Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Charlenedickens · 28/10/2026 08:59

I can’t get my head round people still engaging on this shite.

for me if someone wants to make any group of people an underclass of citizen , penalise them, be it women, children, gay, certain religions, or skin colour, fat, disabled, whatever and argues they should be left to die if they caused their illness or can’t prove they didn’t, then this is something you’d simply not engage in.

but here we have posters actually trying to argue with this heinous bullshit.

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 09:01

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:20

you can indeed base evidence on a sample size of N=1.

Ask the many criminals who are sat behind bars as a result of one piece of evidence.

I think what you mean is you can’t draw statistical conclusions but that’s irrelevant.

You're not a scientist, are you? There's a world of difference in criminal justice and a scientific approach to evidence!

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 09:03

Charlenedickens · 28/10/2026 08:59

I can’t get my head round people still engaging on this shite.

for me if someone wants to make any group of people an underclass of citizen , penalise them, be it women, children, gay, certain religions, or skin colour, fat, disabled, whatever and argues they should be left to die if they caused their illness or can’t prove they didn’t, then this is something you’d simply not engage in.

but here we have posters actually trying to argue with this heinous bullshit.

You're right. I'm out. Thanks for the reminder.

MightyGoldBear · 28/10/2026 09:05

I think it's really complicated and different for everyone the reasons behind it. I think it's particularly really complicated for women. I never had trouble keeping a healthy weight before I had children. After children my body seems to be in such a high state of stress constantly that it stores fat easier and will not let go of much no matter how much I exercise or eat cleanly. Add in medical issues from having children and its not hard to see how anyone can spiral into putting on more and more weight and it becoming harder to be in a position to then get back to a healthy weight.

So it's really not the simple black and white less calories in for many people it's far more complex. I need a lifestyle that is compatible with me keeping a healthy weight,less stress more sleep. Children with additional needs a body with extra things to work around and factor In is not it. That's not to say its impossible but that's really irrelevant to ME and MY body right now.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:12

Charlenedickens · 28/10/2026 08:59

I can’t get my head round people still engaging on this shite.

for me if someone wants to make any group of people an underclass of citizen , penalise them, be it women, children, gay, certain religions, or skin colour, fat, disabled, whatever and argues they should be left to die if they caused their illness or can’t prove they didn’t, then this is something you’d simply not engage in.

but here we have posters actually trying to argue with this heinous bullshit.

No-one, or at least no-one that I’ve seen, is arguing for anyone to be left to die. You’ve made that one up.

Similarly I’ve not seen anyone argue for any group to be a underclass. Quite the contrary.

Given you seem to have completely missed the key points of the thread, maybe it wasn’t @DeliaPith321that was reading the wrong thread as you suggested, perhaps it was you!

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:17

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:12

No-one, or at least no-one that I’ve seen, is arguing for anyone to be left to die. You’ve made that one up.

Similarly I’ve not seen anyone argue for any group to be a underclass. Quite the contrary.

Given you seem to have completely missed the key points of the thread, maybe it wasn’t @DeliaPith321that was reading the wrong thread as you suggested, perhaps it was you!

No-one, or at least no-one that I’ve seen, is arguing for anyone to be left to die

So what happens to people who can't pay for their treatment?

Similarly I’ve not seen anyone argue for any group to be a underclass. Quite the contrary.

So why is it only obese people who would be made to pay for healthcare (despite their existing tax contributions) and not anyone else who has engaged in any behaviour that is linked to illness (such as drinking alcohol or eating processed meats). Doesn't that make obese people an underclass in this system?

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:21

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:48

But the stick isn't necessary. We've agreed on this thread already that smoking rates have dramatically declined. That's without charging smokers for the treatment of lung cancer/respiratory problems etc. And the causal effect is much easier to draw there than it is between obesity and other health conditions. But of course financially penalising smokers in this way wasn't needed - individual behaviour and subsequent health outcomes were improved via better regulation of corporations, freely accessible support systems, use of bans and restrictions and concerted information campaigns. I think we should start there before we hand out bills to cancer patients.

But smokers are already financially penalised, quite drastically:

typical tax on a packet of cigarettes (£11 tobacco duty + £3 Vat)
assume 10 cigarettes per day
over a lifetime (c 40 years) that’s: £100k!

So they are financially penalised for making the decision to smoke. It could be argued more harshly than in my proposal as they’re penalised at point of sale and thus penalised independent of whether they come to harm.

Also, smoking has been reduced but not eradicated.

so perhaps the carrot has got it so far and the stick is needed to eradicate it?

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:23

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:17

No-one, or at least no-one that I’ve seen, is arguing for anyone to be left to die

So what happens to people who can't pay for their treatment?

Similarly I’ve not seen anyone argue for any group to be a underclass. Quite the contrary.

So why is it only obese people who would be made to pay for healthcare (despite their existing tax contributions) and not anyone else who has engaged in any behaviour that is linked to illness (such as drinking alcohol or eating processed meats). Doesn't that make obese people an underclass in this system?

2nd point this was the topic of the thread. I’d apply the concept more broadly (smoking, cause car crash through reckless driving, someone who assaults someone and causes harm etc etc) ie any action or action known at population level to have a net negative impact on society.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:28

MightyGoldBear · 28/10/2026 09:05

I think it's really complicated and different for everyone the reasons behind it. I think it's particularly really complicated for women. I never had trouble keeping a healthy weight before I had children. After children my body seems to be in such a high state of stress constantly that it stores fat easier and will not let go of much no matter how much I exercise or eat cleanly. Add in medical issues from having children and its not hard to see how anyone can spiral into putting on more and more weight and it becoming harder to be in a position to then get back to a healthy weight.

So it's really not the simple black and white less calories in for many people it's far more complex. I need a lifestyle that is compatible with me keeping a healthy weight,less stress more sleep. Children with additional needs a body with extra things to work around and factor In is not it. That's not to say its impossible but that's really irrelevant to ME and MY body right now.

Agreed. The principles are easy but their application can be very challenging at times!

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:35

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:21

But smokers are already financially penalised, quite drastically:

typical tax on a packet of cigarettes (£11 tobacco duty + £3 Vat)
assume 10 cigarettes per day
over a lifetime (c 40 years) that’s: £100k!

So they are financially penalised for making the decision to smoke. It could be argued more harshly than in my proposal as they’re penalised at point of sale and thus penalised independent of whether they come to harm.

Also, smoking has been reduced but not eradicated.

so perhaps the carrot has got it so far and the stick is needed to eradicate it?

So in the same way, certain foods and drinks could be heavily taxed like this. That would mean people paying the financial penalty at the point of buying the product to disincentivise them from making that choice. At that point it's a case of you can choose to pay to eat it or not - and if you do, the tax goes into the healthcare system. That's more ethical and humane than making them pay at the point of health treatment (for conditions that no one could ever definitively prove were caused by obesity!) when the choice is not between buying or not buying a product, but rather a choice between potential disability and/or death vs curative treatments - and the cost is not £100k collected over a lifetime but £100k upfront making it not a viable choice for many, many people.

Now there are flaws in this because no one needs to smoke in the way they do need to eat, and we don't want to price people out of being able to afford food at all. So some of the duty collected would need to subsidise other foods. And there would be a real issue for sufferers of ARFID and some autistic people, children in particular, who can only eat their safe foods which could fall into the highly taxed category. So there would still be problems to figure out. And all the other measures like support services, advertising bans etc would need to be in place alongside the tax. I'd include GLP-1s in the package of measures taken, just as smokers have had access to nicotine replacements which I'd say is a medical treatment. But that will take a lot longer due to the currently high cost of GLP-1 medication which of course a lot of obese people with the means to afford it are currently paying for privately with great success.

You're right that smoking hasn't been eradicated and I don't believe it's likely we'll entirely eradicate obesity either given that it has existed throughout history. What we're trying to reverse is the huge increase in obesity rates that have occurred more recently. The goal is to eradicate smoking altogether now though with the ascending age restrictions on buying tobacco which intends to ensure that ultimately no one will be able to buy it at all. Could it be possible that we will end up there with UPFs? It's not as clear cut as tobacco products but maybe yes.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:40

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:23

2nd point this was the topic of the thread. I’d apply the concept more broadly (smoking, cause car crash through reckless driving, someone who assaults someone and causes harm etc etc) ie any action or action known at population level to have a net negative impact on society.

Which would just be impossible to implement. Absolute chaos to determine who caused what, to what degree (very few health issues have one single cause), what constitutes a net negative to society, to what extent the patient was responsible - so for example, a survivor of child sexual abuse who became obese could argue that their obesity was caused or exacerbated by their experience of abuse (a documented phenomenon) and therefore they aren't culpable. The whole health system would absolutely collapse in confusion. You have to see that it's not remotely feasible?

And what about the first point as it's extremely pertinent: what happens to people who can't afford to pay?

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:43

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 09:01

You're not a scientist, are you? There's a world of difference in criminal justice and a scientific approach to evidence!

Wrong conclusion. Have a science masters from one of the top two unis in the country…. And used statistics on a professional basis early on in my career.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:46

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:40

Which would just be impossible to implement. Absolute chaos to determine who caused what, to what degree (very few health issues have one single cause), what constitutes a net negative to society, to what extent the patient was responsible - so for example, a survivor of child sexual abuse who became obese could argue that their obesity was caused or exacerbated by their experience of abuse (a documented phenomenon) and therefore they aren't culpable. The whole health system would absolutely collapse in confusion. You have to see that it's not remotely feasible?

And what about the first point as it's extremely pertinent: what happens to people who can't afford to pay?

The idea would be that before they get to the point of not being able to pay, they’ve taken corrective action to avoid the situation.

Should they somehow still end up in that situation then it’s beyond the scope of a MN post to determine how they could pay but there’s various options (savings / loans from banks or family members / could envisage a model of higher NI contributions going forward etc etc). Generally where there’s a will there’s a way.

I disagree re. it’d be difficult to apportion “blame”. The insurance industry is already familiar with doing so.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:51

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:35

So in the same way, certain foods and drinks could be heavily taxed like this. That would mean people paying the financial penalty at the point of buying the product to disincentivise them from making that choice. At that point it's a case of you can choose to pay to eat it or not - and if you do, the tax goes into the healthcare system. That's more ethical and humane than making them pay at the point of health treatment (for conditions that no one could ever definitively prove were caused by obesity!) when the choice is not between buying or not buying a product, but rather a choice between potential disability and/or death vs curative treatments - and the cost is not £100k collected over a lifetime but £100k upfront making it not a viable choice for many, many people.

Now there are flaws in this because no one needs to smoke in the way they do need to eat, and we don't want to price people out of being able to afford food at all. So some of the duty collected would need to subsidise other foods. And there would be a real issue for sufferers of ARFID and some autistic people, children in particular, who can only eat their safe foods which could fall into the highly taxed category. So there would still be problems to figure out. And all the other measures like support services, advertising bans etc would need to be in place alongside the tax. I'd include GLP-1s in the package of measures taken, just as smokers have had access to nicotine replacements which I'd say is a medical treatment. But that will take a lot longer due to the currently high cost of GLP-1 medication which of course a lot of obese people with the means to afford it are currently paying for privately with great success.

You're right that smoking hasn't been eradicated and I don't believe it's likely we'll entirely eradicate obesity either given that it has existed throughout history. What we're trying to reverse is the huge increase in obesity rates that have occurred more recently. The goal is to eradicate smoking altogether now though with the ascending age restrictions on buying tobacco which intends to ensure that ultimately no one will be able to buy it at all. Could it be possible that we will end up there with UPFs? It's not as clear cut as tobacco products but maybe yes.

Yes I think so re. UPFs albeit I have some reservations with that as it should be within someone’s right to have, for example, a frankfurter or ready meal, on occasion in full knowledge its doing them no good but knowing that overall it’s in moderation so very likely causing no harm.

Agreed they’re subtly different: smoking does no-one any good and has a clear cause whereas obesity can be the result of other illnesses making avoiding it by just eating healthily and moving more a next to impossible task.

I think fair to say that (and oddly where I think we’re both finally on the same page with something!), both are to be avoided and the goal isn’t to penalise folk who smoke / are obese but instead to avoid people suffering from smoking or being obese in the first place!

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:56

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:46

The idea would be that before they get to the point of not being able to pay, they’ve taken corrective action to avoid the situation.

Should they somehow still end up in that situation then it’s beyond the scope of a MN post to determine how they could pay but there’s various options (savings / loans from banks or family members / could envisage a model of higher NI contributions going forward etc etc). Generally where there’s a will there’s a way.

I disagree re. it’d be difficult to apportion “blame”. The insurance industry is already familiar with doing so.

I'm really not sure you understand insurance, honestly. You have demonstrated that you really don't get how it works in the thread already.

You definitely don't understand anything about health and that concluding that 'obesity is linked to cancer' does not mean you can point at a person and say their particular cancer was caused by their weight and only their weight. Nor can anyone conclusively disprove that.

You also haven't at any point answered whether a person who had consumed alcohol or processed meats would be ineligible for NHS cancer treatment.

And you can't handwave away the impossibility of people paying upfront for their treatment with 'where there's a will there's a way'. You are fully aware that people would die under this system. There is no avoiding that conclusion.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:59

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:51

Yes I think so re. UPFs albeit I have some reservations with that as it should be within someone’s right to have, for example, a frankfurter or ready meal, on occasion in full knowledge its doing them no good but knowing that overall it’s in moderation so very likely causing no harm.

Agreed they’re subtly different: smoking does no-one any good and has a clear cause whereas obesity can be the result of other illnesses making avoiding it by just eating healthily and moving more a next to impossible task.

I think fair to say that (and oddly where I think we’re both finally on the same page with something!), both are to be avoided and the goal isn’t to penalise folk who smoke / are obese but instead to avoid people suffering from smoking or being obese in the first place!

Someone's right to have a frankfurter!! What, and give themselves bowel cancer?! Heaven forbid!

(Tongue in cheek by the way)

I do want to prevent obesity, absolutely. I just want to do it in a way that works and isn't completely insane, totally impractical and wildly unethical.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:59

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:56

I'm really not sure you understand insurance, honestly. You have demonstrated that you really don't get how it works in the thread already.

You definitely don't understand anything about health and that concluding that 'obesity is linked to cancer' does not mean you can point at a person and say their particular cancer was caused by their weight and only their weight. Nor can anyone conclusively disprove that.

You also haven't at any point answered whether a person who had consumed alcohol or processed meats would be ineligible for NHS cancer treatment.

And you can't handwave away the impossibility of people paying upfront for their treatment with 'where there's a will there's a way'. You are fully aware that people would die under this system. There is no avoiding that conclusion.

It’s like speeding.

Not all speeding causes negative outcomes, but speeding is known to in general not be positive overall, so we disincentivise it (fines, penalty points etc).

So treat obesity the same way. Not all instances will lead to negative health outcomes but in general it does, so disincentivise it.

eh? I don’t understand how insurance work? The insurance industry wouldn’t “work” if they couldn’t apportion blame (in the case of car accidents etc).

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:00

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:56

I'm really not sure you understand insurance, honestly. You have demonstrated that you really don't get how it works in the thread already.

You definitely don't understand anything about health and that concluding that 'obesity is linked to cancer' does not mean you can point at a person and say their particular cancer was caused by their weight and only their weight. Nor can anyone conclusively disprove that.

You also haven't at any point answered whether a person who had consumed alcohol or processed meats would be ineligible for NHS cancer treatment.

And you can't handwave away the impossibility of people paying upfront for their treatment with 'where there's a will there's a way'. You are fully aware that people would die under this system. There is no avoiding that conclusion.

Some people might die but I’d like to think that more people might be saved through reduced levels of obesity. On a macro level that’s a positive vs current.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:02

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 09:56

I'm really not sure you understand insurance, honestly. You have demonstrated that you really don't get how it works in the thread already.

You definitely don't understand anything about health and that concluding that 'obesity is linked to cancer' does not mean you can point at a person and say their particular cancer was caused by their weight and only their weight. Nor can anyone conclusively disprove that.

You also haven't at any point answered whether a person who had consumed alcohol or processed meats would be ineligible for NHS cancer treatment.

And you can't handwave away the impossibility of people paying upfront for their treatment with 'where there's a will there's a way'. You are fully aware that people would die under this system. There is no avoiding that conclusion.

I should have added: the whole point is that it’s difficult to pay. That’s where the disincentive comes in, a real burning bridge to make people want to take action.

if it was easy to pay, it wouldn’t work.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:06

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:00

Some people might die but I’d like to think that more people might be saved through reduced levels of obesity. On a macro level that’s a positive vs current.

Well that's very unlikely. You have zero evidence of a policy like this working to change behaviour. There is no precedent for it. There are precedents for public health interventions that do work, but not ever something like this.

Look, people don't enjoy being obese. It's a really miserable experience. People don't get there deliberately. They are already experiencing a negative consequence for their behaviour. Telling them that if they get cancer one day they won't qualify for treatment won't stop them from becoming obese. Your suggestion is predicated on the idea that there are no negative consequences for obese people currently and so you need to introduce them but there are and you don't. Look at the uptake of GLP-1s: people do not want to be obese. Introducing threats will not reduce obesity. That's not how population level behaviour shifts work, not ever.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:07

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:02

I should have added: the whole point is that it’s difficult to pay. That’s where the disincentive comes in, a real burning bridge to make people want to take action.

if it was easy to pay, it wouldn’t work.

So please stop feigning outrage when people point out you are in favour of forcing obese people into destitution, illness and preventable deaths. Own the consequences of what you're proposing and don't take offence when people point them out.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:09

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:06

Well that's very unlikely. You have zero evidence of a policy like this working to change behaviour. There is no precedent for it. There are precedents for public health interventions that do work, but not ever something like this.

Look, people don't enjoy being obese. It's a really miserable experience. People don't get there deliberately. They are already experiencing a negative consequence for their behaviour. Telling them that if they get cancer one day they won't qualify for treatment won't stop them from becoming obese. Your suggestion is predicated on the idea that there are no negative consequences for obese people currently and so you need to introduce them but there are and you don't. Look at the uptake of GLP-1s: people do not want to be obese. Introducing threats will not reduce obesity. That's not how population level behaviour shifts work, not ever.

That’s the problem with only ever designing interventions on the back of data (the old Covid era “follow the data” fallacy). It constrains you to only doing what you’ve ever done as that’s what you’ve got evidence for and data of.

At some point, to progress, someone needs to do something different to what’s been done before.

We’d still be riding around on horses trying to figure out how to get them to go further and faster if Mr Benz and Mr Ford had only ever followed the data and evidence and not had the courage and insight to do something different…..

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:10

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:07

So please stop feigning outrage when people point out you are in favour of forcing obese people into destitution, illness and preventable deaths. Own the consequences of what you're proposing and don't take offence when people point them out.

But I don’t want to force them into that. I want a system that encourages behavioural change and avoids it. That’s the whole premise of the system.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:11

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 09:59

It’s like speeding.

Not all speeding causes negative outcomes, but speeding is known to in general not be positive overall, so we disincentivise it (fines, penalty points etc).

So treat obesity the same way. Not all instances will lead to negative health outcomes but in general it does, so disincentivise it.

eh? I don’t understand how insurance work? The insurance industry wouldn’t “work” if they couldn’t apportion blame (in the case of car accidents etc).

Not all alcohol and processed meat consumption cause negative effects but they are known to contribute towards cancer so anyone who has ever had a glass of wine or a ham sandwich will have to pay for their own treatment. Right?

(You seem to think that any alcohol consumption on holiday invalidates travel insurance claims which is not the case, but I'm assuming you'll apply the same principle to your health model)

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 10:16

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 10:09

That’s the problem with only ever designing interventions on the back of data (the old Covid era “follow the data” fallacy). It constrains you to only doing what you’ve ever done as that’s what you’ve got evidence for and data of.

At some point, to progress, someone needs to do something different to what’s been done before.

We’d still be riding around on horses trying to figure out how to get them to go further and faster if Mr Benz and Mr Ford had only ever followed the data and evidence and not had the courage and insight to do something different…..

GLP-1s are a new development. Very much based on data and expertise! They are also very effective. We can introduce new innovations that build off the body of scientific and medical evidence that has been built up and continues to develop. Rather than at random flinging out a half baked idea that makes no sense and could never be implemented and costs lives unnecessarily.