Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Sister furious. How would a normal person handle this?

167 replies

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 12:58

stiffan · 09/11/2026 11:15

this conversation happens a lot. My sister thrives in chaos and pointing out wrong doings. I wish i had new ways of responding to shut down the conversation without being blocked.

And it's pretty exhausting to go 'i understand you feel frustrated that Friend A is bringing in a new person without your permission, that must feel jarring to feel like you are not the most important person in the room and other people make decisions without your permission. I understand that must be frustrating for you to not be in charge. ...' (I am being sarcastic i would never dare send that!)

I feel i have to validate like that every time but maybe i have to keep at it to keep the peace.

I feel like if i validate i encourage the misery a bit and more misery like this will follow. My sister is autistic, so am I (so i doubt i am handling this well as i too say the wrong thing). She struggles a lot with life and feels so out of control that i think she tries to control what she can and gets very overwhelmed when it doesn't go to plan.

If i get blocked im blocked from my nieces for two weeks and we facetime 1/2 times a week which is a shame so i want to avoid getting blocked.

You’ve answered your own question there though, on how to validate her feelings nicely. You do understand that she dislikes change and feels she’s lost control of her life when external change happens. What’s stopping you from saying that to her?

Then noting that this is a change, it’s not within her power to control who A is seeing, so she’s going to have to live with the discomfort temporarily.

But, 7/8 people in the group remain the same and you’re all going to get to know new person, so the change is limited and temporary.

It reads as though for you, engaging in any discussion about feelings is uncomfortable and you respond with frustration and avoidance. Maybe you could acknowledge that?

Are you able to push through the discomfort of having a discussion about feelings with her from time to time? Or do you need to tell her that for you, that is a discomfort too far? (while she has no choice but to face her discomfort in the next group outing, if she wants to stay part of the group).

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 13:13

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 09/11/2026 07:52

Bit of punishment works wonders on people like OPs sister.

I would argue it just makes them feel more of a victim.

stiffan · 09/11/2026 13:13

@lottiegarbanzo my sister is difficult and i walk on egg shells around her. When we get on it's really great and she is a very lovely, generous person. Validating her in a way encourages more miserable thinking like this which i don't want to do. I think she enjoys it in a way and it keeps it enjoyable for her.

OP posts:
BeCosyOliveScroller · 09/11/2026 13:30

I’m really fed up of when people caveat somebody being a dick by saying ‘well, they are autistic…’.
no. They’re autistic. They’re also a dick. Two separate things.

lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 13:34

stiffan · 09/11/2026 13:13

@lottiegarbanzo my sister is difficult and i walk on egg shells around her. When we get on it's really great and she is a very lovely, generous person. Validating her in a way encourages more miserable thinking like this which i don't want to do. I think she enjoys it in a way and it keeps it enjoyable for her.

The way I’m suggesting you acknowledge / validate her experience, based on your own insight, is to focus on her internal emotional experience.

Not on external causes in a way that suggests she should be able to control those, or that other people are at fault for failing to follow her script.

That isn’t escalating drama. Is it feeding her misery? Depends. Does she recognise that she has internal difficulties with change and lack of control? That this is a problem for her? Something she might want to work on changing? Or does she enjoy wallowing in self-pity and want you to support that?

Can you help her towards recognition of a problem and desire to change? Do you think you’re doing that by dismissIng her perspective? I don’t think that’s working.

But, you may well not be the person who can help her. So just say that. You’re not the patient, empathetic type, she’d be better off talking to someone else.

TaptheCap · 09/11/2026 13:37

BeCosyOliveScroller · 09/11/2026 13:30

I’m really fed up of when people caveat somebody being a dick by saying ‘well, they are autistic…’.
no. They’re autistic. They’re also a dick. Two separate things.

Exactly!

I would (as I said up thread) struggle with the change in dynamic, familiarity with how the group interact etc. but I'm aware I'll struggle and put in strategies to mitigate that. I don't make it other people's problem or try and insist that the change doesn't happen.

I do appreciate when my good friends recognise I find change hard but only so much as "this might be hard for you" or "feel free to talk about anything I can do to help" sort of way. Not a "keep everything the same" thing.

stiffan · 09/11/2026 14:18

my sister takes great pride in being reasonable. So when she learned about boundaries she put them up left right and centre as to her it was reasonable.

When i taught her about how she was misusing boundaries she changed and started using them properly.

She believes the only right way to deal with someone upset is to validate their feelings.

She also believes it is reasonable to be upset. So she will be upset alot.

Oh and Mark was lovely, we all met him Saturday and you would never have guessed my sister and i had this spat 3 days before. She had a long chat about a Rugby match they both watched.

OP posts:
Ilovelifeverymuch · 09/11/2026 14:28

stiffan · 09/11/2026 13:13

@lottiegarbanzo my sister is difficult and i walk on egg shells around her. When we get on it's really great and she is a very lovely, generous person. Validating her in a way encourages more miserable thinking like this which i don't want to do. I think she enjoys it in a way and it keeps it enjoyable for her.

I get that you don't want to lose access to your niece and all but unfortunately you don't have control over how she acts and behaves you and only control your actions.

You need to make peace with the fact that you have to deal with loss or access when she is throwing her tantrums or make the decision to continue to pander to her. Unfortunately the more you pander to people like her the more they take the piss and never learn.

And you need to reframe it as she is the one depriving her kids from a proper relationship with their aunty.

Other wise you need to swallow it and continue to walk on egg shells around her and pander to her to keep her happy.

Answer this question though, what has all your pandering over the years achieved? Had she learnt that her behaviour is wrong and she needs to change or has it made her more entrenched in her ways and demands? Constantly finding more and more things to be upset about.

And saying when you get along it's all nice is like a woman saying when her husband isn't emotionally abusing her or using the silent treatment as control he is amazinggggggggg!!!! No he is not, he is an abuser. Same with your sister

Does she do this with everyone in your family as well or just you?

lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 14:34

stiffan · 09/11/2026 14:18

my sister takes great pride in being reasonable. So when she learned about boundaries she put them up left right and centre as to her it was reasonable.

When i taught her about how she was misusing boundaries she changed and started using them properly.

She believes the only right way to deal with someone upset is to validate their feelings.

She also believes it is reasonable to be upset. So she will be upset alot.

Oh and Mark was lovely, we all met him Saturday and you would never have guessed my sister and i had this spat 3 days before. She had a long chat about a Rugby match they both watched.

Maybe time to teach her about over-sharing. And reciprocity (of the validation).

Great that everyone got on though!

Whatisitsailor · 10/11/2026 18:43

I'm quite blunt so I would tell her to either suck it up or not bother coming along

She's being childish and ridiculous

Dontlletmedownbruce · 10/11/2026 18:55

I agree with your sister that it does completely change the dynamics and friend A shouldn't just bring a date without checking first if it was OK. That said it would probably be unreasonable to say no but a heads up is important. We have a group of 6 that do this regularly and one year a pal invited an extra along, her friend and an acquaintance of mine that I don't really like but she doesn't know that. I hated our night out and probably wouldn't have gone again with the extra as I didn't want to spend time with her. So I do get it. However her behaviour is ridiculous and immature

JJWT · 10/11/2026 19:23

I'm so glad I'm old! This sounds exhausting and tedious. Why have people become so whiny and needy? Literally a non-issue. I'm afraid if I was her sibling I'd be telling her she's pathetic!! Life's too short.

Laura95167 · 10/11/2026 20:50

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

"I feel I might not like my friends new BF because I liked her old one, so she should as my permission to introduce him to some mutual frineds" isnt an actual feelings, its an entitled prejudice.

Of course you arent obliged to validate this "feeling".

Not clear why she needs support for this

Littleorangeonaplate · 10/11/2026 21:14

Your sister sounds a trifle narcissistic. My DB would be the same. He would control me by blocking me. Eventually I have to apologise by using a new email,address. I’ve learned to manage the situation by not expressing an opinion on many things so that he has no opportunity to get on his “high horse” about something totally trivial,that he happens to have a differing opinion on.

Rockpunkdisco · 11/11/2026 18:30

It's sad when couples break up and you liked the partner but it doesn't mean you can't give a new one a chance.

Cherrysoup · 16/11/2026 13:07

stiffan · 09/11/2026 14:18

my sister takes great pride in being reasonable. So when she learned about boundaries she put them up left right and centre as to her it was reasonable.

When i taught her about how she was misusing boundaries she changed and started using them properly.

She believes the only right way to deal with someone upset is to validate their feelings.

She also believes it is reasonable to be upset. So she will be upset alot.

Oh and Mark was lovely, we all met him Saturday and you would never have guessed my sister and i had this spat 3 days before. She had a long chat about a Rugby match they both watched.

Did she unblock you prior to the dinner? Did anyone else care that friend was bringing a new bloke?

Arlanymor · 16/11/2026 13:17

I imagine that Friend A thought that she knew the others in the group so well and that they were such close friends that they would be happy for her and interested in meeting her new partner, hence why she told people in advance that she would be bringing him rather than feeling that she needed to ask anyone’s permission. Guess she’ll have to go up into the loft and get her sackcloth and ashes out…

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread