Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:30

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:11

Not all alcohol and processed meat consumption cause negative effects but they are known to contribute towards cancer so anyone who has ever had a glass of wine or a ham sandwich will have to pay for their own treatment. Right?

(You seem to think that any alcohol consumption on holiday invalidates travel insurance claims which is not the case, but I'm assuming you'll apply the same principle to your health model)

Why would anyone think, and anyone assume someone would think, that alcohol completely invalidates an insurance policy? that’s just ridiculous.

It only invalidates it where it’s relevant.

eg have 4 pints then fall and need treatment? Invalidated

have 4 flights and need an extra nights hotel and new flights home as your original flight home disrupted for whatever reason? Not invalidated.

Please don’t attribute things to me that I’ve never said nor applied.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:36

I'm going to get on with work now, with one final personal anecdote - not data but an illustration.

When covid hit, we were told it was more dangerous for overweight and obese people. I was very scared of catching covid and dying because of my weight which had recently gone up to 17 stone after a period of extreme personal stress in my life. Terrified, I implemented intermittent fasting and low carbing (not for the first time) and lost three stone (also not for the first time). I was very scared of the health threat, and yet I could not maintain that loss and went up to 18 stone - my heaviest ever weight. There was a clear and present danger, but I could not extricate myself from the recurring pattern of a lifetime since I started dieting age 10.

I have lost weight many times, by eating less and moving more, by low carb, by fasting, by weightwatchers and slimming world and meal replacement shakes and everything else you can think of. I've always been a gym member. I've always lost weight and always regained it. Fear of the outcomes - of poor health and an early death - did not get me out of that cycle. So an ultimatum about the potential cost of future cancer treatment wouldn't either. I hated being fat, I hated how I looked and felt and I hated what might happen in the future but I kept regaining the weight I lost plus more every time anyway.

Two and a half years on Mounjaro and I've lost weight slow and steady for the longest sustained period of my life. I eat well, I do Pilates and weightlifting and I walk and swim. I have the lovely, happy, active life I always wanted and kept failing to achieve.

Fear didn't get me there. Medication did. Taking away people's access to healthcare is never going to improve outcomes. There are lots of other measures that can.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:38

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:11

Not all alcohol and processed meat consumption cause negative effects but they are known to contribute towards cancer so anyone who has ever had a glass of wine or a ham sandwich will have to pay for their own treatment. Right?

(You seem to think that any alcohol consumption on holiday invalidates travel insurance claims which is not the case, but I'm assuming you'll apply the same principle to your health model)

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-injury-cost-recovery-scheme/guidance-on-the-application-of-the-nhs-injury-costs-recovery-scheme-for-2025-to-2026

You might find this interesting reading… essentially the concept I’ve been proposing….

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:42

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:36

I'm going to get on with work now, with one final personal anecdote - not data but an illustration.

When covid hit, we were told it was more dangerous for overweight and obese people. I was very scared of catching covid and dying because of my weight which had recently gone up to 17 stone after a period of extreme personal stress in my life. Terrified, I implemented intermittent fasting and low carbing (not for the first time) and lost three stone (also not for the first time). I was very scared of the health threat, and yet I could not maintain that loss and went up to 18 stone - my heaviest ever weight. There was a clear and present danger, but I could not extricate myself from the recurring pattern of a lifetime since I started dieting age 10.

I have lost weight many times, by eating less and moving more, by low carb, by fasting, by weightwatchers and slimming world and meal replacement shakes and everything else you can think of. I've always been a gym member. I've always lost weight and always regained it. Fear of the outcomes - of poor health and an early death - did not get me out of that cycle. So an ultimatum about the potential cost of future cancer treatment wouldn't either. I hated being fat, I hated how I looked and felt and I hated what might happen in the future but I kept regaining the weight I lost plus more every time anyway.

Two and a half years on Mounjaro and I've lost weight slow and steady for the longest sustained period of my life. I eat well, I do Pilates and weightlifting and I walk and swim. I have the lovely, happy, active life I always wanted and kept failing to achieve.

Fear didn't get me there. Medication did. Taking away people's access to healthcare is never going to improve outcomes. There are lots of other measures that can.

Edited

Well done on achieving your weight loss and I get your journey, have had similar analogous.

Point of correction: I’ve never advocated for taking individuals medication away from them (perhaps you’re confusing me with another poster?), very happy for them to use it if they pay for it themselves.

I just think it’s a bizarre world we’re in in which we’ve created a system needing medical intervention to maintain a healthy weight. (Again: That in no way implies I’d prevent people from using medicines, I’m generally a liberal, so they’re free to do so if they choose: just don’t ask me or others to pay for it. Which I know you didn’t).

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:46

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:30

Why would anyone think, and anyone assume someone would think, that alcohol completely invalidates an insurance policy? that’s just ridiculous.

It only invalidates it where it’s relevant.

eg have 4 pints then fall and need treatment? Invalidated

have 4 flights and need an extra nights hotel and new flights home as your original flight home disrupted for whatever reason? Not invalidated.

Please don’t attribute things to me that I’ve never said nor applied.

And thanks for answering; i will take this as clarification then that anyone who has ever drunk alcohol will be paying for their own cancer treatment as it is linked to cancer, just like those four pints might be linked to the fall.

Of course, we could make it so that it only applies to anyone who's ever drunk over the recommended weekly limit but I don't know how anyone is ever going to prove that. Glad I understand, I see the policy gets more and more unworkable the more you explain it.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:50

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:46

And thanks for answering; i will take this as clarification then that anyone who has ever drunk alcohol will be paying for their own cancer treatment as it is linked to cancer, just like those four pints might be linked to the fall.

Of course, we could make it so that it only applies to anyone who's ever drunk over the recommended weekly limit but I don't know how anyone is ever going to prove that. Glad I understand, I see the policy gets more and more unworkable the more you explain it.

Clearly you’d only link it to cancers caused by alcohol, not all cancers, that would just be silly 😉

Im also amazed you seem to attached to alcohol and surprised it could have negative health outcomes: it’s listed as a Group 1 carcinogen by the IARC.

I suspect in many years to come it will be viewed as smoking is now….

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:55

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:50

Clearly you’d only link it to cancers caused by alcohol, not all cancers, that would just be silly 😉

Im also amazed you seem to attached to alcohol and surprised it could have negative health outcomes: it’s listed as a Group 1 carcinogen by the IARC.

I suspect in many years to come it will be viewed as smoking is now….

I don't drink actually! I don't like it, especially in my mid-40s when it messes with sleep so I don't bother. But most people have consumed alcohol at some point in their life and considering it's linked to very common cancers eg breast cancer, you will be charging a huge percentage of cancer patients for their treatment. Now, you said the point of the policy is that it's very hard to pay, so that is an enormous amount of lives ruined and ultimately lost just because people have had a glass of champagne at a wedding once or - more likely for a lot of the population, a couple of pints at the weekend or a g&t every Friday and so on.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 11:11

And if you really want to know why my interest in breast cancer specifically and alcohol particularly, I recently lost a friend. She wasn't obese or overweight or a big drinker but she certainly had the odd drink every now and again - out for lunch with the girls, on holiday, cocktails at the spa. It's quite unimaginable to contemplate the idea that her family could now, in their grief and pain, also have been forced to sell their house to pay for her palliative care so that she could die in dignity and in as little pain as possible. These are the situations that would arise - there is no hyperbole in saying so - except of course they never would because it is such a stupid and ridiculous idea it has never been worth arguing the finer points of! But it does make my mind boggles that you'd consider it worth defending in the slightest. And I will have to try once more to stop picking the scab and leave it there.

DeliaPith321 · 28/10/2026 11:15

There is an interesting point being overlooked in the debate about whether people with obesity should be denied NHS healthcare: to a limited extent, restrictions based on obesity already exist, and the question has been openly debated for years.
In 2016, the Royal College of Surgeons reported that 34% of the NHS Clinical Commissioning Groups responding to its investigation had policies restricting referrals for routine surgery based on BMI or smoking status. In Harrogate, for example, plans were announced to delay non-urgent operations for six months for patients with a BMI of 30 or above unless they completed a weight-management programme. These measures were explicitly linked to NHS financial pressures.
This is not merely historical. A study examining NHS policies in England in 2025 found that 15 of 41 Integrated Care Boards had BMI-based restrictions on eligibility for joint replacement surgery. Some patients can therefore face additional conditions or delays because of their weight, although this is very different from a general refusal to provide healthcare.
The issue has also been discussed openly in Parliament. In April 2026, the Government confirmed that local NHS commissioners retain responsibility for determining eligibility policies, including BMI criteria for joint replacement surgery. However, it also reiterated that BMI should not, by itself, prevent access to surgery.
There are legitimate arguments for considering obesity when allocating NHS resources. Certain operations carry greater risks for patients with severe obesity, including anaesthetic complications, infections and difficulties with recovery. Where reducing weight beforehand would materially improve safety or outcomes, postponing an elective procedure may be clinically justified. The NHS also operates within finite budgets, meaning decisions about clinical effectiveness, cost-effectiveness and prioritisation are unavoidable. It is therefore feasible to introduce eligibility conditions for particular treatments, provided they are clinically justified, proportionate and allow individual assessment.
There is also an argument that publicly funded healthcare should encourage patients to participate in measures that improve treatment outcomes, particularly where these could reduce complications and the need for further treatment. However, encouraging participation is not necessarily the same as making successful weight loss a condition of receiving care.
The counterarguments are substantial. Obesity is influenced by genetics, socioeconomic circumstances, medications, health conditions and environmental factors, alongside individual behaviour. Weight loss is not equally achievable for everyone, and delaying treatment may worsen someone's condition or mobility, potentially making weight reduction harder. Restrictions might also increase long-term NHS expenditure rather than reduce it.
Importantly, NICE concluded that BMI should not be a barrier to referral for joint replacement. Its evidence review found that people with obesity still experienced improvements following surgery, and that BMI alone was an inadequate measure of individual surgical risk.
The distinction, therefore, is between restricting particular treatments for defensible clinical reasons and withholding healthcare as a punishment for someone's perceived lifestyle choices. The former already exists within NHS commissioning and can be implemented through established eligibility policies. The latter would require a much broader ethical, legal and practical justification.
The interesting question is not simply whether restricting treatment for obesity is possible, because it demonstrably is. It is whether particular restrictions actually improve outcomes, represent responsible use of NHS resources, and can be applied fairly without worsening health inequalities.

Sources and further reading

  1. Ofosu, K., Whale, K. & McLaughlin, J. (2025). Persistent use of body mass index policies as a barrier to surgery: Prevalence and analysis of policies across England in 2025. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy. Published online December 2025. Research examining BMI restrictions across NHS Integrated Care Boards.
  2. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13263469/
  3. Royal College of Surgeons of England (2016). Smokers and overweight patients: soft targets for NHS savings? Investigation into NHS restrictions on routine surgery based on BMI and smoking status.
  4. https://rcseng.ac.uk/news-and-events/media-centre/press-releases/more-than-one-in-three-areas-of-england-restrict-surgery-for-smokers-and-overweight-patients/
  5. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2022). Osteoarthritis in over 16s: diagnosis and management. NICE Guideline NG226, particularly recommendation 1.6.3 on referral for joint replacement.
  6. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng226/chapter/recommendations
  7. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2022). Evidence reviews for outcomes of joint replacement surgery dependent on body mass index. Evidence Review P, NICE Guideline NG226.
  8. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK589222/
  9. Wood, G., Neilson, J., Cottrell, E. & Hoole, S.P. (2023). Osteoarthritis in people over 16: diagnosis and management—updated summary of NICE guidance. BMJ, 380, p24.
  10. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p24
  11. UK Parliament (2026). House of Lords Written Question HL16433, tabled 15 April 2026. Parliamentary discussion concerning BMI-related restrictions on joint replacement surgery.
  12. https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-04-15/HL16433/

More than one in three areas of England restrict surgery for smokers and overweight patients — Royal College of Surgeons

The Royal College of Surgeons today warns smokers and overweight patients are becoming soft targets for NHS savings.

https://rcseng.ac.uk/news-and-events/media-centre/press-releases/more-than-one-in-three-areas-of-england-restrict-surgery-for-smokers-and-overweight-patients/

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 11:25

DeliaPith321 · 28/10/2026 11:15

There is an interesting point being overlooked in the debate about whether people with obesity should be denied NHS healthcare: to a limited extent, restrictions based on obesity already exist, and the question has been openly debated for years.
In 2016, the Royal College of Surgeons reported that 34% of the NHS Clinical Commissioning Groups responding to its investigation had policies restricting referrals for routine surgery based on BMI or smoking status. In Harrogate, for example, plans were announced to delay non-urgent operations for six months for patients with a BMI of 30 or above unless they completed a weight-management programme. These measures were explicitly linked to NHS financial pressures.
This is not merely historical. A study examining NHS policies in England in 2025 found that 15 of 41 Integrated Care Boards had BMI-based restrictions on eligibility for joint replacement surgery. Some patients can therefore face additional conditions or delays because of their weight, although this is very different from a general refusal to provide healthcare.
The issue has also been discussed openly in Parliament. In April 2026, the Government confirmed that local NHS commissioners retain responsibility for determining eligibility policies, including BMI criteria for joint replacement surgery. However, it also reiterated that BMI should not, by itself, prevent access to surgery.
There are legitimate arguments for considering obesity when allocating NHS resources. Certain operations carry greater risks for patients with severe obesity, including anaesthetic complications, infections and difficulties with recovery. Where reducing weight beforehand would materially improve safety or outcomes, postponing an elective procedure may be clinically justified. The NHS also operates within finite budgets, meaning decisions about clinical effectiveness, cost-effectiveness and prioritisation are unavoidable. It is therefore feasible to introduce eligibility conditions for particular treatments, provided they are clinically justified, proportionate and allow individual assessment.
There is also an argument that publicly funded healthcare should encourage patients to participate in measures that improve treatment outcomes, particularly where these could reduce complications and the need for further treatment. However, encouraging participation is not necessarily the same as making successful weight loss a condition of receiving care.
The counterarguments are substantial. Obesity is influenced by genetics, socioeconomic circumstances, medications, health conditions and environmental factors, alongside individual behaviour. Weight loss is not equally achievable for everyone, and delaying treatment may worsen someone's condition or mobility, potentially making weight reduction harder. Restrictions might also increase long-term NHS expenditure rather than reduce it.
Importantly, NICE concluded that BMI should not be a barrier to referral for joint replacement. Its evidence review found that people with obesity still experienced improvements following surgery, and that BMI alone was an inadequate measure of individual surgical risk.
The distinction, therefore, is between restricting particular treatments for defensible clinical reasons and withholding healthcare as a punishment for someone's perceived lifestyle choices. The former already exists within NHS commissioning and can be implemented through established eligibility policies. The latter would require a much broader ethical, legal and practical justification.
The interesting question is not simply whether restricting treatment for obesity is possible, because it demonstrably is. It is whether particular restrictions actually improve outcomes, represent responsible use of NHS resources, and can be applied fairly without worsening health inequalities.

Sources and further reading

  1. Ofosu, K., Whale, K. & McLaughlin, J. (2025). Persistent use of body mass index policies as a barrier to surgery: Prevalence and analysis of policies across England in 2025. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy. Published online December 2025. Research examining BMI restrictions across NHS Integrated Care Boards.
  2. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13263469/
  3. Royal College of Surgeons of England (2016). Smokers and overweight patients: soft targets for NHS savings? Investigation into NHS restrictions on routine surgery based on BMI and smoking status.
  4. https://rcseng.ac.uk/news-and-events/media-centre/press-releases/more-than-one-in-three-areas-of-england-restrict-surgery-for-smokers-and-overweight-patients/
  5. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2022). Osteoarthritis in over 16s: diagnosis and management. NICE Guideline NG226, particularly recommendation 1.6.3 on referral for joint replacement.
  6. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng226/chapter/recommendations
  7. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2022). Evidence reviews for outcomes of joint replacement surgery dependent on body mass index. Evidence Review P, NICE Guideline NG226.
  8. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK589222/
  9. Wood, G., Neilson, J., Cottrell, E. & Hoole, S.P. (2023). Osteoarthritis in people over 16: diagnosis and management—updated summary of NICE guidance. BMJ, 380, p24.
  10. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.p24
  11. UK Parliament (2026). House of Lords Written Question HL16433, tabled 15 April 2026. Parliamentary discussion concerning BMI-related restrictions on joint replacement surgery.
  12. https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-04-15/HL16433/

Yes I've lost weight for a procedure before - and there are some medications like the stuff you take to delay a period that aren't prescribed to anyone with a BMI over 35. Not for punitive reasons though, but for safety as the risk of blood clots or something is raised.

DeliaPith321 · 28/10/2026 11:29

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 11:25

Yes I've lost weight for a procedure before - and there are some medications like the stuff you take to delay a period that aren't prescribed to anyone with a BMI over 35. Not for punitive reasons though, but for safety as the risk of blood clots or something is raised.

Indeed. I had a look into it out of interest as it's not an idea I knew much about - found some interesting listening material too. I really just wanted to put across that the concept isn't quite as bad as people are making out - it's not like @ExpectMore has petitioned for the reintroduction of public hanging lol. Having said that, I'll never experience being obese thankfully and coming face to face effectively with someone who you are perceiving thinks you should be 'left for dead' is understandably bringing up some feelings.

Enjoy.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 11:35

DeliaPith321 · 28/10/2026 11:29

Indeed. I had a look into it out of interest as it's not an idea I knew much about - found some interesting listening material too. I really just wanted to put across that the concept isn't quite as bad as people are making out - it's not like @ExpectMore has petitioned for the reintroduction of public hanging lol. Having said that, I'll never experience being obese thankfully and coming face to face effectively with someone who you are perceiving thinks you should be 'left for dead' is understandably bringing up some feelings.

Enjoy.

To delay treatment on safety grounds while supporting a patient to lose weight via a weight management programme in order that a procedure can be carried out with lower risk to that patient is a completely different concept to making people pay for treatment of diseases that may or may not have been caused by their weight as a punishment though? It doesn't seem particularly relevant?

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 12:11

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 11:35

To delay treatment on safety grounds while supporting a patient to lose weight via a weight management programme in order that a procedure can be carried out with lower risk to that patient is a completely different concept to making people pay for treatment of diseases that may or may not have been caused by their weight as a punishment though? It doesn't seem particularly relevant?

That’s the whole crux and you are again misrepresenting me: it’s not as punishment! It’s as a deterrent, an incentive to avoid being obese in the first place. The preferred outcome is no-one pays, as the incentive works.

coupled with creating fairness in the system ie the costs land where they’re incurred rather than others who have made sensible choices having to pick up the bill.

DeliaPith321 · 28/10/2026 12:16

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 12:11

That’s the whole crux and you are again misrepresenting me: it’s not as punishment! It’s as a deterrent, an incentive to avoid being obese in the first place. The preferred outcome is no-one pays, as the incentive works.

coupled with creating fairness in the system ie the costs land where they’re incurred rather than others who have made sensible choices having to pick up the bill.

Edited

It's okay, I was about to question exactly where the idea of 'punishment' had come from - it sounded suspiciously loaded :)

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 12:32

I've dithered about coming back to this thread because so much on it has made me angry. Yes! Shock horror! It has produced an emotional reaction. And, you know what? That's entirely valid and it's not just my problem to manage. And it doesn't make me unsuited to, or some kind of naive newbie at, internet discussion.

Because we're not in University Debate Club, we're not discussing an academic paper, we're in the Weight Loss Chat section of an internet forum. Where people come to support each other in struggling, succeeding and (often) failing to lose weight. This is NOT a neutral environment for some cold academic theorising. And what has been proposed in the latter half of this thread is not some abstract scientific principle. It's a (albeit unrealistic, wildly unworkable) real world suggestion that in its hypothetical implementation would have real life, catastrophic consequences for vast swathes of the population. Others have pointed out that taken to its logical conclusion we're talking way more than just fat people, I'm not repeating all that. You can't detach the proposal from the negative impact it would have on people and the emotional response they would have.

I have a huge problem with the idea, which seems to have been eagerly taken to heart here, that any kind of emotional reaction in a discussion/debate somehow negates the validity of the opinion and response. Ad hominem arguments - sure, those don't belong. Just name calling is pointless. But this insidious implication that the emotionless debaters have superiority purely by being stone cold (even while dropping in little and big judgements and suggesting ideas which are based in emotion themselves: in this case that of resentment)? That kind of tone policing has been used particularly on women for years. Getting angry about what is and isn't sexism? Calm down love, if you were less emotional, we'd listen to you.

When someone suggests something abhorrent, and continues to double down on it while subtly undermining, invalidating and patronising anyone who has a strong reaction to it, that's not a good debate, discussion or any other term you might use.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 12:37

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 12:11

That’s the whole crux and you are again misrepresenting me: it’s not as punishment! It’s as a deterrent, an incentive to avoid being obese in the first place. The preferred outcome is no-one pays, as the incentive works.

coupled with creating fairness in the system ie the costs land where they’re incurred rather than others who have made sensible choices having to pick up the bill.

Edited

Well if people are not successfully deterred (which they won't be because deterrents work when the consequences are swift and directly related as opposed to the muddiness of 'you drank a glass of wine once and now should you develop a potentially alcohol-related cancer at any point in your life you'll pay for treatment) then they will be punished. If you speed, you are punished with a fine. The prospect of a fine deters people but does not eliminate speeding, hence the punishment occurs.

That's not to draw a direct parallel btw because there is much clearer correlation between speeding and the fine and it happens on a much shorter time frame than 'engage in some level of risky behaviour and at some point develop an illness that may or may not be related). But something can act as both a deterrent and punishment; the two are not mutually exclusive. It's quite clear that fatness would be punished in this system. There will always be fat people and some of them will get ill.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 12:43

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 12:32

I've dithered about coming back to this thread because so much on it has made me angry. Yes! Shock horror! It has produced an emotional reaction. And, you know what? That's entirely valid and it's not just my problem to manage. And it doesn't make me unsuited to, or some kind of naive newbie at, internet discussion.

Because we're not in University Debate Club, we're not discussing an academic paper, we're in the Weight Loss Chat section of an internet forum. Where people come to support each other in struggling, succeeding and (often) failing to lose weight. This is NOT a neutral environment for some cold academic theorising. And what has been proposed in the latter half of this thread is not some abstract scientific principle. It's a (albeit unrealistic, wildly unworkable) real world suggestion that in its hypothetical implementation would have real life, catastrophic consequences for vast swathes of the population. Others have pointed out that taken to its logical conclusion we're talking way more than just fat people, I'm not repeating all that. You can't detach the proposal from the negative impact it would have on people and the emotional response they would have.

I have a huge problem with the idea, which seems to have been eagerly taken to heart here, that any kind of emotional reaction in a discussion/debate somehow negates the validity of the opinion and response. Ad hominem arguments - sure, those don't belong. Just name calling is pointless. But this insidious implication that the emotionless debaters have superiority purely by being stone cold (even while dropping in little and big judgements and suggesting ideas which are based in emotion themselves: in this case that of resentment)? That kind of tone policing has been used particularly on women for years. Getting angry about what is and isn't sexism? Calm down love, if you were less emotional, we'd listen to you.

When someone suggests something abhorrent, and continues to double down on it while subtly undermining, invalidating and patronising anyone who has a strong reaction to it, that's not a good debate, discussion or any other term you might use.

Absolutely, I agree with everything you say! But one of the posters dismissing emotional engagement as intellectual weakness is posting largely from chatgpt, which doesn't have emotions. And the other has demonstrated a very unusual lack of empathy in the suggestion of this weird and unworkable system. So it's less a case of those of us with the capacity for human feeling being unable to debate and think clearly, and more a case of a couple of people who are very out of touch with humanity.

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 12:53

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 12:43

Absolutely, I agree with everything you say! But one of the posters dismissing emotional engagement as intellectual weakness is posting largely from chatgpt, which doesn't have emotions. And the other has demonstrated a very unusual lack of empathy in the suggestion of this weird and unworkable system. So it's less a case of those of us with the capacity for human feeling being unable to debate and think clearly, and more a case of a couple of people who are very out of touch with humanity.

Yeah. I'm long out of editing time but there's a post of mine from way back I rather wish I could delete because I've very much changed my opinion!

Lougle · 28/10/2026 13:13

I would say that obesity is not an illness in itself, but it can be caused by illness, or drugs that treat illnesses, and it can cause illnesses. It sounds like you need support to change your relationship with food and that's a really hard position to be in, because it's essential to life so you can't simply abstain.

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 13:21

I meant to say @OrangeBlaze so sorry to hear about your friend.

I was diagnosed with DCIS 4 years ago and had a lumpectomy, so very much a real world thing for me too. Paying for that would have bankrupted me, so I certainly wouldn't have been able to afford MJ in the last couple of years and I'd still be fat. Huh. 🤔

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 13:36

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 12:32

I've dithered about coming back to this thread because so much on it has made me angry. Yes! Shock horror! It has produced an emotional reaction. And, you know what? That's entirely valid and it's not just my problem to manage. And it doesn't make me unsuited to, or some kind of naive newbie at, internet discussion.

Because we're not in University Debate Club, we're not discussing an academic paper, we're in the Weight Loss Chat section of an internet forum. Where people come to support each other in struggling, succeeding and (often) failing to lose weight. This is NOT a neutral environment for some cold academic theorising. And what has been proposed in the latter half of this thread is not some abstract scientific principle. It's a (albeit unrealistic, wildly unworkable) real world suggestion that in its hypothetical implementation would have real life, catastrophic consequences for vast swathes of the population. Others have pointed out that taken to its logical conclusion we're talking way more than just fat people, I'm not repeating all that. You can't detach the proposal from the negative impact it would have on people and the emotional response they would have.

I have a huge problem with the idea, which seems to have been eagerly taken to heart here, that any kind of emotional reaction in a discussion/debate somehow negates the validity of the opinion and response. Ad hominem arguments - sure, those don't belong. Just name calling is pointless. But this insidious implication that the emotionless debaters have superiority purely by being stone cold (even while dropping in little and big judgements and suggesting ideas which are based in emotion themselves: in this case that of resentment)? That kind of tone policing has been used particularly on women for years. Getting angry about what is and isn't sexism? Calm down love, if you were less emotional, we'd listen to you.

When someone suggests something abhorrent, and continues to double down on it while subtly undermining, invalidating and patronising anyone who has a strong reaction to it, that's not a good debate, discussion or any other term you might use.

Oh come on, you’re falling into the same trap of misrepresenting proposals. The purpose of the concept is to improve overall health outcomes and statuses. That’s surely what this topic area is all about?

If the conversation was to be had outwith this topic area, there’d be accusations of discussing a topic in the absence of those who would benefit from it the most (which, to use your particular examples, women have suffered from historically: being discussed when not in the room).

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 13:48

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 13:21

I meant to say @OrangeBlaze so sorry to hear about your friend.

I was diagnosed with DCIS 4 years ago and had a lumpectomy, so very much a real world thing for me too. Paying for that would have bankrupted me, so I certainly wouldn't have been able to afford MJ in the last couple of years and I'd still be fat. Huh. 🤔

Thanks. It has been pretty dreadful. I can only imagine how much worse it would have been if someone had been asking her to prove that it wasn't caused by the fact she had in her life on occasion drunk some alcohol and demanding payment. It's such a bizarre idea! I'm very glad to hear you were treated successfully and could go on to access MJ - it's life changing!

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 13:49

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 13:36

Oh come on, you’re falling into the same trap of misrepresenting proposals. The purpose of the concept is to improve overall health outcomes and statuses. That’s surely what this topic area is all about?

If the conversation was to be had outwith this topic area, there’d be accusations of discussing a topic in the absence of those who would benefit from it the most (which, to use your particular examples, women have suffered from historically: being discussed when not in the room).

Ah, still patronising I see. I'm not falling into any traps, thank you and I'm not misrepresenting anything. The "concept" would do the opposite, and no there wouldn't be any such accusations because fat people aren't banned from the rest of MN any more than non-fat people are excluded from this forum. But its designation should indicate to anyone with a modicum of sensitivity what the large majority of the audience might be. And what their justified reactions might be to your ghastly ideas.

I'm won't be validating your nonsense by responding directly any further. Talk to yourself from now on, or anyone else who really wants to continue.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 14:03

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 13:49

Ah, still patronising I see. I'm not falling into any traps, thank you and I'm not misrepresenting anything. The "concept" would do the opposite, and no there wouldn't be any such accusations because fat people aren't banned from the rest of MN any more than non-fat people are excluded from this forum. But its designation should indicate to anyone with a modicum of sensitivity what the large majority of the audience might be. And what their justified reactions might be to your ghastly ideas.

I'm won't be validating your nonsense by responding directly any further. Talk to yourself from now on, or anyone else who really wants to continue.

Edited

I see you’re similarly not able to evaluate ideas objectively. I guess it’s because you have a conflict of interest.

take care

GiveMeWordGames · 28/10/2026 14:06

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 13:48

Thanks. It has been pretty dreadful. I can only imagine how much worse it would have been if someone had been asking her to prove that it wasn't caused by the fact she had in her life on occasion drunk some alcohol and demanding payment. It's such a bizarre idea! I'm very glad to hear you were treated successfully and could go on to access MJ - it's life changing!

Cancer is such a horrible disease. Again, I'm sorry.

MJ really is life changing isn't it? And that's the thing to focus on here, I realise. The joy in what I've achieved and how much things have changed for me.

Not the sociopathic ideas of the empathy-free.