Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 12:25

Looks like someone got trigger happy with the reporting button, I wonder who,

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 12:33

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 10:33

Have you got kids? Have you ever taught them consequences?

Do A, B happens
Do X, Y happens

Did you consider that exercise “brutal and unfair”?

Transparent consequences aren’t only fair but act as a behavioural motivator, which is what this is about. As a country we have a health and coupled budgetary affordability problem.

A previous poster even said “money” was the all controlling entity: great, let’s make it work for us as a country. If the cost of an unhealthy diet + treatment is more than the costs of a healthy diet, let’s motivate the healthy diet.

Just to come back to this as I phrased it more forcefully earlier 😳 - the consequences are not quite so clear cut as you're suggesting. Cancers being 'linked to' obesity isn't the same as being able to look at a case and conclude one thing that has caused the disease with absolute accuracy. And you would of course also have to look at the cause of the obesity as well. It's all rather complicated.

Processed meats are class 1 carcinogens. You mentioned eating cooked breakfasts regularly during a busy work period, and if those contained bacon and sausages then you, like most people have, consumed something that does cause cancer. It does not mean that you will at any stage in your life develop bowel cancer. But if you did, and the doctor said you must pay for your treatment (and cancer treatment would be extraordinarily expensive by the way, life-ruiningly so unless you're a multimillionaire) because you previously ate processed meats, that would be very unfair. As no one could possibly draw that direct line between a Premier Inn sausage one day and bowel cancer twenty years later. Risk and consequence when it comes to health are not entirely predictable. So it is quite different to telling a child if they don't tidy their room they won't get any pocket money. Your imagined health system could never work because it would be impossible for doctors to definitively state that a person's behaviour had absolutely caused that particular disease at that particular time with enough reliability and accuracy.

Ffiohna · 26/10/2026 12:51

Well I’m hugely impressed by anyone who can run and ultra marathons are another level. Hats off to you for this!

But, @ExpectMore would you not agree that to be able to pursue this sport needs certain - shall we say - privileges that many cannot afford? Time to train. Time and money to compete. Money for decent footwear. Money for the optimum quality foods. Transport to get you to your beloved hills - I sense from your use of outwith you may be Scottish or live there, yes Scotland is awash will hills but they tend not to be in the “poor areas” nor potentially on public transport. Of course, your life, your circumstances, your money and means, but you might show a tad of empathy for others along the way who for whatever reason could not - even if they wanted to - pursue a sport they adored or aspire to do.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 12:53

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 11:50

But people didn't stop smoking just because they were told it was unhealthy. Tobacco companies were made subject to extremely heavy restrictions and regulations. Taxed highly, not allowed to advertise, forced to put graphic health warnings with photos of diseased organs on the packaging. If this happens with UPFs, then yes consumption will decrease. But you do need to regulate companies in order to make it happen. Earlier in the thread you said you didn't think the government should be intervening in people's food choices. But you engage in overly simplistic magical thinking and expect that people will just make better choices because you can't understand any of the very many reasons they can't or don't.

If governments had not intervened with tobacco companies then smoking rates would be much higher now. It might make no sense to you, but it's the truth. Because of the interventions, public health in that measure at least has improved. That's a good thing. It's much better than saying smokers are stupid and weak willed and should be denied NHS care. It hits the corporations making gigantic profits and it protects individuals. Similar measures could be taken with UPFs, but if they aren't then consumption probably won't decrease especially for the lowest-income families who are priced out of healthy eating - again, you dismiss that in the face of plenty of evidence and research, but it is true nonetheless.

I think the cost argument is disingenuous. The food foundation notes the annual cost of a healthy diet is £3,478 whereas a typical (which granted won’t just be unhealthy food) diet is a few hundred per annum less.

So at most the total difference is about £5/week. Thats presumably a cost worth paying and possible to pay for all who prioritise their health. Noting it’ll result in savings elsewhere.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 12:58

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 12:53

I think the cost argument is disingenuous. The food foundation notes the annual cost of a healthy diet is £3,478 whereas a typical (which granted won’t just be unhealthy food) diet is a few hundred per annum less.

So at most the total difference is about £5/week. Thats presumably a cost worth paying and possible to pay for all who prioritise their health. Noting it’ll result in savings elsewhere.

Ok, please do continue to ignore all research and evidence to do with poverty and obesity. You don't want to understand the correlation there and you would prefer to insist that you know better and that actually being poor is no excuse for being overweight. You are wrong, but as you aren't willing to acknowledge any evidence that anyone presents then I guess you will continue to be wrong about that.

So what about all the measures that were taken to reduce smoking - do you agree they made a difference and brought smoking rates down? Do you think that similar could or should be done with UPFs? Do you think it would have an impact on obesity rates if that were to happen?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 13:06

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 12:58

Ok, please do continue to ignore all research and evidence to do with poverty and obesity. You don't want to understand the correlation there and you would prefer to insist that you know better and that actually being poor is no excuse for being overweight. You are wrong, but as you aren't willing to acknowledge any evidence that anyone presents then I guess you will continue to be wrong about that.

So what about all the measures that were taken to reduce smoking - do you agree they made a difference and brought smoking rates down? Do you think that similar could or should be done with UPFs? Do you think it would have an impact on obesity rates if that were to happen?

Of course they reduced the rate of smoking, there’s lower levels of smoking now that historically?

I’d be surprised if many didn’t stop of their own volition once it became apparent how awful they are for you.

I know people do continue even when they know it’s bad for them (and their kids / anyone else inhaling their fumes) which I find incredible.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 13:19

I’d be surprised if many didn’t stop of their own volition once it became apparent how awful they are for you.

I think you might need to gird your loins for a surprise then! It took a huge and concerted public health campaign to shift public attitudes towards smoking. It's also maybe interesting that smoking is more likely for low-income people (like obesity) which I've seen attributed to stress and also mental and/or physical health problems. So people for whom it's actually causing more harm and more financial pressure still are more likely to be the people doing it. I think it's really worth considering why that might be.

But overall, it took:

  • smoking bans
  • higher taxes
  • graphic warnings on packaging
  • advertising bans
  • support services to help people quit, available on the NHS

from what I can remember anyway, to actually drive down rates of smoking. A major public health campaign that held big corporations to account and supported individuals to make better choices.

That's the kind of model I would suggest we look at for obesity - which is a lot more complicated than smoking admittedly - rather than your proposition of taking away healthcare from fat people.

But that depends on whether you are interested in improving public health outcomes or if you prefer just to feel superior to fat people.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 13:35

Ffiohna · 26/10/2026 12:51

Well I’m hugely impressed by anyone who can run and ultra marathons are another level. Hats off to you for this!

But, @ExpectMore would you not agree that to be able to pursue this sport needs certain - shall we say - privileges that many cannot afford? Time to train. Time and money to compete. Money for decent footwear. Money for the optimum quality foods. Transport to get you to your beloved hills - I sense from your use of outwith you may be Scottish or live there, yes Scotland is awash will hills but they tend not to be in the “poor areas” nor potentially on public transport. Of course, your life, your circumstances, your money and means, but you might show a tad of empathy for others along the way who for whatever reason could not - even if they wanted to - pursue a sport they adored or aspire to do.

Thanks but trust me, anyone can do them if they put their mind to them (assuming not disabled): I’m evidence of that as I’m very much average!

To an extent but not significantly nor outwith what’s maybe reasonable. For example time: we all have the same time in the week. My time pressures are that I have two small children, no family support nearby, a busy stressful job that requires me to travel a lot so I have to find ways to carve time out to run (I do so by getting up at 5am so I’m out and back by the time the kids rise etc).

Cost: I’d guess that it costs me less than the cost of most annual gym memberships, with the main costs being trainers and backpack, waterproofs etc. I also choose to do local races to it costs less plus for environmental reasons and for greater personal connection to the race.

I live in the north west of England in an area with lower than national average (and local regional) house prices so it wouldnt be considered affluent.

I’m “lucky” in that I can run into the hills from my front door, but that’s by design: I chose to move here for that, and other (eg general affordability) reasons.

Most can afford trainers and thus to be able to go for a run out their front door, independent of whether that’s in the hills or not.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 13:44

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 13:19

I’d be surprised if many didn’t stop of their own volition once it became apparent how awful they are for you.

I think you might need to gird your loins for a surprise then! It took a huge and concerted public health campaign to shift public attitudes towards smoking. It's also maybe interesting that smoking is more likely for low-income people (like obesity) which I've seen attributed to stress and also mental and/or physical health problems. So people for whom it's actually causing more harm and more financial pressure still are more likely to be the people doing it. I think it's really worth considering why that might be.

But overall, it took:

  • smoking bans
  • higher taxes
  • graphic warnings on packaging
  • advertising bans
  • support services to help people quit, available on the NHS

from what I can remember anyway, to actually drive down rates of smoking. A major public health campaign that held big corporations to account and supported individuals to make better choices.

That's the kind of model I would suggest we look at for obesity - which is a lot more complicated than smoking admittedly - rather than your proposition of taking away healthcare from fat people.

But that depends on whether you are interested in improving public health outcomes or if you prefer just to feel superior to fat people.

You keep misquoting me. I’ve never said take it away. I’ve just suggested charging for it. Very different

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 14:02

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 13:44

You keep misquoting me. I’ve never said take it away. I’ve just suggested charging for it. Very different

It would be the same in practice. Who could afford the cost of cancer treatment? Lots of people can barely afford the cost of living right now; how would they manage paying to treat type 2 diabetes? You can blame them all you want, but in reality you are advocating to deny them healthcare by making it impossible to afford. In a plan that I have of course explained wouldn't work so it's a moot point.

Look, surely you can accept that if people had been told 'smoking is bad for your health, stop doing it or else if you ever get lung cancer you can foot the bill' it would not have been anywhere near as successful as the measures that were actually taken?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 14:27

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 14:02

It would be the same in practice. Who could afford the cost of cancer treatment? Lots of people can barely afford the cost of living right now; how would they manage paying to treat type 2 diabetes? You can blame them all you want, but in reality you are advocating to deny them healthcare by making it impossible to afford. In a plan that I have of course explained wouldn't work so it's a moot point.

Look, surely you can accept that if people had been told 'smoking is bad for your health, stop doing it or else if you ever get lung cancer you can foot the bill' it would not have been anywhere near as successful as the measures that were actually taken?

Why should others that have not chosen to put themselves at risk of needing treatment have to contribute to the bill of treatment in your (the current) model?

Not Withstanding the fact it’s unaffordable, it doesn’t seem fair. Does it?

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 14:38

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 14:27

Why should others that have not chosen to put themselves at risk of needing treatment have to contribute to the bill of treatment in your (the current) model?

Not Withstanding the fact it’s unaffordable, it doesn’t seem fair. Does it?

Yes it seems absolutely fair to me. I strongly believe in taxation funding good public services that are accessible to all. I'm a higher-rate taxpayer with two kids in private school. I voted Labour despite the VAT because I want state education to be better funded. I don't love it when January and July roll around and I pay a big tax bill, or when I fork out £14k at the start of every term. I pay for my own Mounjaro, gym membership and a personal trainer. I definitely should be getting on with the job that pays for it all right now instead of arguing on the internet. But I want my taxes to contribute to society. I want to be part of a society that looks after it's most vulnerable and would never leave people to die of treatable diseases for lack of funds even if those diseases were definitively proven to be self inflicted (a point you refuse to engage with btw as regards proving that any one disease has been self inflicted!) I also want major corporations and the super wealthy to pay their fucking taxes too.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 14:41

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 14:27

Why should others that have not chosen to put themselves at risk of needing treatment have to contribute to the bill of treatment in your (the current) model?

Not Withstanding the fact it’s unaffordable, it doesn’t seem fair. Does it?

And to continue from my response to this, rather than advocating to let people get sicker and die because we 'don't want to pay for their choices' I suggest we take the anti-smoking model and apply some of those principles to obesity. For one, it's a lot more practical and realistic than presenting fat people with a bill if they get cancer or have a heart attack. It will cost a lot less than implementing your model (all the checks we would have to do to attempt to establish the cause as definitely obesity and definitely self inflicted!) It will save money in the long run. And it's the humane, decent approach to take.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 15:00

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 14:27

Why should others that have not chosen to put themselves at risk of needing treatment have to contribute to the bill of treatment in your (the current) model?

Not Withstanding the fact it’s unaffordable, it doesn’t seem fair. Does it?

By that model as a net contributor why should I pay for anyone else’s treatment , and still pay for my child’s education and our healthcare,

i grew up poor I’d the same or less opportunities as others so why should I pay.

let’s all stop paying for others and just pay for ourselves.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 15:03

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 14:38

Yes it seems absolutely fair to me. I strongly believe in taxation funding good public services that are accessible to all. I'm a higher-rate taxpayer with two kids in private school. I voted Labour despite the VAT because I want state education to be better funded. I don't love it when January and July roll around and I pay a big tax bill, or when I fork out £14k at the start of every term. I pay for my own Mounjaro, gym membership and a personal trainer. I definitely should be getting on with the job that pays for it all right now instead of arguing on the internet. But I want my taxes to contribute to society. I want to be part of a society that looks after it's most vulnerable and would never leave people to die of treatable diseases for lack of funds even if those diseases were definitively proven to be self inflicted (a point you refuse to engage with btw as regards proving that any one disease has been self inflicted!) I also want major corporations and the super wealthy to pay their fucking taxes too.

You’ve only stated why you’re happy to pay towards it, you’ve not articulated why you say it’s fair.

you also approach it from a perspective of covering the costs of the vulnerable when many of those aren’t typically vulnerable. They’re well off.

So continuing in that vein, why is it fair for the costs of treatment of the well off to be born by lower income tax payers?

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 15:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 15:54

Anyway, we keep going so far away from the OP - is obesity an illness? This thread has really crystallised for me that we need to treat it as one and also as a public health issue. Punishing fat people is not only cruel but also pointless - it won't save money or reverse the rising rates of obesity. We have had a major breakthrough in treatment via GLP-1s and, as a society, there are public health measures that can be taken. I think there will always be people who disagree because they really want to see anyone they consider less than them suffer. The last thing these people want is humane and effective treatment that preserves fat people's dignity and improves their health. The 'pull yourself up by the bootstraps' approach tends to be woefully ignorant and unable to engage with any level of complexity. I know we can argue in circles until 1000 posts, but that really sums it up for me.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 16:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree with a lot but not all of what you’ve said, albeit a lot of it is going off topic.

one question though: these taxes you’re more than happy to pay. Wouldn’t you rather they went towards improving things such as schools, universities, infrastructure, better support for the disabled etc rather than being spent on a preventable problem?

The later wouldn’t seem a very good investment when the money could be better spent elsewhere.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 16:55

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 16:27

I agree with a lot but not all of what you’ve said, albeit a lot of it is going off topic.

one question though: these taxes you’re more than happy to pay. Wouldn’t you rather they went towards improving things such as schools, universities, infrastructure, better support for the disabled etc rather than being spent on a preventable problem?

The later wouldn’t seem a very good investment when the money could be better spent elsewhere.

Well, the problem exists right now and you can't prevent something that's already happened. But as I've said plenty of times, I would support public health measures to address the rising rates of obesity going forwards.

Your plan to deny people healthcare would, I believe, not just be impossible (and wildly unethical) to put into practice but also would cost a great deal - in pointless investigations and wrangling over pinpointing a cause of illness that is likely to never be able to be identified. It would also open the NHS up to a great deal of very expensive litigation. And doctors have sworn the hippocratic oath, they aren't going to be happy to let people suffer and die if they can't pay. Not to mention the conditions that would become more expensive if left untreated - type 2 diabetes potentially rendering someone blind for example or requiring an amputation. So that plan is absolutely not a good use of taxpayer money.

Telling people to eat less and move more - well, the NHS, schools and other organisations have been saying that a long time but obesity rates have continued to rise.

I'd like to do something that works, is ethical and ultimately saves money if possible in the long term. I would guess that the anti-smoking measures saved money both in preventing future illness and also in raising revenue from heavily taxed sales of tobacco. That seems like a good place to start. But I, a poster on MN, cannot solve the obesity crisis I'm afraid. Governments and health organisations across the world have been trying for years. It's been GLP-1s that have actually made an impact. There isn't an easy solution. It's a major public health issue, caused by many factors with no simple resolution. I know it seems very simple to you, but in reality it isn't.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 17:00

I really don't know why my explanation of why I support taxation and the funding of public services has been deleted! I can't see that there is anything in breach of talk guidelines in saying that a fair society funds public services.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 17:42

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 17:00

I really don't know why my explanation of why I support taxation and the funding of public services has been deleted! I can't see that there is anything in breach of talk guidelines in saying that a fair society funds public services.

I’ve a sneaking suspicion it might have been your accusation that anyone who had an alternative opinion to yours was a “sociopathic idiot”.

Can’t quite see which bit of an honest and credible explanation such a claim would fit into….

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 17:56

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 17:42

I’ve a sneaking suspicion it might have been your accusation that anyone who had an alternative opinion to yours was a “sociopathic idiot”.

Can’t quite see which bit of an honest and credible explanation such a claim would fit into….

I think i said selfish sociopath, not idiot, and it wasn't in reference to anyone with a different opinion but with regards to people who don't think they have any duty towards the rest of society. In the context of explaining why tax and public services are so important. I think that wealthy people and corporations who try to evade tax and not contribute are pretty sociopathic - will I get deleted again for that? It's certainly selfish! And I think it's a sociopathic suggestion to deny people healthcare as well. Because that would involve watching people die of treatable causes - that is sociopathic, isn't it?

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 18:17

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 17:56

I think i said selfish sociopath, not idiot, and it wasn't in reference to anyone with a different opinion but with regards to people who don't think they have any duty towards the rest of society. In the context of explaining why tax and public services are so important. I think that wealthy people and corporations who try to evade tax and not contribute are pretty sociopathic - will I get deleted again for that? It's certainly selfish! And I think it's a sociopathic suggestion to deny people healthcare as well. Because that would involve watching people die of treatable causes - that is sociopathic, isn't it?

I don’t want to break the news to you but that’s already what happens on the NHS when a treatment isn’t approved as not considered affordable

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 18:31

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 18:17

I don’t want to break the news to you but that’s already what happens on the NHS when a treatment isn’t approved as not considered affordable

That's quite different to your suggestion. Anyway, no one on the thread has taken your idea of denying fat people treatment seriously because it's patently absurd, unworkable, enormously expensive and deeply unethical. You are fully aware of that and have given up trying to defend the indefensible. It has become clear that you don't have an argument for it and you do realise it was never a sensible or practical suggestion. You probably realised that from the start!

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 18:36

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 18:31

That's quite different to your suggestion. Anyway, no one on the thread has taken your idea of denying fat people treatment seriously because it's patently absurd, unworkable, enormously expensive and deeply unethical. You are fully aware of that and have given up trying to defend the indefensible. It has become clear that you don't have an argument for it and you do realise it was never a sensible or practical suggestion. You probably realised that from the start!

I think you’re believing what you want to believe. I’ve come to the conclusion that no-one wise seems to have the insight nor open mindedness to consider an alternative approach to the problem. Most are stuck in the “it’s not anyone’s fault”, “we’ll spend more money we don’t have on it”, and “we’ll tax the rich more to afford it”. Thats the issue with solving such issues: people can’t think logically only emotively and from blinkered perspectives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread