Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Sister furious. How would a normal person handle this?

167 replies

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

OP posts:
Happyjoe · 09/11/2026 08:50

Why does your sister make everything about her?

New partner of your mutual friend has nothing to do with your sister and she doesn't need her permission for him to come along to the group night. It's very strange behaviour to appoint herself lord and master of the group.

And as for the blocking and unblocking you, I'd be tempted to block her back. She won't like it but she may learn from it.

BeanNaGealai · 09/11/2026 08:53

Your sister sounds very similar to mine. Basically, she suffers from main character syndrome. If it's not about her, she'll figure out some way of making it about her and you're the worst in the world of you don't agree.

We used to get on until I realised we were only getting on when I humoured her and made all the compromises. I'm not willing to do that anymore so we now have a much more distant relationship. The expression "The bride at every wedding and the corpse at every funeral." describes her perfectly.

Your sister is entitled to be unhappy about a new person coming along ever though it does seem like an ott reaction. It's the rest of it that is unreasonable.

Oxaloacetate · 09/11/2026 09:00

Sounds like your sister was shagging your mates ex to me.

formigas · 09/11/2026 09:06

"i will be unblocked at some point and life will resume as if nothing happened".
Presumably by this you mean it's never spoken of again. What would happen if you said to your sister something along the lines of "blocking people and then pretending it never happened is really poor behaviour"? Or if you blocked her or ignored her for a time after she unblocked you? Or you just did something different? (I think I could guess what would happen. Flying monkeys i.e. she'd try to involve someone else in it).

She's being completely unreasonable about friend A. In your shoes I'd just leave her and BIL out (or just leave her out). But I cannot stand drama and distance myself from people like this. It all sounds a bit Queen Bee and as if she must be in charge of everything.

I suppose you could say to sister "Look friend A is our/my friend of x years and I am very fond of her. How do you think she'd feel at being told not to bring partner?" or "how would you feel if someone wanted to exclude BIL?". But this depends on your sister having empathy which it doesn't sound like is the case.

DelphiniumBlue · 09/11/2026 09:08

Im wondering why your sister even has an opinion on this that is strong enough to require ‘ validating’. Your friend wants to bring a.ong her new bf and introduce him to her mates. She has given ‘ notice’ of this ( although why someone should need notice to meet a new person in a group situation I don’t know). Maybe the group dynamic will change, so what? Surely the main thing a ‘ normal’ friend would be thinking is “ Ooh, A is bringing new bf, I wonder what he’s like?” And that’s all. Your sister is behaving in a very self centred, neurotic way. I wouldn’t be having any truck with it. Why does she think the world revolves around her? Life must be very exhausting for her living like that.
OP, I’m validating your feelings here by saying your sister is a loon.

researchers3 · 09/11/2026 09:12

HeddaGarbled · 09/11/2026 01:14

Actually, I’m with your sister. This is an established group of couples. The friend is trying to insert her new boyfriend way too quickly, expecting you to erase all memory of someone who was a member of your friendship group as if he didn’t exist. Your sister seems to be less hard-hearted than the rest of you.

Another few months, a tentative introduction would be reasonable, but jeez, she’s swapped out the old guy fast, hasn’t she?

They're friends, not children. They don't need a tentative introduction.

OPs sister is being ridiculous especially with the blocking. She needs to grow up.

Sassylovesbooks · 09/11/2026 09:23

Your sister is being ridiculous. Relationships break down, and new ones start, that's life. It's not down to your sister to decide when or if a friend's new partner is introduced to the friendship group. The fact she liked the friend's ex, is completely irrelevant here, the friend is no longer with him!! Nothing stopping her from still being friends with him, if she wants.

It sounds to me as if your sister thinks she's the groups Queen Bee and all decisions should involve her within the group! Why on earth should the friend feel the need to check with your sister, that she can bring her new partner?! She's a grown adult, and perfectly capable of making that choice herself.

lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 09:24

OP can you swap the word acknowledge for validate? Validation is recognising that someone’s feelings are real, it’s not agreeing with them.

But you’re uncomfortable with her asking for acknowledgment and she’s said she won’t seek support from you any more, so a mutually acceptable conclusion.

HoppityBun · 09/11/2026 09:26

5128gap · 09/11/2026 08:33

I'd say "I get you don't want a new person coming. However, I'm not in charge here, so I don't know why you're making this my problem to sort out. If you feel that strongly either tell A yourself or don't come. But think first about what it could do to the group dynamic if you create a fuss. Probably more harm than accepting a stranger for the weekend. Up to you."

I agree. Some posters are focusing on whether or not OP’s is correct to object to Friend A’s partner attending. But the issue is her behaviour to the OP.

Chilly80 · 09/11/2026 09:26

Your sister has blocked you how pathetic

5128gap · 09/11/2026 09:29

HoppityBun · 09/11/2026 09:26

I agree. Some posters are focusing on whether or not OP’s is correct to object to Friend A’s partner attending. But the issue is her behaviour to the OP.

Exactly! The validity of the sisters feelings is neither here nor there. The issue is an adult woman who wants to make the bullets for her sister to fire. If sister feels so strongly she needs to own it and act herself, not hide behind the OP.

MajorProcrastination · 09/11/2026 09:32

Your sister's being the weird one with no social understanding here.

We've had friends who are couples who've split and we've had meals and nights out and trips away with both halves of the split couple with their new people.

If friend A was the original mate, I don't see why it would be weird for her to bring her new partner like a grown up. Sure, it'll be a bit odd and awkward for a moment but hopefully this new person is a great human who you'll want to get to know as he's important to your friend.

OffTheMap · 09/11/2026 09:40

It takes time to get to know someone new and will change the dynamic for the first meet up.

But why is that bad? It’s getting to know someone new and just takes normal social skills.

And amongst 7 other adults a new person is easily absorbed.

Who the hell does your sister think she is that she can dictate and manage the group?

I don’t know how you handle it though.

Maybe start with her objections, e.g ‘what is it that makes you feel uncomfortable about a new person?’ And then ‘that’s understandable from your pov, but I think we will get to know him at some point, that always takes adjustment, and between 7 of us we can absorb him. If you are uncomfortable maybe sit at the other end of the table?’

Obviously it is your DSis who is ‘socially inept’ and is looking for someone to blame for her discomfort. You.

Stay calm, don’t react to being blocked. Don’t try and appease.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/11/2026 09:45

What I don't get is that you're both equally part of this friendship group. Your sister feels one way about it and you feel another way. Both of you are allowed these feelings. Why is it your job to validate your sisters feelings, but not your sisters job to validate your feelings?

However saying all that, although I agree with your thoughts on this, from what you've said, I'm not sure you communicated them in the best way:
"I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.
My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.
I said to give the new partner a chance."

You actually are arguing that her opinion is wrong here and trying to get her to change her mind and telling her that her feelings are wrong. So I can see a little bit where she is coming from. It's fine to share your thoughts. But a 'I get you feel uncomfortable with this, but do you think it's fair to do anything about it? I think it's OK because of this but agree it's still a bit uncomfortable when group dynamics change and its a shame we won't see Dave again as we all liked him' would likely have gone down a lot better. Instead you did kind of tell her that her feelings were wrong. You can see from this thread that a lot of people find changes in friendship groups difficult and it wouldn't have hurt to acknowledge that rather than implying that she shouldn't find it difficult.

claphamjunction123 · 09/11/2026 09:50

Ponderingwindow · 09/11/2026 01:58

I would feel like your sister. Bringing a stranger to an established group changes it from a comfortable outing to a stressful social situation. That should not be done casually.

Am I normal? Well, that depends on your definition. I am autistic. Some would say that makes me abnormal. I personally think it just makes me more attuned to the difficult social dynamics in these situations. Some people can gloss right over them. Some of us are highly aware of them at all times. I think it is the people who ignore them that are in the wrong.

I don’t think you are highly aware at all, in fact I have seen on other posts when you appear equally insufferable

Benjithedog · 09/11/2026 10:16

If anyone is being socially inept it’s your sister. Don’t buy into the drama. Tell her the new partner is coming and if she doesn’t feel comfortable with this she doesn’t go.

fruitbrewhaha · 09/11/2026 10:16

researchers3 · 09/11/2026 09:12

They're friends, not children. They don't need a tentative introduction.

OPs sister is being ridiculous especially with the blocking. She needs to grow up.

Or dogs……….

TwoPSLsPlease · 09/11/2026 10:20

we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic.

She's got to be kidding. If she liked the original friend A's partner so well, she is free to maintain friendship with them if she pleases. That has nothing to do with friend A being allowed to bring her new partner to the function as long as it's something you normally do.

19Since7 · 09/11/2026 10:24

fruitbrewhaha · 09/11/2026 10:16

Or dogs……….

Dogs usually sniff one another's backsides for two minutes and they're fine! So much simpler!

SylvanMoon · 09/11/2026 10:32

Your sister is 1/8 (now 1/7) of a group. What is the opinion of the other 6 members? She should be going along with the majority view.

But I agree that your problem with her is not just this issue, it's that she's misinterpreting the concept of having "boundaries" and thinks that means she gets to impose her will on others.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 09/11/2026 10:32

Does your sister struggle with change generally? I wonder if she has some kind of anxiety regarding change and she tries to control her anxiety by controlling other people and how they behave?

Because obviously it's ridiculous for her to say that things must be done her way or she's being basically ignored and her boundaries are being stepped on - as though she's gained a smattering of Therapy Speak and has misunderstood it. What is she so scared of? That Person A's new partner might not be as nice as her previous one? That's a matter for everyone, not just her, and can be dealt with in due course. But it seems as though she wants everything to stay as it always has, which of course will never be the case.

Itsthewoluff · 09/11/2026 10:33

I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

Yes you can. It’s possible to understand why they feel like that, but then explain why you feel differently.

So you empathise then say “but…”

Otherwise you may coma across as I am right, you are wrong, whereas neither of you are right or wrong. You both have equally valid feelings. So acknowledge that.

I’m with your sister in that I probably wouldn’t like the changed dynamic however I can see that in that set up it would be unreasonable for our feelings to stop her bringing a partner as couples are the norm.

Your sister shouldn’t be blocking you whenever you disagree, but perhaps you can look at how you word things sometimes. Just like she listened to you about boundaries.

Comtesse · 09/11/2026 10:37

Hang on she “needs support” cos Friend A has a new boyfriend and wants to bring him on a night out and now she’s blocked you because you were insufficiently kind about this??

What the heck, that’s mad. It’s not you it’s HER.

Clearinguptheclutter · 09/11/2026 10:38

Your sister is being utterly childish and immature
unless there is some complicated backstory to do with the friend and her partner but seems unlikely

if she doesn’t like it then the other three couples go out and sis and BIL (or perhaps just sis) stay at home

Sunshineandgrapefruit · 09/11/2026 10:42

Tell your sister that the old partner is not coming back into your group. The new partner may be a big part of it in future. You should all be supporting your friend in her decision. Does she have a sport spot for the ex? She needs to understand it's not a slight on him, his group invite terminated with the relationship to a group member!

Swipe left for the next trending thread