Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 18:38

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 18:36

I think you’re believing what you want to believe. I’ve come to the conclusion that no-one wise seems to have the insight nor open mindedness to consider an alternative approach to the problem. Most are stuck in the “it’s not anyone’s fault”, “we’ll spend more money we don’t have on it”, and “we’ll tax the rich more to afford it”. Thats the issue with solving such issues: people can’t think logically only emotively and from blinkered perspectives.

But your solution would cost money, not save it. So it really isn't logical.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:05

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 18:38

But your solution would cost money, not save it. So it really isn't logical.

Not sure how you work that one out. I’d save a significant proportion of £9Bn per annum in the NHS alone, given that’s the estimated annual cost and it’s recognised most obesity is preventable and reversible.

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/life-sciences-healthcare-goals/obesity-healthcare-goals

Obesity and overweight

Obesity and overweight fact sheet from WHO providing key facts and information on causes, health consequences, double burden of disease, prevention, WHO response.

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:10

I'm pretty stoked to come back to this and see it's become a debate focused on the topics at hand as opposed to all the personal attacks, childishness, and mudslinging I left this morning. Yay.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:12

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 11:28

I think some might have to spend more of their income on quality food than others, but I think in the uk there’s a very small proportion who if they choose to prioritise food, couldn’t afford to eat healthily (when I grew up in poverty, we literally had next to nothing but always had healthy food as cooking from scratch with basic ingredients was cheaper than takeaways, eating out etc. similarly when I first set out and was on just above NMW I found it possible to afford good food, if you prioritise that).

Im also not sure there’s much excuse for not understanding the basics of nutrition in the uk. It’s taught to every school kid. Don’t you think?

I think your personal experience is perfectly valid, but I'm not sure we can generalise from it to the wider population.
The evidence suggests that healthy eating isn't simply a question of prioritising food expenditure.
For example, the Food Foundation's 2026 Broken Plate report found that the poorest 20% of UK households would need to spend 49% of their disposable income after housing costs to afford a diet meeting government healthy eating recommendations. For the poorest 20% of households with children, that figure rises to 85%.
That's a rather different picture from the suggestion that only a very small proportion of people cannot afford to eat healthily.
There's also an important distinction between the cost of individual ingredients and the affordability of a consistently healthy, varied and nutritionally adequate diet. Rice, lentils and vegetables may be inexpensive, but that doesn't necessarily mean everyone can afford to meet their nutritional needs consistently, particularly when balancing other essential expenditure.
Similarly, being taught nutrition at school doesn't automatically translate into nutritional literacy or the ability to apply that knowledge. Knowledge is only one influence on dietary behaviour, alongside socioeconomic circumstances, working hours, stress, cooking facilities, access to affordable food and the wider food environment.
I think the more useful question is not whether healthy eating is theoretically possible on a low income, but how realistically accessible and sustainable it is across different circumstances.
Your experience demonstrates that it can be achieved under some conditions, but it doesn't establish how achievable it is for the wider population.
Source: Food Foundation, Broken Plate 2026
https://foodfoundation.org.uk/press-release/poorest-families-children-need-spend-85-their-disposable-income-afford-healthy-diet

Poorest families with children need to spend 85% of their disposable income to afford a healthy diet

Food Foundation's 2026 Broken Plate report shows the price gap between healthy and unhealthy food is at its widest in over a decade

https://foodfoundation.org.uk/press-release/poorest-families-children-need-spend-85-their-disposable-income-afford-healthy-diet

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 19:16

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:10

I'm pretty stoked to come back to this and see it's become a debate focused on the topics at hand as opposed to all the personal attacks, childishness, and mudslinging I left this morning. Yay.

You must be reading a different thread to me, it’s utterly bonkers, arguing the ludicrous whilst hurling childish insults.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:23

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:12

I think your personal experience is perfectly valid, but I'm not sure we can generalise from it to the wider population.
The evidence suggests that healthy eating isn't simply a question of prioritising food expenditure.
For example, the Food Foundation's 2026 Broken Plate report found that the poorest 20% of UK households would need to spend 49% of their disposable income after housing costs to afford a diet meeting government healthy eating recommendations. For the poorest 20% of households with children, that figure rises to 85%.
That's a rather different picture from the suggestion that only a very small proportion of people cannot afford to eat healthily.
There's also an important distinction between the cost of individual ingredients and the affordability of a consistently healthy, varied and nutritionally adequate diet. Rice, lentils and vegetables may be inexpensive, but that doesn't necessarily mean everyone can afford to meet their nutritional needs consistently, particularly when balancing other essential expenditure.
Similarly, being taught nutrition at school doesn't automatically translate into nutritional literacy or the ability to apply that knowledge. Knowledge is only one influence on dietary behaviour, alongside socioeconomic circumstances, working hours, stress, cooking facilities, access to affordable food and the wider food environment.
I think the more useful question is not whether healthy eating is theoretically possible on a low income, but how realistically accessible and sustainable it is across different circumstances.
Your experience demonstrates that it can be achieved under some conditions, but it doesn't establish how achievable it is for the wider population.
Source: Food Foundation, Broken Plate 2026
https://foodfoundation.org.uk/press-release/poorest-families-children-need-spend-85-their-disposable-income-afford-healthy-diet

Looking at your stats from a different perspective, they make clear that all families can afford to eat healthily as even the poorest families would have 15% of their disposable income (after housing) spare.

The poorest 20% would have 51% spare.

so after housing and food is accounted for (the two main priorities) even the poorest have spare.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 19:24

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:05

Not sure how you work that one out. I’d save a significant proportion of £9Bn per annum in the NHS alone, given that’s the estimated annual cost and it’s recognised most obesity is preventable and reversible.

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/life-sciences-healthcare-goals/obesity-healthcare-goals

Because there would be all the time spent proving that the condition you're refusing to treat has been caused by the patient's obesity. How would you make it legally sound? Say someone is obese and has the BRCA mutation and develops breast cancer. Did the obesity cause it or was it the gene mutation? Was it a combination? Were there more factors? Can someone demonstrate this patient wouldn't have developed breast cancer if they weren't obese? How are you going to do that? If you deny them treatment, can they sue? There would be a lot of cases going through and that would cost time and money. And you would have to demonstrate the cause, because presumably you aren't suggesting an obese person is charged if they come into A&E after a car accident? That wasn't caused by their weight, was it - so you have to have a clear and watertight rationale for when you are and aren't withholding treatment that is free at the point of delivery. So doctors will be spending a lot of time trying to figure out when they can absolutely and definitively attribute an illness to obesity - because while obesity raises your risk of various problems that doesn't make it the direct cause every time.

Ok, then you have the cost of people who are now too ill to work because they're not getting treatment for their conditions as they've been attributed to their weight and they can't afford to pay. So they're getting sicker and sicker and are out of the workforce. That's another cost.

Then you have the healthcare staff who will leave rather than weigh a heart attack patient who's just come in and then tell them to pay up or drop dead because guess what, their BMI is over 30.

I don't think you're seeing much of that £9bn nor are you seeing any reduction in obesity rates. Because that's not how public health interventions work - look at programs that have achieved changes in public behaviour eg smoking reduction, vaccinations, the success of sunscreen promotion in Australia to reduce skin cancer rates and see what could be taken from them. What you will notice is that at no point did anyone take healthcare away from smokers/anti vaxxers/people who sunbathed recklessly - that's not a solution that works, but we do have examples lf programs which have had success.

I don't expect you will respond to any of this but I've typed it all out anyway, I really don't know why at this point.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:27

Why denying NHS treatment to people with obesity is scientifically unsound, ethically indefensible and practically unworkable
The suggestion that people with obesity should be denied NHS treatment because they have supposedly chosen to become obese rests on a fundamental misunderstanding of obesity, human behaviour and the purpose of a publicly funded healthcare system.

1. Obesity is not simply a choice
People make choices about what they eat, but that doesn't mean they consciously choose to develop obesity. Body weight is influenced by a complex interaction of biological, psychological, environmental and socioeconomic factors.
These include:

  • Genetics: Inherited differences influence appetite, satiety, energy expenditure and susceptibility to weight gain.
  • Appetite regulation: Hormones and neural signalling systems influence hunger, fullness and food-seeking behaviour, much of which occurs outside conscious control.
  • The brain's reward systems: Highly palatable foods can strongly influence motivation, cravings and eating behaviour.
  • Metabolic adaptation: Following weight loss, the body can respond with increased hunger and reduced energy expenditure, making weight maintenance difficult.
  • Childhood experiences: Adverse childhood experiences, including abuse and neglect, are associated with an increased risk of obesity later in life.
  • Psychological distress: Chronic stress, anxiety, depression and emotional difficulties can influence appetite, eating patterns and weight regulation.
  • Socioeconomic inequality: Poverty affects access to nutritious food, housing, leisure facilities, transport and opportunities for physical activity.
  • The food environment: Cheap, heavily marketed, energy-dense products are widely available and often more convenient than healthier alternatives.
  • Commercial influence: Food manufacturers invest heavily in product formulation, advertising, pricing and promotion to influence purchasing and consumption.
  • Medication: Certain antidepressants, antipsychotics, corticosteroids and other medications can contribute to weight gain.
  • Medical conditions: Conditions affecting hormonal or metabolic functioning can contribute to weight gain.
  • Sleep deprivation: Inadequate sleep can affect appetite regulation, food preferences and energy balance.
  • Working conditions: Long hours, shift work, fatigue and limited time can make healthy routines more difficult to sustain.
  • Physical disability and chronic illness: Pain, reduced mobility and other health limitations can restrict physical activity and influence weight.
  • Pregnancy, menopause and ageing: Hormonal, physiological and body-composition changes can affect weight regulation.
  • Early-life influences: Maternal health, childhood nutrition and other developmental factors can influence later susceptibility to obesity.
These factors do not eliminate personal agency, but they demonstrate why obesity cannot reasonably be reduced to a simple decision to eat too much.

2. Denying NHS treatment would be practically unworkable
How would we establish whether somebody was personally responsible for developing obesity?
Would clinicians investigate their childhood, genetics, income, medication history, psychological experiences and food environment before deciding whether they deserved treatment?
What proportion of someone's obesity would need to be considered voluntary before treatment could be refused?
And how would we distinguish between somebody whose obesity resulted predominantly from biological susceptibility and somebody whose circumstances made weight management exceptionally difficult?
There is no scientifically validated method of calculating an individual's moral responsibility for their body weight.
Any system attempting to do so would be arbitrary, inconsistent and potentially discriminatory.

3. The NHS does not operate on a principle of moral deservingness
The NHS was established to provide healthcare according to clinical need, not to determine whether patients deserve treatment based on their past behaviour.
If we introduced personal responsibility as a criterion for access, where would we stop?
Would we refuse treatment to people injured while skiing, cycling or playing rugby? People who smoke? People who drink alcohol? People who develop skin cancer after sun exposure? People who experience complications from dietary choices or sedentary lifestyles?
Almost every area of medicine involves some interaction between human behaviour, biology and environment.
The NHS already considers clinical risks when deciding which treatments are appropriate. That is entirely different from withholding healthcare as punishment.

4. Taxpayers funding obesity-related healthcare is entirely reasonable
The NHS is a collective system of risk-sharing. We contribute through taxation so that people can receive treatment according to need, recognising that illness and injury are not distributed equally.
Some people will require very expensive treatment, while others may need relatively little throughout their lives.
That is how social insurance and publicly funded healthcare work.
People with obesity are also taxpayers, employees, parents, carers and contributors to society. They are not a separate population receiving healthcare at everyone else's expense.
Furthermore, refusing treatment would not necessarily save public money. Untreated conditions can progress into more serious and expensive illnesses, increase disability and reduce people's ability to work.
Healthcare is not a reward for good behaviour. It is a public service designed to protect health and wellbeing.

5. Why should responsibility fall entirely on individuals rather than the corporations profiting from the food environment?
This is where I think the debate becomes particularly interesting.
We live in a food environment heavily influenced by multinational corporations that manufacture, advertise and distribute highly processed, energy-dense products.
These companies can invest enormous resources in understanding consumer behaviour, optimising palatability, encouraging repeat purchases and increasing consumption.
Yet when population-level obesity and associated healthcare costs are discussed, responsibility is frequently placed almost entirely on the individual consumer.

Why?
There is a reasonable argument that corporations whose products and commercial practices contribute to preventable ill health should bear a proportionate share of the resulting social costs.
This is consistent with the polluter pays principle: businesses whose activities generate costs for society should contribute towards addressing those costs rather than leaving the public to absorb them.
That doesn't mean every ultra-processed food is harmful or that every food manufacturer causes obesity. Products and practices should be assessed according to the evidence of harm.
However, policy could include:

  • Taxes on products demonstrably associated with adverse health outcomes, with revenue supporting prevention and healthcare.
  • Restrictions on marketing unhealthy foods, particularly to children.
  • Limits on promotions designed to encourage excessive consumption of energy-dense, nutritionally poor products.
  • Stronger requirements for transparency around ingredients, nutritional composition and marketing practices.
  • Incentives and regulatory requirements for reformulating products to improve nutritional quality.
  • Greater corporate accountability for misleading health claims and marketing.
  • Investment in making nutritious foods more affordable and accessible, potentially funded through levies on harmful products.
These approaches target the commercial and environmental influences on population health rather than punishing people after they have developed a health condition.

6. We should distinguish between individual behaviour and population-level causes
Of course individuals can make dietary changes, become more physically active and improve their health.
But recognising individual agency does not mean ignoring the conditions within which choices are made.
If obesity prevalence increases dramatically across a population over several decades, it is not credible to explain that change simply by suggesting that millions of people simultaneously became less disciplined.
Population-wide changes demand population-level explanations.

Ultimately, the question should not be whether people with obesity deserve healthcare. It should be why we would consider punishing patients for a complex health condition while leaving the commercial and structural influences contributing to that condition comparatively unchallenged.

The scientifically and economically sensible response is to treat illness according to clinical need, support individuals to improve their health, and hold commercial actors appropriately accountable for demonstrable harms.

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:29

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 19:16

You must be reading a different thread to me, it’s utterly bonkers, arguing the ludicrous whilst hurling childish insults.

You've literally just quoted me. So how could it be a different thread 😂

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:36

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:23

Looking at your stats from a different perspective, they make clear that all families can afford to eat healthily as even the poorest families would have 15% of their disposable income (after housing) spare.

The poorest 20% would have 51% spare.

so after housing and food is accounted for (the two main priorities) even the poorest have spare.

Edited

This is a common misconception around the definition of disposable income.
It's important to understand what 'disposable income after housing costs' actually means, because it doesn't refer to money left over after paying all essential bills.
In UK household income statistics, disposable income generally means income after direct taxes and certain deductions. The 'after housing costs' measure additionally deducts expenses such as rent, mortgage interest and council tax, but does not deduct essential expenditure such as energy bills, transport, childcare, food, clothing or other living costs.
For example, a household might have £1,500 in disposable income after housing costs, but after paying for energy, transport, childcare and other necessities, have only £300 remaining.
This makes the Food Foundation's 2026 findings particularly significant. The poorest 20% of UK households would need to spend 49% of their disposable income after housing costs to afford the recommended healthy diet, rising to 85% for the poorest households with children.
Crucially, those percentages are calculated before accounting for many other essential living expenses. The figures therefore illustrate why healthy eating cannot simply be reduced to a matter of financial prioritisation.

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:47

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 19:24

Because there would be all the time spent proving that the condition you're refusing to treat has been caused by the patient's obesity. How would you make it legally sound? Say someone is obese and has the BRCA mutation and develops breast cancer. Did the obesity cause it or was it the gene mutation? Was it a combination? Were there more factors? Can someone demonstrate this patient wouldn't have developed breast cancer if they weren't obese? How are you going to do that? If you deny them treatment, can they sue? There would be a lot of cases going through and that would cost time and money. And you would have to demonstrate the cause, because presumably you aren't suggesting an obese person is charged if they come into A&E after a car accident? That wasn't caused by their weight, was it - so you have to have a clear and watertight rationale for when you are and aren't withholding treatment that is free at the point of delivery. So doctors will be spending a lot of time trying to figure out when they can absolutely and definitively attribute an illness to obesity - because while obesity raises your risk of various problems that doesn't make it the direct cause every time.

Ok, then you have the cost of people who are now too ill to work because they're not getting treatment for their conditions as they've been attributed to their weight and they can't afford to pay. So they're getting sicker and sicker and are out of the workforce. That's another cost.

Then you have the healthcare staff who will leave rather than weigh a heart attack patient who's just come in and then tell them to pay up or drop dead because guess what, their BMI is over 30.

I don't think you're seeing much of that £9bn nor are you seeing any reduction in obesity rates. Because that's not how public health interventions work - look at programs that have achieved changes in public behaviour eg smoking reduction, vaccinations, the success of sunscreen promotion in Australia to reduce skin cancer rates and see what could be taken from them. What you will notice is that at no point did anyone take healthcare away from smokers/anti vaxxers/people who sunbathed recklessly - that's not a solution that works, but we do have examples lf programs which have had success.

I don't expect you will respond to any of this but I've typed it all out anyway, I really don't know why at this point.

Just change burden of proof. It’s on the individual to prove it didn’t cause it rather than the NHS to prove it did. That’d save the NHS £££ and effort.

Clearly treatment for an unrelated accident (car crash) or illness (eg tonsillitis) would be excluded.

OrangeBlaze · 26/10/2026 19:53

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 19:47

Just change burden of proof. It’s on the individual to prove it didn’t cause it rather than the NHS to prove it did. That’d save the NHS £££ and effort.

Clearly treatment for an unrelated accident (car crash) or illness (eg tonsillitis) would be excluded.

How does an individual without a medical qualification prove what did or didn't cause their illness? People go to the doctor for diagnosis and treatment, not to explain themselves what's wrong with them and how it happened. How do they know if they have a particular gene mutation? You're going to haul someone into an office, tell them they have cancer and ask them to justify why they deserve treatment? It's not how the NHS can, should or ever would work. You do know this.

Again, why your refusal to engage with public health initiatives that have proven to be successful? Because you aren't interested in success, only in punishing fat people.

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 20:02

DeliaPith321 · 26/10/2026 19:29

You've literally just quoted me. So how could it be a different thread 😂

Oh you were being sarcastic, 😂

honestly I can’t beleive peiple are acrually responding to the utter nonsense being posted, it’s like ni matter how extreme or bizzare the post, folks want to pretend it’s a debate,

I mean seriously make fat people pay for their own care and prove they didn’t cause their own cancer 😂

MyDarlingWhatIfYouFly · 26/10/2026 22:55

ExpectMore · 26/10/2026 16:27

I agree with a lot but not all of what you’ve said, albeit a lot of it is going off topic.

one question though: these taxes you’re more than happy to pay. Wouldn’t you rather they went towards improving things such as schools, universities, infrastructure, better support for the disabled etc rather than being spent on a preventable problem?

The later wouldn’t seem a very good investment when the money could be better spent elsewhere.

Every time someone has a sport-related injury it won’t be treated as it could have been prevented.

Only treat the passengers of car crashes because they definitely didn’t cause the crash.

Don’t treat elderly people with the flu because they should have self isolated in flu season.

Anyone who drinks alcohol should not be treated for any cancers or heart related diseases as alcohol us a known risk factor.

Where do you draw the line?

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 07:36

MyDarlingWhatIfYouFly · 26/10/2026 22:55

Every time someone has a sport-related injury it won’t be treated as it could have been prevented.

Only treat the passengers of car crashes because they definitely didn’t cause the crash.

Don’t treat elderly people with the flu because they should have self isolated in flu season.

Anyone who drinks alcohol should not be treated for any cancers or heart related diseases as alcohol us a known risk factor.

Where do you draw the line?

That poster has already explained she exempts sports from her bizarre system because she likes sports. But she doesn't like fat people. Honestly, you might as well just leave it at that because you won't get anywhere further. I just wrote more and deleted it because there is no point.

I've been on MN under various usernames for close to twenty years now and have read some fairly shocking things but this particular poster's comments rank pretty high. In all that time I've never had a comment deleted on a thread until yesterday so I have really had to reflect on why I broke my streak. I think this thread ended up an incredibly toxic and depressing read which took up way too much of my day yesterday. If I'm that invested in a thread, I know it's time to take a break - I like MN as a place to scroll and be amused and get advice on dogs in a few breaks during the day. But getting sucked into reading something as dark as this had a really bad effect on me yesterday. There is never a need to take something seriously that is so untethered to reality as the places this thread has gone and I see most people who were on it were sensible enough to leave it alone a long way back. So I am hoping to exercise the willpower to hide it now and get on with my life!

MyDarlingWhatIfYouFly · 27/10/2026 07:59

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 07:36

That poster has already explained she exempts sports from her bizarre system because she likes sports. But she doesn't like fat people. Honestly, you might as well just leave it at that because you won't get anywhere further. I just wrote more and deleted it because there is no point.

I've been on MN under various usernames for close to twenty years now and have read some fairly shocking things but this particular poster's comments rank pretty high. In all that time I've never had a comment deleted on a thread until yesterday so I have really had to reflect on why I broke my streak. I think this thread ended up an incredibly toxic and depressing read which took up way too much of my day yesterday. If I'm that invested in a thread, I know it's time to take a break - I like MN as a place to scroll and be amused and get advice on dogs in a few breaks during the day. But getting sucked into reading something as dark as this had a really bad effect on me yesterday. There is never a need to take something seriously that is so untethered to reality as the places this thread has gone and I see most people who were on it were sensible enough to leave it alone a long way back. So I am hoping to exercise the willpower to hide it now and get on with my life!

Edited

You are totally right, it’s far too easy to get drawn into these types of threads and it is just a waste of energy at the end of the day!

MoneyJo · 27/10/2026 08:06

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 07:36

That poster has already explained she exempts sports from her bizarre system because she likes sports. But she doesn't like fat people. Honestly, you might as well just leave it at that because you won't get anywhere further. I just wrote more and deleted it because there is no point.

I've been on MN under various usernames for close to twenty years now and have read some fairly shocking things but this particular poster's comments rank pretty high. In all that time I've never had a comment deleted on a thread until yesterday so I have really had to reflect on why I broke my streak. I think this thread ended up an incredibly toxic and depressing read which took up way too much of my day yesterday. If I'm that invested in a thread, I know it's time to take a break - I like MN as a place to scroll and be amused and get advice on dogs in a few breaks during the day. But getting sucked into reading something as dark as this had a really bad effect on me yesterday. There is never a need to take something seriously that is so untethered to reality as the places this thread has gone and I see most people who were on it were sensible enough to leave it alone a long way back. So I am hoping to exercise the willpower to hide it now and get on with my life!

Edited

Absolutely. I backed out pretty quickly because thankfully some crazy posts will never become reality and we can just decide not to even engage with that level of hate for sections of society.

Charlenedickens · 27/10/2026 08:13

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 07:36

That poster has already explained she exempts sports from her bizarre system because she likes sports. But she doesn't like fat people. Honestly, you might as well just leave it at that because you won't get anywhere further. I just wrote more and deleted it because there is no point.

I've been on MN under various usernames for close to twenty years now and have read some fairly shocking things but this particular poster's comments rank pretty high. In all that time I've never had a comment deleted on a thread until yesterday so I have really had to reflect on why I broke my streak. I think this thread ended up an incredibly toxic and depressing read which took up way too much of my day yesterday. If I'm that invested in a thread, I know it's time to take a break - I like MN as a place to scroll and be amused and get advice on dogs in a few breaks during the day. But getting sucked into reading something as dark as this had a really bad effect on me yesterday. There is never a need to take something seriously that is so untethered to reality as the places this thread has gone and I see most people who were on it were sensible enough to leave it alone a long way back. So I am hoping to exercise the willpower to hide it now and get on with my life!

Edited

Yeah I pretty much backed out quite quickly with just the occasional comment especially when I suspected someone was reporting any comments they didn’t like as a personal attack, weaponising mnhq, and posting ludicrous arguments about fat people, all because these meds are available, it’s astonishing how furious some women are about it.

I just couldn’t beleive people were actually responding like a debate was to be had.

One of the most idiotic threads I’ve seen on here and that’s saying something,

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 09:58

Charlenedickens · 26/10/2026 20:02

Oh you were being sarcastic, 😂

honestly I can’t beleive peiple are acrually responding to the utter nonsense being posted, it’s like ni matter how extreme or bizzare the post, folks want to pretend it’s a debate,

I mean seriously make fat people pay for their own care and prove they didn’t cause their own cancer 😂

I wasn't being sarcastic.

Charlenedickens · 27/10/2026 10:08

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 09:58

I wasn't being sarcastic.

Then I didn’t say the same as you?

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 10:09

It's been interesting reading people's experiences of the thread. I can't say I was particularly phased by what was coming up but then I've explained a bit about my background and the experience with which I came to the thread so that's unsurprising too. I love dealing with different viewpoints and talking through where they come from in a person but I also understand that for the layman in an internet thread it's not pleasant and can affect mental health to be exposed to these ideas especially when they involve things you have experienced or are experiencing. I decided to go into Criminology because I'm interested in understanding what leads to serious criminal behaviour as I believe that's the only way we can make sea changes.
It definitely takes a certain type of disposition not to get waylaid by the emotions that can tend to come up in the process of unpicking these processes.

Fun stuff. Anyway I'm guessing this has kinda ground to a halt now. It's the only thread I've been in on MN and pushed me to dive the rabbit hole a little further on UPFs and some perimenopausal obesity stuff so all valuable.

Be well.

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 12:06

Charlenedickens · 27/10/2026 10:08

Then I didn’t say the same as you?

That's correct. You quoted my post, so I could not have been looking at a different thread.

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 13:58

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 10:09

It's been interesting reading people's experiences of the thread. I can't say I was particularly phased by what was coming up but then I've explained a bit about my background and the experience with which I came to the thread so that's unsurprising too. I love dealing with different viewpoints and talking through where they come from in a person but I also understand that for the layman in an internet thread it's not pleasant and can affect mental health to be exposed to these ideas especially when they involve things you have experienced or are experiencing. I decided to go into Criminology because I'm interested in understanding what leads to serious criminal behaviour as I believe that's the only way we can make sea changes.
It definitely takes a certain type of disposition not to get waylaid by the emotions that can tend to come up in the process of unpicking these processes.

Fun stuff. Anyway I'm guessing this has kinda ground to a halt now. It's the only thread I've been in on MN and pushed me to dive the rabbit hole a little further on UPFs and some perimenopausal obesity stuff so all valuable.

Be well.

Thanks for your contributions and debating with good intent and spirit rather than getting caught up in mud slinging and emotions - makes a pleasant change and good to see folk that can consider perspectives outside the box by suspending judgement - thanks!

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 14:33

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 13:58

Thanks for your contributions and debating with good intent and spirit rather than getting caught up in mud slinging and emotions - makes a pleasant change and good to see folk that can consider perspectives outside the box by suspending judgement - thanks!

'Considering perspectives outside the box' is one thing, asking whether we should sincerely contemplate making a specific group of people suffer and die on the basis that they might have caused themselves an illness which could easily be attributable to something else and most likely be multifactorial is...quite another. I think if you've gone so far outside the box that you genuinely believe people with a high BMI are that worthless then you could probably do with revisiting the box tbh.

Highly ironic that you thank Delia for engaging in debate when you ignored every single point she raised and only answered her questions about your running 🤣 It's fairly obvious why you avoided almost every question that anyone posed to you really.

I'm back to the dog threads now, hope everyone else has managed to cleanse their brains of this thread - very dark and unpleasant stuff. 💐 to those who found it troubling - not because we're silly overly emotional irrational little ladies as implied. I think it's a good thing to possess empathy, a moral compass and the ability to interrogate and examine proposals even if almost all of our questions went unanswered.

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 15:32

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 14:33

'Considering perspectives outside the box' is one thing, asking whether we should sincerely contemplate making a specific group of people suffer and die on the basis that they might have caused themselves an illness which could easily be attributable to something else and most likely be multifactorial is...quite another. I think if you've gone so far outside the box that you genuinely believe people with a high BMI are that worthless then you could probably do with revisiting the box tbh.

Highly ironic that you thank Delia for engaging in debate when you ignored every single point she raised and only answered her questions about your running 🤣 It's fairly obvious why you avoided almost every question that anyone posed to you really.

I'm back to the dog threads now, hope everyone else has managed to cleanse their brains of this thread - very dark and unpleasant stuff. 💐 to those who found it troubling - not because we're silly overly emotional irrational little ladies as implied. I think it's a good thing to possess empathy, a moral compass and the ability to interrogate and examine proposals even if almost all of our questions went unanswered.

Yet again you are demonstrating that you selectively miss the point. This is why I realised it’s pointless engaging with you. Enjoy the dog boards