The thing is it’s not only two rapes really. The majority of their sexual interactions are non-consensual. If you know that if you say no enough times, you’ll be raped anyway, then none of those sexual experiences are really consensual because consent can’t be freely and enthusiastically given within that dynamic. Those are the incidents that stand out to Poet I think because it must be so devastating to not be able to pass things off as him having misunderstood or it being an accident or any other of the myriad of excuses she’s made for his behaviour to try to reconcile the man she thinks loves her with the way her abusive husband actually behaves and who he really is.
I think having a safe space is really important. I also think that not challenging the narrative is problematic because it’s become a way, in the past, of almost co-signing that this is all acceptable. Therapy is her safe space as I think her therapist is trying to work with her but is trapped really by the fact that she doesn’t want to leave.
In terms of what the right thing to do is, once again I don’t think OP has any intention of leaving. She has said multiple times she doesn’t want to. When she returned to him this time (having not told anyone anything!), she said she’d done so because she ‘needed’ him. She hasn’t said once throughout all of the threads that she wants to leave. What she wants is to make him change but that will never happen. And so change or progress is not possible.
Unfortunately, nobody knows about this and so nobody can safeguard her children from the emotional and psychological effects of witnessing the coercive control and the sexual dynamic.
Many women return to their abusers but if they’ve had contact with services, they will be referred on and so at least the relevant authorities are aware. It’s seen as the women’s choice to return, as adults we have autonomy and obviously you can never stop someone from returning no matter how painful it is to watch it happen. However the children don’t. They don’t have a voice and they don’t have a choice and that’s why referrals are put in place.