Whispers in the Confessional | Traitors 2026 | Thread 6 | Spoiler Free!

[CaveMum]

Link to previous thread: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/telly_addicts/5472793-this-time-its-personal-traitors-2026-thread-5-spoiler-free?page=1

Welcome to Thread 6 of Traitors 2026.

This thread runs at TV pace so do not read any further if you are not up to date with the live broadcast. Whilst most discussion will be on the current series, inevitably people will refer to previous series/players/winners so reader beware if you’ve not seen the 3 previous editions, or the celebrity version.

While we welcome posters discussing their theories and speculating on relationships/connections between players, please don’t post spoilers from elsewhere that may ruin things for those of us who like to see things unfold over the course of the series.

The story so far:

Traitors
Hugo
Rachel
Stephen
Fiona (Secret Traitor)

Murdered
Netty
Ben
Maz
Reece

Banished
Judy (Faithful)
Hugo (Traitor)
Ross (Faithful)
Amanda (Faithful)
Fiona (Traitor)

No murder cliffhanger after episode 6, but Matthew (aka Interchangeable Male #3) has taken an interesting approach. We wait to see what cunning questions Harriet can come up with.

The floor is yours…

Why can the traitors never work together? Every year they start going for each other. It just happened much earlier this year. But the traitors have power in numbers. Once they get to half way they have so much power as a block of three vote. I also wonder why they never talk about who they want to banish as well as murder. They could be so powerful.

I so agree - if they worked more as a Team and thought of who to get out in banishment they could really do well - but I guess it's of course different when you're in that position and tbh there's a lot of footage we don't see

Just re watched last night's episode.

Theory about Matt, the fairest, standing there in his slightly too small clothes, with his innocent demeanor. He's a Creative Director so he knows how to frame a narrative. Do we think he is playing a long game of misdirection and if let into the turret will slaughter anyone without mercy, including his fellow traitors?

If I were them I'd pretend to make a deal and murder him asap.

There's so much more discussion at the round table than we actually see so it's possible Jade's name has been discussed more extensively, and Amanda's behaviour towards her felt very personal.
I still think Rachel really shot herself in the foot announcing what Amanda told her so, if they go for Jade who is then shown as a faithful, they discredit anything Amanda said and it throws suspicion on Rachel. A smart move for Rachel now would be to recruit Jade, expose her as a traitor and secure her own position. That would be incredibly devious though.
I hope Jessie is more vocal at highlighting what she's noticed before they kill her off....murdering her does rather endorse what she's saying. Also, I really like her and wanted her to win so I'm cheesed off at them killing off another interesting and likeable player.

I thought that on Uncloaked Ed quickly moved away from talking to Reece when Reece said he'd wanted a hug from Amanda as she was leaving (possibly because they have a family connection and he didn't want it to be revealed accidentally?).

I am also 6/7 years younger than Fiona and feel she's about 3 decades older than me in respect of her behaviour and attitudes. I don't know why she referred to Tena - having stress incontinence is nothing to be ashamed of.

I'm not sure either Amanda or Fiona have done the police any favours given their comments and 'strategy' during the programmes. Neither covered themselves in glory. Maz was lovely and a credit to himself and the force though.

An aside:

If you watch the speed climbing at the Olympics is really interesting to watch what the contestants are using to listen to music.
The thing with speed climbing is that you can’t see the course in advance so they all sit out the back waiting for their turn. They are allowed to listen to music but not on an internet capable device so they all have ancient iPods instead.

back to the traitors.

Butteredtoast55

That’s true about the amount of editing. I tend to forget that.

And it was frustrating - though expected - how she dominated the show and how much Charlotte Church and Amanda liked her. When she was banished didn't Claudia call her a brilliant traitor? In the episode when Fiona accused Rachel it was so explosive and unexpected I'm worried that it will be seen as the moment of the series. Here's to more explosive episodes which will eradicate what she did. My 15 year old finds it funny how much I loathe Fiona:)

One of my closest friends liked her!

Honestly, it made me look at said friend through narrowed eyes, with my head one side and think "Hmmm....have I got you all wrong?" 😂😂

In Rachel's position I would see Stephen as an easy victim as he's already been suspected by others and therefore keep him onside until near the end, then work to get him banished so I (Rachel) was the only Traitor left.

The risk is there may be a recruitment and we have seen slight variations in the game so the rules may change towards the end.

I thought Fiona did think Rachel was telling the truth- that was what annoyed her most. Amanda was ex police but hadn't told her and even worse had told Rachel. Her ego was bruised so in a hissy fit she declared Rachel was lying.

I think this must have come up but wasn't shown. I think this is why Fiona got so many votes and Rachel didn't get any.

I guess Rachel could sell it as Fiona trying to deflect from the names Amanda gave (Jade and ?Sam) and say that she must have been protecting other traitor/s. Then get them out at RT, two RTs and 2 murders before the theory is shown to be false by which time she'll have to hope she's nearly won it (or, ideally, recruited one of them then thrown them under bus)

Or everyone believed Rachel as they realised in hindsight how obvious an ex-copper Amanda was!

Fiona said that her husband was a serving police officer. Surely most police have retired by their 60s- unless he's a lot younger than her?

Rachel hasn’t been backhanded though. She never voted Hugo that was Fiona and Stephen. She’s actually. Been the most loyal. Stephen’s voted traitors twice.

I thought they meant before they asked them so as not to give the traitors time to plan. I assume they will have to say what they asked at some point. Presumably when they come up with a theory. They could/will lie of course.

He’s maz. 🙄

I really hope it’s not because he will plummet down in my estimation if he’s put up with married to her.

Maz is retired from the police and is now a civil servant - if Fiona’s husband is a serving police officer, he’s definitely not Maz.

Talking of stats, how does the speed of threads look this time compared to previous series?

Are the Traitors stats published anywhere else? I’m not the biggest fan of Richard and Marina plus I’d really like to read up on the raw data myself and produce forecasts which turn out to be useless 😁

It's as much to do with how they've featured in the episodes. With 22 players at the start, the only way most of us learn who's who is either because they physically stand out from the crowd (age, height, hair, ethnicity, sex, or other attributes). Or they have a key role in an early episode (selected as traitor, do something stupid or controversial etc.). There were a relatively large number of youngish men, who's physical differences are not great enough to be memorable and they didn't get featured significantly in the early episodes. So, they weren't being talked about and were inadvertently grouped together in many of our minds. Hence interchangeables.

Jade irritated me with her ongoing petulant responses to being nominated as a traitor and that response also made her seem more like a traitor to those nominating her. Last night was the first time we have seen her respond to being nominated in a similar manner to others.
Being incorrectly nominated on the “evidence’ that you looked a bit funny at a random event is all part of the game. In her bio she emphasises her gaming experience and yet seemed not to grasp this basic aspect of the game.

On a side note I think it was Jade’s outfits which made me wonder if the show provides wardrobe/styling to contestants. She has been wearing some pretty pricey outfits for someone who describes living on a PhD grant salary. I’ve seen other contestants pop up with quite fancy outfits but I wasn’t sure of the mismatch between wardrobe and their income. I would defer to the S&B posters on this - perhaps we need a matching Traitors style thread as was created for Shetland!

I agree. She takes everything so seriously

So if I was one to ask the traitors a question I would ask what the others have asked!
But maybe they don't know if they were first or last to ask

I thought it was fun!