Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Partner says I’m favouring my own children over his because I’ve spent more on their Christmas presents

410 replies

LadyShade · 12/10/2026 18:05

Been with DP just over 3 years and living together about 14 months. Between us we have 4 DC, mine are 13 and 8 and his are 15 and 10. His girls are with us alternate weekends and some of the holidays.

Weve always mainly sorted presents for our own children ourselves. I usually spend around £250 each on mine for Christmas, thats including their stockings and bits, and DP spends about £100-125 on each of his. I earn a bit less than him on paper some months but I do more hours than I used to and have been putting money away since the summer. Im not saying everyone should spend that much btw, its just what I budget for and I dont go into debt over it.

This is the first year all 4 will be here Christmas morning and his girls are staying Christmas Eve too. Ive bought them both a little Christmas eve box because I do them for my two and didnt want them to be the only ones without one. I havent bought their main presents because DP usually does that and we hadnt discussed doing it differently this year.

He saw some of the stuff Ive bought for mine at the weekend and asked what I was getting the girls. I said I wasnt, not their main presents anyway, and he got a bit funny about it. He says its going to look awful if mine have loads to open and his have hardly anything and that I should spend less on mine so we can make it fair between all 4. I said he can spend what he can afford on his girls but I dont see why mine should get less when Ive saved for it all year.

I do get that it could look a bit rubbish on Christmas morning if theres a massive difference, and I dont want them to feel like theyre less important. But they also get presents at their mums and from her family, same as mine get things from their dad. DP says thats not the point and that we are meant to be one family now. I said we are one family but that doesnt mean I suddenly have to pay for all their presents as well.

I did say maybe if he started putting money aside earlier he wouldnt be in this position, which I admit was a bit harsh as I know money is tighter for him with maintenance and his car. He said Ive made him feel like a crap dad and that I clearly dont see his girls as my family.

I dont know if Im being unreasonable here. I dont want the girls to feel left out but I also dont think its fair to cut back on my own kids presents to make up the difference. What would you do?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 11:38

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:38

It's not because he can't budget though.

Ben and Sarah live together. Ben earns 4k.. Sarah earns 3k. Their bills are £2000 a month. Because of their income, they split those bills 60/40. Ben pays £1200, Sarah £800. Sarah has £2,200 left and Ben £2,800.

Sarah's two kids move in and the bills go up to £2600. They then split this ,60/40. Sarah pays an extra £240 and Ben pays £360. Sarah's "leftover" is now £1960, Ben's, £2,440.

Sarah then receives £600 CMS for the kids in the household. She puts "a bit' in, say £200. She keeps the rest. Sarah's leftover is now £2,360. And she's reduced Ben's contribution to her kids by £200.. His leftover is now £2,640.

Ben then has to pay £700 CMS, and this comes out of his °leftover.^ So now Sarah has £2,360 and Ben has £1,940. £160 of that paying for Sarah's kids while she banks the CMS. Then tells him he should have saved better, when she's used that to buy things for her kids alone.

What should happen is:

Sarah gets £3,000. Plus £600 CMS.
Ben gets £3,300 after his CMS.

The bills of £2,600, Sarah pays in her £600 of CMS. That's literally what she's being paid it for. Her kids expenses while they are with her.

The bills are now £2,000. And the corrected income figures are still with Ben paying more, but at 53/47 not the distorted 60/40 plus a chunk for Sarah's kids. Ben pays £1,060. Sarah pays £940. Ben has £2,240 left over. Sarah has £2,060.

Sarah needs to save from that £2060, not pocket £300 off Ben by making him pay for her kids whilst banking the CMS, and by overstating his household income to include the CMS sent straight to another household.

Suddenly Ben isn't a "crap dad" who can't save. Ben has been overpaying £300 every single month into the household pot. If Sarah returned the £3,600 of Ben's money she's pocketed just in 12mths some, he can more than afford his kids presents.

Interesting to see what Sarah puts away for savings once she's actually paying her way for her and her children.

I think this is a really good illustration (although I would aay the £600 CMS received by Sarah doesn't necessarily need to go just on household bills - a big chunk of it yes, but she would be entitled to treat some of it as paying for the kids clothes and clubs and toys etc. if these aren't included in the household expenses).

I would say though, I think some of your posts have been a little unfair to OP in assuming she is knowingly underpaying. As I've said in my previous posts, it sounds like OP and her DP thought they were doing things fairly - so both have been a bit naive and not appreciated the wider financial picture with the CMS. Hopefully this thread has prompted her to have a conversation with her DP.

Equally, all the posters who have started assuming hes probably spending too much on an expensive car, and that she's probably doing all the housework so shouldn't have to pay, are making a lot of unfair assumptions about her DP.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 12:23

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 11:38

I think this is a really good illustration (although I would aay the £600 CMS received by Sarah doesn't necessarily need to go just on household bills - a big chunk of it yes, but she would be entitled to treat some of it as paying for the kids clothes and clubs and toys etc. if these aren't included in the household expenses).

I would say though, I think some of your posts have been a little unfair to OP in assuming she is knowingly underpaying. As I've said in my previous posts, it sounds like OP and her DP thought they were doing things fairly - so both have been a bit naive and not appreciated the wider financial picture with the CMS. Hopefully this thread has prompted her to have a conversation with her DP.

Equally, all the posters who have started assuming hes probably spending too much on an expensive car, and that she's probably doing all the housework so shouldn't have to pay, are making a lot of unfair assumptions about her DP.

Yes as long as she's covering all their household bills she can definitely use any CMS excess for their savings/extra clubs etc.

I agree I don't think OP necessarily knew she was underpaying. Maybe a little way in she cottoned on that she was quids in every month so kept quiet. Either way she knows it's the case now. Her initial response was that they should maybe take a look at it, but as the thread progressed her response was to try and excuse her underpayments, rather than acknowledge it's effectively his money she's been pocketing then bought her kids presents from.

She's then told him he should have saved better. Ouch. If he sits down and does the maths, she probably owes him a lot back. I think her best bet is to draw out some of these "savings" and give the money back to get his kids presents from. Then have a chat about how finances will be more fairly calculated going forwards and hope he doesn't want to backdate that. Hopefully that would settle the situation, if she keeps arguing that it's down to her ability to save and budget, and refuses to reimburse at least to the value of his kids presents, it may well result in a bigger argument where he wants all his money back.

She doesn't mention what she drives. Maybe she's got her own paid up car. He pays his separately to the household bills, so neither affects the other financially.

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 14:19

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 10:41

Ahhh just seen you doing the same to people on another thread.

I wish you well.

Pretty sure you stalking my previous posts is against mumsnet rules. But how you must be to waste your time searching and reading them

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 14:24

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 21:36

I wonder why this has hit such a nerve with you.

Same set up at home?

Ironically it’s obviously you that this thread has hit a nerve with as you are getting your knickers in. such a knot over it.

FayeMumsnet · 17/10/2026 14:44

Hi everyone.

We're taking a look at this thread and can see that several exchanges have moved away from the OP's topic and into personal disagreements. This makes the thread harder for other users to follow and participate in. Please report any posts you believe breach our Talk Guidelines and leave the moderation to us, rather than continuing the argument on the thread.

Best wishes,
Faye
MNHQ.

kkloo · 17/10/2026 17:41

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:38

It's not because he can't budget though.

Ben and Sarah live together. Ben earns 4k.. Sarah earns 3k. Their bills are £2000 a month. Because of their income, they split those bills 60/40. Ben pays £1200, Sarah £800. Sarah has £2,200 left and Ben £2,800.

Sarah's two kids move in and the bills go up to £2600. They then split this ,60/40. Sarah pays an extra £240 and Ben pays £360. Sarah's "leftover" is now £1960, Ben's, £2,440.

Sarah then receives £600 CMS for the kids in the household. She puts "a bit' in, say £200. She keeps the rest. Sarah's leftover is now £2,360. And she's reduced Ben's contribution to her kids by £200.. His leftover is now £2,640.

Ben then has to pay £700 CMS, and this comes out of his °leftover.^ So now Sarah has £2,360 and Ben has £1,940. £160 of that paying for Sarah's kids while she banks the CMS. Then tells him he should have saved better, when she's used that to buy things for her kids alone.

What should happen is:

Sarah gets £3,000. Plus £600 CMS.
Ben gets £3,300 after his CMS.

The bills of £2,600, Sarah pays in her £600 of CMS. That's literally what she's being paid it for. Her kids expenses while they are with her.

The bills are now £2,000. And the corrected income figures are still with Ben paying more, but at 53/47 not the distorted 60/40 plus a chunk for Sarah's kids. Ben pays £1,060. Sarah pays £940. Ben has £2,240 left over. Sarah has £2,060.

Sarah needs to save from that £2060, not pocket £300 off Ben by making him pay for her kids whilst banking the CMS, and by overstating his household income to include the CMS sent straight to another household.

Suddenly Ben isn't a "crap dad" who can't save. Ben has been overpaying £300 every single month into the household pot. If Sarah returned the £3,600 of Ben's money she's pocketed just in 12mths some, he can more than afford his kids presents.

Interesting to see what Sarah puts away for savings once she's actually paying her way for her and her children.

Well we can all make up imaginary figures if we wanted to but really not sure how you think that proves your point.

We don't know if he is able to budget or not from the information given, and you making up imaginary figures doesn't help anyone to know if he is able to budget.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 17:59

kkloo · 17/10/2026 17:41

Well we can all make up imaginary figures if we wanted to but really not sure how you think that proves your point.

We don't know if he is able to budget or not from the information given, and you making up imaginary figures doesn't help anyone to know if he is able to budget.

They are figures based on what she's said. Him a bit higher than her. Then split the bills on that. You do get that you can pick any figures you like as long as he's earning more and you don't deduct his CMS, right?

He earns a bit more. So whether you call it £4k and £3k, or £3k and £2.5k it matters not. The end result will always be that he overpays. Could be £300. Or £220. Or £450? Makes no odds. He's overpaying.

They don't account for her kids being resident when splitting bills in proportion to income. They don't deduct his CMS when calculating his income. She only pays in a bit of her CMS then banks the rest.

What part of that do you believe is imaginary? It's all from OP. Do you not get that if he pays 60% or 72% or 59% of the bills, based on £4k, £3k or £9k, if the % is calculated before taking out his CMS then he's overpaying.

So, when you can't see how it "proves my point" ....um.... it's black and white maths 🤷

kkloo · 17/10/2026 18:12

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 17:59

They are figures based on what she's said. Him a bit higher than her. Then split the bills on that. You do get that you can pick any figures you like as long as he's earning more and you don't deduct his CMS, right?

He earns a bit more. So whether you call it £4k and £3k, or £3k and £2.5k it matters not. The end result will always be that he overpays. Could be £300. Or £220. Or £450? Makes no odds. He's overpaying.

They don't account for her kids being resident when splitting bills in proportion to income. They don't deduct his CMS when calculating his income. She only pays in a bit of her CMS then banks the rest.

What part of that do you believe is imaginary? It's all from OP. Do you not get that if he pays 60% or 72% or 59% of the bills, based on £4k, £3k or £9k, if the % is calculated before taking out his CMS then he's overpaying.

So, when you can't see how it "proves my point" ....um.... it's black and white maths 🤷

Edited

OP already said he pays more so I'm not sure why you think you need to prove that to anyone or solve a maths problem that no one needed to be solved.

You used your example to prove that it's not that he can't budget, which we cannot tell at all from any imaginary figures or what OP has said and it's certainly not proven by you claiming that if he paid less then he could budget..

Maybe he could easily budget but he just doesn't. Maybe even if he wasn't paying a bit more he still wouldn't be better at budgeting. We simply don't know and applying imaginary numbers and saying he'd have X amount more doesn't prove anything about his ability to budget.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 18:20

kkloo · 17/10/2026 18:12

OP already said he pays more so I'm not sure why you think you need to prove that to anyone or solve a maths problem that no one needed to be solved.

You used your example to prove that it's not that he can't budget, which we cannot tell at all from any imaginary figures or what OP has said and it's certainly not proven by you claiming that if he paid less then he could budget..

Maybe he could easily budget but he just doesn't. Maybe even if he wasn't paying a bit more he still wouldn't be better at budgeting. We simply don't know and applying imaginary numbers and saying he'd have X amount more doesn't prove anything about his ability to budget.

Edited

FML.

It's literally maths. If you don't deduct something, and split at that point, the outcome is always the same. He's overpaying. She's saving that amount because he's paying it for her.

I can't make it any simpler for you.

The amount he's overpaying seems to be really important to you for some reason.

Whatever he's overpaying would cover his kids Christmas presents, so it's not that he can't budget/save whatever word makes you understand 😁🙈🙈

kkloo · 17/10/2026 18:30

@StockingsByTheFire

You are the one who is misunderstanding here, not me.

It would only cover his kids presents if he had the ability to budget and save, which we don't know if he has, having extra money does not equate to someone being able to budget and save, having the financial resources doesn't equate to having the practical skills required. We also don't know from what was posted if he really didn't have the financial resources to save an extra £2 a week as it was. He may well have had.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 18:42

kkloo · 17/10/2026 18:30

@StockingsByTheFire

You are the one who is misunderstanding here, not me.

It would only cover his kids presents if he had the ability to budget and save, which we don't know if he has, having extra money does not equate to someone being able to budget and save, having the financial resources doesn't equate to having the practical skills required. We also don't know from what was posted if he really didn't have the financial resources to save an extra £2 a week as it was. He may well have had.

Jeez.

Are you genuinely trying to say that despite the fact OP has been pocketing his overpayment, so he couldn't have saved it, that it doesn't matter because he could have spent it all on...fuck knows what.

So it's irrelevant that she's got his money, right now, that he can buy his kids presents from, banked for her own kids. The real issue is that he could have spent it on something else. Not that OP has been pocketing his cash, spent it on her own kids, then told him to save better 🙈😂

Rather than looking at the actual reality of her banking his money, the more reasonable stance is to say... but...but if he did have it...he might spend it all burgers and Pokémon cards, so it's not down to OP that he hasn't got money?

He has. It's literally sitting in her bank account called "savings for my kids." Think of it like she's saved it for him.

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 18:45

kkloo · 17/10/2026 18:30

@StockingsByTheFire

You are the one who is misunderstanding here, not me.

It would only cover his kids presents if he had the ability to budget and save, which we don't know if he has, having extra money does not equate to someone being able to budget and save, having the financial resources doesn't equate to having the practical skills required. We also don't know from what was posted if he really didn't have the financial resources to save an extra £2 a week as it was. He may well have had.

His ability to budget is separate to the fairness of the split of household finances though?

The information OP has given indicates that he is paying more than her towards the bills, despite her having 2 kids there far more than his 2 kids are there, and despite her receiving maintenance. By OPs own admission, she was "harsh" to tell him he should have saved more when he has maintenance and a car to pay for - which would suggest that she (who knows more about the actual figures than any of us) would consider he would have some limits on his ability to save extra towards Christmas presents.

I think you are confusing everyone with your insistence that we don't have enough information, then ignoring information given by OP and trying to make suggestions that would put her DP at fault?

Ultimately you can't have it both ways - either accept the known info and reach a view on that, or point out that there could be additional info that could shift the problem in either direction. It's unfair to tell posters they're being unfair to OP when you're being unfair to her DP - she doesn't get a free pass just because she's a woman.

kkloo · 17/10/2026 19:06

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 18:45

His ability to budget is separate to the fairness of the split of household finances though?

The information OP has given indicates that he is paying more than her towards the bills, despite her having 2 kids there far more than his 2 kids are there, and despite her receiving maintenance. By OPs own admission, she was "harsh" to tell him he should have saved more when he has maintenance and a car to pay for - which would suggest that she (who knows more about the actual figures than any of us) would consider he would have some limits on his ability to save extra towards Christmas presents.

I think you are confusing everyone with your insistence that we don't have enough information, then ignoring information given by OP and trying to make suggestions that would put her DP at fault?

Ultimately you can't have it both ways - either accept the known info and reach a view on that, or point out that there could be additional info that could shift the problem in either direction. It's unfair to tell posters they're being unfair to OP when you're being unfair to her DP - she doesn't get a free pass just because she's a woman.

Yes it is separate to it, I'm not the one who is linking them and speaking about OP like she is scum of the earth depriving him of the ability to save or budget anything because of the financial split of the bills.

I already responded on the point where she admitted it was harsh.

I've also already explained why I keep repeating that we don't have enough information and saying maybe x and y are relevant here, but of course it seems you mainly have an issue with my posts and ones similar to mine, earlier saying that people who are suggesting things about the OP are making 'unfair assumptions' while telling the poster on here who is speaking about the OP like she's scum of the earth that you think she's just being a 'little unfair'.

I think that is extremely unfair of you actually, plus you also said I accused you of being part of the pile on of the OP when I didn't at all, which you then didn't respond to,so I think you're looking at my comments and others like mine from an overly critical lens while mainly being fine about the extremely aggressive and harsh posts from another poster.

Not sure where your last sentence has come from or why you think this is because OP is a woman.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 19:16

I think you are confusing everyone with your insistence that we don't have enough information, then ignoring information given by OP and trying to make suggestions that would put her DP at fault?

@SplishSplash123 nail on the head.

I admire your perseverance 😁

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 20:00

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 19:16

I think you are confusing everyone with your insistence that we don't have enough information, then ignoring information given by OP and trying to make suggestions that would put her DP at fault?

@SplishSplash123 nail on the head.

I admire your perseverance 😁

Haha thank you, my perseverance ends here - unfortunately you can't have a reasoned debate with people who aren't prepared to work within the bounds of reason! 🙈

kkloo · 17/10/2026 20:10

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 20:00

Haha thank you, my perseverance ends here - unfortunately you can't have a reasoned debate with people who aren't prepared to work within the bounds of reason! 🙈

Or when you're not reasonable and are in fact highly biased yourself and aligned with the most aggressive person on the thread!

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 20:31

kkloo · 17/10/2026 20:10

Or when you're not reasonable and are in fact highly biased yourself and aligned with the most aggressive person on the thread!

Fine, I will try once again...
I'm not biased towards OP or her DP at all - as Ive said repeatedly, they both need to look at a fairer split of finances but I don't think either have deliberately caused the situation.

I agreed with @StockingsByTheFire on the point that the split of bills was unfair and I thought her example using illustrative figured was a very effective explanation. I didn't fully agree with her views on OP though, and I said that, so I'm not aligned with her per se - just sharing some common ground on an issue and able to discuss that with her respectfully despite holding slightly different views.

We're all allowed to have different views here, but a fair debate relies on everyone using the known facts on which to form opinions. You start with the facts and use those to form a reasonable view.

You're trying to say that OP wasnt harsh (when OP twice admitted she was - she didn't give us the info to allow us to judge whether or not she was, so we will have to take her word for it). You're going on about her DP not being able to budget and spending too much on a car - OP hasn't indicated either of those things are an issue, so they're unnecessary considerations here. Of course if there's more facts then they may be relevant, but it becomes pointless - because maybe OP smokes 40 a day and that comes out of the hosuehold bills as she buys them when she does the food shop, and maybe shes got 100k of secret savings stashed away, and maybe her ex is a millionaire and her CMS is thousands a month, and maybe DP does all the cooking and cleaning while she sits and watches TV all evening. See why it gets silly to start thinking of other possibly relevant facts?!

kkloo · 17/10/2026 20:53

SplishSplash123 · 17/10/2026 20:31

Fine, I will try once again...
I'm not biased towards OP or her DP at all - as Ive said repeatedly, they both need to look at a fairer split of finances but I don't think either have deliberately caused the situation.

I agreed with @StockingsByTheFire on the point that the split of bills was unfair and I thought her example using illustrative figured was a very effective explanation. I didn't fully agree with her views on OP though, and I said that, so I'm not aligned with her per se - just sharing some common ground on an issue and able to discuss that with her respectfully despite holding slightly different views.

We're all allowed to have different views here, but a fair debate relies on everyone using the known facts on which to form opinions. You start with the facts and use those to form a reasonable view.

You're trying to say that OP wasnt harsh (when OP twice admitted she was - she didn't give us the info to allow us to judge whether or not she was, so we will have to take her word for it). You're going on about her DP not being able to budget and spending too much on a car - OP hasn't indicated either of those things are an issue, so they're unnecessary considerations here. Of course if there's more facts then they may be relevant, but it becomes pointless - because maybe OP smokes 40 a day and that comes out of the hosuehold bills as she buys them when she does the food shop, and maybe shes got 100k of secret savings stashed away, and maybe her ex is a millionaire and her CMS is thousands a month, and maybe DP does all the cooking and cleaning while she sits and watches TV all evening. See why it gets silly to start thinking of other possibly relevant facts?!

You're biased towards people who share my opinion and have been overly critical while just saying that the other poster was a little unfair.

You even had an issue with me telling someone they weren't the authority on what is reasonable or not, when they kept saying in every comment in response to me that the OP was unreasonable. Am I supposed to bow down and accept their authority on it when I very much disagree with some of the things they were saying and when I also don't think the reasonableness could even be fully assessed from the information given. There was nothing wrong with what I said.

You're not just discussing the OP. You were specifically taking issue with my responses and what I said to people, which weren't even bad, and also imagined that I accused you of joining the pile on when I hadn't, and then to the other poster she was just being a 'little unfair'..........just a tad even though she has been speaking about the OP like she's scum of the earth.

but a fair debate relies on everyone using the known facts on which to form opinions. You start with the facts and use those to form a reasonable view.

This is how some use forums, but others use them a different way and consider the fact that information is missing and point that out. Your way isn't inherently more likely to lead to fair debate than my way, and a lot of the time when people ask obvious questions that does in fact lead to getting answers that can help people to form a more reasonable and accurate view of the situation. Of course when a pile on begins we also often never get an answer to relevant questions because the OP doesn't come back.

You're going on about her DP not being able to budget and spending too much on a car - OP hasn't indicated either of those things are an issue, so they're unnecessary considerations here.

I said that one thing doesn't prove the other, I asked questions about how much he spent on the car, to me they are necessary considerations, to you they may not be, that doesn't mean that they're unnecessary, just that you think they are, while others think otherwise.

. See why it gets silly to start thinking of other possibly relevant facts?!

I don't think it's silly at all to want to know other information that would normally be a straightforward consideration, it's normal and common to ask the obvious questions. Asking did he spend excessively on a car would be a straightforward consideration in my view and things like that, but of course there may be other things that aren't obvious questions that the OP may not volunteer and no one thinks to ask.

kkloo · 17/10/2026 21:03

What on earth did my post get deleted for?

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 23:21

kkloo · 17/10/2026 20:10

Or when you're not reasonable and are in fact highly biased yourself and aligned with the most aggressive person on the thread!

Agreed. The aggressive stance is bizarre

kkloo · 18/10/2026 06:11

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 23:21

Agreed. The aggressive stance is bizarre

Yep! My comment got reinstated anyway, not sure if someone had reported it for no reason or what......🤔

nevernotmaybe · 24/10/2026 19:24

Theunamedcat · 12/10/2026 18:14

He earns more but spends less on his children and thinks you should make up the difference?

How much is he spending on your children?

Splitting it equally means there isnt a need. Pretty basic maths.

OP is the one unbalancing the equation, and how would him spending more on the OPs balance it again? What a bizarre question.

amenabel · 24/10/2026 20:13

Why? pretty obvious to most…

RAPSMom · 24/10/2026 20:41

What are you doing New Years Eve/Day??? Could you just say to your children that things will be a little different this Christmas and they won’t get usual amount but…there’ll be presents for them New Years Eve/Day? Just a thought.

MrsE1 · 24/10/2026 22:39

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · 12/10/2026 18:12

What's he bought for your children?

That’s exactly what I thought.

Swipe left for the next trending thread