I would just keep the sample and try it again in warmer weather. There are two from my BDK set that need that for certain and potentially 3rd. Villa Neroli - I am not biggest Neroli fan as it is but there is no hope I want to smell it right now, better chance in the summer. 312 Saint Honore - love the scent but I feel I will appreciate better in the late spring/summer. And maybe even Bouquet de Hongrie - right up my alley most of the year between October and 1st of January - I prefer stronger scents and only choose that type due to being office appropriate.
Gypsy Water Byredo sample/Commodity Gold for me today. They are supposed to be very similar. I have 30ml of commodity gold - need to decide keep or sell/gift. I also have 20ml Tocca Colette similar vibe
@QueefofSheena trying to go over what I have and having the goal of no more than 4 fragrances in one year (started 1st of October, one month down!) will help me buy less and think more before buying but bundles are hard to resist. The sample sets I will test one a month max, and will try to get 10ml travel or decant if I want something and only after that consider full size.
My BDK likes from least to best - top 5 could change.
Pas Ce Soir extrait -> Pas Ce Soir -> Nuit De Sable -> Tubéreuse Impériale -> Creme de Cuir ->Vila Neroli -> Rouge Smoking -> Velvet Tonka -> 312 Saint Honore -> Bouquet De Hongrie ->Gris Charnel Extrait -> Vanille Leather -> Gris Charnel
I have not tried Rouge Smoking Extrait and to be fair, apart from the bottom few that are just too busy for me I like all. I will likely get few 10ml at some point. In September I tested the female Parfums de Marley sample set plus few extra they send with the order and there was only one that appealed, I think they are more polarising.
My November sample set is Sana Jardin.