Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Sister furious. How would a normal person handle this?

167 replies

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

OP posts:
Janetwin · 09/11/2026 07:10

HeddaGarbled · 09/11/2026 01:14

Actually, I’m with your sister. This is an established group of couples. The friend is trying to insert her new boyfriend way too quickly, expecting you to erase all memory of someone who was a member of your friendship group as if he didn’t exist. Your sister seems to be less hard-hearted than the rest of you.

Another few months, a tentative introduction would be reasonable, but jeez, she’s swapped out the old guy fast, hasn’t she?

Maybe you’re right but it’s hardly the OP’s fault that friend A invited her new partner along? Why is OP getting the blame? That’s not right

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 07:11

Your sister is being unreasonable.

It's clear this is a couples meet-up - friend A isn't, for example, shoehorning her new partner into a girls' night out. Does your sister really expect friend A to sit there by herself when everyone else is in a couple? Obviously if friend A were single, she'd have no choice and I'm sure you'd do all you could not to make her feel like a spare part, but if it's a 'couples' dynamic, it should be a no-brainer that partners are welcome.

As a pp has said, the odds are that if this meet-up continues over the years, others in the core group will change partners. If new partners are potentially such an issue, the only other option would be if you all agreed this was a 'no partners' meet up, which would be a shame if it's always worked well as couples.

CheeryOP · 09/11/2026 07:12

Your sister sounds really hard work. YANBU.

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 07:14

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/11/2026 04:46

Ok putting to one side how your dsis feels differently from you. The way to avoid these situations is to validate her feelings first and foremost. Then say, friend A is probably a more the merrier type person and likely didn’t realise it would cause any issues. And suggest that we all meet him and take it from there. And ask her what she thinks.

Whilst she’s definitely overreacting, personally I’d not like it without a heads up. And a bit of politeness from the friend acknowledging how anyone else may feel about bringing someone new into the group. However, as I said, I doubt if she thought it would upset anyone.

And if you want to smooth it over now, you apologise to her for not seeing things from her pov and doing the above. You of course don’t need to do that at all. It’s totally your choice. However, you asked how to handle these things in future.

Whilst I agree with what @Sweetbeansandmochi. If you come across this so matter of fact, it will be inflammatory and resolve nothing as you’re still telling her you’re right and she’s wrong. So she’s going to react and go back to blocking you. You need to validate her first. And can say all of this stuff in a much softer way and she likely won’t. ‘Well I’m guessing perhaps from friend A’s pov, she sees it like this bla bla bla’. And ask her how that sits with her. Break it down slowly. I suggest you read up on rejection sensitivity dysphoria and see if that explains how your dsis reacts. It just might.

That reads like a "How To" guide for tiptoeing around emotionally abusive people

BendingSpoons · 09/11/2026 07:16

I don't think friend A should have asked permission to bring her partner, and it wouldn't bother me in the slightest that she was planning on bringing him. However this thread shows some people would find this harder. To me you could respond with one of the options below:

  • Don't be silly, of course A can bring him, she doesn't need to ask us!
  • I can see why you are worried about changing the group dynamics, but I think it's great A is happy and it will be nice to meet X and get to know him

The first response dismisses the feelings and is presumably what you did if you felt it was a ridiculous suggestion. The second response validates your sister's feelings without agreeing, and is maybe what your sister wanted. I regularly use something like the second response at work or with people I'm less close to. Whether you are willing to use that sort of response with your sister is up to you. Unless your sister actually wanted a third response of essentially saying 'I agree' when you understandably don't.

Scottishskifun · 09/11/2026 07:18

A normal person would say that's great can't wait to meet them!

Your sister sounds like she is trying the run the group of friends like she is the keeper - she's not everyone is adults and in friends A defence she wants to bring her new bf rather then be the only singleton with 3 other couples!

Honestly I would have said I get that the unknown can be unsettling however your not in charge of Friend A or the group. If you don't fancy coming fair enough and I would have left it like that.

Sounds like your sister needs to leave the teenage years of school in the past!

WonderingWanda · 09/11/2026 07:20

BeCosyOliveScroller · 09/11/2026 06:43

And I am afraid I disagree about the whole validating feelings thing.
Obviously if you’re dealing with a 5year old and they can’t find their favourite bit of Lego and are sad - sure validate away.
but your adult sister is behaving so immaturely and having main character syndrome.
and feelings aren’t the important thing - it’s actions. I wish we’d all stop focusing so much on our feelings. I’d probably feel a bit worried - who is this guy, is he going to be nice, will dh like him, what a shame the dynamic has changed - it’s fine to feel that. PRIVATELY.
actions - be civil. Polite. Certainly don’t throw a hissy fit and block your sister because she’s your emotional punchbag when liked doesn’t quite work out just how you like it.

I agree with this completely.

Your sister is being a dick to you, rather than address it with friend A herself who is the one who has changed the dynamic. She won't do that because she knows it would be unreasonable.

I would ignore her and let her get on with it. You can't change her op, only your reaction. Stop feeling like you did something wrong.

Yogabearmous · 09/11/2026 07:25

Block her, have the dinner and enjoy yourself without her and bil. Stop allowing her to control everything, and only unblock her when you are ready. She is a controller and again this about controlling you and your opinions and actions.

RampantIvy · 09/11/2026 07:27

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 09/11/2026 03:09

I'm quite surprised at the number of pp who agree with OP's sister. Do they really think a friend should be ostracised just because they have a new partner?
OP's sister actually comes over as a really unpleasant person who thinks she should control everything. If I were OP I would be distancing myself from her rather than putting up with her. Including organising social occasions without her sister and BiL but with her friends.

So am I.

The sister sounds immature and attention seeking though.

Funnywonder · 09/11/2026 07:27

I would feel like the sister, but I would keep my mouth zipped because I know I am a bit sensitive about stuff like this (shifts in group dynamic/meeting a new person) and that it is absolutely my problem. I certainly wouldn’t need anyone to ‘validate’ my feelings.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 09/11/2026 07:28

stiffan · 09/11/2026 00:44

is there a different way i can handle this? How can i word it to her? Sometimes when i explain something to her she will go off in a huff but will change.

At one point she kept putting up 'boundaries'. Ordering me around and telling me what i could and couldn't say. If i disagreed i 'violated her boundary.' But when i explained boundaries don't control the action of a person only yourself such as 'you're not allowed to talk about mum at the family party.' is controlling but if you instead say 'if you talk about mum at the family party i will leave' is a boundary. She changed her behavior for the better.

Well, about this incident, I would have said something like "you're only in control of yourself, so of course it's fine if you want to skip this catch up, but I think if you try organising a seperate one to exclude him then you risk the same thing happening to you in the future".

Given she's now blocked you though, I'd ignore her until she unblocks you and then keep it frosty until she has it out with you, at which point you could say something like "I'm a person, not a toy you can pick up and put down".

And say nothing to mutual friend- don't help sis bring the drama into the light. She likely knows she's being OTT or she'd have spoken to friend instead of talking behind her back.

BackJustToSay · 09/11/2026 07:29

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2026 01:58

I would feel like your sister. Bringing a stranger to an established group changes it from a comfortable outing to a stressful social situation. That should not be done casually.

Am I normal? Well, that depends on your definition. I am autistic. Some would say that makes me abnormal. I personally think it just makes me more attuned to the difficult social dynamics in these situations. Some people can gloss right over them. Some of us are highly aware of them at all times. I think it is the people who ignore them that are in the wrong.

I'm sorry but I disagree that you are the 'right' one here (if such a thing even exists). I am also quite attune to social dynamics, and sure, it might be slightly less comfortable than the regular group, but these people aren't children and should be able to handle speaking to a new person. They have been together a number of months and the OP says no one was even that close to the original boyfriend who wasn't the core friend, Friend A is. No one is the gatekeeper of this group and one person feeling slightly less comfortable shouldn't automatically get veto powers. Presumably, she wants to introduce her new man to her friends which is fairly understandable!

Refusing to allow new people along to a group gathering for a few hours is pretty exclusionary, unkind and cliquey IMO. This is the kind of group which gives themselves a name and has members I imagine (sadly, I genuinely know one of these in the adult world). I'd withdraw myself from any group which behaved like this (and I have a very tight knit and well established group of friends of 30+ years, but we'd never do that).

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 09/11/2026 07:31

Another way to deal with people who like to talk but not speak up is just say "mm, so what are you going to do?"

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 09/11/2026 07:32

Your sister is a controlling drama queen. This is not a fortnight in a villa. If he comes and is an arsehole, he doesn’t get to come again.

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 07:38

I would lay out the rules clearly. If she does X your response will be Y and stick to it.
Don ignore the behaviour though. She needs to know its not okay to silent treatment you, and what the consequences will be.

Keep unemotive and stick to your rules around what is and isnt okay behaviour.

I feel for her because it sounds her behaviour has been enabled for years to avoid conflict. Tell her how it lands and calmly ask her to stop it.

I had to do this with an inlaw who bullied people. He hadnt been given clear rules for decades.

Moonnstarz · 09/11/2026 07:39

To me it is a couples gathering which is why friend A saw no harm in inviting her new partner. If isn't just a group of friends socialising, it is friends with their partners. Maybe if you all met when she split from her ex that she was a bit of a gooseberry amongst everyone else being paired up.
Do you ever meet without partners?

I don't think friend A needed to ask permission and while you sister may express concerns about it being too soon or wondering if he will get on with everyone, she needs to get over it. The blocking is very immature and if she doesn't want to attend then that's her choice and she should be given that option.

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 07:41

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 09/11/2026 07:28

Well, about this incident, I would have said something like "you're only in control of yourself, so of course it's fine if you want to skip this catch up, but I think if you try organising a seperate one to exclude him then you risk the same thing happening to you in the future".

Given she's now blocked you though, I'd ignore her until she unblocks you and then keep it frosty until she has it out with you, at which point you could say something like "I'm a person, not a toy you can pick up and put down".

And say nothing to mutual friend- don't help sis bring the drama into the light. She likely knows she's being OTT or she'd have spoken to friend instead of talking behind her back.

Keep it frosty? Why not just be assertive and clear?

Maisymouse2 · 09/11/2026 07:43

Sweetbeans yes.
We are all our own person with differing thoughts & opnions so get used to it sis!
I could not be bothered.

Soontobe60 · 09/11/2026 07:43

Validating someone else’s feelings does not mean you have to feel the same way. It means that you accept they feel a particular way. You’re telling her she’s wrong to feel the way she does, which is the opposite of validation - it’s dismissal.
“hey sis, I understand that you feel upset about this situation, what would be a good solution for you?”

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 09/11/2026 07:44

stiffan · 09/11/2026 00:44

is there a different way i can handle this? How can i word it to her? Sometimes when i explain something to her she will go off in a huff but will change.

At one point she kept putting up 'boundaries'. Ordering me around and telling me what i could and couldn't say. If i disagreed i 'violated her boundary.' But when i explained boundaries don't control the action of a person only yourself such as 'you're not allowed to talk about mum at the family party.' is controlling but if you instead say 'if you talk about mum at the family party i will leave' is a boundary. She changed her behavior for the better.

That sounds positive. It sounds like she's very immature but she is capable of learning.

She's being a drama queen about the situation in your OP. The prospect of meeting a friend's new boyfriend at a social event to which partners are invited may feel daunting to her, but the support that is reasonable to expect from her sister is help with dealing with that feeling and participating anyway, not having the event changed in order to centre and validate her feeling of social awkwardness. You are right that not all feelings should be validated but I do think it's unhelpful to have used the word invalid. There will be aspects of her feelings that may well be valid but what's unreasonable is expecting that you'd anticipate and share her feelings and that the natural response is to tell friend A not to brimg the new bf is totally unreasonable.

Your sister sounds like hard work. Carry on with seeing your friends with their partners. Sis doesn't need to come.

thepariscrimefiles · 09/11/2026 07:49

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2026 01:58

I would feel like your sister. Bringing a stranger to an established group changes it from a comfortable outing to a stressful social situation. That should not be done casually.

Am I normal? Well, that depends on your definition. I am autistic. Some would say that makes me abnormal. I personally think it just makes me more attuned to the difficult social dynamics in these situations. Some people can gloss right over them. Some of us are highly aware of them at all times. I think it is the people who ignore them that are in the wrong.

How will the group ever get to know Friend A's new boyfriend if he isn't allowed to meet them? Would you advocate for separate meet-ups for each couple? I think that would be more stressful because, if he does turn out to be a dick, you can't just ignore him and speak to other people as you would be able to do in the larger group.

Or are you expecting Friend A to attend all meet-ups on her own from now on?

Ethelspagetti · 09/11/2026 07:49

I think your sister is being ridiculous and very controlling! I wouldn’t bother talking to her about it at all. Partners come and go and it would be nice to meet him as he might make a nice addition to the group. Otherwise she might stop coming all together. Everytime someone breaks up, they won’t be allowed their new partner and they’ll stop too. Until it dwindles to a few people. Keep the group going and invite them all.

ThePM · 09/11/2026 07:50

stiffan · 09/11/2026 00:19

i find this situation with sister happens over and over again. This is just one example. I am currently blocked. i will be unblocked at some point and life will resume as if nothing happened. I just don't know how to respond wihtout it ending up like this every time.

If it helps, maybe try to frame it as your sister “having big feelings” that she literally doesn’t know how to cope with.
She obviously can’t rationalize it, and by blocking you she is blocking out having to engage her brain- she is so used to being dominated by her feelings that rational thinking is literally beyond her.
In summary, she is someone to be pitied more than anything.

Perhaps a different way of handling it would be “You seem to feel very strongly about this? It is coming across that this is really important to you, and I just don’t feel strongly about it.” So acknowledging her feelings but not sharing them. Alternatively “I hear you, in what you would have liked to happen, but given that it hasn’t- what do you think is the best way forward from here?”

Yes she is being ridiculous, but don’t blow up your relationship over someone else’s boyfriend of a month.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 09/11/2026 07:52

TheFriendlyPotato · 09/11/2026 07:41

Keep it frosty? Why not just be assertive and clear?

Bit of punishment works wonders on people like OPs sister.

MyDeftDuck · 09/11/2026 07:53

I think I would be telling ‘sister’ to stay home and not bother meeting up with the others………who needs a stroppy, self-important princess spoiling everyone’s pleasure?