I've dithered about coming back to this thread because so much on it has made me angry. Yes! Shock horror! It has produced an emotional reaction. And, you know what? That's entirely valid and it's not just my problem to manage. And it doesn't make me unsuited to, or some kind of naive newbie at, internet discussion.
Because we're not in University Debate Club, we're not discussing an academic paper, we're in the Weight Loss Chat section of an internet forum. Where people come to support each other in struggling, succeeding and (often) failing to lose weight. This is NOT a neutral environment for some cold academic theorising. And what has been proposed in the latter half of this thread is not some abstract scientific principle. It's a (albeit unrealistic, wildly unworkable) real world suggestion that in its hypothetical implementation would have real life, catastrophic consequences for vast swathes of the population. Others have pointed out that taken to its logical conclusion we're talking way more than just fat people, I'm not repeating all that. You can't detach the proposal from the negative impact it would have on people and the emotional response they would have.
I have a huge problem with the idea, which seems to have been eagerly taken to heart here, that any kind of emotional reaction in a discussion/debate somehow negates the validity of the opinion and response. Ad hominem arguments - sure, those don't belong. Just name calling is pointless. But this insidious implication that the emotionless debaters have superiority purely by being stone cold (even while dropping in little and big judgements and suggesting ideas which are based in emotion themselves: in this case that of resentment)? That kind of tone policing has been used particularly on women for years. Getting angry about what is and isn't sexism? Calm down love, if you were less emotional, we'd listen to you.
When someone suggests something abhorrent, and continues to double down on it while subtly undermining, invalidating and patronising anyone who has a strong reaction to it, that's not a good debate, discussion or any other term you might use.