Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court

225 replies

Another2Cats · 27/03/2026 12:28

Again, I apologise for this being very long. TL;DR this looks to be the first case at the High Court which will consider the exclusion of trans-identifying men post FWS.

So, for some background, there was a case last year, just after FWS, concerning a trans-identifying man who had been banned from a women's pool competition organised by the English Blackball Pool Federation.

Back at the end of 2023, the Pool Federation changed their rules so that only women could play in women's competitions.

The trans-identifying man, Haynes, then brought a claim of direct discrimination on the ground of gender reassignment against the federation.

The trial took place during 2025 before the judgment in FWS was handed down. The court heard from several witnesses about whether pool was a gender-affected activity (Section 195(3) Equality Act) including Dr Emma Hilton - who is the interim chair of Sex Matters.

However, the FWS judgment came out before the County Court judge had made his judgment on the case and so the pool federation said that each side should make detailed written submissions about the effect of FWS on this case.

The judge agreed and the submissions for the pool federation were written by Sarah Crowther KC of Outer Temple Chambers and those for the trans-identifying man were written by Jane Russell KC. Some may recognise her name from the Sandie Peggie case (and other cases).

.

The judge decided that FWS was sufficient to decide the case in favour of the pool federation but, since he had heard detailed argument, he also set out his conclusions with regard to the sport exception (Section 195) and also about the provision of separate services (Schedule 3 para 28)

The court concluded that pool is a ‘gender-affected activity’ and that excluding those born as male from the female category is necessary to secure fair competition. The court also concluded that this was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

There is a link to the judgment here:

https://jrlevins.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/K01CT207-judgment-1-8-25-handed-down.pdf

.

Haynes has now been granted permission to appeal and has published the grounds of appeal on Haynes Instagram account. I've attached the images here. Haynes tried to get the case "leapfrogged" directly to the Court of Appeal but this was refused.

A brief summary of the grounds, which the judge who considered the application said were all arguable are as follows (personally, I don't they stand up at all, but this is the case he is putting forward):

1 There was no evidence that trans-identifying men had any competitive advantage over women. The judge failed to consider the "mental processes" of the federation and that they were significantly influenced in their decision to exclude trans-identifying men as they were in some way unfairly discriminatory.

2 In considering direct discrimination, the court applied the wrong comparator. Following Croft [Croft v Royal Mail [2003] EWCA Civ 1045] Haynes claims that the correct comparator in this case should be a woman rather than a man.

3 FWS, when applied to the facts of this case, does not comply with Article 8 and Article 14 of the ECHR and, in a claim by an individual, the ECHR applies, whereas it did not for the organisations claiming in FWS.

4 The Court failed to apply S195 Equality Act [the sport exemption] in a ECHR compliant manner. The pool federation did not show that it was necessary to exclude trans-identifying men for the reasons of safety or fair competition. Cue sports are precision sports thus not affected by power/sex. No explanation was given for changing from a testosterone testing system or handicap system.

5 Something about the court wrongly saying that another, professional, pool organisation would have refused Haynes permission to play in this federation's competitions

.

Frankly, I don't think any of those will really hold up. But it will be interesting to see what happens when it does get to court as this will be a High Court judgment rather than just a County Court judgment.

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MrsOvertonsWindow · 15/11/2026 23:07

That's great. And thoroughly deserved.

ItsCoolForCats · 16/11/2026 08:53

The Reddit thread linked above, and that whole subReddit in general show such a wilful misunderstanding of the GRA. They think having a GRC changes their sex for all purposes and then they ignore the exceptions and carve outs, such as when the GRA interacts with other legislation.

Is the appeal going to argue that pool isn't a gender affected sport?

ItsCoolForCats · 16/11/2026 10:42

Someone on the Reddit thread said that if it gets to Strasbourg, it will be a slam dunk 🙄

This is true only if you conveniently forget that a) women also have rights and b) rights under the convention are qualified and have to be balanced against competing rights.

BellaBlackberry83 · 16/11/2026 11:20

According to Haynes on that Reddit thread, Linden J will hear it. I don't know a huge amount about him (although, unlike Ritchie J, I believe he is a public law / discrimination specialist).

He also upheld the judicial review in respect of the CC Northumbria Police's involvement in Pride marches.

Wishesandhorses · 16/11/2026 12:52

ItsCoolForCats · 16/11/2026 10:42

Someone on the Reddit thread said that if it gets to Strasbourg, it will be a slam dunk 🙄

This is true only if you conveniently forget that a) women also have rights and b) rights under the convention are qualified and have to be balanced against competing rights.

Exactly. They have never been able to compute that Strasbourg will have to think about other people's rights too. It's not a gender affirmation borg.

Frankly the sooner this goes to Europe the better, women's rights have never been considered or weighed against gender based stuff, nor have gay rights. I predict though the second Strasbourg says 'other people have rights too' they will instantly shift, like the SC, from being framed as the ultimate appeal to mum authority, to being pish no one cares about.

BettyFilous · 16/11/2026 14:40

Igmum · 15/11/2026 18:15

Bloody Harriet Haynes, convinced he is God’s gift (I practice more) rather than a mediocre man who cheats. I hope the court sees right through him. I feel so sorry for the volunteers who sacrificed their time to run this Federation who have spent years being dragged through the courts and presumably risk personal bankruptcy.

Harriet is just demonstrating make privilege here without realising it. Why is it that women don’t practice as much? Could it possibly be that so much more of the domestic load falls to them? Child care, elder care, housework, all the mental load that men get to palm off on the women in their lives. 😠 Sure ‘Harriet’, you practice more but who is doing all the work that facilitates that?

Igmum · 16/11/2026 15:17

BettyFilous · 16/11/2026 14:40

Harriet is just demonstrating make privilege here without realising it. Why is it that women don’t practice as much? Could it possibly be that so much more of the domestic load falls to them? Child care, elder care, housework, all the mental load that men get to palm off on the women in their lives. 😠 Sure ‘Harriet’, you practice more but who is doing all the work that facilitates that?

I suspect the elite women players practice every bit as much as HH but they don't have his height, upper body strength, explosive power, arm length, hand breadth or any of the other things that maketh a man. And he has the gall to attribute it to practice? Pull the other one.

moto748e · 16/11/2026 17:02

It's not like HH hammers the women players, though; they can, and do, beat him.

Wishesandhorses · 16/11/2026 17:43

It's rather like the conversation about is it ok for a really sweet, gentle, fully transitioned, lovely man with a gender identity to be in a women's single sex space.

It doesn't matter if women can beat this particular man - goodness knows most of the men in women's sports are there because they're mediochre and wouldn't place anywhere in the men's events - it's the principle that women are entitled to their own competitions and events on a sexed basis, due to the need for equality.

moto748e · 16/11/2026 18:24

Wishesandhorses · 16/11/2026 17:43

It's rather like the conversation about is it ok for a really sweet, gentle, fully transitioned, lovely man with a gender identity to be in a women's single sex space.

It doesn't matter if women can beat this particular man - goodness knows most of the men in women's sports are there because they're mediochre and wouldn't place anywhere in the men's events - it's the principle that women are entitled to their own competitions and events on a sexed basis, due to the need for equality.

Oh, I agree with that. I was just saying that he's not some superman who thrashes all comers in women's comps. Which he shouldn’t be in, and currently isn't AIUI.

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 16/11/2026 21:21

moto748e · 16/11/2026 17:02

It's not like HH hammers the women players, though; they can, and do, beat him.

And not all sports people who dope win, doesn’t make them any less cheaters.

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 09:04

GargoylesofBeelzebub · 15/11/2026 11:17

The appeal is this week coming. https://www.reddit.com/r/transgenderUK/s/hvNcnkofnp

Well hes wrong in his assumption that his is the 1st case to challenge the fws rulling using articles 8 & 14 of the human rights act that was fws vs scot gov and sps (they also used articles 2, 3 and 5) and lost on all counts its not a human right to be treated as the opposite sex and women have human rights too

Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 11:53

Tribunal Tweets 2 are at the hearing.

Ground 1 of the Appeal has been abandoned. This was that trans-identifying men had no competitive advantage over women and that the judge failed to consider whether the defendants were significantly influenced by the claimant being trans

From TT

HS [KC for appellant] I will turn over to my colleague JR rises J how long will. you need JR about an hour J an hour? it's a straightforward case of direct discrim JR outlines subs, 3 main points, one over arching point, the over arching point is that this case is about the complaint of a group of

people who complained about the inclusion of trans people (TP) on the grounds with fairness and the organisers then changed the rule, called the natal female rule. Then HH was excluded. The reason for the rule change was explicitly to exclude TW, must be DD.

Categories in the EA, pc of GR. Para 134 of FWS said that the comparator is likely to be a man, infer they meant a cis man, they were dealing the intent to transition or in process of transition, did not deal with those who have transitioned. That past scenario where someone

has completed transition like HH, the comparator is likely to be a cis woman. Nutshell bit over, back to 1st principles. 'there must be no material difference between the circumstances' It's trite EA law that the purpose of the exercise is to ascertain why the discrim occurred

You should have Shamood in the supplementable bundle of authorities. YL will be very familiar with that. Let's go to another case.

J so you start with the treatment complained of, there was a service provided, why did they fail to provide that service, the application of the rule

will only apply to those who were born women
JR [Jane Russell KC for the appellant] it was made to exclude transwomen
J that is my difficulty with your submission, you have abandoned Ground 1,
JR let me first take you to Shamood, 'the purpose of the comparative exercise to compare like with like', describes

essential treatment
J you must anchor the analysis in the act complained of, they excluded HH on the grounds not born female, is that sex discrim or gra
JR they excluded HH on grounds of complaints J what is the detriment, unable to enter, you have to ask is the rule sex dd or

GRD.
JR it is very difficult to analyse without considering GRA status, it is the reason they took the decision, part of the material circumstances, very difficult to consider without status. The natal female rule was to exclude TW.
J so that's Shamood,
JR turning to another case

J what proposition are you going to put forward
JR emphasised importance of comparative exercise
J what do you want me to read
JR 4 lines up from bottom, the purpose of comparative exercise must assist the court, what Parker got wrong in original case was to compare HH to a cis man,

OP posts:
Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 11:56

J it needs to be like a scientific control, to isolate the reasons for the discrim, I've looked at the last 5 lines, what do you want me to take from that
JR the purpose of comparative test is to isolate the difference, when applying to this case HH is in more similar

circumstances to a cis female competitor than a cis male competitor, can we go to the bundle
J you don't want to take me to the case,
JR assumed YH was familiar with it
J well yes, but haven't been back to it recently
JR gives bundle ref, para 81,

and there described the hypothetical control group
J comforting to know that I've been consistent over the years
JR similar to what you just said, create the control group to compare HH to control group, but in order to do that you need to know a little bit about HH and the control group.

J you need to look at the decisions about who can enter the competition and who can't, it's quite specific who can enter and who can't
JR lets look at it this way, before the rule change cis women and TW could enter competition, cis men could never play, TM could

play, then the change and TW couldn't play. Why they should be able to play is because they have a very low amount of testosterone in their bodies, page 18 of HH WS.
J yes
JR HH says that testosterone levels at 1.1 well below male levels of 10. Taking you now to what IOC says

bout that, basis of rule, page 92, Nov 2015, para 2.2 at page 93, athlete must demonstrate testosterone level below 10, HH has been taking oestrogen since Feb 2016, a decade. Had sex reassignment security in 2018. Circumstances of HH and other TW is that they had low

testosterone levels and previously played in women's competitions for 10 years. HH in a materially different position to a cis man, man would never have played in women's competition. HH would have been observed as a man at birth, and has a GRC, that's part of the factual

picture that cis men don't share. It's not as black and white as MLF argument, more like a male player because born male. Shares natal biology with a man, but whether or not she has the physical advantages of a man will depend on particular TW and the stage of transition.

HH is at the furthest end of the spectrum of transition. I invite you to consider that HH was treated as man because of natal biology but ignoring transition.
J so you say that the proper comparator is a biological woman
JR yes, a cis woman

OP posts:
ItsCoolForCats · 17/11/2026 12:00

Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 11:53

Tribunal Tweets 2 are at the hearing.

Ground 1 of the Appeal has been abandoned. This was that trans-identifying men had no competitive advantage over women and that the judge failed to consider whether the defendants were significantly influenced by the claimant being trans

From TT

HS [KC for appellant] I will turn over to my colleague JR rises J how long will. you need JR about an hour J an hour? it's a straightforward case of direct discrim JR outlines subs, 3 main points, one over arching point, the over arching point is that this case is about the complaint of a group of

people who complained about the inclusion of trans people (TP) on the grounds with fairness and the organisers then changed the rule, called the natal female rule. Then HH was excluded. The reason for the rule change was explicitly to exclude TW, must be DD.

Categories in the EA, pc of GR. Para 134 of FWS said that the comparator is likely to be a man, infer they meant a cis man, they were dealing the intent to transition or in process of transition, did not deal with those who have transitioned. That past scenario where someone

has completed transition like HH, the comparator is likely to be a cis woman. Nutshell bit over, back to 1st principles. 'there must be no material difference between the circumstances' It's trite EA law that the purpose of the exercise is to ascertain why the discrim occurred

You should have Shamood in the supplementable bundle of authorities. YL will be very familiar with that. Let's go to another case.

J so you start with the treatment complained of, there was a service provided, why did they fail to provide that service, the application of the rule

will only apply to those who were born women
JR [Jane Russell KC for the appellant] it was made to exclude transwomen
J that is my difficulty with your submission, you have abandoned Ground 1,
JR let me first take you to Shamood, 'the purpose of the comparative exercise to compare like with like', describes

essential treatment
J you must anchor the analysis in the act complained of, they excluded HH on the grounds not born female, is that sex discrim or gra
JR they excluded HH on grounds of complaints J what is the detriment, unable to enter, you have to ask is the rule sex dd or

GRD.
JR it is very difficult to analyse without considering GRA status, it is the reason they took the decision, part of the material circumstances, very difficult to consider without status. The natal female rule was to exclude TW.
J so that's Shamood,
JR turning to another case

J what proposition are you going to put forward
JR emphasised importance of comparative exercise
J what do you want me to read
JR 4 lines up from bottom, the purpose of comparative exercise must assist the court, what Parker got wrong in original case was to compare HH to a cis man,

Thanks @Another2Cats. I glad TT are covering it.

Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 12:02

JR want to take you to the judgment, begins reading about complains
J what do you want to say about this, I've read the judgment
JR they were responding to complaints, the reason for complaints is that it was unfair, fair comp is sec 195 of the EA. Nothing else from this part

of the judgment. Take you to the defence; the primary defence was not asserted as natal sex or being a biological man, it was professional status.
J so hasn't been subjected to any less fav treatment on grounds of GRA, what do you want me to look at
JR the primary reason relied on here is professional status,

J that's not what we're talking about, what point am I taking from the defence here
JR they don't raise biological sex here, although they do later on
J well they do later on
JR it's not the sex defence in the way that they are putting it now

J what am I supposed to get from that, this is about legal analysis, saying that they didn't plead it, doesn't help me decide if the judge's legal analysis is correct
JR it's part of the relevant circumstances that the decision maker took it into account, not sure how much to go into this, harder to take in account

J in this case, I don't want to be distracted, this case is one of legal analysis, the rule is being applied to those who would otherwise be eligible to enter the competition. Why is it that your client won't be able to enter the women's comp

because wasn't born a female. You need to keep to the legal analysis.
JR I disagree with you and can I explain why, the org was trans inclusive, then changed it's mind about TW, cis men were always excluded, that must be about GRD. And that's because it does not,

J I thought this was Ground 1, looking at mental processes of decision maker, and it was abandoned
JR yes
J why is it reappearing under Ground 2
JR it was abandoned because of something conceded at trial
J what was the concession
JR its in the Ds skeleton, gives the page ref

J how is your position different from that?
JR I can see the overlap but the comparator issue involves looking at why something happened and that's what we say the J got wrong.
J so lets' move on with your submission
JR moving on to the law, 3 propositions

JR section 7 identifies a 3 stage process, shall I take you to it
J I'm familiar with that and J Chamberlain's analysis
JR let me take you to Croft,
J in terms of your subs, what proposition are you making
JR there can be a change in comparator depending on the stage of GRA

JR clear from judgments and J in this case was wrong, shall we go to Croft first,
J I'm familiar but refresh me on the facts
JR Croft was in the middle category, proposing to undergo but had not undergone transition, what toilet to use, can't ignore stage of transition

JR now on to another case, says talks about HR jurisprudence, persons not to be dx'd against, the category includes all persons undergoing transition, but don't get right to use opposite sex facilities without ref to stage of transition. There's a point in time where you treat someone as lived gender.

J yeah...
JR now to talk about HR and now about Goodwin, cannot escape HR, trans not a 3rd sex, cannot be dx'd against, refusing to treat as a woman.
J is this consistent with FWS?
JR yes, it is. Let's go to Parker but let me make this point that

Pill and Parker go on same journey, the comparator changes as transition changes. The right does not arise automatically but is acquired by making progress in the procedure.
J this is saying that the result of GRA changes sex under the EA, and FWS doesn't say that

OP posts:
Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 12:07

JR this para doesn't say that. Can I tell you what I surmise from what you just read? the CoA saw the rights of some transgender people to live in acq'd gender under Art 8.
J so, CoA rights of at least some trans people to live in acq'd gender
JR those that have made some progress

J can you be more specific than 'some'
JR need to make some progress, are in the process of undergoing, doesn't follow that until final stage is reacher
J it is sufficient that they are undergoing is that your submission
JR yes, but Southey says it's wider

JR from a HR point of view, it's appearance,
J so they don't need, well what's the proposition then? They must be undergoing and have the appearance
JR says 'proposing' 'undergoing' 'has completed' and Croft said you don't get it on day one, but at some point

J I'm trying to pin you down on your proposition in law
JR my proposition is that HH is at the end of the process
J so no need to consider the niceties of Croft
JR HH has gone beyond Croft. Para 71-73 says can't ignore the fact that process has begun, para 73, you also can't

ignore that process not completed, and then the true comparator is employees who are not trans - cis employees.
J yup
JR looking at FWS, para 134, last third of para,
J yes
JR my submission is that they are saying that where a male person is proposing or undergoing GRA comparator is a man. Does not address a person who has completed

J why would the position be different
JR when someone who has completed transition, they have changed sex, and be treated for all purposes as acquired gender
J so they should be recognised by the law as female, that should like what your proposition is

JR I propose that they have completed the process in Sec 7, and has gone on the journey and it is a materially different position in the circumstances, FWS did not deal with completed transitions,
J that's the analytical gap

JR a man cannot be the correct comparator for someone who has completed transition
J so how does it apply, when doing comparator, trying to isolate the person from the pc, I don't see the analytical gap, they are most logically a biological man

OP posts:
rebax · 17/11/2026 12:09

IANAL but this appeal does not seem to be going well. Croft is a case from 2003, so predates Equality Act.

Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 12:11

JR so HH has much more in common with a cis woman; surgery, hormones, played in competition as a woman.
J so that's Ground 2 and possibly Ground 1 as well,
JR well I have a couple more points, the suggestion that Croft doesn't survive FWS is not correct,
J I have Swift's judgment in front of me.

JR Parker didn't take up Pills reasoning
J can you show me that
JR there's nothing in 74 that says there's a departure from Pill
J so, 74 is the same of para 144 of FWS, doesn't matter if bio woman or bio male, is what made the difference GRA, so it's flat against you

JR 74 says a cis person, but doesn't say man or woman. Says you can't ignore GRA but can't ignore stage. Can we go to Croft, page 69, its a clear illustration of difficulties in applying statutory test. Diff between someone undergoing and someone who has completed transition

J but then goes on to para 74, it has to be someone who doesn't have the GRA pc,
JR can be a cis man or a cis woman but my submission is if someone has undergone transition, it is the acquired sex, the correct comparator is not a woman from the outset, he's talking about when it is a cis man or cis woman, he's not using those terms, it's just shorthand

J so you're saying that he's wrong
JR it is not a dead letter, endorse the idea of change in comparator, in para 73
J alright
JR the idea of a comparator, it wasn't before him, it was the legality of the interim guidance

J so that's Ground 2, the analytical part, not the motivation part
JR the last part I can do in 5 minutes, errors in J Parker's analysis, para 89, when he says that differences of sex area material diff and the comparator must be the same sex, FWS did not esolve comparator

J yes, it says sex means biological sex
JR and it also did not establish sex as an overarching criteria, it's not an iceberg that the case runs on,
J what should I be looking at
JR it's our reply, sorry, there are various sets of subs, it's our reply to the county court

J yes, there were various sets of submissions to court
JR the lives of a transwoman and a cis man cannot be more different
J yes
JR sec 23, where I started, the correct comparator is someone who is not trans, it should be a cis man or a cis woman

and if you remove the pc of GRA, you have a person who is not trans, someone who has some similarities to a woman, lives as a woman, has been allowed to play as a woman, that is a cis woman. Comparing HH to a cis man - not trans - who has not been allowed to play automatically

defeats HH claim. A black person who had been denied a promotion would not compare self to white person denied promotion but to someone who did get the job. If HH is not compared to a cis woman, then is not properly analysed by the court
J which court
JR the county court

OP posts:
Another2Cats · 17/11/2026 12:14

JR If I'm completely wrong and a cis man is the correct comparator, then HH was treated less favourably, because it was jarring, embarrassing, had been allowed to play. 3 more errors; doesn't fail on FWS, Croft still relevant, SC views on sport in FWS.

JR essentially he's going to say biological sex is not subject to jurisprudence although he's going to say it much more elegantly than that.
J right
JR and the language around fair competition was adopted by defence
J why are you making this point to me

JR not realistic for this claim which should fall under HR, should be defeated under 195.2
J not right for the claim under HR to be defeated by 195.2
JR all used language of fair competition, but should have been proportionate advantage under IOC rules

JR if HH cannot be considered a woman, the rights of trans people will be diluted as no direct discrim case will survive
J did you have something else to say
JR it would be pointless to bring a GRA case
J it won't be pointless, because a GRA case can succeed when there is GRA discirm

JR standing back, its hard to see how the pc of GRA is not engaged
J your point is that the pc of GRA is engaged, if the conclusion is that this is a sex discrim case, is that the end of the appeal
JR it's correct that the case is GRA discrim but HS will address you on human rights grounds
J so your point is that this is straight GRA discrim and HS will argue that it is a human rights matter.

End of part one of morning session.

OP posts:
ItsCoolForCats · 17/11/2026 12:17

The judge doesn't sound convinced. And bloody Croft again.

CassOle · 17/11/2026 12:20

Well, here we are, a quote for all those who insist that 'no one actually says that a trans person changes sex'.

"JR when someone who has completed transition, they have changed sex, and be treated for all purposes as acquired gender
J so they should be recognised by the law as female, that should like what your proposition is"