Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Has anyone ever offered 400k on a 500k house?

201 replies

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

OP posts:
Fair3nough · 18/11/2026 20:42

Sounds like you’re not far apart. I’d sleep on it and really crunch your numbers. Don’t overstretch yourself in this market.
i think this sounds like good news and you might be able to make a deal.

rainingsnoring · 18/11/2026 21:10

DarkForces · 18/11/2026 20:27

It sounds like it'll be an expensive house to run so you're right to think carefully. The stress of overstretching yourself is huge however gorgeous the house with. There's nothing to be done tonight though so I'd try to sleep on it. Often these things are clearer in the morning. Good luck

Yes, give yourself a little pause to think about it and don't rush in. If this house doesn't work out, spend some time doing 'market research', general house buying and economic research!

KeepPumping · 18/11/2026 22:54

PermanentTemporary · 18/11/2026 06:11

Was that an estate agent commenting? The 13% drop is a very optimistic estimate suggesting they’re trying to shore up the market, as they will do I guess.

Ive seen leasehold flats in London and local to me in the Home Counties that have eventually sold this year WAY under asking price eg on at £230k, sold at £146k.

I’ve pulled out of buying a listed house because the permissions hadn’t been obtained, so I wouldn’t continue with this purchase myself. But if you are only willing to buy a house at a particular price, by all means make the offer.

That is nice big price drops.

XVGN · 19/11/2026 08:45

TBH, there are a lot of folks who kite-fly their homes at the start then face a reality check and are willing to drop hundreds of thousands. Your offer can come just before their reality check - and win.

You can see many examples on Zoopla. Just list homes by most reduced. Here's one gone from £865K (listed last December and relisted March) to £625K (Nov) by big chunks periodically.

https://www.zoopla.co.uk/for-sale/details/72020232/?search_identifier=1feeaf571fd28b0b302c54813c89fe239cdf9984e081c7805046fe0c146ebe9e

Sheeshbee · 19/11/2026 10:10

parkezvous · 18/11/2026 07:50

Someone did this to us. Offered 350 on our 450 selling price! Was a cash buyer, house ended up being sold to FTB for 500. Even if the 350 offer had increased I wouldn’t accept, I just couldn’t sell to someone who thought that was acceptable, would have worried further down the line if they would try and reduce price.

In what year, and how long had your house been on sale?

It's obviously a context thing:

House on sale for 2 years - a low offer is very realistic.
House for sale in 2026 in a rapidly falling market with more property for sale than ever in history - a low offer is very realistic

How much depends on the local market and how expensive the house is to start with obviously, clearly 100k off a 450k house is a lot.

Sheeshbee · 19/11/2026 10:15

Alexalee · 18/11/2026 20:25

So it was more of a you can't afford it thing than actually thinking it was worth less!!
Anyhow if you do love it and can actually afford the repayments 5k is nothing in time. But to avoid a mortgage shock or negative equity I would be doing a 5 year fix if I were you

It's very much worth less if the OP can't afford it at a higher price and there are zero other bidders. Houses are worth what people are willing to pay, not a penny more.

But it's about what the house is worth to you; I've offered well under on several houses where we can easily afford the asking price, but it's obviously way above the market, way above what anything else has ever sold for on the street, and way above what it's worth to us to live there.

KeepPumping · 19/11/2026 13:44

Sheeshbee · 19/11/2026 10:15

It's very much worth less if the OP can't afford it at a higher price and there are zero other bidders. Houses are worth what people are willing to pay, not a penny more.

But it's about what the house is worth to you; I've offered well under on several houses where we can easily afford the asking price, but it's obviously way above the market, way above what anything else has ever sold for on the street, and way above what it's worth to us to live there.

Amazing that people still want to think that a house "stores value" like a bank account, it doesn"t.

MN2025 · 19/11/2026 15:44

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

It all depends on the motive of the seller and whether they are in need of a quick sale and can afford to drop.

We purchased a property to add to our BTL portfolio in around 2013 - was advertised at £155k but needed a lot of work doing to it (other houses on the street were selling for £170k at that time)
We offered £100k at first offer and it was accepted! Got lucky - renovated and rented it out for 12 years - we sold it early this year for £259k!

Tortephant · 19/11/2026 16:13

KeepPumping · 19/11/2026 13:44

Amazing that people still want to think that a house "stores value" like a bank account, it doesn"t.

So you think everyone should be reliant on the state or large corporations to provide rental accommodation and nobody should ever buy?

FruAashild · 19/11/2026 19:43

Tortephant · 19/11/2026 16:13

So you think everyone should be reliant on the state or large corporations to provide rental accommodation and nobody should ever buy?

No, she means, like the stock market, prices can go up or down.

rainingsnoring · 19/11/2026 20:16

FruAashild · 19/11/2026 19:43

No, she means, like the stock market, prices can go up or down.

That's how I would interpret it. Homes should be places to live, not investment vehicles.

KeepPumping · 19/11/2026 22:11

Tortephant · 19/11/2026 16:13

So you think everyone should be reliant on the state or large corporations to provide rental accommodation and nobody should ever buy?

People can buy if they want, they just might not get back the price they paid, that is my point, the house is valued by the market when you sell, not by how much you paid or how much you want.

Pipsquiggle · Yesterday 06:22

@Fairiesarereal345 have you got a house to sell? Are you proceedable?

If you are chain free and proceedable then that is 'worth' something.

If you love the property, losing it for £5k isn't worth it. See if they come back to you

anyolddinosaur · Yesterday 07:32

No. If the house was that over-valued I'd tell the agent that but not offer. But I've never "fallen in love with" a house, even if I've liked some.

There's quite a lot of wishful thinking on this thread. Flats are harder to dell in London but house prices, and flat prices in most areas. have not fallen by anything like the amount that would justify offering 20% less.

XVGN · Yesterday 07:35

anyolddinosaur · Yesterday 07:32

No. If the house was that over-valued I'd tell the agent that but not offer. But I've never "fallen in love with" a house, even if I've liked some.

There's quite a lot of wishful thinking on this thread. Flats are harder to dell in London but house prices, and flat prices in most areas. have not fallen by anything like the amount that would justify offering 20% less.

I gave a concrete example (see further up) of a deluded seller asking for 40% more, when they first listed, than they are now. A 20% reduction wouldn't have even touched the sides.

bringmenoodles · Yesterday 07:59

I would offer and when they most likely decline, let them know that your offer still stands if they change their mind. They might realise in a few months that they're not going to get any better offers.

We did a similar thing, but not as big of a reduction, and within a day or two they'd come back to us and said they'd accept just £5k more so we did that!

Tortephant · Yesterday 08:39

KeepPumping · 19/11/2026 22:11

People can buy if they want, they just might not get back the price they paid, that is my point, the house is valued by the market when you sell, not by how much you paid or how much you want.

yes, like any investment - risk and reward.

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:51

Tortephant · Yesterday 08:39

yes, like any investment - risk and reward.

As you think of housing as an investment, you then need to accept the risk as well as the reward and treat it more like a business transaction when you sell.

Tortephant · Yesterday 09:04

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:51

As you think of housing as an investment, you then need to accept the risk as well as the reward and treat it more like a business transaction when you sell.

exactly.

housethatbuiltme · Yesterday 17:17

We dont have that kind of money but got a 10% reduction on our house. However 10% is not an unusual amount off, many EA even price a little high due to expecting up to 10% off.

You are talking about 20% it can happen but there tends to need to be good reason for knocking 1/5th off the price. Its normally reserved for building priced quite high but with a bad structural issue etc...

Fair3nough · Yesterday 20:20

Any news @Fairiesarereal345 ?

Fairiesarereal345 · Today 08:47

Fair3nough · Yesterday 20:20

Any news @Fairiesarereal345 ?

Nope, I just emailed back the estate agent to say I needed to think about it and consider finances.

I was thinking maybe to leave it a week and then offer 445? Maybe i should leave it longer and hope they will give another counter offer, if they are so keen to move?

OP posts:
DrySherry · Today 08:49

Fairiesarereal345 · Today 08:47

Nope, I just emailed back the estate agent to say I needed to think about it and consider finances.

I was thinking maybe to leave it a week and then offer 445? Maybe i should leave it longer and hope they will give another counter offer, if they are so keen to move?

Leave it 2 weeks at least imo

rainingsnoring · Today 09:16

Fairiesarereal345 · Today 08:47

Nope, I just emailed back the estate agent to say I needed to think about it and consider finances.

I was thinking maybe to leave it a week and then offer 445? Maybe i should leave it longer and hope they will give another counter offer, if they are so keen to move?

Just leave the offer with them, move on and view other houses.
Also, do plenty of research into the housing market, etc. You've had quite a few suggestions on this thread.

KeepPumping · Today 12:59

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:51

As you think of housing as an investment, you then need to accept the risk as well as the reward and treat it more like a business transaction when you sell.

Yes, but most people can"t do that. they have been brainwashed for a couple of decades that you can"t lose with property.