I think the problem is I want lots of bags.
I want something that's eveningy without being too posh (which I think the lilly works in).
I want casual but not too big. And then I'm still drawn to massive shoulder distroying totes - and yes I could just not pack a tonne of stuff in them, but I never do, the bigger the bag, the more I carry and the more the physio shakes her head at my inability to help myself...
The croc makeup bag would work really well as a clutch. And if you have things like a big beach bag in the summer, help to have your important stuff together in it as an insert so you aren't scrambling around the bottom of it trying to find your keys/lip barm and you can just grab the insert with valuables in when you walk away from your sunlounger. (A dear friend taught me this on holidays, after watching me not being able to find the room key card in a massive beach bag)