Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Has anyone ever offered 400k on a 500k house?

201 replies

Fairiesarereal345 · 12/11/2026 22:34

Or other massively low offers? Any success stories?

OP posts:
ForRedPoet · 14/11/2026 10:55

bugalugs45 · 13/11/2026 17:05

There will be people that say well you have nothing to lose , but it entirely depends on your reasoning , if it’s because ‘ thats all you can afford’ then if I was the vendor I would refuse to deal with you further even if you upped
your offer as i’d have you ear marked as a piss taker & time waster .

This exactly.

Aneversolongwalk · 14/11/2026 10:57

They clearly aren’t in any rush to move if house been up since July.

And lopping off 25% would just be farcical to them I imagine

go ahead and offer and give them a giggle

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 14/11/2026 11:14

I doubt most people could afford to take that reduction, even if you offer reflects the current market. It depends when the bought and what they paid obviously but that £100k could easily be the entire equity they are planning to put into their onward purchase. We took a small reduction on our house (about £15k) but couldn’t have afforded to go lower and still have bought what we wanted in which cause we would have likely just stayed put.

You can offer what you want but I wouldn’t expect them to accept and I would actually anticipate them being offended and unwilling to entertain any counter offer on that basis

Why do you want to offer so low?

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 14/11/2026 11:19

RoseWylie · 13/11/2026 22:49

Where I live sellers are knocking hundreds of thousands off the price. There’s a house I like that was on at £1.8m. It’s now listed at £1.5m. If it drops to £1.25 I’ll offer. If not, never mind.

These days people prove they are serious by providing proof of funds. The idea that you need to do it in your offer strategy doesn’t really work in this market. Offer what you’re happy to pay. If they don’t accept, that’s up to them, but a sensible seller is grateful for all offers because they are all information. Being offended is just silly.

I do think that’s different though - you’re talking about houses in a bracket way beyond what most people can afford. £500k is a standard price for a relatively normal family home in many parts of the county and achievable for middle earners so the pool of buyers is much greater. They don’t need to accept such a low offer.

daisychain01 · 14/11/2026 13:23

Fair3nough · 14/11/2026 08:20

i don’t think offering what you can afford in this market is a lack of integrity problem. It is what it is. People can’t afford as much as they could when rates were 1-2%. Now they are 5-6% they aren’t going to give sellers as much as they can’t afford to.

you can take offence to that and say they are chancers and time wasters but the fact is the market is going down. Buyers are taking a much bigger financial risk than a few years ago. They won’t be willing to throw money at you to avoid causing you offence. In this market we all need our hard hats on sadly.

eta: I meant to quote @daisychain01

Edited

People taking a fancy to a house irrespective of the price tag need to think again. A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter.

Ideally don't set your heart on a property you dont stand a snowball's chance in hell of affording and think you can just knock £100K off because its a buyers' market, that's nuts.

If you find a property going for £500K and offer £575K where you've done your sums and your numbers add up, that's not unreasonable in the current market.

Offer £400k on a property on the market for £500k for no other reason than you can't afford the price and think it'll be accepted, and think the vendor is desperate so they'll take it, don't be surprised if your offer is declined and you're seen as a time waste

and to clarify I am not taking offence at anything, just giving a perspective. We haven't been messed around because we read the room and know the signs of someone who likes a property enough and gets into a worthwhile negotiation where both side's needs are met. To many people only think what's in it for me and not enough of what's in it for them.

FrauPaige · 14/11/2026 14:32

daisychain01 · 14/11/2026 13:23

People taking a fancy to a house irrespective of the price tag need to think again. A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter.

Ideally don't set your heart on a property you dont stand a snowball's chance in hell of affording and think you can just knock £100K off because its a buyers' market, that's nuts.

If you find a property going for £500K and offer £575K where you've done your sums and your numbers add up, that's not unreasonable in the current market.

Offer £400k on a property on the market for £500k for no other reason than you can't afford the price and think it'll be accepted, and think the vendor is desperate so they'll take it, don't be surprised if your offer is declined and you're seen as a time waste

and to clarify I am not taking offence at anything, just giving a perspective. We haven't been messed around because we read the room and know the signs of someone who likes a property enough and gets into a worthwhile negotiation where both side's needs are met. To many people only think what's in it for me and not enough of what's in it for them.

Edited

You are operating from some sort of moral code from the sounds of things. Not sure that is where the market is. People aren't even getting viewings let alone offers. I would laugh if somebody didn't want to deal with me as a investment cash buyer because I put an offer in on a property that had been sat on the market gathering dust for a year and a half. On to the next, good luck with the sale.

Conduct your research, understand why the seller is selling - some can't take the 100k hit because they are splitting and need the equity to buy a place each, for example - but if they are a motivated seller - perhaps landlord liquidating - or a distressed seller, whyever not?

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 14:46

A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter

Of course, and if they are not bothered whether they sell or not they can wait indefinitely. But I’m not sure it’s the potential buyer who is the time waster in this scenario 😉

Flyingdolphins · 14/11/2026 19:40

We offered 450 on a 500 house but also asked for the garage and outbuildings to be included which were listed separately for 25k....so I guess the equivalent of offering £75k under. Settled at 470 eventually.

Context is the house had been on the market for about 8 months and reduced a couple of times. Had not been looked after, terribly dated, damp problems etc.

Part of our offer was a promise that we wouldn't ask for more money off based on survey results as it was obvious the survey would be terrible.

daisychain01 · 14/11/2026 20:25

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 14:46

A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter

Of course, and if they are not bothered whether they sell or not they can wait indefinitely. But I’m not sure it’s the potential buyer who is the time waster in this scenario 😉

You sound very entitled, and your scenario does not equate to the vendor timewasting. I'm not sure what the passive aggressive emoji was for ,,,,

If someone puts their property on the market but doesn't get a viable offer, whose time are they wasting? Nobody's.

They advertise the price that they expect, people see the photos and decide if they want to view and if they think the property price is acceptable.

It's in the gift of the vendor to keep the property on the market until they get an acceptable offer for it. If people make unacceptably low offers, the vendor is not legally obliged to sell it to them. If they make a reasonable offer, then they have a deal.

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 21:32

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 14:46

A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter

Of course, and if they are not bothered whether they sell or not they can wait indefinitely. But I’m not sure it’s the potential buyer who is the time waster in this scenario 😉

This is either very naive or totally arrogant. Either way very misplaced and I won’t be selling to you.

Pipsquiggle · 14/11/2026 21:35

@Fairiesarereal345 you need to find out if they have had any offers and whether they've been rejected.
Can you find out the position of the sellers e.g. they need to sell quick and for x amount for them to get a forward purchase or they are in no hurry?

Ideally you don't want to be the first potential buyer to give a lowball offer, this will probably piss them off and entrench their position

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 22:05

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 21:32

This is either very naive or totally arrogant. Either way very misplaced and I won’t be selling to you.

This is a very emotional response to something that it’s better to keep emotions out of if you can.

People can offer what they like. You can accept or decline, your choice. Getting cross because the market price for your house is lower than you would like is at best a waste of emotional energy, at worst a good way to waste money.

If you are wise you will welcome every offer as a data point- not because you have to accept it but because it’s a rare bit of information specific to your house. If you are foolish you will have an emotional response, blame it on personalities and ignore the information. All of this is completely within your control.

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 22:28

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 22:05

This is a very emotional response to something that it’s better to keep emotions out of if you can.

People can offer what they like. You can accept or decline, your choice. Getting cross because the market price for your house is lower than you would like is at best a waste of emotional energy, at worst a good way to waste money.

If you are wise you will welcome every offer as a data point- not because you have to accept it but because it’s a rare bit of information specific to your house. If you are foolish you will have an emotional response, blame it on personalities and ignore the information. All of this is completely within your control.

Thanks for clarifying arrogant was the word I needed.

Zero emotion, anger or blame in my world, I deal with facts and people. You are correct with it all being in the sellers control, thanks for backing my point about not selling to somebody like you.

RoseWylie · 14/11/2026 22:41

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 22:28

Thanks for clarifying arrogant was the word I needed.

Zero emotion, anger or blame in my world, I deal with facts and people. You are correct with it all being in the sellers control, thanks for backing my point about not selling to somebody like you.

I am at a loss as to what you could find arrogant about the idea that people can offer what they like and you can accept or decline, but good luck with it all.

TediousTim · 14/11/2026 22:42

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 13/11/2026 07:39

That depends, if the surveyor discovered an issue that isn't easily visible then the estate agent wouldn't have reflected that in the original price.
If the sales details had stated that it required substantial roof repairs then that would have been reflected in the sales price.

And this is exactly where we are at. There are other issues with the property that were flagged on the survey too - the roof (the problems with which can only be viewed from inside the loft) is the biggest, but not the least.

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 22:47

TediousTim · 14/11/2026 22:42

And this is exactly where we are at. There are other issues with the property that were flagged on the survey too - the roof (the problems with which can only be viewed from inside the loft) is the biggest, but not the least.

It’s a period listed property: unless you used a specific heritage surveyor with era specific understanding then your survey will not be informing you of what you need to know.
A standard RICS level 3 survey will be giving you modern construction information.

Share more if you want but I really don’t feel this is the right house for you.

Fairiesarereal345 · 14/11/2026 22:51

Pipsquiggle · 14/11/2026 21:35

@Fairiesarereal345 you need to find out if they have had any offers and whether they've been rejected.
Can you find out the position of the sellers e.g. they need to sell quick and for x amount for them to get a forward purchase or they are in no hurry?

Ideally you don't want to be the first potential buyer to give a lowball offer, this will probably piss them off and entrench their position

This is a good point, thank you, i will ask about other offers and the position of the seller.

OP posts:
TediousTim · 14/11/2026 22:52

Minasama · 13/11/2026 21:50

We did that, they refused to drop the price and we pulled out. They ended up taking it off the market. No idea if it eventually sold.

Good luck!

Thank you. Unfortunately we've now found out that they have used non-compliant paint to the exterior of the house and didn't make a Listed Building Consent application. So it not only needs a new roof, but also will need sandblasting, re-rendering, and then painting with breathable paint that is compliant with the listing.

I've contacted the conservation officer, but they seemed clueless about the type of paint used, so I can't imagine they have applied for consent to change the type of paint.

We won't be able to proceed with the purchase until they've put it right. Or they reduce enough to cover both the roof and the paint.

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 23:04

TediousTim · 14/11/2026 22:52

Thank you. Unfortunately we've now found out that they have used non-compliant paint to the exterior of the house and didn't make a Listed Building Consent application. So it not only needs a new roof, but also will need sandblasting, re-rendering, and then painting with breathable paint that is compliant with the listing.

I've contacted the conservation officer, but they seemed clueless about the type of paint used, so I can't imagine they have applied for consent to change the type of paint.

We won't be able to proceed with the purchase until they've put it right. Or they reduce enough to cover both the roof and the paint.

Roof: almost certainly won’t be fully replaced, it will need repairing.
Sandblasting: is not a conservation approved method.
Rendering will need to be Lime. Then limewash for colour.

LBC can take a long time to be approved, then you have the lead time on heritage trades. This is realistically a two year timescale for you or them.

If this work has been done without permission, what else has? what’s the interior decor? With the plastic paint outside, if this is also inside then the walls could be quite damp even if not showing yet. Plaster and paint may need to be stripped back internally too.

If you buy at 100k less than asking, can you afford the work required and do you have the patience for it? FYI I suspect the render will cost more than the roof repairs. Let’s say 3-4ksqft, 2 storey, 50-60k for heritage render removal then lime . You haven’t said the issues with the roof so can’t ball park that for you.

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:45

TediousTim · 14/11/2026 22:52

Thank you. Unfortunately we've now found out that they have used non-compliant paint to the exterior of the house and didn't make a Listed Building Consent application. So it not only needs a new roof, but also will need sandblasting, re-rendering, and then painting with breathable paint that is compliant with the listing.

I've contacted the conservation officer, but they seemed clueless about the type of paint used, so I can't imagine they have applied for consent to change the type of paint.

We won't be able to proceed with the purchase until they've put it right. Or they reduce enough to cover both the roof and the paint.

If that's the case, surely you need to pull out and let the sellers sort out their own mess!

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:50

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 14/11/2026 11:19

I do think that’s different though - you’re talking about houses in a bracket way beyond what most people can afford. £500k is a standard price for a relatively normal family home in many parts of the county and achievable for middle earners so the pool of buyers is much greater. They don’t need to accept such a low offer.

I agree that the pool of buyers who can afford 500k is much greater than the pool who can afford 1.5mill but it doesn't follow that 500k is achievable by 'middle earners' nor that a seller doesn't need to accept a low offer (although probably not as low % wise as the v high end seller). It will very much depend on the area, the house and the seller. If this house has already been on the market for 3.5 months without a sale, it is likely to be over priced relative to the local market.

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:54

daisychain01 · 14/11/2026 13:23

People taking a fancy to a house irrespective of the price tag need to think again. A property is worth what people are prepared to pay but the vendor also has a choice in the matter.

Ideally don't set your heart on a property you dont stand a snowball's chance in hell of affording and think you can just knock £100K off because its a buyers' market, that's nuts.

If you find a property going for £500K and offer £575K where you've done your sums and your numbers add up, that's not unreasonable in the current market.

Offer £400k on a property on the market for £500k for no other reason than you can't afford the price and think it'll be accepted, and think the vendor is desperate so they'll take it, don't be surprised if your offer is declined and you're seen as a time waste

and to clarify I am not taking offence at anything, just giving a perspective. We haven't been messed around because we read the room and know the signs of someone who likes a property enough and gets into a worthwhile negotiation where both side's needs are met. To many people only think what's in it for me and not enough of what's in it for them.

Edited

The seller certainly has the choice of whether to accept any offer or not but, if the market doesn't produce their desired price, they may have no choice but to stay put!
Sellers can choose to wait for better offers, and historically, they have often been fortunate, because the market has mostly risen, but they may well be less fortunate in a falling market.

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:59

Tortephant · 14/11/2026 22:28

Thanks for clarifying arrogant was the word I needed.

Zero emotion, anger or blame in my world, I deal with facts and people. You are correct with it all being in the sellers control, thanks for backing my point about not selling to somebody like you.

Do you not see that your response is the arrogant one?
Your previous post was indeed full of emotion, even to the extent of threatening not to sell to a random person on an internet forum who isn't interested in whatever you are trying to sell!
I never understand why some sellers get so angry when people make low offers on their homes. If you are confident that the market will offer you something much better, why not just laugh about it and say no! If you are not confident, a more sensible response would be to negotiate rather than having a tantrum!

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 15/11/2026 04:49

rainingsnoring · 14/11/2026 23:50

I agree that the pool of buyers who can afford 500k is much greater than the pool who can afford 1.5mill but it doesn't follow that 500k is achievable by 'middle earners' nor that a seller doesn't need to accept a low offer (although probably not as low % wise as the v high end seller). It will very much depend on the area, the house and the seller. If this house has already been on the market for 3.5 months without a sale, it is likely to be over priced relative to the local market.

Maybe by £40k, not £100k! 3.5 months is nothing in the current market either

rainingsnoring · 15/11/2026 05:16

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 15/11/2026 04:49

Maybe by £40k, not £100k! 3.5 months is nothing in the current market either

I agree that a seller is very unlikely to take a 20% reduction after 3.5 months. I don't think 3.5 months on the market is nothing though. Houses that are correctly priced will attract interest in any market. The issue is that many sellers price too high relative to what buyers can and will pay currently. Of course, some of these sellers will get lucky after 6 months on the market, but many will not and some will regret not lowering their price in 2026 and getting on with their move, particularly the downsizers.