Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Sister furious. How would a normal person handle this?

167 replies

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 07:53

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

Yes.

A normal sister would say "I understand why you're concerned that a new person who's a stranger to the group might upset the dynamic"

Then you say "but I think we've got to give him a chance for the sake of our friend".

Validating her feelings does not mean agreeing with her opinion.

rememberingthem · 09/11/2026 07:55

Your sister is behaving like a spoilt child having a tantrum. Treat her as such and ignore her until she decides to behave like an adult. Not all feelings/behaviours are valid and therefore should not be validated. She needs to grow up and realise that she is not in charge of who can or cannot attend these events.

Pedant61 · 09/11/2026 07:58

What's all this validation nonsense? We have a group of 10 couples we have known for over 40 years. In that time, through death and divorce, there has been a small number of changes. Whenever someone has had a new partner, they are made very welcome, as we understand how hard it can be to become part of a long-term group.

lottiegarbanzo · 09/11/2026 07:59

You could say ‘can you explain why you feel that way? I’d like to understand’. That way you’re not lying by faking agreement but you’re not telling her she’s wrong. Then you can acknowledge her feelings and tell her what your, different, feelings are (and she could acknowledge those).

I can understand her feeling uncomfortable at a new person appearing in an established group where you’re all comfortable with each other. It changes the dynamic. So I can understand she’d have liked as much forewarning as possible - which she might be getting. That’s very different from friend A needing to ‘seek permission’.

How does BIL respond to sister’s self-centred behaviour? Does he support her, or let it float past him?

Janetwin · 09/11/2026 07:59

BeCosyOliveScroller · 09/11/2026 06:43

And I am afraid I disagree about the whole validating feelings thing.
Obviously if you’re dealing with a 5year old and they can’t find their favourite bit of Lego and are sad - sure validate away.
but your adult sister is behaving so immaturely and having main character syndrome.
and feelings aren’t the important thing - it’s actions. I wish we’d all stop focusing so much on our feelings. I’d probably feel a bit worried - who is this guy, is he going to be nice, will dh like him, what a shame the dynamic has changed - it’s fine to feel that. PRIVATELY.
actions - be civil. Polite. Certainly don’t throw a hissy fit and block your sister because she’s your emotional punchbag when liked doesn’t quite work out just how you like it.

I agree with your validating feelings thing! Another poster above said that’s how she deals with school kids and that’s also something I did with my own kids when they were younger (like, throwing tantrums age). But it’s exhausting having to deal with an adult that needs that validation constantly.

Janetwin · 09/11/2026 08:02

Bitsostuff · 09/11/2026 07:14

That reads like a "How To" guide for tiptoeing around emotionally abusive people

If it wasn’t her sister, I’d suggest forming a different social circle for the meet ups without the sister and her demanding social media psycobabble. It just sounds like “work”.

BertieBotts · 09/11/2026 08:03

Emotional validation is a different thing to accepting something is valid in terms of logic, proportion or truth.

It seems a bit much for your DSis to be "furious" but equally you might be being overly literal?

It's possible to understand why somebody feels a certain way without agreeing with them.

I do agree with posters saying adults don't always need their feelings validated. However it is empathetic to do that when you can.

Melancholyflower · 09/11/2026 08:04

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 09/11/2026 03:09

I'm quite surprised at the number of pp who agree with OP's sister. Do they really think a friend should be ostracised just because they have a new partner?
OP's sister actually comes over as a really unpleasant person who thinks she should control everything. If I were OP I would be distancing myself from her rather than putting up with her. Including organising social occasions without her sister and BiL but with her friends.

The friend shouldn't be ostracised, but she doesn't need to bring a man with her; presumably if she hadn't started seeing this bloke she would be included on her own? This isn't a partner, it's a boyfriend of a month, and the marriage only broke up 4 months ago, so I think it would be weird for the others in the group to just be expected to just accept the swap and carry on as normal.

Melancholyflower · 09/11/2026 08:05

However, the sister's behaviour towards the OP is not normal, but is obviously not only related to this issue.

Uniqueusername3 · 09/11/2026 08:05

HeddaGarbled · 09/11/2026 01:14

Actually, I’m with your sister. This is an established group of couples. The friend is trying to insert her new boyfriend way too quickly, expecting you to erase all memory of someone who was a member of your friendship group as if he didn’t exist. Your sister seems to be less hard-hearted than the rest of you.

Another few months, a tentative introduction would be reasonable, but jeez, she’s swapped out the old guy fast, hasn’t she?

Yeah if you were her children.

Do people really get that attached to their friends boyfriends? You need a mourning period?

Why should she sit there alone surrounded by couples when she is also a couple. Because her friends aren't ready to meet her boyfriend?

DreamyRedNewt · 09/11/2026 08:06

Your sister is being a bit dramatic. However, I don't think it is normal to bring a partner who you have been dating for a month to a group holiday, she cannot even know him that well. I think it would be more natural to meet him in a different context to start with, then with time he could join the group holiday. I don't think I'd like a complete stranger to come to these holidays too and it would be really annoying if that means she is going to be uncomfortable (and potentially other people too)

ThePM · 09/11/2026 08:09

HeddaGarbled · 09/11/2026 01:14

Actually, I’m with your sister. This is an established group of couples. The friend is trying to insert her new boyfriend way too quickly, expecting you to erase all memory of someone who was a member of your friendship group as if he didn’t exist. Your sister seems to be less hard-hearted than the rest of you.

Another few months, a tentative introduction would be reasonable, but jeez, she’s swapped out the old guy fast, hasn’t she?

Wow, you’re just as ridiculous as the sister.

In what way does a new partner create an expectation of erasing the old? It doesn’t- you just think it does, and maybe if you are mourning the end of your friend’s relationship longer than they are, maybe it is time to adjust the dial to “I trust my friend to bring a suitable match for the group”

I’m sorry but if it takes you months to get to the point where you can cope with the idea of “a tentative introduction” that is on you. It isn’t that she is hard hearted, it is that someone else is emotionally inflexible, and trying to make a virtue out of something unkind.

RosemaryRusset · 09/11/2026 08:10

DreamyRedNewt · 09/11/2026 08:06

Your sister is being a bit dramatic. However, I don't think it is normal to bring a partner who you have been dating for a month to a group holiday, she cannot even know him that well. I think it would be more natural to meet him in a different context to start with, then with time he could join the group holiday. I don't think I'd like a complete stranger to come to these holidays too and it would be really annoying if that means she is going to be uncomfortable (and potentially other people too)

I think it's just an evening out, not a holiday?

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 09/11/2026 08:16

Melancholyflower · 09/11/2026 08:04

The friend shouldn't be ostracised, but she doesn't need to bring a man with her; presumably if she hadn't started seeing this bloke she would be included on her own? This isn't a partner, it's a boyfriend of a month, and the marriage only broke up 4 months ago, so I think it would be weird for the others in the group to just be expected to just accept the swap and carry on as normal.

She has just gone through presumably an upsetting relationship breakup and is trying to get her life back on track. But you and OP's sister expect her to come along as a singleton to a social event where every one else is a couple? It sounds as though you want to punish her for having the temerity to break up with her long term partner.

She has been with her new bf for a month. It's not as though he is a guy she just picked up the night before. I find the unkindness towards the friend, the absolutely closed mindedness of not wanting to meet her new bf inexplicable. So narrowminded.

Janetwin · 09/11/2026 08:19

stiffan · 09/11/2026 00:44

is there a different way i can handle this? How can i word it to her? Sometimes when i explain something to her she will go off in a huff but will change.

At one point she kept putting up 'boundaries'. Ordering me around and telling me what i could and couldn't say. If i disagreed i 'violated her boundary.' But when i explained boundaries don't control the action of a person only yourself such as 'you're not allowed to talk about mum at the family party.' is controlling but if you instead say 'if you talk about mum at the family party i will leave' is a boundary. She changed her behavior for the better.

the more you pander to this, the worse it will get. She should probably speak to a psychologist but I’d be wary of suggesting that also as she’s likely to fly off the handle. She seems to think that her feelings are your responsibility which frankly, as an adult, they’re not. All that said, I’m assuming that when she is in a good mood, you like her company so estrangement is not an option you would go for?

chirrupybird · 09/11/2026 08:29

You are both being rather rigid, she is entitled to think it will change the dynamic in the group and might make the evening awkward, but your friend doesn't need to ask your sister's permission to bring him, is she meant to come alone? That would also change the dynamic three couples and a single. But not recognising that it might be a problem is also not right. I would put it like it's a shame she broke up with the guy we got to know and like, but you can't expect her to be single forever and it is nice to support her and welcome the bf into the group even though it might be awkward at first.

LancsMa · 09/11/2026 08:29

Obviously your sister is being controlling and irrational - she also sounds very young and that she's got her psychology degree from Tik Tok. I'd suggest playing the same cod-psychology game back and 'validating' her feelings when she says mad stuff with something like, "I understand that you feel like that. The change has made you feel unsettled and ignored. Those are unpleasant feelings. But life goes on and relationships change... let's help friend A welcome her new partner to the group, after all it's just a couple of drinks and he'll probably be feeling a bit nervous". At no point have you actually said she's right. That kinda Tik-Tokieness.

thepariscrimefiles · 09/11/2026 08:31

HeddaGarbled · 09/11/2026 01:14

Actually, I’m with your sister. This is an established group of couples. The friend is trying to insert her new boyfriend way too quickly, expecting you to erase all memory of someone who was a member of your friendship group as if he didn’t exist. Your sister seems to be less hard-hearted than the rest of you.

Another few months, a tentative introduction would be reasonable, but jeez, she’s swapped out the old guy fast, hasn’t she?

Another few months before Friend A is even allowed to introduce her new partner to the group? That's ridiculous! How long before she can invite him to the meet-up with the group? Five years? 10 years? Maybe the group should go into mourning for decades like Queen Victoria did after Prince Albert died.

It sounds like OP's sister has 'main character syndrome' and is making this all about her. The group should just get together without her.

BustyLaRoux · 09/11/2026 08:32

Your sister is a dramatic self centred arse!

5128gap · 09/11/2026 08:33

I'd say "I get you don't want a new person coming. However, I'm not in charge here, so I don't know why you're making this my problem to sort out. If you feel that strongly either tell A yourself or don't come. But think first about what it could do to the group dynamic if you create a fuss. Probably more harm than accepting a stranger for the weekend. Up to you."

ClearFruit · 09/11/2026 08:38

A couple who have been 'dating' for a month are not 'partners'.

TaptheCap · 09/11/2026 08:39

Whilst i can understand some of your sister's feelings (it will change the dynamic, at least initially and I would struggle with that), I don't think the friend needed to asked permission or that if she had, permission should have been withheld at all.

I'd say "it can be hard when social groups change and we don't know how I new person will fit in but it's important to friend and it'll be nice to meet her new partner. I'm sure he'll fit in soon enough".

ScotiaLass · 09/11/2026 08:41

I can see your sister would have a point if you'd all been married for 30 years, you were all equally friends with both partners and she had cheated on her partner with new boyfriend for example, but that's not the scenario. It sounds like your sister likes the status quo and isn't prepared for it to change. It reminds me of when I was younger I had a friend who filled in the name of a man I was seeing in a guest list for a wedding she was planning two years ahead. When I saw it I told her I didn't think we'd still be together then, and she got cross at me for ruining her planning book. Your sister needs to accept that we all settle down at different rates and just because she has found her life partner, it doesn't mean your friends need to settle for whoever they happen to be with now.

Ally886 · 09/11/2026 08:44

stiffan · 09/11/2026 00:44

is there a different way i can handle this? How can i word it to her? Sometimes when i explain something to her she will go off in a huff but will change.

At one point she kept putting up 'boundaries'. Ordering me around and telling me what i could and couldn't say. If i disagreed i 'violated her boundary.' But when i explained boundaries don't control the action of a person only yourself such as 'you're not allowed to talk about mum at the family party.' is controlling but if you instead say 'if you talk about mum at the family party i will leave' is a boundary. She changed her behavior for the better.

She sounds like she expects the world to revolve around her. Let me guess, your parents minimise it because they're absolutely gutted they've realised someone so badly?

The situation about the new fella is not about her. She's irrelevant. People separate. She can always not go.

Just ignore her, or you're just as bad. Don't be complicit in the whole charade

angelasim · 09/11/2026 08:46

She sounds very sensitive. You might get round it by saying'Mmm, we will miss her ex, he was fun' before saying, 'for myself, I am happy to meet the new guy , but if it really bothers you perhaps you should say so'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread