Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court

225 replies

Another2Cats · 27/03/2026 12:28

Again, I apologise for this being very long. TL;DR this looks to be the first case at the High Court which will consider the exclusion of trans-identifying men post FWS.

So, for some background, there was a case last year, just after FWS, concerning a trans-identifying man who had been banned from a women's pool competition organised by the English Blackball Pool Federation.

Back at the end of 2023, the Pool Federation changed their rules so that only women could play in women's competitions.

The trans-identifying man, Haynes, then brought a claim of direct discrimination on the ground of gender reassignment against the federation.

The trial took place during 2025 before the judgment in FWS was handed down. The court heard from several witnesses about whether pool was a gender-affected activity (Section 195(3) Equality Act) including Dr Emma Hilton - who is the interim chair of Sex Matters.

However, the FWS judgment came out before the County Court judge had made his judgment on the case and so the pool federation said that each side should make detailed written submissions about the effect of FWS on this case.

The judge agreed and the submissions for the pool federation were written by Sarah Crowther KC of Outer Temple Chambers and those for the trans-identifying man were written by Jane Russell KC. Some may recognise her name from the Sandie Peggie case (and other cases).

.

The judge decided that FWS was sufficient to decide the case in favour of the pool federation but, since he had heard detailed argument, he also set out his conclusions with regard to the sport exception (Section 195) and also about the provision of separate services (Schedule 3 para 28)

The court concluded that pool is a ‘gender-affected activity’ and that excluding those born as male from the female category is necessary to secure fair competition. The court also concluded that this was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

There is a link to the judgment here:

https://jrlevins.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/K01CT207-judgment-1-8-25-handed-down.pdf

.

Haynes has now been granted permission to appeal and has published the grounds of appeal on Haynes Instagram account. I've attached the images here. Haynes tried to get the case "leapfrogged" directly to the Court of Appeal but this was refused.

A brief summary of the grounds, which the judge who considered the application said were all arguable are as follows (personally, I don't they stand up at all, but this is the case he is putting forward):

1 There was no evidence that trans-identifying men had any competitive advantage over women. The judge failed to consider the "mental processes" of the federation and that they were significantly influenced in their decision to exclude trans-identifying men as they were in some way unfairly discriminatory.

2 In considering direct discrimination, the court applied the wrong comparator. Following Croft [Croft v Royal Mail [2003] EWCA Civ 1045] Haynes claims that the correct comparator in this case should be a woman rather than a man.

3 FWS, when applied to the facts of this case, does not comply with Article 8 and Article 14 of the ECHR and, in a claim by an individual, the ECHR applies, whereas it did not for the organisations claiming in FWS.

4 The Court failed to apply S195 Equality Act [the sport exemption] in a ECHR compliant manner. The pool federation did not show that it was necessary to exclude trans-identifying men for the reasons of safety or fair competition. Cue sports are precision sports thus not affected by power/sex. No explanation was given for changing from a testosterone testing system or handicap system.

5 Something about the court wrongly saying that another, professional, pool organisation would have refused Haynes permission to play in this federation's competitions

.

Frankly, I don't think any of those will really hold up. But it will be interesting to see what happens when it does get to court as this will be a High Court judgment rather than just a County Court judgment.

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
nicepotoftea · Yesterday 15:42

WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 15:34

"If the state is treating a TW as a man, that is a significant interference with their rights doesn't reflect social reality, and inconsistent with having been given a GRC. "

Yep, they're trying to use this case to relitigate FWS, aren't they.

And apparently the terms of the GRA.

Another2Cats · Yesterday 15:53

Missed some discussion of Art 6.
J let me just pause you there, I understand your free standing claim on Art 8, if the law doesn't protect HH from what happened, then the law must be read down to protect HH. But if the law is contrary to Art 8 and Art 14 I'm clearly looking to see if there is less favourable treatment for analogous persons. I'm not clear how the D can infringe Art 14.

HS what Semenya is saying is that state has to prevent discrim
J I see that and understand it, what I don't see is how the Ds are held responsible for the Art 8 rights of HH.

HS suppose the state got rid of all equality legislation, well then no one is being discriminating against, but under Art 14 is breached
J Your proposition starts with saying that private individuals can breach Art 14.

HS World Athletics were private individuals in Semenya, it was about the state failing to provide a remedy, thus Art 14. So Semenya identifies differences, but doesn't say if significant, what the state and Ds have done is produce rules intended to produce fairness and everyone has the same interests in relation to that.

HS two things I should address on MLFs subs on 195, Parliament defined tests in 195, plainly intended to comply with convention, there's a need for justification didn't invent proportionality. Parliament decided that bio sex should be comparator in circumstances,

but the notes to GRA said that 195.2 is the section that should be applied when TW excluded from women's sports. Even if I'm wrong about convention compliant reading, you must consider declarations of incompatibility. We gave you an authority that says the burden of proof is on those making the interference with rights of others.

Let's now go to what the judge said 'impossible to say that difference between tw and bio women'
J I've read that 3 times now, what's your point

HS the judge was relying on uncertainty with regard to advantage, fair comp is not about absolute similarity, sport allows for difference. The previous rule was based on IOC rule, at the material time, the starting point was that TW who have suppressed testosterone can compete.
J did I read that they changed that rule
SC yes, in January 2026
J yes I have that

OP posts:
ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Yesterday 16:07

My understanding is that they are trying to have FWS/ EA declared incompatible with ECHR so that the EA legislation can be reworked...

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/S87CAoDdg8

Apologies for the Reddit link but it links to the grounds of appeal

Another2Cats · Yesterday 16:07

HS now on to refusal of competitors to play against HH, doesn't take us any further what if they refused to play against a black person
J but the point is that if it indicates that you won't have any women's comp if you don't exclude TW, then surely it needs to come into decision unless its unreasonable prejudice.

HS I probably shouldn't have said black, but refusal to compete, you need to see underlying reasons. And the rule on testosterone is easy to see, could have applied the IOC rule. And the judge did not balance the impact on the individual.

J it's the group impact that would be most relevant because rule applies to groups
HS now to turn Ground 5.
J I haven't quite followed, what do want me to look at

HS I want you to look at para 7 of judgment and the argument is that what is said by judge is C would continue to play, but one needs to be a little cautious about dismissing it, despite his finding at para 30. This may address the unwillingness to consider the evidence of other professionals.
J the point against you is HH wouldn't have been playing because wouldn't have give permission

HS reading the judgment as a whole doesn't point one way, it may explain the failure to address the position of other professionals that C said had been able to play.
J you're going to trace that second point through then

HS can I just address one factual matter first, we don't accept the point that when competition began in the period. Going to particulars of claim
J what page are we on
HS 138, in relation to that injured feelings was pleaded, was reflected in evidence of C, talked about,
J HH gave evidence about that, give me references I will look up.

HS yes, we do submit that injured feelings were in play. Our ability to raise the convention relies on the rule might be applied in the future.
J it's Shamoo, detriment if someone could complain
HS I make the point on Ground 5, the 17 days. Now on to professionals

the point being made, there were a number of ways in which it could be shown about UPG players, we set this out in the skeleton, could have been challenged, not about county comps and it's reflected in the witness statement. Judge doesn't address that evidence.

OP posts:
Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 16:11

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · Yesterday 16:07

My understanding is that they are trying to have FWS/ EA declared incompatible with ECHR so that the EA legislation can be reworked...

https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/S87CAoDdg8

Apologies for the Reddit link but it links to the grounds of appeal

Is this still an attempt to make the guidance say something different to the law that the guidance is about?

Edited to add: Ah. Yes, on reading that reddit thread: that's exactly what it's about. And that a trans person's article 8 rights are infringed. (Still not getting the limits and other people have rights too. Sigh.)

Seriously. Can we put Mr Tumble to trying to get this across with some signs and songs?

Another2Cats · Yesterday 16:16

J doesn't address that evidence of other players contractual terms and I haven't heard that disputed
HS it's not disputed, but the point was that other players did not have problems playing so would have been able to play, key point is judge didn't deal with that

J the specific point is that the J does not make the point, he doesn't make the point that we weren't aware of the contractual arrangements.
HS that's how C was putting case. Thank you, i think I've covered everything.

J the thought does occur to me reading the judgment, why not call someone to give evidence on UPG practices, that doesn't stop HH from calling someone to give evidence about not being impeded from competing.
HS that's how HH put case
J speaking as a judge it wouldn't be that unusual to call someone to give evidence

HS it wasn't thought to be necessary, because it was thought to be so evident
J I've got your answer on that. It's also been said, should have been disclosure of contract.
HS was disclosed during x-exam.
J But disclosure takes place earlier.
HS I understand that pro forma was disclosed earlier.

J is that actually the case
SC we were given a pro forma contract and we asked for the actual contract, and it was different, it had additional rules
J it's extraordinary that we are talking about this

SC when I x-examined her, she said only that's not my contract, and I couldn't take it any further. That's why the judge made those findings about relying on HH evidence.
J I will give you time to deal with this
HS the full list of players that were playing at the time is in the bundle

J so if the judge was going to question that they were under similar terms he should have mentioned it. I now don't understand points made on clause because it was disclosed in pro forma.
SC the C was flippant and dismissive in x-exam about the contract because I say HH had a problem with the contract. And HH had to be recalled again to answer questions on the contract.

J I'm going to reserve judgement, not sure when that will be.

Court rises

OP posts:
Madcats · Yesterday 17:23

I've not been following this Appeal properly but I was having a little chat with Gemini about what might happen if EBPF win the Appeal and Haynes is indeed impecunious.

"In rare cases, if a winning party can prove that a third-party organization or wealthy backer funded and controlled the litigation behind the scenes, they can apply to the court to make that third party pay the legal costs instead".

At the moment this just feels like vexatious litigation to me.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 17:57

Can anyone explain what the whole contract issue was about?

HH didn’t disclose it, only later on when x examined, I think. A pro forma contract had been provided earlier, but this was different from the contract HH had. He also wouldn’t answer any questions on it in x examined.

Judge seemed a bit put out about points made on clause (by previous Judge?) without mentioning something about the contracts, I think.

Zebracat · Yesterday 18:07

Blimey. I can’t make any sense of any of that.

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 18:16

I probably explained it really badly. You can read the TT a couple posts up, from 16:16.

hatosh · Yesterday 18:32

Cailleach1 · Yesterday 17:57

Can anyone explain what the whole contract issue was about?

HH didn’t disclose it, only later on when x examined, I think. A pro forma contract had been provided earlier, but this was different from the contract HH had. He also wouldn’t answer any questions on it in x examined.

Judge seemed a bit put out about points made on clause (by previous Judge?) without mentioning something about the contracts, I think.

One of the defence's points is that HH wouldn't have been able to play in their events anyway, because of a contract HH signed with UPG. HH tried to hide this at the first trial by not disclosing the actual contract details until mid-trial (previosuly HH shared a generic contract that did not have the restrictive terms in it), then claimed the contract terms wouldn't have been enforced anyway, and finally pointed at the fact that other players were allowed to play in EBPF events without UPG sanctioning them. The Judge dismissed this for a number of reasons: maybe those players had different contract terms, or maybe they were actually sanctioned, also HH hadn't actually asked UPG for permission, and also HH didn't call a witness from UPG to say what their policy actually was, or one of the other players to confirm their contractual terms and whether or not they were sanctioned.

HH's lawyers are now saying that this was improper and the simple list of other UPG players who competed in EBPF events should have been enough evidence. Seems weak, tbh.

moto748e · Yesterday 18:37

By this point UPG were starting to realise what a PITA HH was, and how could they best cut him adrift.

JamesKirkupReviewWritersFund · Yesterday 18:40

I know this from the Judge at close of play is a usual line

”J I'm going to reserve judgement, not sure when that will be.”

I suspect I’m not the only one who read it as “I need a good long break from this madness”

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 18:43

J speaking as a judge it wouldn't be that unusual to call someone to give evidence

Who said Judges have no humour?

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 18:48

The danger here is that the more categorical the judge is that no trans identifying man can ever be allowed to play in women's sport (which is what many of us believe is the correct outcome) the easier it gets for the ECHR to say the UK doesn't have - and should have - a mechanism to consider how horrible it is for any individual trans-identifying woman not to compete in women's sport, and that needs to change.

Reading HH's own posts on Reddit, he really does see this case as setting the scene for an appeal to Strasbourg.

SabrinaThwaite · Yesterday 18:57

Glad to see that the judge has a specialism in sports litigation. He is indeed a balding white man, with a sense of humour (and infinite patience).

Retiredfromthere · Yesterday 21:20

Posting two screenshots from the Reddit thread about the appeal being granted. To which HH contributed with this info about their team and how costs were being covered. (From seven months ago so may have changed but its interesting ...)
So lots of pro bono support from the legal profession.

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
ItsCoolForCats · Today 08:49

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 18:48

The danger here is that the more categorical the judge is that no trans identifying man can ever be allowed to play in women's sport (which is what many of us believe is the correct outcome) the easier it gets for the ECHR to say the UK doesn't have - and should have - a mechanism to consider how horrible it is for any individual trans-identifying woman not to compete in women's sport, and that needs to change.

Reading HH's own posts on Reddit, he really does see this case as setting the scene for an appeal to Strasbourg.

Yes, over on Reddit, they do seem to be positioning HH as the next Goodwin. They have latched onto the idea that the GRA changes a person's sex for all purposes and then conveniently ignore the exceptions.

If this did get to the ECtHR, isn't it likely it would fall well within our margin of appreciation? The UK recognises Haynes's acquired gender. Gender reassignment is a protected characteristic. However, sex in the Equality Act is defined as biological sex,.and section 195 of the EA permits sex separation in sport. Pool is gender-affected sport. Having a female-only category balances the rights of women to fair competition. Haynes is not excluded from competing because there is an open category.

I thought it was interesting when the respondent's barrister said the the ECtHR was feeling it's way on this issue. Major international sporting bodies have moved towards biological sex eligibility, so that is the wider context and consensus.

BellaBlackberry83 · Today 09:09

thought it was interesting when the respondent's barrister said the the ECtHR was feeling it's way on this issue

I am unaware of any ECt authority that expressly considers the rights of women in this context, so that is clearly next on the cards for them. The TRAs do not appreciate that the GRA went far beyond what was mandated by Goodwin.

I also think there is a good point to be made about "tru trans" and the requirement for expensive medical interventions - the moment you go down that path, there is a clear A8 / A14 point for those with gender feelz but without the means to pursue body modification.

nicepotoftea · Today 09:15

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 18:48

The danger here is that the more categorical the judge is that no trans identifying man can ever be allowed to play in women's sport (which is what many of us believe is the correct outcome) the easier it gets for the ECHR to say the UK doesn't have - and should have - a mechanism to consider how horrible it is for any individual trans-identifying woman not to compete in women's sport, and that needs to change.

Reading HH's own posts on Reddit, he really does see this case as setting the scene for an appeal to Strasbourg.

I thought classification in sport was governed less by legal sex and more by whether somebody had gone through male puberty.

moto748e · Today 10:59

nicepotoftea · Today 09:15

I thought classification in sport was governed less by legal sex and more by whether somebody had gone through male puberty.

It surely shouldn't be legal sex, cos that can mean different things in different countries.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Today 11:26

moto748e · Today 10:59

It surely shouldn't be legal sex, cos that can mean different things in different countries.

It previously was legal sex as in the case of Imane Khelif all that was necessary for him to "prove" he was female was to show his passport said "female".

moto748e · Today 12:31

According to the IOC, back then, yes. Fortunately the IOC has moved on from there.

ItsCoolForCats · Today 14:56

Judgement expected before Christmas

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
MyAmpleSheep · Today 15:22

ItsCoolForCats · Today 14:56

Judgement expected before Christmas

Anyone want to guess at the outcome?

I will make myself a hostage to fortune and share mine: appeal rejected on all grounds. If sought, leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal will be granted, but only on the human rights arguments.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page