Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Charity shops, I apologise

311 replies

thedevilinablackdress · 13/10/2026 07:56

I've loved charity shopping for over 30 years, but like many I've long mixed it with online second hand shopping.
The stories in this Guardian article are not new to those of us who've read threads on here, work in the shops or know people who do.
I never sell online myself and am a very mindful donatter, but my own eBay addiction and Vinted dabbling is contributing to this in a way.
Shops won't want to discourage donations, but it seems more push back on the mountains of crap is needed.

www.theguardian.com/fashion/2026/oct/13/people-sell-their-best-stuff-on-vinted-how-charity-shops-became-a-dumping-ground-for-unsellable-clothes

OP posts:
PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 15:48

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 15:38

'... In 1975 fabrics derived from fossil fuels like polyester, nylon and acrylic represented just 30% of the global fibre market. In 2021, that figure was 64%. By comparison in 2021, wool represented just 1% of the global fibre market and silk was just under 0.2%, although the total production of most fibres has increased significantly in that time.'

Laura Ashley had some nice-looking jumpers this season… 12% wool! They only add it so they can say it’s a wool blend IMO, no other reason. It’s a waste of good wool as the jumper will be hopelessly tatty by the end of the season.

I have a fabric shaver that I use frequently, but eventually you shave holes in your clothing. And it doesn’t change the fact that you’re wearing plastic and shedding it everywhere.

I long for the days of the “pure new wool” tag.

KassandraOfSparta · 14/10/2026 15:51

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

Honestly, just pass a critical eye over all your donations and make sure they are the sort of thing that is sell-able in that particular shop. Check whether they can accept things like electricals. Ask for policies about things like bike helmets, baby cots, stair gates. Phone ahead of time if you have anything really bulky - the last place I volunteered the back shop was tiny, we had three play gyms donated in the same afternoon and could not move. Don't donate Christmas decorations in February or very summery things in November.

But sounds like you are a brilliant donor!

ShanghaiDiva · 14/10/2026 15:57

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

Give us a ring to check we are accepting the items you want to donate eg we don’t want summer clothes now as we need to store them and have limited space. Also check which day would be best for us. I know it’s a faff to check but we really do appreciate it.
Your other suggestions are ideal!

ShanghaiDiva · 14/10/2026 16:06

We do also receive some fabulous donations: - beautifully washed and ironed clothing, items with tags on, books in pristine condition, complete jigsaws and clean saucepans which will sell as soon as they hit the shop floor.
I sort the books and it brings me joy when I receive a large bag of books and sell some of them the same afternoon.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 16:11

BadSkiingMum · 14/10/2026 14:49

Regarding renting a warehouse it doesn’t take account of the huge variation within the sector. There are huge charities that run enormous chains of shops; there are small charities that run one shop. Yes, they may have a volunteer who is happy to upload items onto EBay but three months pass and that volunteer has an operation or moves away so it all grinds to a halt.

However, a lot of charities are very slick operations and know exactly what works in their charity shops, which is to make money for the charity. This may be a cheap-fast-turnover model or a high-quality-boutique model, and it may not overlap with exactly what a random customer wants to see. There will be problems, as described in the article, but if the model is profitable then they will continue.

In the vast majority of cases the ideas of preventing waste and providing low cost items for people in the local community are just happy byproducts of raising funds for the charitable purpose.

Edited

Maybe would be good to know which shops are going to be able to get a good value for your quality donations so people don't donate used Levis only for them to get ragged? People could donate the better quality stuff to the boutiquey ones, and the run of the mill stuff to the high volume quick turnover shops.

I usually sort into a rag bag, which goes to the red cross that have asked for it, or into the big bins, and good quality stuff which goes to the small local shop.

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 16:17

I donate to a local chain which has a good quality bookshop in one town and a more boutique-y shop in a posher local village, with the others being 'regular' shops.

I think they have some capacity to move donations around (but each shop still has to store them until the van turns up to move sorted bags about).

allmycats · 14/10/2026 16:35

The shop where I volunteer had a donation today of a used toilet seat and fitting’s because, as the donor told us “we decided we needed a new one “ .
They were quite put out when we politely declined it. !’

TheSnootiestFox · 14/10/2026 16:52

I am an avid charity shopper, have been for a while. Started out of necessity when I became a single mum to two growing boys and now I admit is more environmental in motive, but its one of my favourite hobbies. I don't see the piles of tat, tbh, and I use a selection of different shops up to 50 miles apart. Last Fridays haul close to where I live included a Hobbs trench coat, Boden suede ballet flats, m and s cashmere and a Barbour jacket for DS2. The week before was a Holland Cooper top, Jigsaw silk top, a Boden shirt and a Hartwell shirt for me, then a Crew quarter zip, Crew Rugby shirt, Hackett lambswool sweater, Woolovers Aran sweater and a Howie Aran sweater for DS 2, and an Austin Reed leather jacket for DP. There was more but I can't remember 😂 Yesterday was my office day so 40 miles away and in my hours lunch I found (for me) a Poetry silk mix tweed jacket, an Orvis wool black watch and velvet jacket, a Gieves and Hawkes shirt, a Woolovers cardigan, a Bonart town and country 100% wool jumper for DS2, and also for DS2 a vintage Burberry rugby shirt and a Tommy Hilfiger rugby shirt. I would also have bought him an Ariat padded jacket (he's horsey) had I not got him the Barbour on Friday. That's in a week and a half, no tat involved and while I probably couldn't have done it if I was on the breadline, we all are spectacularly well dressed!

I wouldn't have the patience for Vinted and all that I buy the family use. Its people like me that the charities make their money from (Ive just totted up and I've spent £450 so far this month and it was around £230 last month,) not the people who buy from Shein and Temu in the first place and I most certainly don't apologise for that!

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 17:01

“Its people like me that the charities make their money from (Ive just totted up and I've spent £450 so far this month and it was around £230 last month,) not the people who buy from Shein and Temu in the first place and I most certainly don't apologise for that!”

@TheSnootiestFox I genuinely don’t understand what you mean by the above.

WearyAuldWumman · 14/10/2026 17:03

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 15:48

A donor not a volunteer, but I tend to take in a carrier bag or two at a time and ask the staff if they want X or Y at the moment (e.g. donating a lovely jumper in August might not be helpful from a storage perspective).

Appreciate this is a lot easier with a car and another reason to go into town (supermarket is next to the charity shop) so it's not lots of special trips.

I do check as well, when I hand things in.

I was put in a situation where a friend insisted that I take in some things for her. To my mind, they needed to go to the tip.

I checked with the volunteer on duty and she agreed that they could use a couple of items which were in good condition and I took the rest to the landfill section of the tip. (Lampshades.)

Wildgoat · 14/10/2026 17:06

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 17:01

“Its people like me that the charities make their money from (Ive just totted up and I've spent £450 so far this month and it was around £230 last month,) not the people who buy from Shein and Temu in the first place and I most certainly don't apologise for that!”

@TheSnootiestFox I genuinely don’t understand what you mean by the above.

I don’t understand either, or why you think anyone is asking you to apologise.

letmebetheone · 14/10/2026 17:14

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

That's a lovely question. However, what I would say is that if you are the kind of person that would ask such a question then you are already someone who would be thoughtful with donations.

In an ideal world it would be lovely if -
All donations were clean.
Toys were complete (if it had a remote control then it would be helpful if you could retrieve it from under the couch and let us have it)
Book were not written in and have no torn pages.
Clothing was actually fit to sell, if you wouldn't buy it then why would someone else.
Cd's and Dvd cases actually had the contents inside. (Linda Lovelace is not part of the Peppa Pig family)
Plates were not chipped and cups were free from tea stains. (We don't read tealeaves before selling the cups)
Saucepans had been washed after use. (You may have enjoyed the beans, we dont)
Shoes and trainers were mud free
Bedding was not stained and free of bodily fluids.
Handbags were free of dirty tissue/pills of all kind/condoms (new and used. Yes we have had both)
Heated hairbrushes were not complete with 12 months hair loss.
Children's clothes did not come complete with last nights evening meal
Tights were just disposed of at home.
Towels were actually dry
All pairs of shoes consisted of a left foot and a right foot (they always sell better in pairs)
Likewise gloves are better if you have one for each hand.
Your grandmas lamp shade may have been a favourite of hers for 40+ years. The 40+ years of dust dont help it sell.
Glasses are a bit of a niche item and not easy to sell when they have 'Brenda and Eddie Wedding Day 6th August 1972' etched on them.
Holiday souvenirs of a lady with rather large assets stood by a palm tree in Barbados is only likely to appeal to a buyer if they have actually been to Barbados (or they are very lonely)

and finally If it says 'Live Love Laugh' please just wrap it up and give it to the Mother in Law/Boss/Person who bullied you at school/Annoying nest door neighbour for Christmas.

Other than that we accept all donations gladly.

nuttymut · 14/10/2026 17:15

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 14:18

I suspect, if anything, those would get even more rubbish in them than current donations in store. You don’t have to look anyone in the eye for a donation bin, after all.

I note you also propose charities hire people to market on vinted rather than using volunteers. Would those hired for this work also be expected to sort through the stained and soiled clothes or would this remain a volunteer job? Would charities get as many volunteers if the work was solely sorting and cleaning and not partly working in a shop team and chatting to customers and donors?

Edited

No they wouldn’t . A lot of our volunteers are older ladies and some are widows . They like being on the shop floor and interacting with the customers . For some volunteers it’s more than a charity shop.

nuttymut · 14/10/2026 17:24

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

As a volunteer, I’d say you’re doing the right thing . The one thing about reusable bags is that you’re happy to leave them . Some donors bring in about 4 bags for life or plastic boxes full of donations and ask for the bags back . Fine if we’re quiet but if we’re busy we don’t have time to unload them there and then .

nuttymut · 14/10/2026 17:28

letmebetheone · 14/10/2026 17:14

That's a lovely question. However, what I would say is that if you are the kind of person that would ask such a question then you are already someone who would be thoughtful with donations.

In an ideal world it would be lovely if -
All donations were clean.
Toys were complete (if it had a remote control then it would be helpful if you could retrieve it from under the couch and let us have it)
Book were not written in and have no torn pages.
Clothing was actually fit to sell, if you wouldn't buy it then why would someone else.
Cd's and Dvd cases actually had the contents inside. (Linda Lovelace is not part of the Peppa Pig family)
Plates were not chipped and cups were free from tea stains. (We don't read tealeaves before selling the cups)
Saucepans had been washed after use. (You may have enjoyed the beans, we dont)
Shoes and trainers were mud free
Bedding was not stained and free of bodily fluids.
Handbags were free of dirty tissue/pills of all kind/condoms (new and used. Yes we have had both)
Heated hairbrushes were not complete with 12 months hair loss.
Children's clothes did not come complete with last nights evening meal
Tights were just disposed of at home.
Towels were actually dry
All pairs of shoes consisted of a left foot and a right foot (they always sell better in pairs)
Likewise gloves are better if you have one for each hand.
Your grandmas lamp shade may have been a favourite of hers for 40+ years. The 40+ years of dust dont help it sell.
Glasses are a bit of a niche item and not easy to sell when they have 'Brenda and Eddie Wedding Day 6th August 1972' etched on them.
Holiday souvenirs of a lady with rather large assets stood by a palm tree in Barbados is only likely to appeal to a buyer if they have actually been to Barbados (or they are very lonely)

and finally If it says 'Live Love Laugh' please just wrap it up and give it to the Mother in Law/Boss/Person who bullied you at school/Annoying nest door neighbour for Christmas.

Other than that we accept all donations gladly.

Can I add to check if the shop takes electricals.
Many don’t have anyone who can Pak test them .

TheSnootiestFox · 14/10/2026 18:01

OK, let me reword....

OP links to a Guardian article which states that all the best stuff goes on Vinted and apologises for doing similar which leaves Charity Shops with tat. I listed some if the really nice things I've found in Charity Shops in the past 10 days, and said that the tat is not something I recognise, said how much I've effectively given to Charity this month and last and that I obviously don't apologise for it (sort of referring to the original post.) It's me and my kind (more bothered about the environment and saving nice quality things from landfill) that also by default make money for the Charities as we don't mind spending 30 or 40 quid on one item, so maybe the issue is elsewhere with Charity Shops rather than the stock which is still good and the customers who are still willing to spend.

Floisme · 14/10/2026 18:30

TheSnootiestFox · 14/10/2026 18:01

OK, let me reword....

OP links to a Guardian article which states that all the best stuff goes on Vinted and apologises for doing similar which leaves Charity Shops with tat. I listed some if the really nice things I've found in Charity Shops in the past 10 days, and said that the tat is not something I recognise, said how much I've effectively given to Charity this month and last and that I obviously don't apologise for it (sort of referring to the original post.) It's me and my kind (more bothered about the environment and saving nice quality things from landfill) that also by default make money for the Charities as we don't mind spending 30 or 40 quid on one item, so maybe the issue is elsewhere with Charity Shops rather than the stock which is still good and the customers who are still willing to spend.

I think the op said she doesn't sell on Vinted but she buys from there and Ebay. I do that too now, although I resisted for a long time as I'd much rather see, feel and sniff my second hand clothes before I buy, or have the option to return them. (Incidentally I'd love to claim it was all totally selfless and for the good of the planet but to be frank it's also partly because I can't afford to buy the kind of clothes I like at new prices. Anyway.)

I can't speak for the op but the main reason I started using online second hand platforms is because the quality in my local charity shops - including the high end one where I've been known to pay £30+ if the item warranted it - has fallen through the floor. So good as it is to hear you're still finding good stock, your experience doesn't chime with mine at all.

SquirrelGG · 14/10/2026 20:44

Black bags are the worst as things are hidden under nice stuff but it would be impossible to refuse then as 75% of donations are in black bags.

One of the charity shops here has a note on the door saying they won't take black bags for that very reason. Of course you can refuse them, people will soon learn.

Edited to say, it doesn't appear to have affected donations. My neighbour works there one day a week and says they have more clothes than they know what to do with. They are selling all clothes for 50 cents each at the moment to get rid of them.

Peakyblinder18 · 15/10/2026 00:07

I thought charity shops were putting the best stuff online. I bought a jumper from one of them for about £7. I'd never have bought it their shop as the condition was so bad.
Bang went my theory. Sigh.

mathanxiety · 15/10/2026 02:56

Spaniels4Eva · 13/10/2026 11:54

People just think it's an easy way of dumping their unwanted tat sadly.

I wonder are a lot of people out there who are what might be called low level hoarders?

People who think every old bit of tat must have some use.

I bet their junk drawers are spectacular.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 15/10/2026 12:13

mathanxiety · 15/10/2026 02:56

I wonder are a lot of people out there who are what might be called low level hoarders?

People who think every old bit of tat must have some use.

I bet their junk drawers are spectacular.

Edited

I honestly think it’s just to assuage people’s guilt about throwing stuff out.

There have been times when I’ve been both shocked and annoyed at how things become useless simply because a small part has broken. I spent many hours trying to track down a replacement basket for my air fryer when the handle broke (after I dropped it down the stairs - long story). In the end I had to admit defeat and accept that the entire unit was useless. I think a lot of people can’t handle those feelings and think, oh, someone will be able to do something with it - and donate it!

MotherWol · 15/10/2026 12:58

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 15/10/2026 12:13

I honestly think it’s just to assuage people’s guilt about throwing stuff out.

There have been times when I’ve been both shocked and annoyed at how things become useless simply because a small part has broken. I spent many hours trying to track down a replacement basket for my air fryer when the handle broke (after I dropped it down the stairs - long story). In the end I had to admit defeat and accept that the entire unit was useless. I think a lot of people can’t handle those feelings and think, oh, someone will be able to do something with it - and donate it!

I agree, I think this is part of it. Someone commented up thread about not being able to recycle bed linen that had worn thin and ripped - in previous generations yes, that could have been down cycled into other textiles, but now there’s literally so much textile production that it genuinely is landfill rather than reclaimable. The value of rag has collapsed and the cost of labour and has skyrocketed, and landfill or even incineration are the more realistic ends for our stuff.

I understand the frustration at binning things that could be useful, but the reality is it’s not worth the cost and energy to do so, and some things really are landfill.

Londonmummy66 · 15/10/2026 13:30

MotherWol · 15/10/2026 12:58

I agree, I think this is part of it. Someone commented up thread about not being able to recycle bed linen that had worn thin and ripped - in previous generations yes, that could have been down cycled into other textiles, but now there’s literally so much textile production that it genuinely is landfill rather than reclaimable. The value of rag has collapsed and the cost of labour and has skyrocketed, and landfill or even incineration are the more realistic ends for our stuff.

I understand the frustration at binning things that could be useful, but the reality is it’s not worth the cost and energy to do so, and some things really are landfill.

That was me - I did downcycle the better bits for glass cloths and gift bags but the rest went in the dustbin as there was no other way to dispose of it so it will be in landfill. My grandmother would have sent the sheets to a little old lady to turn them sides to middle but nowadays a dry cleaner would charge more to do that than new sheets would cost (and I simply don't have the time to do it myself).

MidnightMeltdown · 15/10/2026 18:13

I think people have different standards, and are often not good at judging the ‘worth’ of items to other people.

On one hand, I’ve known people dump expensive items in the tip that others bite their arm off for. I tend to offer things on freecycle before chucking them out and am often surprised at the things people want.

At the other end of the spectrum, you have people handing their soiled broken crap over to the charity shop thinking that someone else might want it.

LathkillDale · 15/10/2026 19:01

mathanxiety · 15/10/2026 02:56

I wonder are a lot of people out there who are what might be called low level hoarders?

People who think every old bit of tat must have some use.

I bet their junk drawers are spectacular.

Edited

DH wants to keep bits of wood, broken electrical gadgets, etc “just in case”, it comes in “useful” one day. I think he’s inherited it from his parents, who lived through WW2. I ask him, who does he know that repairs old kettles, irons, etc? Nobody thinks it worth their time and effort, even if they could get the parts - in which case, he might as well throw them out!