Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Partner says I’m favouring my own children over his because I’ve spent more on their Christmas presents

410 replies

LadyShade · 12/10/2026 18:05

Been with DP just over 3 years and living together about 14 months. Between us we have 4 DC, mine are 13 and 8 and his are 15 and 10. His girls are with us alternate weekends and some of the holidays.

Weve always mainly sorted presents for our own children ourselves. I usually spend around £250 each on mine for Christmas, thats including their stockings and bits, and DP spends about £100-125 on each of his. I earn a bit less than him on paper some months but I do more hours than I used to and have been putting money away since the summer. Im not saying everyone should spend that much btw, its just what I budget for and I dont go into debt over it.

This is the first year all 4 will be here Christmas morning and his girls are staying Christmas Eve too. Ive bought them both a little Christmas eve box because I do them for my two and didnt want them to be the only ones without one. I havent bought their main presents because DP usually does that and we hadnt discussed doing it differently this year.

He saw some of the stuff Ive bought for mine at the weekend and asked what I was getting the girls. I said I wasnt, not their main presents anyway, and he got a bit funny about it. He says its going to look awful if mine have loads to open and his have hardly anything and that I should spend less on mine so we can make it fair between all 4. I said he can spend what he can afford on his girls but I dont see why mine should get less when Ive saved for it all year.

I do get that it could look a bit rubbish on Christmas morning if theres a massive difference, and I dont want them to feel like theyre less important. But they also get presents at their mums and from her family, same as mine get things from their dad. DP says thats not the point and that we are meant to be one family now. I said we are one family but that doesnt mean I suddenly have to pay for all their presents as well.

I did say maybe if he started putting money aside earlier he wouldnt be in this position, which I admit was a bit harsh as I know money is tighter for him with maintenance and his car. He said Ive made him feel like a crap dad and that I clearly dont see his girls as my family.

I dont know if Im being unreasonable here. I dont want the girls to feel left out but I also dont think its fair to cut back on my own kids presents to make up the difference. What would you do?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
SplishSplash123 · 16/10/2026 20:10

kkloo · 16/10/2026 16:32

@SplishSplash123

The point is that her partner should have the same opportunity to spend on/save for his kids, if he wishes to do so.

It's possible that he did have the same opportunity to save, we just don't have all the information, did he take out a car loan that was too expensive and leave himself with little leftover? Is he really on the breadline or could he have easily saved an extra £2 a week if he wasn't wasteful? We just don't know enough information.

I actually said in my post "in the absence of further info..." so I have acknowledged we don't have all the information...

You seem quite hellbent on pushing a POV that OPs partner is at fault here. You've also told someone they're not the authority on whats reasonable, just because you disagree with them, the whole point of OPs post was to ask for other people's views...

What information is available can be seen in OPs posts:

"I did say maybe if he started putting money aside earlier he wouldnt be in this position, which I admit was a bit harsh as I know money is tighter for him with maintenance and his car."

" I dont think hes housing us though, we both live here and I pay my share of the bills. I know he has CMS to pay and his car as well which is why I said I probably shouldnt have made the comment about saving earlier."

So she has twice admitted it was "harsh" of her to say he should have saved more, which implies she knows it would be hard for him to do so. She hasn't said the car is too expensive or non-essential, its reasonable to assume that she sees the car the same as the maintenance - something that needs paying for.

OP has also said: "Maybe we should look again at how we split things, Im not saying thats off the table."

My post was trying to be fair and balanced to OP and her partner, as views here have become very polarised. I don't think anyone comes across as the villain or victim in this scenario, it's just two people who seemingly haven't found the right balance in their joint finances and need to have a chat to see if they can figure out a way forward.

kkloo · 16/10/2026 20:20

SplishSplash123 · 16/10/2026 20:10

I actually said in my post "in the absence of further info..." so I have acknowledged we don't have all the information...

You seem quite hellbent on pushing a POV that OPs partner is at fault here. You've also told someone they're not the authority on whats reasonable, just because you disagree with them, the whole point of OPs post was to ask for other people's views...

What information is available can be seen in OPs posts:

"I did say maybe if he started putting money aside earlier he wouldnt be in this position, which I admit was a bit harsh as I know money is tighter for him with maintenance and his car."

" I dont think hes housing us though, we both live here and I pay my share of the bills. I know he has CMS to pay and his car as well which is why I said I probably shouldnt have made the comment about saving earlier."

So she has twice admitted it was "harsh" of her to say he should have saved more, which implies she knows it would be hard for him to do so. She hasn't said the car is too expensive or non-essential, its reasonable to assume that she sees the car the same as the maintenance - something that needs paying for.

OP has also said: "Maybe we should look again at how we split things, Im not saying thats off the table."

My post was trying to be fair and balanced to OP and her partner, as views here have become very polarised. I don't think anyone comes across as the villain or victim in this scenario, it's just two people who seemingly haven't found the right balance in their joint finances and need to have a chat to see if they can figure out a way forward.

I'm just counteracting all the people who are hellbent on piling on even though there is a ton of missing information.

I told that poster they're not the authority on what is reasonable because in all of her comments to me they kept stating what was reasonable or not, and saying the OP was unreasonable, again even though there is a lot of missing information.

OP admitted it was harsh, doesn't mean it actually was harsh though, we see people on here all the time 'admitting' they were harsh or wrong or OTT when they weren't.

SplishSplash123 · 16/10/2026 20:21

kkloo · 16/10/2026 20:20

I'm just counteracting all the people who are hellbent on piling on even though there is a ton of missing information.

I told that poster they're not the authority on what is reasonable because in all of her comments to me they kept stating what was reasonable or not, and saying the OP was unreasonable, again even though there is a lot of missing information.

OP admitted it was harsh, doesn't mean it actually was harsh though, we see people on here all the time 'admitting' they were harsh or wrong or OTT when they weren't.

Edited

But how is my post piling onto OP?!

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 20:31

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 17:17

Are you ok?

I’m fine thanks can’t say the same about you

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 20:34

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 09:14

Of course he could.

He just didn't think he'd be told to find his own money to buy his kids the same as OP has spent out of his money on hers.

OP couldn't afford to live there without him. He can. But she thinks it's the same because she contributes towards the bills, so he "financially benefits" from her being there no more than she financially benefits. She flippantly ignores that her two children are permanently there.

Turns out, being subsided and banking your kids CMS as savings, on someone else's dollar might have just come home to roost for her. All because she's too greedy to relinquish any of that money on the children of the person who's been paying out for hers, on Christmas Day.

The OP said he COULDN’T live by himself there. Yet another scenario made up in your head

kkloo · 16/10/2026 20:46

SplishSplash123 · 16/10/2026 20:21

But how is my post piling onto OP?!

Where did I say that you were joining the pile up?

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 21:36

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 20:31

I’m fine thanks can’t say the same about you

I wonder why this has hit such a nerve with you.

Same set up at home?

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 21:37

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 20:34

The OP said he COULDN’T live by himself there. Yet another scenario made up in your head

Lol.

Try reading it properly.

Awkward.

kkloo · 16/10/2026 21:49

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 21:37

Lol.

Try reading it properly.

Awkward.

OP said I wouldnt be able to afford this house on my own with the children no, but neither would he be paying the same bills if he lived on his own so I dont think its quite as simple as saying hes subsidising us. We both benefit from living together financially.

It could be read either way but if you read and consider the paragraph properly it looks like what the OP meant was that she wouldn't be able to afford it alone but 'neither would he, he'd be paying the same bills if he lived on his own'.

The paragraph doesn't make any sense if you're taking it to mean that he could afford it, because why would she say oh I couldn't live here alone, but he could, and he wouldn't be paying the same bills either so it's not as simple as saying he's subsiding them, if she meant that he'd be paying a lot less bills then her argument saying it's not as simple to say he's subsidising her makes no sense.

Plus considering he can't save an extra £100 between now and Christmas it's hard to imagine how he could possibly afford to live there on his own.

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 21:59

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 21:37

Lol.

Try reading it properly.

Awkward.

I think that’s you who needs to read it properly. How embarrassing for you

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 22:00

kkloo · 16/10/2026 21:49

OP said I wouldnt be able to afford this house on my own with the children no, but neither would he be paying the same bills if he lived on his own so I dont think its quite as simple as saying hes subsidising us. We both benefit from living together financially.

It could be read either way but if you read and consider the paragraph properly it looks like what the OP meant was that she wouldn't be able to afford it alone but 'neither would he, he'd be paying the same bills if he lived on his own'.

The paragraph doesn't make any sense if you're taking it to mean that he could afford it, because why would she say oh I couldn't live here alone, but he could, and he wouldn't be paying the same bills either so it's not as simple as saying he's subsiding them, if she meant that he'd be paying a lot less bills then her argument saying it's not as simple to say he's subsidising her makes no sense.

Plus considering he can't save an extra £100 between now and Christmas it's hard to imagine how he could possibly afford to live there on his own.

Edited

This is exactly how I read it. No doubt there will be yet another aggressive reply

laughinglovingliving · 16/10/2026 22:24

between ages of about 9 and 18 I watched my dad and my step mother consistently favour my step/siblings. It felt completely unfair. My siblings would get brand new iPad each and I would get some awful scarf/hat combo.
Try and treat them fairly if you’re in it for long term.

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 23:26

Benjithedog · 16/10/2026 21:59

I think that’s you who needs to read it properly. How embarrassing for you

I'm sorry you have comprehension issues. I do think it's cute though, you copying what I write each time as your own "retort".

She can't afford it.

He wouldn't be paying the same bills because she chips in. What stupid reasoning 😂 Unless she totally freeloads of course she has to pay something. This isn't the same as he can't afford it without her.

She thinks it's all ok calling it how they both "financially benefit.". Totally ignoring how much less his bills would be without the three people OP's package is. He's just got himself to cover.

And as PP says, they've done their calcs all wrong. Like a childless couple. Not two resident children, two non resident, CMS coming in and CMS going out. And if OP hadn't been so greedy over this and told him to buy his own kids presents out of his money, she'd likely continue this subsided living indefinitely, not rocking the boat. But the fact she's not only squirreled (his) money away to splash out on her own kids, she's then gone on about his failings to provide for his own children, resulting in him being a "crap dad"...

He probably hadn't really registered how OP was saving each month. She's very much highlighted having a look at their finances.

kkloo · 17/10/2026 00:50

What on earth.......

Justmindingmybusiness2025 · 17/10/2026 07:55

I really feel for you and I have the same. I plan, I budget, I get deals and I by throughout the year for my kids he chooses not to and then complains mine have loads. You were kind enough to do Christmas Eve boxes. I tend to do my Christmas with my kids Christmas Day or Christmas Eve depending if they are with their dad and then we do Boxing Day with my partner when his kids come. To keep the peace I just keep the same amount of presents aside to gift mine at his x

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:38

It's not because he can't budget though.

Ben and Sarah live together. Ben earns 4k.. Sarah earns 3k. Their bills are £2000 a month. Because of their income, they split those bills 60/40. Ben pays £1200, Sarah £800. Sarah has £2,200 left and Ben £2,800.

Sarah's two kids move in and the bills go up to £2600. They then split this ,60/40. Sarah pays an extra £240 and Ben pays £360. Sarah's "leftover" is now £1960, Ben's, £2,440.

Sarah then receives £600 CMS for the kids in the household. She puts "a bit' in, say £200. She keeps the rest. Sarah's leftover is now £2,360. And she's reduced Ben's contribution to her kids by £200.. His leftover is now £2,640.

Ben then has to pay £700 CMS, and this comes out of his °leftover.^ So now Sarah has £2,360 and Ben has £1,940. £160 of that paying for Sarah's kids while she banks the CMS. Then tells him he should have saved better, when she's used that to buy things for her kids alone.

What should happen is:

Sarah gets £3,000. Plus £600 CMS.
Ben gets £3,300 after his CMS.

The bills of £2,600, Sarah pays in her £600 of CMS. That's literally what she's being paid it for. Her kids expenses while they are with her.

The bills are now £2,000. And the corrected income figures are still with Ben paying more, but at 53/47 not the distorted 60/40 plus a chunk for Sarah's kids. Ben pays £1,060. Sarah pays £940. Ben has £2,240 left over. Sarah has £2,060.

Sarah needs to save from that £2060, not pocket £300 off Ben by making him pay for her kids whilst banking the CMS, and by overstating his household income to include the CMS sent straight to another household.

Suddenly Ben isn't a "crap dad" who can't save. Ben has been overpaying £300 every single month into the household pot. If Sarah returned the £3,600 of Ben's money she's pocketed just in 12mths some, he can more than afford his kids presents.

Interesting to see what Sarah puts away for savings once she's actually paying her way for her and her children.

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:46

StockingsByTheFire · 16/10/2026 23:26

I'm sorry you have comprehension issues. I do think it's cute though, you copying what I write each time as your own "retort".

She can't afford it.

He wouldn't be paying the same bills because she chips in. What stupid reasoning 😂 Unless she totally freeloads of course she has to pay something. This isn't the same as he can't afford it without her.

She thinks it's all ok calling it how they both "financially benefit.". Totally ignoring how much less his bills would be without the three people OP's package is. He's just got himself to cover.

And as PP says, they've done their calcs all wrong. Like a childless couple. Not two resident children, two non resident, CMS coming in and CMS going out. And if OP hadn't been so greedy over this and told him to buy his own kids presents out of his money, she'd likely continue this subsided living indefinitely, not rocking the boat. But the fact she's not only squirreled (his) money away to splash out on her own kids, she's then gone on about his failings to provide for his own children, resulting in him being a "crap dad"...

He probably hadn't really registered how OP was saving each month. She's very much highlighted having a look at their finances.

Nothing wrong with my comprehension. Shame that could be said about yours.

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:48

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:38

It's not because he can't budget though.

Ben and Sarah live together. Ben earns 4k.. Sarah earns 3k. Their bills are £2000 a month. Because of their income, they split those bills 60/40. Ben pays £1200, Sarah £800. Sarah has £2,200 left and Ben £2,800.

Sarah's two kids move in and the bills go up to £2600. They then split this ,60/40. Sarah pays an extra £240 and Ben pays £360. Sarah's "leftover" is now £1960, Ben's, £2,440.

Sarah then receives £600 CMS for the kids in the household. She puts "a bit' in, say £200. She keeps the rest. Sarah's leftover is now £2,360. And she's reduced Ben's contribution to her kids by £200.. His leftover is now £2,640.

Ben then has to pay £700 CMS, and this comes out of his °leftover.^ So now Sarah has £2,360 and Ben has £1,940. £160 of that paying for Sarah's kids while she banks the CMS. Then tells him he should have saved better, when she's used that to buy things for her kids alone.

What should happen is:

Sarah gets £3,000. Plus £600 CMS.
Ben gets £3,300 after his CMS.

The bills of £2,600, Sarah pays in her £600 of CMS. That's literally what she's being paid it for. Her kids expenses while they are with her.

The bills are now £2,000. And the corrected income figures are still with Ben paying more, but at 53/47 not the distorted 60/40 plus a chunk for Sarah's kids. Ben pays £1,060. Sarah pays £940. Ben has £2,240 left over. Sarah has £2,060.

Sarah needs to save from that £2060, not pocket £300 off Ben by making him pay for her kids whilst banking the CMS, and by overstating his household income to include the CMS sent straight to another household.

Suddenly Ben isn't a "crap dad" who can't save. Ben has been overpaying £300 every single month into the household pot. If Sarah returned the £3,600 of Ben's money she's pocketed just in 12mths some, he can more than afford his kids presents.

Interesting to see what Sarah puts away for savings once she's actually paying her way for her and her children.

You really are far too invested in this thread. I suggest you step away

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:50

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:48

You really are far too invested in this thread. I suggest you step away

Lol.

You're a wee bit obsessed with me. I think it's you that needs to step away or perhaps share your comments with the thirty other people saying the same thing as me. No doubt you "can't see" any of those....

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:50

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:46

Nothing wrong with my comprehension. Shame that could be said about yours.

Edited

😂😂😂 (let me copy what she says and say "same about you")

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:51

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:50

Lol.

You're a wee bit obsessed with me. I think it's you that needs to step away or perhaps share your comments with the thirty other people saying the same thing as me. No doubt you "can't see" any of those....

Not really but your reaction and aggression to this is so staggeringly OTT is almost comical.

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:52

kkloo · 17/10/2026 00:50

What on earth.......

Agree it’s so bizarre

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:59

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 09:51

Not really but your reaction and aggression to this is so staggeringly OTT is almost comical.

Just to you

You're strangely obsessed with just me.

But that's ok.

Doesn't change the maths.

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 10:32

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 09:59

Just to you

You're strangely obsessed with just me.

But that's ok.

Doesn't change the maths.

Your comprehensive is shocking as you have taken an aggressive tone with anyone who disagrees with you. But carry on as it’s quite funny in it’s ridiculousness.

StockingsByTheFire · 17/10/2026 10:41

Benjithedog · 17/10/2026 10:32

Your comprehensive is shocking as you have taken an aggressive tone with anyone who disagrees with you. But carry on as it’s quite funny in it’s ridiculousness.

Ahhh just seen you doing the same to people on another thread.

I wish you well.