Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Charity shops, I apologise

311 replies

thedevilinablackdress · 13/10/2026 07:56

I've loved charity shopping for over 30 years, but like many I've long mixed it with online second hand shopping.
The stories in this Guardian article are not new to those of us who've read threads on here, work in the shops or know people who do.
I never sell online myself and am a very mindful donatter, but my own eBay addiction and Vinted dabbling is contributing to this in a way.
Shops won't want to discourage donations, but it seems more push back on the mountains of crap is needed.

www.theguardian.com/fashion/2026/oct/13/people-sell-their-best-stuff-on-vinted-how-charity-shops-became-a-dumping-ground-for-unsellable-clothes

OP posts:
ShanghaiDiva · 14/10/2026 11:05

Floisme · 14/10/2026 11:00

Yes, to go back to the original Guardian article, it talks about charity shop volunteers sorting through stuff such as 'saucepans with food still in the bottom, babies’ soiled sleep-suits and used sanitary products.' I don't think this is just about recycling facilities, it's also quite simply about not being an arse.

Absolutely! I’m a volunteer and have seen all of these. 🤮
as the article says: if you wouldn’t give it to a friend, please don’t donate it.

letmebetheone · 14/10/2026 12:35

The charity shop debate can be endless. Lots of people who have no idea how much work is involved and lots of people who think all charity shops can be grouped together and run the same way.
Ours is a small local charity for a hospice and every penny really counts.
We dont have any paid staff but we have a group of 20 plus volunteers in our shop alone.
We are very cheap compared to a lot of shops, we get more donations than we can manage but I can only remember 2 times in the years I have been there when we have had to put a notice up saying 'No more please'.

Just the other side of things-
The amount of abuse we get if we refuse any items. We cant check everything as it arrives but sometimes you can see/smell things are disgusting just by looking at the tops of the bag. Black bags are the worst as things are hidden under nice stuff but it would be impossible to refuse then as 75% of donations are in black bags.

The amount of shoplifters that come in, we get crowds of people in at a time and despite always having 3 or 4 people on the shop floor there is no end to the creativity of the thieves. We do catch some and ban them from the shop but they are soon replaced by others. You honestly need eyes in the back of your head, we have (and this is usually men for some reason) some who come in, try on shoes and walk out with a new pair leaving their own (Usually crocs) behind. Same with coats, some will try on coat after coat till you are so confused that you cant remember which one they actually came in the shop wearing, then walk out again leaving a scruffy one behind.

The state of some donations- just this Monday I opened bags to find knickers with dirty panty liners still attached, the contents of someone's kitchen swing bin, 4 odd shoes??? dirty socks, dirty nappies, one bag containing a t-shirt which had been vomited on, one bag which had clearly been in someone's shed/garage with everything in it damp and stinking, a bag full of broken xmas decorations, 2 handbags with broken zips, a really nice jacket, till you found all the sticky chewing gum lining the pocket, I could go on and on.

We do not take rugs and when we refused one the customer picked it up, went back out to her car then when we were not looking she kindly left it by our door.
We are on a busy high street and when its raining the 'just eat' drivers use our shop to 'browse but never buy' whilst they wait for orders.
We sell children's clothes at 50p but the number of people who come back for a refund as 'it doesn't fit' or the little darling didn't like it!
We get abuse for refusing to barter, we are dirt cheap to start with yet you would think we are at a car boot sale sometimes.
The number of tags removed from garments, items switched on the rails in hope of getting them cheaper, the people who take tags off a size 8 ladies top and try to say it was on the childrens rail for 50p, those who ask us to reduce a £1 item because it has a loose button.

I work 7.30 till 5.30 on Mondays and other additional hours during the rest of the week.
Before we open at 9 each day we have to tidy the shop floor, sweep and mop the floor, fill up the shelves and fill and rotate stock on the rails. Within 5 mins of opening we are crowded and this is pretty much the same till mid afternoon. Then when we close at 5 there is the cashing up and banking to do.

its not all fun and trying to get the best stuff before anyone else.!

Motheranddaughter · 14/10/2026 12:51

KassandraOfSparta · 14/10/2026 10:54

Or buy a pair of jeans or dress and wear it until it absolutely falls to bits beyond repair rather than buying a new dress or pair of jeans every fortnight.

I am all for saving the planet but draw the line at wearing clothes that are falling apart

OrangeLane · 14/10/2026 12:54

SheilaFentiman · 13/10/2026 17:11

But how many people wander into a charity to spend £10 on a coffee table arty hardback? Maybe at an Oxfam or other charity bookshop, but not generally. But if they can offload ten “recent thrillers” for £2 a pop in a morning session, they can stock the shelf again for the afternoon.

Edited

This. (Not to knock the poster about the books, as I would also love to find those in a charity shop!)

But my close relative volunteers in a charity shop and is very aware of the brand and reputation of the shop. I.e. It's one of about seven in town, one of the smallest, and for some legacy reason tends to get pretty low-quality donations. Because they know this, they behave accordingly.

For example, last year (2025) they got a wedding dress that (in another charity shop) could go for £100. But no one would look in this specific one to spend that kind of money. So my relative took it home, put it on ebay, and then donated the money to the charity of her shop.

They've tried putting out the higher quality stuff before and it languishes on the rails as they don't get the customers for it. And after 2 weeks on the rails it goes to the nearby city 'headquarters' for the charity where everything sells for £1. So a few times a year it's worth someone's (very kind) time to put a few pieces online, because they wouldn't sell in store and would end up going for £1 in the city.

The shops works well. So many things priced at 50p or £1, and anything hanging around for a couple of days is quickly discounted further. They get a fair bit of traffic, but to break even they need to take in £300 a day, and often fall short.

Trappedinthecastofawhodunnit · 14/10/2026 13:09

I sort my clothes into wearable stuff that I drop off at the most expensive shop in town - they get good money for the clothes and most of my clothes are good quality, desirable brands.
The rest got to the clothing bins at the council reuse centre.

VikingLady · 14/10/2026 13:11

KassandraOfSparta · 13/10/2026 15:49

Blimey jeans are something I would pick up in a charity shop if they had them! Don't rag them for goodness sake! Get rid of some of the other tat you put out instead! This just shows that staff have no idea.

Our figures consistently showed that trousers and skirts were very slow to sell. We could sell 20 tops for every one pair of trousers, and we had decent branded trousers from Next, M&S, Zara etc. The general feeling is that people are happy to buy a dress, jacket or top but are not comfortable for whatever reason for wearing something which has been around someone else's bum and crotch. BNWT trousers sold OK. Used didn't.

As someone who buys most of my family’s clothes in charity shops, I think it’s more about the chance of it fitting. I can tell whether a top will fit by holding it up against me/them, but trousers are a complete gamble unless they are coincidentally exactly the same as a pair I already have.

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 14:08

ShanghaiDiva · 14/10/2026 11:05

Absolutely! I’m a volunteer and have seen all of these. 🤮
as the article says: if you wouldn’t give it to a friend, please don’t donate it.

I suspect no-one here would ever admit to having given this kind of item to the charity shop, but I genuinely wonder what goes through the minds of people who do. I can sort of understand a bag of rubbish getting mixed up with the donations now and then, but really, what are people thinking?

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:13

SheilaFentiman · 13/10/2026 13:07

@Sunbringer if they closed the shops, where would the donations to sell on Vinted come into their systems?

BHF has an eBay shop as well as retail, which makes sense as they accept large items like furniture. but they will also do pick ups and house clearances etc so that's their 'supply' route.

Donation bins.

Cadeaukatze · 14/10/2026 14:13

Floisme · 14/10/2026 11:00

Yes, to go back to the original Guardian article, it talks about charity shop volunteers sorting through stuff such as 'saucepans with food still in the bottom, babies’ soiled sleep-suits and used sanitary products.' I don't think this is just about recycling facilities, it's also quite simply about not being an arse.

Yes and although I am one of the people who complains about bins and recycling bins not being emptied often enough, it did (rather belatedly) occur to me that people are filling the bins with tat as well. So I come along with some books and I can't get them in because people have stuck old pots and pans in there or something but you can't see because of the design of the containers.

Agree we should buy less and use what we have until it wears out. I have a few tops now that I bought a year or so ago and I just don't like them. But I will keep them now and wear them under jumpers in the winter, then I don't need to worry about (a) not liking them and (b) how to get rid of them!

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 14:18

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:13

Donation bins.

I suspect, if anything, those would get even more rubbish in them than current donations in store. You don’t have to look anyone in the eye for a donation bin, after all.

I note you also propose charities hire people to market on vinted rather than using volunteers. Would those hired for this work also be expected to sort through the stained and soiled clothes or would this remain a volunteer job? Would charities get as many volunteers if the work was solely sorting and cleaning and not partly working in a shop team and chatting to customers and donors?

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:20

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 14:18

I suspect, if anything, those would get even more rubbish in them than current donations in store. You don’t have to look anyone in the eye for a donation bin, after all.

I note you also propose charities hire people to market on vinted rather than using volunteers. Would those hired for this work also be expected to sort through the stained and soiled clothes or would this remain a volunteer job? Would charities get as many volunteers if the work was solely sorting and cleaning and not partly working in a shop team and chatting to customers and donors?

Edited

You’d centralise to cheaper properties and have sorting stations and sellers. Far far cheaper to rent a central warehouse for this and hire a few people to do it than pay high street rents with hired managers and dozens of volunteers.

Charities are trying to make money not provide a place for volunteers to chat.

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 14:24

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:20

You’d centralise to cheaper properties and have sorting stations and sellers. Far far cheaper to rent a central warehouse for this and hire a few people to do it than pay high street rents with hired managers and dozens of volunteers.

Charities are trying to make money not provide a place for volunteers to chat.

Edited

Far far cheaper to rent a central warehouse for this and hire a few people to do it than pay high street rents with hired managers and dozens of volunteers.

Maybe. Do you have figures? Don't forget commercial transport costs to get the bins of donations to the central warehouse.

BTW, I'm not suggesting that charity shops are 'a place for people to chat' - but any body (scouts, marching band etc) that relies on volunteers to run has to have a mind to the volunteer experience.

Whatalunatic · 14/10/2026 14:31

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:20

You’d centralise to cheaper properties and have sorting stations and sellers. Far far cheaper to rent a central warehouse for this and hire a few people to do it than pay high street rents with hired managers and dozens of volunteers.

Charities are trying to make money not provide a place for volunteers to chat.

Edited

around me a number of charities have very large outlets on industrial estates or large shop estates that are out of town. These are great if you have a car - absolutely love a trip out to these, takes all day for a good rummage! Not so much if you are reliant on (non-existent) public transport or have to walk. I suspect many people who need them from a pricing point of view will be struggling to make the use of them they might have done whilst they were on the high street. I don't know what the answer is - I can't bear the idea of the charity shops disappearing - but I am not sure the out of town model will be the answer in all cases.

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:34

Whatalunatic · 14/10/2026 14:31

around me a number of charities have very large outlets on industrial estates or large shop estates that are out of town. These are great if you have a car - absolutely love a trip out to these, takes all day for a good rummage! Not so much if you are reliant on (non-existent) public transport or have to walk. I suspect many people who need them from a pricing point of view will be struggling to make the use of them they might have done whilst they were on the high street. I don't know what the answer is - I can't bear the idea of the charity shops disappearing - but I am not sure the out of town model will be the answer in all cases.

No shoppers would be attending them… they are for online selling.

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:34

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 14:24

Far far cheaper to rent a central warehouse for this and hire a few people to do it than pay high street rents with hired managers and dozens of volunteers.

Maybe. Do you have figures? Don't forget commercial transport costs to get the bins of donations to the central warehouse.

BTW, I'm not suggesting that charity shops are 'a place for people to chat' - but any body (scouts, marching band etc) that relies on volunteers to run has to have a mind to the volunteer experience.

Edited

No I don’t have the figures this isn’t a final business plan this is an online chat forum.

Whatalunatic · 14/10/2026 14:41

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:34

No shoppers would be attending them… they are for online selling.

ah, with you. Still don't like it. I don't tend to buy secondhand online - had too many issues. I use Vinted and ebay for new with tags/new without tags but charity shops and car boots for second hand so I can see what I'm paying for. I don't like the add on costs when buying secondhand - usually it's more expensive than I'm prepared to pay. It's not about me, but this isn't a model that would work for me and I suspect many others. I would withdraw from second hand and just seek out cheaper new stuff. And that's a shame because I at least rescue some stuff from landfill!

There are no easy answers. Maybe the carboots would be better if there were no charity shops....that would work for me!

BadSkiingMum · 14/10/2026 14:49

Regarding renting a warehouse it doesn’t take account of the huge variation within the sector. There are huge charities that run enormous chains of shops; there are small charities that run one shop. Yes, they may have a volunteer who is happy to upload items onto EBay but three months pass and that volunteer has an operation or moves away so it all grinds to a halt.

However, a lot of charities are very slick operations and know exactly what works in their charity shops, which is to make money for the charity. This may be a cheap-fast-turnover model or a high-quality-boutique model, and it may not overlap with exactly what a random customer wants to see. There will be problems, as described in the article, but if the model is profitable then they will continue.

In the vast majority of cases the ideas of preventing waste and providing low cost items for people in the local community are just happy byproducts of raising funds for the charitable purpose.

Floisme · 14/10/2026 15:02

But isn't the key point of that Guardian article that sorters are so overwhelmed by soiled, unusable tat that they're struggling to get to the sellable donations? I'm not seeing how the online warehouse model would address that? In fact I can imagine it making things worse as donors might be even more anonymous than they are now. One advantage of car boot and yard sales is that sellers have to literally stand behind their stuff and tell you how much they want for it.

KassandraOfSparta · 14/10/2026 15:05

Floisme · 14/10/2026 15:02

But isn't the key point of that Guardian article that sorters are so overwhelmed by soiled, unusable tat that they're struggling to get to the sellable donations? I'm not seeing how the online warehouse model would address that? In fact I can imagine it making things worse as donors might be even more anonymous than they are now. One advantage of car boot and yard sales is that sellers have to literally stand behind their stuff and tell you how much they want for it.

Agree. A couple of the charities near me have taken over large warehouse style shops, the local Salvation Army has a couple - one in a shop which used to be a sofa shop and is cavernous. Outside they have donations bins for when they're closed. Given the absence of local council recycling or tips, it's the easy option.

It's not that charities are being overwhelmed with amazing things theyt haven't time to process, it's that only 20% of donations are fit for sale in the first place.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 15:36

Seymour5 · 14/10/2026 10:54

Agreed! I’ve been a volunteer in the same shop for over 10 years, and have seen a huge difference in donations. We get far more, but the % of saleable clothing has plummeted.

We’d perhaps put on a display of denim if we had too many good pieces, they wouldn’t be ragged. We try not to leave anything on display for more than two or three weeks. I read the article in the Guardian, it reinforced all our experiences.

Edited

There's a woman who blogs about clothing quality, and iirc her posts have discussed a drop in quality overall throughout the sector, including what are positioned as 'quality' end of the market. For example, the creation of 'new' fabrics which are just really new ways of describing plastic, i.e., 'cashmink'.

It's really interesting, I'll see if I can find it.

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 15:37

Might have been this woman, not sure:

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/19/garment-quality-not-the-same-why-closet-clinic

'Mass production and synthetic materials are so pervasive it’s increasingly difficult to buy well-made clothes, no matter how much you are willing to spend.
“Fast fashion has normalised cheaper methods and fabrics,”'

‘One size fits nobody’: markers of high-quality clothing are getting harder to find

From poorly finished seams to an over-reliance on elastane, cost-cutting in the manufacturing process is leading to less comfortable, less durable clothing

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/19/garment-quality-not-the-same-why-closet-clinic

ArabellaScott · 14/10/2026 15:38

'... In 1975 fabrics derived from fossil fuels like polyester, nylon and acrylic represented just 30% of the global fibre market. In 2021, that figure was 64%. By comparison in 2021, wool represented just 1% of the global fibre market and silk was just under 0.2%, although the total production of most fibres has increased significantly in that time.'

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 15:40

Sunbringer · 14/10/2026 14:34

No I don’t have the figures this isn’t a final business plan this is an online chat forum.

Sure, but you are asserting it's far, far cheaper, so I wondered if that was based on anything.

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

SheilaFentiman · 14/10/2026 15:48

MotherWol · 14/10/2026 15:45

Also, for the charity shop volunteers here, what can we as donors do to make your life easier? I try to put donations in reusable bags rather than bin bags so a) you can see it's not literal trash and b) use the bag, and also group stuff by type (all books together, clothes, toys) to make sorting easier, and do a recce first to make sure the shop sells the type of thing I'm donating (not all do children's stuff). What else can we do to make the sorting experience easier?

A donor not a volunteer, but I tend to take in a carrier bag or two at a time and ask the staff if they want X or Y at the moment (e.g. donating a lovely jumper in August might not be helpful from a storage perspective).

Appreciate this is a lot easier with a car and another reason to go into town (supermarket is next to the charity shop) so it's not lots of special trips.

Swipe left for the next trending thread