be allowed. No one is entitled to a child, however nice, or however desperate.

littlebub11 · Yesterday 16:24

76 and buying a baby ? Really ! Hw needs castrating, the filthy lowlife!

Awwlookatmybabyspider · Yesterday 16:26

This is why I say Paedophiles should be looked away for life because there is no cure for them. They can get as much therapy as they want but it’s not help they need it’s a miracle to change their disgusting sexual orientation toward children and you can’t change your sexual orientation it’s impossible. Thank God this was flagged before this beast took this beautiful baby home because I feel physically sick at the thought of what would have happened.

FlatCatYellowMat · Yesterday 16:27

Buying and selling people is wrong. Even very small ones.