Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Sister furious. How would a normal person handle this?

167 replies

stiffan · 08/11/2026 23:57

Theres 4 couples and we go out as a group of 8 about 6 times a year.

One couple is my sister and BIL. the rest are friends.

Friend A who is very nice and normal recently broke up with her partner who we all liked but weren't close to and started dating a new man 3 months later.

We didn't know about the new partner until plans for this week were made and she mentioned she will bring him. She's been dating him a month.

Sister is really annoyed that friend A didn't ask permission to bring a new person and didn't consider that we may not like it as we liked her original partner and bringing a new person changes the dynamic. (Friend A was the original friend and we are all her friend first not her partner)

I told sister it's not a big deal and shes overthinking it.

My sister said it is a big deal to her and friend A is being unreasonable.

I said to give the new partner a chance. My sister said i was socailly inept. i should know to validate her feelings first and she won't turn to me for support in the future.

I said i can't validate a thought i don't think is valid. But should I?

So would a normal person validate a thought they don't think is valid? I can't say 'i understand why you feel that way' because i really don't.

OP posts:
Bloozie · 09/11/2026 10:55

Your sister is being a dick. You can acknowledge her feelings, but you don't have to validate them when they're fucking ridiculous. "I'm sorry you feel that way, I can see this is hard for you" is very different to, "You're right, let's exclude Friend A from our circle now because her relationship ended". That is just batshit behaviour. Especially as Friend A is the person both of you are friends with. I'd understand it slightly more if it was the partner she is no longer with - but even then, friends are friends are friends, and trying to exclude people is extremely childish behaviour.

I can understand her fears that the dynamic will change, that the new partner might be a total arsehole, but that's something you tackle when you've all been out a few times. Even then, you can't control who Friend A is in a relationship with.

Your sister sounds like an exhausting drama llama.

DontEatTheMushies · 09/11/2026 11:05

Did the sister have a thing for the now replaced EX? That is the only reasoning I can think of..........or.......she has had a thing with the new person (I assume you all know who that is now?

Her reaction makes 0 sense as the friends partner is one of the 'changeable part' in the whole dynamic of the friend group.

JuliaAgrippina · 09/11/2026 11:10

Was she expecting friend A to come with ex or by herself in group of couples or not come at all- or was it the asking sister permission that was important bit?

Sometime instead of telling people they are behaving oddly you can ask them questions that make them think about how they are coming across - but honestly if she flies of the handle this frequently do you not just ignore as much as possible and not engage with it all?

BillieWiper · 09/11/2026 11:12

So when you do things you used to do as couples she must attend alone, forever? Or she's not permitted to attend at all if it's only couples?

What would be the point of her asking permission to bring someone everyone has never met before. They can hardly make an informed decision about whether he's nice or not until they meet? Like she needs her friends permission to have a new partner?!

'Oh no, he can't come. I don't like the sound of him. He's got the same name as my neighbour's cat who pisses on my daffodils...?!'

You are definitely not the one who is 'socially inept'.

stiffan · 09/11/2026 11:15

this conversation happens a lot. My sister thrives in chaos and pointing out wrong doings. I wish i had new ways of responding to shut down the conversation without being blocked.

And it's pretty exhausting to go 'i understand you feel frustrated that Friend A is bringing in a new person without your permission, that must feel jarring to feel like you are not the most important person in the room and other people make decisions without your permission. I understand that must be frustrating for you to not be in charge. ...' (I am being sarcastic i would never dare send that!)

I feel i have to validate like that every time but maybe i have to keep at it to keep the peace.

I feel like if i validate i encourage the misery a bit and more misery like this will follow. My sister is autistic, so am I (so i doubt i am handling this well as i too say the wrong thing). She struggles a lot with life and feels so out of control that i think she tries to control what she can and gets very overwhelmed when it doesn't go to plan.

If i get blocked im blocked from my nieces for two weeks and we facetime 1/2 times a week which is a shame so i want to avoid getting blocked.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 09/11/2026 11:15

Permission from who and why does she need support. Has she shagged this new bloke or something?

JLou08 · 09/11/2026 11:17

I could understand someone being nervous about a new person being brought to the group and the dynamic changing. Even more so if they're seen as a replacement for someone else.

purplecorkheart · 09/11/2026 11:18

It would have been polite for Person A to ask the group before inviting her new partner to join but your sister reaction is bizarre. She sounds like she is very immature and a drama queen. She needs to know that not everyone is going to agree with her all the time. This blocking and unblocking is childish. She sounds exhausting.

stiffan · 09/11/2026 11:19

@JLou08 i really don't think its nerves, its more a pattern of thinking. Looking for potential social problems and getting annoyed by them like a habit.

OP posts:
Bloozie · 09/11/2026 11:24

Sounds like she's very anxious and trying to control things as a means of avoiding uncomfortable feelings.

You saying something like, "i understand you feel frustrated that Friend A is bringing in a new person without your permission, that must feel jarring to feel like you are not the most important person in the room and other people make decisions without your permission. I understand that must be frustrating for you to not be in charge. ..." isn't validating her feelings though. It's empathising and acknowledging them. (I know you'd never say that)

Validating would be saying, you're right. The way you feel is right.

I'd say, you can't control everything that makes you uncomfortable and I know that's hard. Why don't you sit out this first get together with the new partner? Or only come along for a little bit?

sprigatito · 09/11/2026 11:24

I would send her a letter saying “the next time you block me after a disagreement, I will make the estrangement permanent. This is not how adults resolve minor conflict, and I am not prepared to tolerate it any longer. I am here if you want to have a conversation about the disagreement we had.”

And mean it.

JuliaAgrippina · 09/11/2026 11:25

stiffan · 09/11/2026 11:19

@JLou08 i really don't think its nerves, its more a pattern of thinking. Looking for potential social problems and getting annoyed by them like a habit.

Which is why I'm suggesting you ask questions that make her work through her thinking - not just tell her she is wrong.

Along lines of what were you expecting her to do - and is that really reasonable way to think.

If you tell her she is wrong - she can fly off the handle and blame you if you ask questions that make her justify why she thinks that - she may still fly off the handle but that moral high ground isn't as secure and you are less likely to feel on the back foot with vauge feeling you did something wrong when you didn't.

Comtesse · 09/11/2026 11:25

Ok so with the update about autism this makes SLIGHTLY more sense. Still deeply annoying of your sister.

ViciousCurrentBun · 09/11/2026 11:35

So what your sister is saying is the group is shut out to anyone new? It’s massively unreasonable. It’s just a night out if it was bring new man along to a week long holiday then that would be different. Doe she expect friend A to live like a Nun forever?

So you both have autism, remember people have their personalities as well as their conditions. One my colleagues had autism and a nicer bloke you couldn’t meet, one of my friends adult DS had autism and was obnoxious.

I would just leave sister to it.

Tryandmakeadifference · 09/11/2026 11:41

I've never been a fan of cliquey groups who don't welcome others so thats my reply.

MyMilchick · 09/11/2026 11:41

Your sister is being ridiculous and mean towards Friend A

NuffSaidSam · 09/11/2026 11:59

NormasArse · 09/11/2026 04:37

Why is it off though? Is she just supposed to be alone now?

No, of course not. But you ask before bringing someone into an established group.

In the same way, she's allowed to have other friends (they all are of course!), but you don't just bring them along to a specific group meet-up. She's allowed other family, neighbours, colleagues etc etc etc, but if they're not part of that specific group they don't get an automatic invite. That's generally how groups like that work, it's not just eight people, it's eight specific people. If one of the eight isn't coming you don't draft in a sub without asking anyone (particularly not when you've known that sub for a month!).

Magicpaintbrush · 09/11/2026 12:03

Your sister is being manipulative and gas-lighty because she immature and behaving like a stroppy 15 year old. end of. Ridiculous behaviour from a grown woman.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 09/11/2026 12:05

NuffSaidSam · 09/11/2026 00:44

I totally see your sister's pov re. the new boyfriend tbh. I wouldn't say anything though, I'd give him a chance. But I would (in my head) think it's a bit off from friend A.

Would I validate feelings I don't believe are valid? I'd sympathise with the fact that they were finding it difficult, but I wouldn't agree with their point. I'm not sure if that's validating or not. I think you can acknowledge that one person is struggling with a situation without casting blame on to the other person. Both things can be true at the same time.

This is what I was gong to post (excepted it wouldn't be as well articulated). The situation will be aggravated from sister's perspective, I suspect by the fact she has only been seeing this guy (I hesitate to say partner) for a few weeks

formigas · 09/11/2026 12:05

"If i get blocked im blocked from my nieces for two weeks and we facetime 1/2 times a week which is a shame so i want to avoid getting blocked."

You can't avoid getting blocked or make her behave differently. Changing your own behaviour might prompt her to change her own or it might not. Continuing to tiptoe round her won't change anything though, she'll likely get even worse.

I don't know how old your nieces are but they will eventually be old enough to manage their own relationship with you. If they're very young and she's stopping them from having weekly chats with you because you haven't sufficiently kowtowed to her latest demand then she really is a despicable piece of work. She goes on about having boundaries but someone with decent boundaries wouldn't drag children into what is ostensibly a tiny disagreement about social etiquette but in fact all about control and her massive ego.

Janetwin · 09/11/2026 12:10

It reads like she’s looking to pick a fight

Minasama · 09/11/2026 12:16

Your sister sounds like a more introverted person who wants control.
But she can control her actions, not those of others.
If she doesn’t like the new person she’s welcome not to go.
She’s silly to pick a fight with you over it, she sounds like she needs careful handling.

NormasArse · 09/11/2026 12:32

NuffSaidSam · 09/11/2026 11:59

No, of course not. But you ask before bringing someone into an established group.

In the same way, she's allowed to have other friends (they all are of course!), but you don't just bring them along to a specific group meet-up. She's allowed other family, neighbours, colleagues etc etc etc, but if they're not part of that specific group they don't get an automatic invite. That's generally how groups like that work, it's not just eight people, it's eight specific people. If one of the eight isn't coming you don't draft in a sub without asking anyone (particularly not when you've known that sub for a month!).

So what amount of time is she allowed to know him before introducing him?

The group isn’t eight people anymore, anyway- he’s not just not coming for that night, they’ve split up- he won’t be coming again.

MeridaBrave · 09/11/2026 12:33

I think block her back so when she unblocks she finds she can’t. So immature.

NuffSaidSam · 09/11/2026 12:35

NormasArse · 09/11/2026 12:32

So what amount of time is she allowed to know him before introducing him?

The group isn’t eight people anymore, anyway- he’s not just not coming for that night, they’ve split up- he won’t be coming again.

Well, that's why you ask in the group isn't it? To find that out.

For me, I'd wait until I was pretty certain he was a keeper (or at least a long-term temp), which I wouldn't be after a month of dating. I'd probably wait six months or so. But everyone is different, which is why you ask.

Swipe left for the next trending thread