Please or to access all these features

Weight loss chat

A space to talk openly about weight loss journeys and challenges. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Is being Obese an illness?

803 replies

agel · 18/10/2026 16:15

Yes or No
Im really not trying to start an argument. I want to understand what people actually think/know/believe about this.

I am obese and am trying to gain some sort of control over my eating through therapy at the moment. I’ve tried diets and exercising that do work but long term I don’t seem to be able to change my lifestyle enough to keep the weight off. I hate living like this and how people treat me differently because of my size. My family don’t understand at all. My partner is not understanding and it’s seriously affecting our relationship in many ways. It seems unfair because I don’t feel I have much control over this. It’s actually very lonely being in this situation. I rarely mention the topic of my health or weight to others because pardon the pun it’s always the elephant in the room! But you can almost hear what people are thinking. I hate the judgemental looks and comments. I rarely go out now because of anxiety and panic attacks brought on by this situation.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
MoneyJo · 27/10/2026 15:43

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 15:32

Yet again you are demonstrating that you selectively miss the point. This is why I realised it’s pointless engaging with you. Enjoy the dog boards

Pot...kettle...

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 16:14

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 15:32

Yet again you are demonstrating that you selectively miss the point. This is why I realised it’s pointless engaging with you. Enjoy the dog boards

Disagreeing with a point doesn't mean I missed it. I got the point loud and clear.

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 19:06

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 13:58

Thanks for your contributions and debating with good intent and spirit rather than getting caught up in mud slinging and emotions - makes a pleasant change and good to see folk that can consider perspectives outside the box by suspending judgement - thanks!

You're welcome :) I enjoyed hearing your views. Good luck with your running!
There's so much toxicity online, including in this thread, it can be near impossible to get a proper debate going. I mean it's rarely accomplished but I think our interactions were a good example of being able to hold very different views and maintain respect and kindness.

Charlenedickens · 27/10/2026 19:11

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 19:06

You're welcome :) I enjoyed hearing your views. Good luck with your running!
There's so much toxicity online, including in this thread, it can be near impossible to get a proper debate going. I mean it's rarely accomplished but I think our interactions were a good example of being able to hold very different views and maintain respect and kindness.

Seriously ?

ExpectMore · 27/10/2026 20:37

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 19:06

You're welcome :) I enjoyed hearing your views. Good luck with your running!
There's so much toxicity online, including in this thread, it can be near impossible to get a proper debate going. I mean it's rarely accomplished but I think our interactions were a good example of being able to hold very different views and maintain respect and kindness.

Agreed and thank you!

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 21:22

DeliaPith321 · 27/10/2026 19:06

You're welcome :) I enjoyed hearing your views. Good luck with your running!
There's so much toxicity online, including in this thread, it can be near impossible to get a proper debate going. I mean it's rarely accomplished but I think our interactions were a good example of being able to hold very different views and maintain respect and kindness.

There are times when agreeing to disagree is really worthwhile and laudable. But there are some views which are so poorly thought out, so badly argued and most importantly so deeply abhorrent that they should make anyone recoil. I can see that you're interested in what makes a person think such terrible things and that your work in criminology has made you accustomed to the depths of darkness in the human soul. But I'm really not sure that all views should be afforded respect, and I do think when someone holds human life in such slight regard and advocates for such pointless cruelty that it's very hard to see where you're coming from on this, particularly when your attempts to probe further were so completely ignored.

Charlenedickens · 27/10/2026 21:24

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 21:22

There are times when agreeing to disagree is really worthwhile and laudable. But there are some views which are so poorly thought out, so badly argued and most importantly so deeply abhorrent that they should make anyone recoil. I can see that you're interested in what makes a person think such terrible things and that your work in criminology has made you accustomed to the depths of darkness in the human soul. But I'm really not sure that all views should be afforded respect, and I do think when someone holds human life in such slight regard and advocates for such pointless cruelty that it's very hard to see where you're coming from on this, particularly when your attempts to probe further were so completely ignored.

Well written.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 04:25

OrangeBlaze · 27/10/2026 21:22

There are times when agreeing to disagree is really worthwhile and laudable. But there are some views which are so poorly thought out, so badly argued and most importantly so deeply abhorrent that they should make anyone recoil. I can see that you're interested in what makes a person think such terrible things and that your work in criminology has made you accustomed to the depths of darkness in the human soul. But I'm really not sure that all views should be afforded respect, and I do think when someone holds human life in such slight regard and advocates for such pointless cruelty that it's very hard to see where you're coming from on this, particularly when your attempts to probe further were so completely ignored.

“Liberal Fascism” Will I suspect interest you given you clearly believe that only views you agree with should be afforded respect…. 🙄

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 05:26

Used to weigh 163kg at 5 foot 3 so I hope you will view this as a post that is sincere through experience.

Obesity is not an illness. Obesity is a lifetime of bad habits and bad choices and is brought on by lack of education, often promoted by food industries, the government etc and the consequences of those result in stigma by the population where the 'habits and choices' do not have the same reach or effect.

It is not a coincidence that people from a lower income bracket are more likely to be obese. Food choice is restricted and education about processed foods, and their short and long term effects, varies. Some will say 'eat in moderation' and now some will say that you shouldn't eat any at all.

I now weigh 50kg. The only way I accomplished this was calorie restriction and removing processed foods. I have maintained this weight loss for 15+ years and, by all accounts, a very rare example of someone who has achieved this without medicine or surgery and not gained any back.

You have to accept that your eating is disordered and not serving your body. You have to forget people who tell you it's okay to eat cake or it's not okay. Only you know how eating cake affects you e.g. sets off a binge, craving for other sweets or nothing at all.

You are not diseased or disabled. Obesity is in the mind but it's not an illness but a mindset. Get rid of all of the white noise, stop giving in when you want to and justifying it by all the contradicting 'advice' and give yourself a chance to succeed without victimising yourself which will only stagnate you or set you back.

You can do it but it's hard work and you have to want to stop blaming anyone, including yourself, and just get it done.

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 07:22

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 05:26

Used to weigh 163kg at 5 foot 3 so I hope you will view this as a post that is sincere through experience.

Obesity is not an illness. Obesity is a lifetime of bad habits and bad choices and is brought on by lack of education, often promoted by food industries, the government etc and the consequences of those result in stigma by the population where the 'habits and choices' do not have the same reach or effect.

It is not a coincidence that people from a lower income bracket are more likely to be obese. Food choice is restricted and education about processed foods, and their short and long term effects, varies. Some will say 'eat in moderation' and now some will say that you shouldn't eat any at all.

I now weigh 50kg. The only way I accomplished this was calorie restriction and removing processed foods. I have maintained this weight loss for 15+ years and, by all accounts, a very rare example of someone who has achieved this without medicine or surgery and not gained any back.

You have to accept that your eating is disordered and not serving your body. You have to forget people who tell you it's okay to eat cake or it's not okay. Only you know how eating cake affects you e.g. sets off a binge, craving for other sweets or nothing at all.

You are not diseased or disabled. Obesity is in the mind but it's not an illness but a mindset. Get rid of all of the white noise, stop giving in when you want to and justifying it by all the contradicting 'advice' and give yourself a chance to succeed without victimising yourself which will only stagnate you or set you back.

You can do it but it's hard work and you have to want to stop blaming anyone, including yourself, and just get it done.

This is interesting however your experience isn't everyone's experience.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:00

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 04:25

“Liberal Fascism” Will I suspect interest you given you clearly believe that only views you agree with should be afforded respect…. 🙄

Edited

Only views I agree with? No, not at all. There are plenty of views I disagree with that I can respect. But I don't respect eg Andrew Tate's view of women. I don't respect the views of neo-Nazis who consider the concentration camps the correct way to deal with Jewish people, the disabled, homosexuals etc. Those are not views that deserve anyone's respect, wouldn't you agree?

And those are views which sit at the far end of a spectrum that begins with devaluing certain groups of people. They are the final product of a viewpoint that says 'x group does not deserve the same rights as everyone else because they are inferior'. An example of that kind of viewpoint would be someone stating that anyone with a BMI over 30 should be denied healthcare. And to clarify my use of the phrase 'denied healthcare', the average salary in the UK is about £40k and that means a considerable amount of people earn less. From their salary, people are already paying tax towards the NHS and if they aren't then it's because they don't earn enough to pay tax. So there will be very few people who can afford to pay out of pocket for cancer treatment (which their taxes have already contributed towards!) and therefore those people would get sicker, suffer greatly and die if told they had to pay or get out of hospital. So when you say you would charge obese people, what you mean in practice is let them die painful and undignified and terrifying deaths.

Now, I don't think that's a proposal that deserves respect. And not one other person on the thread could find any merit in it whatsoever. But I've been on MN for almost twenty years as I mentioned, and that's because I do like to debate - that's why I'm on a discussion forum! I've been here since Ye Olde Breastfeeding vs Formula debates (you might have enjoyed those!) all the way through Brexit and Covid and I've debated with lots of people whose views I don't agree with. But in order for those discussions to function, people do have to be willing to answer questions. And you ignored almost every single question posed to you about your system. There is no useful debate to be had when one poster is copying and pasting lengthy screeds from ChatGPT and another is refusing to engage with 99% of questions asked of them. It does become rather frustrating. It really isn't a demonstration of 'kind and respectful debate'!

I do think you should understand that what you suggested is something the majority of people will find abhorrent. If I was having a coffee with a new acquaintance and they declared that they felt fat people deserved to die of cancer because they brought it on themselves (the logical conclusion of your proposal) then I am fairly sure I would just get up and walk out. Most people would distance themselves! And on the other hand, I do think there is a value in persevering and one point that Delia made which I really do agree with is the importance of finding connection and common ground across the political spectrum and reaching out to people who lack empathy in the hope of nurturing the seeds of it within them. When we ostracise and condemn people for shocking and profoundly unethical viewpoints, of course we run the risk of driving them further away into radicalisation and that's probably how we end up with the Tates and the neo-Nazis of this world. So I do see the value of trying, but all of us have our limits and I think when the person we're talking to is either unwilling or unable to answer any questions or engage in any meaningful way then it just gets too frustrating to continue.

I'd recommend the episode of If Books Could Kill which covers Liberal Fascism by the way - it's very funny and extremely informative!

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:01

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 05:26

Used to weigh 163kg at 5 foot 3 so I hope you will view this as a post that is sincere through experience.

Obesity is not an illness. Obesity is a lifetime of bad habits and bad choices and is brought on by lack of education, often promoted by food industries, the government etc and the consequences of those result in stigma by the population where the 'habits and choices' do not have the same reach or effect.

It is not a coincidence that people from a lower income bracket are more likely to be obese. Food choice is restricted and education about processed foods, and their short and long term effects, varies. Some will say 'eat in moderation' and now some will say that you shouldn't eat any at all.

I now weigh 50kg. The only way I accomplished this was calorie restriction and removing processed foods. I have maintained this weight loss for 15+ years and, by all accounts, a very rare example of someone who has achieved this without medicine or surgery and not gained any back.

You have to accept that your eating is disordered and not serving your body. You have to forget people who tell you it's okay to eat cake or it's not okay. Only you know how eating cake affects you e.g. sets off a binge, craving for other sweets or nothing at all.

You are not diseased or disabled. Obesity is in the mind but it's not an illness but a mindset. Get rid of all of the white noise, stop giving in when you want to and justifying it by all the contradicting 'advice' and give yourself a chance to succeed without victimising yourself which will only stagnate you or set you back.

You can do it but it's hard work and you have to want to stop blaming anyone, including yourself, and just get it done.

Thanks for sharing your story and well done on your weight loss (and mindset that drove it!), that’s a hell of an achievement that you should be very proud of.

it shows what’s possible when people take ownership and stop blaming others or the system.

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 08:04

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 07:22

This is interesting however your experience isn't everyone's experience.

Your view is also interesting and I didn't suggest that my experience was everyone's.

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 08:04

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:01

Thanks for sharing your story and well done on your weight loss (and mindset that drove it!), that’s a hell of an achievement that you should be very proud of.

it shows what’s possible when people take ownership and stop blaming others or the system.

As we know, this is one person's experience and not everyone's. You can't base evidence on a sample of N equals 1.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:08

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:00

Only views I agree with? No, not at all. There are plenty of views I disagree with that I can respect. But I don't respect eg Andrew Tate's view of women. I don't respect the views of neo-Nazis who consider the concentration camps the correct way to deal with Jewish people, the disabled, homosexuals etc. Those are not views that deserve anyone's respect, wouldn't you agree?

And those are views which sit at the far end of a spectrum that begins with devaluing certain groups of people. They are the final product of a viewpoint that says 'x group does not deserve the same rights as everyone else because they are inferior'. An example of that kind of viewpoint would be someone stating that anyone with a BMI over 30 should be denied healthcare. And to clarify my use of the phrase 'denied healthcare', the average salary in the UK is about £40k and that means a considerable amount of people earn less. From their salary, people are already paying tax towards the NHS and if they aren't then it's because they don't earn enough to pay tax. So there will be very few people who can afford to pay out of pocket for cancer treatment (which their taxes have already contributed towards!) and therefore those people would get sicker, suffer greatly and die if told they had to pay or get out of hospital. So when you say you would charge obese people, what you mean in practice is let them die painful and undignified and terrifying deaths.

Now, I don't think that's a proposal that deserves respect. And not one other person on the thread could find any merit in it whatsoever. But I've been on MN for almost twenty years as I mentioned, and that's because I do like to debate - that's why I'm on a discussion forum! I've been here since Ye Olde Breastfeeding vs Formula debates (you might have enjoyed those!) all the way through Brexit and Covid and I've debated with lots of people whose views I don't agree with. But in order for those discussions to function, people do have to be willing to answer questions. And you ignored almost every single question posed to you about your system. There is no useful debate to be had when one poster is copying and pasting lengthy screeds from ChatGPT and another is refusing to engage with 99% of questions asked of them. It does become rather frustrating. It really isn't a demonstration of 'kind and respectful debate'!

I do think you should understand that what you suggested is something the majority of people will find abhorrent. If I was having a coffee with a new acquaintance and they declared that they felt fat people deserved to die of cancer because they brought it on themselves (the logical conclusion of your proposal) then I am fairly sure I would just get up and walk out. Most people would distance themselves! And on the other hand, I do think there is a value in persevering and one point that Delia made which I really do agree with is the importance of finding connection and common ground across the political spectrum and reaching out to people who lack empathy in the hope of nurturing the seeds of it within them. When we ostracise and condemn people for shocking and profoundly unethical viewpoints, of course we run the risk of driving them further away into radicalisation and that's probably how we end up with the Tates and the neo-Nazis of this world. So I do see the value of trying, but all of us have our limits and I think when the person we're talking to is either unwilling or unable to answer any questions or engage in any meaningful way then it just gets too frustrating to continue.

I'd recommend the episode of If Books Could Kill which covers Liberal Fascism by the way - it's very funny and extremely informative!

Your hyperbole is incredible. Such a reaction to a consideration of charging for medical care. Something that is common place. But yes, “abhorrent” 🙄

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:18

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:00

Only views I agree with? No, not at all. There are plenty of views I disagree with that I can respect. But I don't respect eg Andrew Tate's view of women. I don't respect the views of neo-Nazis who consider the concentration camps the correct way to deal with Jewish people, the disabled, homosexuals etc. Those are not views that deserve anyone's respect, wouldn't you agree?

And those are views which sit at the far end of a spectrum that begins with devaluing certain groups of people. They are the final product of a viewpoint that says 'x group does not deserve the same rights as everyone else because they are inferior'. An example of that kind of viewpoint would be someone stating that anyone with a BMI over 30 should be denied healthcare. And to clarify my use of the phrase 'denied healthcare', the average salary in the UK is about £40k and that means a considerable amount of people earn less. From their salary, people are already paying tax towards the NHS and if they aren't then it's because they don't earn enough to pay tax. So there will be very few people who can afford to pay out of pocket for cancer treatment (which their taxes have already contributed towards!) and therefore those people would get sicker, suffer greatly and die if told they had to pay or get out of hospital. So when you say you would charge obese people, what you mean in practice is let them die painful and undignified and terrifying deaths.

Now, I don't think that's a proposal that deserves respect. And not one other person on the thread could find any merit in it whatsoever. But I've been on MN for almost twenty years as I mentioned, and that's because I do like to debate - that's why I'm on a discussion forum! I've been here since Ye Olde Breastfeeding vs Formula debates (you might have enjoyed those!) all the way through Brexit and Covid and I've debated with lots of people whose views I don't agree with. But in order for those discussions to function, people do have to be willing to answer questions. And you ignored almost every single question posed to you about your system. There is no useful debate to be had when one poster is copying and pasting lengthy screeds from ChatGPT and another is refusing to engage with 99% of questions asked of them. It does become rather frustrating. It really isn't a demonstration of 'kind and respectful debate'!

I do think you should understand that what you suggested is something the majority of people will find abhorrent. If I was having a coffee with a new acquaintance and they declared that they felt fat people deserved to die of cancer because they brought it on themselves (the logical conclusion of your proposal) then I am fairly sure I would just get up and walk out. Most people would distance themselves! And on the other hand, I do think there is a value in persevering and one point that Delia made which I really do agree with is the importance of finding connection and common ground across the political spectrum and reaching out to people who lack empathy in the hope of nurturing the seeds of it within them. When we ostracise and condemn people for shocking and profoundly unethical viewpoints, of course we run the risk of driving them further away into radicalisation and that's probably how we end up with the Tates and the neo-Nazis of this world. So I do see the value of trying, but all of us have our limits and I think when the person we're talking to is either unwilling or unable to answer any questions or engage in any meaningful way then it just gets too frustrating to continue.

I'd recommend the episode of If Books Could Kill which covers Liberal Fascism by the way - it's very funny and extremely informative!

I should have added to my previous: in your apparent anger you’re also making up things I never said and/or attributing your extrapolation incorrectly to me. It’s incorrect and offensive of you to do so.

eg “deserved to die of cancer”…

….what a load of offensive rubbish.

For the record, whilst I disagree with many, I will always agree with and defend their right to hold their views. To do otherwise is dangerous: see some of the many examples you cite yourself.

Also, I didn’t respond to each and every one of your questions as the answers had either already been provided or were self evident and I’m not in the habit of wasting my time just because you can’t keep up or apply some critical thought.

Eg you asked various permutations of “would a victim in a car crash have to pay” when clearly the answer was self evidently no given the basis of the proposal.

Anyway, I respect you have a different opinion to mine, that’s what makes the world great after all, but I can’t continue to waste time engaging with you so I’ll do much harder at taking my own medicine and avoid doing so :)

Have a good day

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:19

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:08

Your hyperbole is incredible. Such a reaction to a consideration of charging for medical care. Something that is common place. But yes, “abhorrent” 🙄

It's not commonplace to charge any obese person for all healthcare that could in any way be linked to obesity. It's absurd and it isn't done anywhere. It's not how the NHS works and it isn't how health insurance models in other countries work. It isn't even how it works in the States, which operates a deeply punitive and unfair system which generates extremely poor health outcomes that should put a rich country to shame and causes the bankruptcy, destitution, suffering and unnecessary deaths of far too many of its citizens every year.

More importantly than any of that, you really can't explain why the extremely flawed and unworkable system you propose is better than trying models of public health intervention that actually have been used successfully to change public behaviour around eg smoking, vaccinations and sunscreen use to improve health outcomes without penalising individuals. I do think it's quite inexplicable that you prefer to punish individuals than effect systemic change not least because the latter is so much more likely to achieve the desired outcome - if the desired outcome is actually a reduction in obesity rates as opposed to a humiliation of and punishment of fat people.

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:20

MoneyJo · 28/10/2026 08:04

As we know, this is one person's experience and not everyone's. You can't base evidence on a sample of N equals 1.

you can indeed base evidence on a sample size of N=1.

Ask the many criminals who are sat behind bars as a result of one piece of evidence.

I think what you mean is you can’t draw statistical conclusions but that’s irrelevant.

InfoSecInTheCity · 28/10/2026 08:26

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 05:26

Used to weigh 163kg at 5 foot 3 so I hope you will view this as a post that is sincere through experience.

Obesity is not an illness. Obesity is a lifetime of bad habits and bad choices and is brought on by lack of education, often promoted by food industries, the government etc and the consequences of those result in stigma by the population where the 'habits and choices' do not have the same reach or effect.

It is not a coincidence that people from a lower income bracket are more likely to be obese. Food choice is restricted and education about processed foods, and their short and long term effects, varies. Some will say 'eat in moderation' and now some will say that you shouldn't eat any at all.

I now weigh 50kg. The only way I accomplished this was calorie restriction and removing processed foods. I have maintained this weight loss for 15+ years and, by all accounts, a very rare example of someone who has achieved this without medicine or surgery and not gained any back.

You have to accept that your eating is disordered and not serving your body. You have to forget people who tell you it's okay to eat cake or it's not okay. Only you know how eating cake affects you e.g. sets off a binge, craving for other sweets or nothing at all.

You are not diseased or disabled. Obesity is in the mind but it's not an illness but a mindset. Get rid of all of the white noise, stop giving in when you want to and justifying it by all the contradicting 'advice' and give yourself a chance to succeed without victimising yourself which will only stagnate you or set you back.

You can do it but it's hard work and you have to want to stop blaming anyone, including yourself, and just get it done.

I was obese at 11 yo, no one else in my family was and my mum made good healthy homemade well balanced meals but I just kept gaining weight.

when I was 30 and had been TTC for 2 years Drs finally took my concerns about my hormone levels seriously and found I had insulin resistant PCOS.

They refused any actual medical help telling me to just eat less and move more.

I finally got pregnant and was diagnosed with gestational diabetes. Miraculously giving me metformin and insulin made the weight drop off and at the end of my pregnancy I weighed 2 stone less than at the start.

As soon as the pregnancy was over so was the medication because the assumption (without any testing) is that you are cured as soon as you deliver.

A few years later I ended up in A&E diagnosed with diabetes and again put on metformin and insulin.

Since then, with medication that regulated my blood sugar I have lost 10 stone and have a healthy BMI of 22.

Sometimes it’s a medical issue.

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:28

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:18

I should have added to my previous: in your apparent anger you’re also making up things I never said and/or attributing your extrapolation incorrectly to me. It’s incorrect and offensive of you to do so.

eg “deserved to die of cancer”…

….what a load of offensive rubbish.

For the record, whilst I disagree with many, I will always agree with and defend their right to hold their views. To do otherwise is dangerous: see some of the many examples you cite yourself.

Also, I didn’t respond to each and every one of your questions as the answers had either already been provided or were self evident and I’m not in the habit of wasting my time just because you can’t keep up or apply some critical thought.

Eg you asked various permutations of “would a victim in a car crash have to pay” when clearly the answer was self evidently no given the basis of the proposal.

Anyway, I respect you have a different opinion to mine, that’s what makes the world great after all, but I can’t continue to waste time engaging with you so I’ll do much harder at taking my own medicine and avoid doing so :)

Have a good day

Ah, I cross-posted. No, it wasn't just my questions you ignored, it was everyone's. I didn't bring up car crashes except to say that presumably they were exempt, but I did bring up other 'risky' behaviour eg eating processed meats and drinking alcohol. But the answers I was most interested in were relating to systemic change vs individual punishment as I outlined above. Nothing to do with car crashes, apparently impossible for you to answer nonetheless.

I'm surprised that you keep refuting the obvious consequences of your plan as 'hyperbole' - clearly you must know that if you charged fat people the full cost of cancer treatment, a lot of fat people would die of cancer? How could that outcome be avoided?

The stance of 'I disagree with what you say but defend your right to say it' is interesting. I can agree with the laudable principle there, but then I also support the prohibition of hate speech. I cannot defend the right of Andrew Tate to go online and tell teenage boys and men that women are worthless sluts who should be pimped out, raped and beaten. There is a point at which some things become unacceptable to say.

Fine if you don't answer any further, we both have decided to disengage but keep coming back and in the end one of us has to exercise the willpower to actually do it 🤣

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:29

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:19

It's not commonplace to charge any obese person for all healthcare that could in any way be linked to obesity. It's absurd and it isn't done anywhere. It's not how the NHS works and it isn't how health insurance models in other countries work. It isn't even how it works in the States, which operates a deeply punitive and unfair system which generates extremely poor health outcomes that should put a rich country to shame and causes the bankruptcy, destitution, suffering and unnecessary deaths of far too many of its citizens every year.

More importantly than any of that, you really can't explain why the extremely flawed and unworkable system you propose is better than trying models of public health intervention that actually have been used successfully to change public behaviour around eg smoking, vaccinations and sunscreen use to improve health outcomes without penalising individuals. I do think it's quite inexplicable that you prefer to punish individuals than effect systemic change not least because the latter is so much more likely to achieve the desired outcome - if the desired outcome is actually a reduction in obesity rates as opposed to a humiliation of and punishment of fat people.

Go look up NHS dental care model and you might be surprised to see an example of where clinically necessary care is provided on a fee basis, incentivising good dental hygiene and care. You might be amazed to find an analagous example of the concept I’ve been proposing so close to home 😉

Best make sure you’re sat down and have stacks of blank letters ready to be drafted with made up claims about the abhorrent NHS policies o be sent to NHS England and your local mp before you do any googling as I can guess your reaction…

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:38

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:29

Go look up NHS dental care model and you might be surprised to see an example of where clinically necessary care is provided on a fee basis, incentivising good dental hygiene and care. You might be amazed to find an analagous example of the concept I’ve been proposing so close to home 😉

Best make sure you’re sat down and have stacks of blank letters ready to be drafted with made up claims about the abhorrent NHS policies o be sent to NHS England and your local mp before you do any googling as I can guess your reaction…

It's not analogous to what you're suggesting, and I do note that you're still steadfastly avoiding the question about other public health intervention models!

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:41

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:38

It's not analogous to what you're suggesting, and I do note that you're still steadfastly avoiding the question about other public health intervention models!

Ok. I’ll give you that one…: I’d implement them in parallel. Stick and carrot.

StompingGround · 28/10/2026 08:45

InfoSecInTheCity · 28/10/2026 08:26

I was obese at 11 yo, no one else in my family was and my mum made good healthy homemade well balanced meals but I just kept gaining weight.

when I was 30 and had been TTC for 2 years Drs finally took my concerns about my hormone levels seriously and found I had insulin resistant PCOS.

They refused any actual medical help telling me to just eat less and move more.

I finally got pregnant and was diagnosed with gestational diabetes. Miraculously giving me metformin and insulin made the weight drop off and at the end of my pregnancy I weighed 2 stone less than at the start.

As soon as the pregnancy was over so was the medication because the assumption (without any testing) is that you are cured as soon as you deliver.

A few years later I ended up in A&E diagnosed with diabetes and again put on metformin and insulin.

Since then, with medication that regulated my blood sugar I have lost 10 stone and have a healthy BMI of 22.

Sometimes it’s a medical issue.

Once it's established that it is or isn't, it gets addressed and then weight loss happens. Speculation is not justification for inaction. I'm glad you have got it sorted out and are healthy!

OrangeBlaze · 28/10/2026 08:48

ExpectMore · 28/10/2026 08:41

Ok. I’ll give you that one…: I’d implement them in parallel. Stick and carrot.

But the stick isn't necessary. We've agreed on this thread already that smoking rates have dramatically declined. That's without charging smokers for the treatment of lung cancer/respiratory problems etc. And the causal effect is much easier to draw there than it is between obesity and other health conditions. But of course financially penalising smokers in this way wasn't needed - individual behaviour and subsequent health outcomes were improved via better regulation of corporations, freely accessible support systems, use of bans and restrictions and concerted information campaigns. I think we should start there before we hand out bills to cancer patients.