It's not because he can't budget though.
Ben and Sarah live together. Ben earns 4k.. Sarah earns 3k. Their bills are £2000 a month. Because of their income, they split those bills 60/40. Ben pays £1200, Sarah £800. Sarah has £2,200 left and Ben £2,800.
Sarah's two kids move in and the bills go up to £2600. They then split this ,60/40. Sarah pays an extra £240 and Ben pays £360. Sarah's "leftover" is now £1960, Ben's, £2,440.
Sarah then receives £600 CMS for the kids in the household. She puts "a bit' in, say £200. She keeps the rest. Sarah's leftover is now £2,360. And she's reduced Ben's contribution to her kids by £200.. His leftover is now £2,640.
Ben then has to pay £700 CMS, and this comes out of his °leftover.^ So now Sarah has £2,360 and Ben has £1,940. £160 of that paying for Sarah's kids while she banks the CMS. Then tells him he should have saved better, when she's used that to buy things for her kids alone.
What should happen is:
Sarah gets £3,000. Plus £600 CMS.
Ben gets £3,300 after his CMS.
The bills of £2,600, Sarah pays in her £600 of CMS. That's literally what she's being paid it for. Her kids expenses while they are with her.
The bills are now £2,000. And the corrected income figures are still with Ben paying more, but at 53/47 not the distorted 60/40 plus a chunk for Sarah's kids. Ben pays £1,060. Sarah pays £940. Ben has £2,240 left over. Sarah has £2,060.
Sarah needs to save from that £2060, not pocket £300 off Ben by making him pay for her kids whilst banking the CMS, and by overstating his household income to include the CMS sent straight to another household.
Suddenly Ben isn't a "crap dad" who can't save. Ben has been overpaying £300 every single month into the household pot. If Sarah returned the £3,600 of Ben's money she's pocketed just in 12mths some, he can more than afford his kids presents.
Interesting to see what Sarah puts away for savings once she's actually paying her way for her and her children.