Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court

225 replies

Another2Cats · 27/03/2026 12:28

Again, I apologise for this being very long. TL;DR this looks to be the first case at the High Court which will consider the exclusion of trans-identifying men post FWS.

So, for some background, there was a case last year, just after FWS, concerning a trans-identifying man who had been banned from a women's pool competition organised by the English Blackball Pool Federation.

Back at the end of 2023, the Pool Federation changed their rules so that only women could play in women's competitions.

The trans-identifying man, Haynes, then brought a claim of direct discrimination on the ground of gender reassignment against the federation.

The trial took place during 2025 before the judgment in FWS was handed down. The court heard from several witnesses about whether pool was a gender-affected activity (Section 195(3) Equality Act) including Dr Emma Hilton - who is the interim chair of Sex Matters.

However, the FWS judgment came out before the County Court judge had made his judgment on the case and so the pool federation said that each side should make detailed written submissions about the effect of FWS on this case.

The judge agreed and the submissions for the pool federation were written by Sarah Crowther KC of Outer Temple Chambers and those for the trans-identifying man were written by Jane Russell KC. Some may recognise her name from the Sandie Peggie case (and other cases).

.

The judge decided that FWS was sufficient to decide the case in favour of the pool federation but, since he had heard detailed argument, he also set out his conclusions with regard to the sport exception (Section 195) and also about the provision of separate services (Schedule 3 para 28)

The court concluded that pool is a ‘gender-affected activity’ and that excluding those born as male from the female category is necessary to secure fair competition. The court also concluded that this was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

There is a link to the judgment here:

https://jrlevins.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/K01CT207-judgment-1-8-25-handed-down.pdf

.

Haynes has now been granted permission to appeal and has published the grounds of appeal on Haynes Instagram account. I've attached the images here. Haynes tried to get the case "leapfrogged" directly to the Court of Appeal but this was refused.

A brief summary of the grounds, which the judge who considered the application said were all arguable are as follows (personally, I don't they stand up at all, but this is the case he is putting forward):

1 There was no evidence that trans-identifying men had any competitive advantage over women. The judge failed to consider the "mental processes" of the federation and that they were significantly influenced in their decision to exclude trans-identifying men as they were in some way unfairly discriminatory.

2 In considering direct discrimination, the court applied the wrong comparator. Following Croft [Croft v Royal Mail [2003] EWCA Civ 1045] Haynes claims that the correct comparator in this case should be a woman rather than a man.

3 FWS, when applied to the facts of this case, does not comply with Article 8 and Article 14 of the ECHR and, in a claim by an individual, the ECHR applies, whereas it did not for the organisations claiming in FWS.

4 The Court failed to apply S195 Equality Act [the sport exemption] in a ECHR compliant manner. The pool federation did not show that it was necessary to exclude trans-identifying men for the reasons of safety or fair competition. Cue sports are precision sports thus not affected by power/sex. No explanation was given for changing from a testosterone testing system or handicap system.

5 Something about the court wrongly saying that another, professional, pool organisation would have refused Haynes permission to play in this federation's competitions

.

Frankly, I don't think any of those will really hold up. But it will be interesting to see what happens when it does get to court as this will be a High Court judgment rather than just a County Court judgment.

Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
Haynes v Blackball Pool Federation is back on - this time at the High Court
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 14:23

@Another2Cats I've not totally caught up yet, but in case someone hasn't already explained MLF= "my learned friend" ie opposing counsel.

I assume "the case is continuing to evolve so will do my best to respond to what I think they are pleading" is legalese for "opposing counsel is making shit up as they go along"?

Another2Cats · Yesterday 14:24

J para 9
SMT yes, no evidence about future actions or future contracts was given
J your point, bound by contract at time of trial
SMT no evidence given about possible future termination, to address further on contents of pleading, nothing in pleading about announcement being a detriment under the EA.

J was HH said to be distressed, has an impact on C's identity, I think I'm right in saying claim included injury to feeling
SMT only ground pleaded was exclusion based on rule, no separate sec 13 claim for injury to feelings. If we look at part of claim, you can see that in the pleadings, Ds position that the contents of the announcement or the grounds of the announcement, were not discriminatory

J the overall point, I thought that there were findings about the rule causing distress,
SMT the implementation of the rule, the impact, the C did not plead that announcement caused distress

J we've gone on to announcement to existence of rule, well there could be a detriment that had been able to play in women's comp, now cannot, that could be a detriment.
SMT not pleaded and was parasitic given that it came into effect on 1/1/2024.

J if someone puts up a sign that says no bald white men welcome in this cafe, whether or not I wanted to go in, I might be distressed
SMT it could have been pleaded that way but wasn't
J so that's your argument

SMT back to the chronology, there was a 17 or 18 day period when might have been impacted by rule before signing pro contract, but there were no events organised in that period. And no evidence introduced to say that there were events. Contract would have prohibited participation from 1 jan.

SMT now on to point raised in supplementary skeleton, that might hypothetically be a victim in the future, under Art 34
J i thought this was a relatively bread and butter point, now HR
SMT it came up for the first time in the supp skeleton,
J is there some HRA authority you want me to look at

SMT C relies on Burdon, but I say there was no withholding of service. I'll move on to the next point on perversity.
J the perversity point, trust you will rely on Henderson

SMT there's nothing else that I'm relying on, what the C is seeking to do is 2 fold, first of all seeking to persuade you that her version of events is true and should have prevailed at trial, and is trying to rerun the case that failed at trial. Doesn't seem to be any of the necessary elements for perversity, unclear which element C relies on, I say that C is seeking to undermine the findings of fact because judge preferred evidence of others.

OP posts:
Another2Cats · Yesterday 14:39

J that's the usual claim in this case so lets look at the facts
SMT facts, for one there were two definitions of professional status, saying honorary professional status and then contractual professional status. Then C was reluctant to provide the contract and the J was reasonable to draw inferences about HH reticence, and the j was apprehensive about how the contract came about. J was right to accept sub from Ds that HH was reticent about the contract because wanted to downplay how it came about and its consequences.

Have you seen a copy of the contract? I can hand it up, its 211 at the end of the main documents bundle,
J well I've got 3 bundles, perhaps quicker if you just pass it up
SMT relevant clause is 2.1,
J please wait until I've found it. I've got it but not with page numbers.

SMT relevant clause is 2.1,
J no dispute that contract prohibited playing in non UPG event without permission, was it perverse to find that without asking for permission, it would not have been given.

SMT we're looking at how to deal with a hypothetical counter factual situation and was his finding perverse, and the C had provided no evidence that permission would have been granted
J the judge made a finding of fact
SMT there are 2 issues here, the terms of the contract and then was it enforceable.

J but the hypothetical was had contract, could ask for consent, what would have happened when she did.
SMT C's case was that no enforcement was taken when other UPG players broke contract
J two strands; if I had asked they would have agreed and if I hadn't asked they wouldn't have done anything.

SMT the C had plenty of time to provide evidence in advance of trial, Rs sought an order for evidence, nothing produced, you can see that in her WS.
J give me a reference for that please
SMT page 47

SMT now onto skeleton; the argument here is not relevant to any of the factual findings of the judge, this particular argument. Then raising prohibited from playing in other professional event, no evidence produced at trial of this. Then C gave evidence not aware of UPG not giving permission, her subjective awareness not relevant.

J have I got a transcript? In a case of perversity, don't I need to see the evidence.
SMT C gave no evidence to the - may I use the word - conjecture of C that would have been allowed. Then the C gave compelling doc evidence of UPG male players playing in other comps.

J we don't know if they got permission
SMT we don't know if they were honorary profs or contracts, what there contracts said, had they sought or received permission or been refused permission and been sanctioned.

OP posts:
Another2Cats · Yesterday 14:40

This stood out to me:

SMT C gave no evidence to the - may I use the word - conjecture of C that would have been allowed.

OP posts:
MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 14:45

WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 14:23

@Another2Cats I've not totally caught up yet, but in case someone hasn't already explained MLF= "my learned friend" ie opposing counsel.

I assume "the case is continuing to evolve so will do my best to respond to what I think they are pleading" is legalese for "opposing counsel is making shit up as they go along"?

I assume "the case is continuing to evolve so will do my best to respond to what I think they are pleading" is legalese for "opposing counsel is making shit up as they go along"?

Yes, I was going to call out exactly that section too.

On the topic of alternative measures to ensure fairness, like a handicap system: does anyone think that team HH on Reddit would be happy if trans identifying men were allowed to compete as long as they took a handicap? I doubt it.

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 14:47

if someone puts up a sign that says no bald white men welcome in this cafe, whether or not I wanted to go in, I might be distressed

I take it the Judge is pale of skin and short of hair?

Another2Cats · Yesterday 14:54

SMT all the C did at trial was point to docs in bundle showing screenshots and invite Judge to draw inferences about contractual status, leaps of logic. No evidence here. A fellow UPG player Emma Cunningham was allowed to play, no evidence produced about contractual status. C was silent on the point. May have assumed had a contract but never sought to confirm that.

J could have called Emma Cunningham
SMT seeking perversity on a lack of evidence
J C failed to provide evidence
SMT yes no inconsistency in J's finding that C's evidence not persuasive

SMT the main thrust of evidence about Emma Cunningham was the unfairness of the professional rule, that is not the subject of this appeal
J to be absolutely stark about it, she didn't say that Emma Cunningham had been allowed to play and she hadn't

SMT I don't think that it was disingenuous.
J so the C relied on contractual status that wasn't established - C did say at trial that Emma C was playing in county comps and so she must have got permission.
SMT she did say that. Yes of course she suggested that because Emma C was playing she got consent

J need to be careful with what you say, it's not disingenuous, if she was relying on Emma C you're saying she didn't evidence the consent point.
SMH if I may turn my back [SMH/SC talking]
SMH the safest way I can put it is that there was no explanation at trial of Emma C contractual arrangements.

J but C was saying she must have got consent, wasn't saying I know she asked, etc
SMT but in so doing she was speculative
J your target is to say there is no knock out evidence that says the J was perverse, I've got your point on Emma C

SMT a different point, it was common ground at trial that Danielle Randall sought permission from UPG and was denied, it was relied on by C to show differences between professional and amateur comps.
J are we looking at the same thing?

SMT apologies, I was on ground h,
J go back to f & g
SMT the table is just a listing of players and we know nothing about their contractual arrangements
J so the same as d & e
SMT now point g is about convos that may or may not have taken place.

OP posts:
GarlicNothing · Yesterday 14:56

MyAmpleSheep · 03/04/2026 19:18

Right. If it's established that there's no advantage for men then the whole separate women's category becomes unlawful discrimination against (all) men and vice versa, and the various sporting bodies would have to abandon any kind of separation by sex.

Yes, I can't see how this dispute has got so far. Following FWS, an organisation is all-female, all-male or mixed. The question of sex-related advantage in pool speaks to whether there needs to be a women's competition - if there's no advantage, disgruntled players could reasonably agitate for all competitions to be mixed sex.

But none of this has anything to do with 'trans-ness'. The plaintiff isn't arguing that the league should be mixed sex. He's saying he should be included in the women's team. He should not, because he isn't female. There's no special token for some men to be with women; it's no men or any men.

Why's he still being allowed to tie up judicial resources on a matter that's been firmly decided?

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 15:00

This appeal has a fascinating mixture of arguing the toss about what Emma B said to Victoria B behind the bike sheds at 3pm on 23 November 2021, and whether the European Court of Human Rights is all but guaranteed to rule that Willoughby has a real vagina and anyone who says she will never bear the twins she's longed for since the age of three should be imprisoned in the Tower of London. The sublime and the ridiculous all mixed together.

moto748e · Yesterday 15:02

I am but vaguely following this. Is HH claiming that Ultimate Pool stitched him up by letting Emma Cunningham (an actual woman) play in other (blackball?) comps, but not him? I think UP originally stood by HH, than dumped him later.

There is a bit of war between the blackball people and UP, and this case has to be seen in the light of that. I think UP very much don't want any averse publicity over this; they are presenting themselves as the shiny, 21st century face of pool.

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 15:04

moto748e · Yesterday 15:02

I am but vaguely following this. Is HH claiming that Ultimate Pool stitched him up by letting Emma Cunningham (an actual woman) play in other (blackball?) comps, but not him? I think UP originally stood by HH, than dumped him later.

There is a bit of war between the blackball people and UP, and this case has to be seen in the light of that. I think UP very much don't want any averse publicity over this; they are presenting themselves as the shiny, 21st century face of pool.

Why would what UP did or didn't do count against EBPF?

Another2Cats · Yesterday 15:09

J the C put in certain evidence and now G, the Ds didn't put any positive evidence of their own
SMT the Ds put in evidence of whatsapp convos
J put in evidence about Danielle Randall and it was about professional comps

SMT the Ds were not in a position to have knowledge of the contractual arrangements of UPG and players. And I addressed you out of turn on f.
J so your point is there was not an evidential point in which the judge took a different approach and you say that C had pleaded this from the outset, could have produced evidence and could have called witnesses.

SMT if you look at the judgment, that is what she said.
J and the didn't explain why
SMT the C gave no reason why she hadn't produced evidence. So there was an evidentiary void, the judge reached his conclusion.

J was the C cross examined on this
{SC indicated she didn't remember}
SMT if you look at WS, no explanation on this,
J perhaps didn't seek permission because knew couldn't compete and there was an RFI
SMT said she didn't seek consent but doesn't give reasons.

SMT C had an opportunity to fill in evidential unknowns, did not do so, perversity is not made out.
J is that the end of the D's submissions.
JR rises
J how many points are you going to make
JR 3 points, and I don't know how many points HS will make
J how long
JR 5 to 10 mins

JR start with you are correct with focusing on whether Ds refused to provide a service. And the comparator and the reason why are inextricably linked. You correctly ascertained that issue is not less favourable treatment its the reason for that treatment, you said that natal female case gives the answer and it's a criterion case.

J I did not say it's a criterion case, I'm not about classifying cases
JR here the answer is not within the natal female rule, this is not a criterion case, it's a motivation case

J now we are going to get into this, ground one was looking into the motivation of decision makers and it was quite properly withdrawn. We are not reopening ground 1, it would not be fair. And then we are left with the comparator. Make your submissions with that in mind.

JR I am bearing that in mind. The purpose of the comparator, is to reveal the reasons why. Particularly here where the Ds evidence is that the reason why the rule was introduced was because people had complained about TW competing and the point of the rule was to ban TW. To say here that it's a criterion case and the

answer is the name of the natal female rule, is artificial and Orwellian. The reason is that we have introduced a rule and you HH are banned is not because you are trans. That is self contradictory and absurd. That's the mischief that Judge Underhill said when he was discussing that in AA.

OP posts:
moto748e · Yesterday 15:12

MyAmpleSheep · Yesterday 15:04

Why would what UP did or didn't do count against EBPF?

You're expecting logic now? 😀Your guess is as good as mine. I was trying to find out what EC had to do with anything.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 15:20

Just checked in for the first time today - we're on the afternoon of day 2, J so that's your argument

........ poor Judge still trying to find what the complainant's argument actually is.

mateysmum · Yesterday 15:20

I'm hoping one of you learned ladies will do a TL:DR on this one, because I'm rather lost in the weeds and have been following the Amy Gallagher case instead.

Another2Cats · Yesterday 15:20

J shall we look at where he says that, do you want me to read the para, read it
JR that's my first point. My 2nd point was does likely mean, it' is not right to say to correct comparator is always a man. If it was the SC would not said likely. And in Croft, not right to say that Pill was not dealing comparator in Croft, would you like to go there.

J if you would like to take me there
JR yes I would para 45, applicant been treated differently from comparable employees, assessing less fav treatment, looking a comparator and then taken up by Parker,

J so 48, I'm looking at then paras 71, what are you taking from this
JR at 71, 3 qs about comparator
J so Pill referring to comparator and so is Parker, can I just make a note of your points on Crofts
JR another case about pleading the case
J what did you want me to get from this

JR the judge determined an issue that hadn't been claimed,
J to be fair to the judge, he decided that it wasn't GRA discrim, it wasn't sex discrimination.
JR He didn't determine the issue before him, which is not permissible. I have nothing else.

HS going back to Semenya case and his explanation earlier, had mis-remembered finding in the case. Now on to 2 factual matters, first that C would have been able to play in comps during period before contract came into affect. Now on to open comps. The C says that is a male competition.

J what is your point
HS the C says it's the male comp, and HH would have been the only woman in that comp
J you're agreeing that anyone could play in it, where in WS
HS para 102, page 25
J can I just check, would have been able to play in county if UPG agreed

HS we don't accept there were no comps in that period, there was a comp on 3 Dec,
J there was a comp on 3 Dec
HS there's no evidence and you shouldn't take my instructions as evidence, but I don't think its safe to rely on no comps. I now want to focus on the HR aspects

If bringing a claim against individual, can't bring HR claim, must bring under some other basis, say the EA.
J yes I've seen that
HS when FWS comes out,
J HS there's not criticism of how it's pleaded, its part of picture when it was pleaded, need to construe EA in accordance with the convention

OP posts:
WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 15:24

"J now we are going to get into this, ground one was looking into the motivation of decision makers and it was quite properly withdrawn. We are not reopening ground 1, it would not be fair. And then we are left with the comparator. Make your submissions with that in mind."

If this was a football related case, I'd suggested that the Judge was getting quite tired of Jane Russell's repeated attempts to move the goalposts. Can anyone suggest a more appropriate pool related metaphor here?

TWETMIRF · Yesterday 15:24

Someone at Cat's Protection once saw an injured bird in their carpark and helped it, therefore HH should be allowed to play in the women's game of EBPF.

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · Yesterday 15:24

GarlicNothing · Yesterday 14:56

Yes, I can't see how this dispute has got so far. Following FWS, an organisation is all-female, all-male or mixed. The question of sex-related advantage in pool speaks to whether there needs to be a women's competition - if there's no advantage, disgruntled players could reasonably agitate for all competitions to be mixed sex.

But none of this has anything to do with 'trans-ness'. The plaintiff isn't arguing that the league should be mixed sex. He's saying he should be included in the women's team. He should not, because he isn't female. There's no special token for some men to be with women; it's no men or any men.

Why's he still being allowed to tie up judicial resources on a matter that's been firmly decided?

We can only speculate who is funding the case. If it was the GLP, Amnesty or some other pro-trans organisation you would expect them to be publicising the fact. Perhaps they know the case is futile & don't want to have their name associated with the defeat? When this JR fails the judge is just going to confirm FWS & rule that Chris "Harriet" Haynes is a man who cannot compete in a woman's competition. The TRAs will be in a frenzy again when yet another court confirms TWAM.

TBH as he has no intention of paying the costs awarded to the defendants I think he should have been barred from appealing.

Another2Cats · Yesterday 15:31

HS post FWS there were many submissions on HR issues,
J it's my fault, it's not being said that the issues weren't raised, but the particular issues that you raise here were not raised at trial.

HS two matters being raised, in relation to Sec 23 we submit that it was clearly compatibility with Art 8 & 14 that was being raised. What flows from that is how the court should address that. And all we're saying is how compatibility can be achieved, If ignoring sec 23, we're into incompatibility. In terms of proportionality, which was

being raised was this isn't consistent with Art 8 and 14. C in written subs specifically asked for findings that were relevant in that regard, sought a finding on proportionality, sought findings on steps taken by D and there was a need for relevant findings to assist the court

going forward. Judge said because of FWS there's no HR issue here has been determined. Turning to the substance of Ds argument, how does C get round the finding of this is sex discrim not GRA discrimination. The point on HRs is that if JRs points are rejecting the problem that

arises from FWS is that it must be dealt with as sex discrim. If the state is treating a TW as a man, that is a significant interference with their rights doesn't reflect social reality, and inconsistent with having been given a GRC. Not automatically a breach of Art 8, requires

proportionality assessment. It is the FWS approach we say that there is a tension between that and the Art 8 case law. Turning to the substance of the HR arguments, can I start with addressing factual point from MLF, she started with a submission that there is an inherent

difference on average physical findings between men and women. Physical difference is not the same on fairness. GAA focuses on size, stamina and strength, then looks at need for fair competition. Sport tolerates physical differences,

OP posts:
WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 15:34

"If the state is treating a TW as a man, that is a significant interference with their rights doesn't reflect social reality, and inconsistent with having been given a GRC. "

Yep, they're trying to use this case to relitigate FWS, aren't they.

GarlicNothing · Yesterday 15:36

Oh, good lord, they're recycling all the same, old arguments that have been tried & retried for years!

Basically boils down to "I am a laydee so the women must let me play with them".

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 15:38

WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 15:34

"If the state is treating a TW as a man, that is a significant interference with their rights doesn't reflect social reality, and inconsistent with having been given a GRC. "

Yep, they're trying to use this case to relitigate FWS, aren't they.

And HS is back to that good old chestnut 'article 8 rights are not absolute and WOMEN HAVE ARTICLE 8 RIGHTS TOO'.

Which never goes in, because this ideology fundamentally rejects women as being equal humans to men. Even while those men insist they're women.

Another2Cats · Yesterday 15:41

J you said this yesterday
HS I did but it's an important starting point, MLF submission was that it required the reading in of words
J that's not relevant, she explained the consequence of your submissions, that in all cases involving trans, Art 8 and 14 would be engaged, therefore alway engaged.

HS it's not if they are are engaged, it if there is a violation. So the interpretation only comes into play if the interference is disproportionate.
J you are submitting if it is contrary to Art 8, then you start reading it in your manner, is that correct
HS exactly ML

J got that submission
HS MLF says prohibited to me by FWS, I disagree, but then into incompatibility
J yes, I've got all that

HS we submit there is no problem with 195 and proportionality, it's actually necessity, and necessity we submit in practical terms how you take account of things like private life. Now MLF says we go beyond case law, in our submission that's no answer. There appears to be no dispute, it is a significant interference with the rights of C, there is a very clear line of authority that there is a narrowing margin, that's not

inventing novel principles, MLF said it's no part of Ds obligation to recognise HH identity. Now on to Semenya, she relied on a minority judgement to said wide margin of appreciation. I say you have to read whole of that portion of Semenya, it says there that it is not for ECrHR to determine rules for all sports.

OP posts:
Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 15:42

And as above pps and HS is skirting:

the questions go:

Is there a proportionate reason to let women have this space free of men because their specific needs? Yes? Then no men. At all. If single sex is justified then it's sex based. The end. Have a safe journey home.

And there is no way to separate some men from all the other men on a case by case basis, AND those men still retain unfair advantage AND equality requires that women are allowed to have stuff for themselves that is about them. It's not the case in terms of equality that women are allowed what's left after men have staked their prior right and claim to whatever it is.

The SCJ went through all of this in great detail.

Swipe left for the next trending thread